30 Mar 2001, 12:00 UTC
Fwd: FERC Chairman Curt HSbert Will Block Western Price Caps
- From
- Alan Comnes alan.comnes@enron.com
- To
- Tim Belden, Mike Swerzbin, michael.driscoll@enron.com, Matt Motley, Robert Badeer, Diana Scholtes, Sean Crandall, Chris Mallory, Jeff Richter, Tom Alonso, Mark Fischer, Phillip Platter
- Date
- Fri, 30 Mar 2001 04:00:00 -0800 (PST)
This just in ... IssueAlert for March 30, 2001 FERC Chairman Curt HSbert Will Block Western Price Caps by Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis [News item from Energy Info Source] Reuters is reporting that Curt HSbert, FERC Chairman, said he would block a move by fellow commissioners to impose a temporary price cap on wholesale electricity prices in the western United States. HSbert reportedly said that even if a majority of the three member commission favored price caps, he would prevent a vote from being taken because he does not believe price curbs would increase electricity supplies or reduce demand in the region. "Absent someone proving to me that price caps would bring more supply and less demand in California and the West, my answer is yes," HSbert said, when asked by reporters if he would block a FERC vote on western price caps. A FERC spokesman later downplayed HSbert's remarks. "He did not say he would block any vote," said FERC spokesman Hedley Burrell. "He said he would need to be shown that price caps would bring more supply or less demand to the West." Analysis: Just last week, I discussed the growing dissension with the FERC over the price cap issue (see 3/21 IssueAlert). The dissension appears to be coming to a head, just as FERC grows from a three-member commission to its standard five members. As the philosophical complexion of the new FERC is unknown, it remains questionable whether or not HSbert's adamant stand against price caps will be sufficient to keep the commission from moving in this direction. HSbert's hard line against price caps was espoused during the same week that the FERC chairman appeared at a Santa Fe, N.M. conference and spoke about high wholesale prices in California and the fact that the state's utilities could have saved about $5 billion had they accepted proposals for long-term contracts six months ago. First, let's look at how the structure of FERC is presently changing and how this might impact the commission's divided position on price caps. On March 27, President Bush announced his intention to nominate state utility officials Nora Mead Brownell of Pennsylvania and Patrick Wood III of Texas to serve on FERC. Word on the nomination of Wood was expected, although rumors had indicated that Wood might be named to replace HSbert as chairman. Brownell, a commissioner with the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission, will be appointed to the remainder of a five-year term that expires June 30 of this year and an additional term expiring in 2006. Wood, who formerly served on FERC from 1991 to 1993, will be appointed to the remainder of a five-year term that expires in 2005. As I mentioned in the 3/21 IssueAlert, the FERC is presently divided on the issue of price caps. Obviously, HSbert has expressed strong opposition to any kind of restriction on pricing. However, Commissioner William Massey has said that he will continue to push for price caps to help calm the volatility of the California market. Linda Key Breathitt, the third commissioner presently at FERC, has remained undecided on the issue. What could change the balance of power at FERC with the two new appointments is the fact that both Brownell and Wood come from states in which some form of wholesale price caps are presently in place. Consequently, there is a real possibility that HSbert, despite his role as chairman, could soon find himself in the minority position with regard to the price cap issue. HSbert seems unconcerned about this possibility and has made reference to "like-minded friends" in Washington who would side with him on the issue. The rationale behind HSbert's opposition to price caps has been well documented. The FERC chairman has not been fully convinced that price caps would do anything to increase supply or reduce demand in the Western region, or anywhere else for that matter. Rather, HSbert believes that price caps have the potential to cause serious damage and actually cause supply to decrease further as power generators will opt to build plants in other regions that do not place restrictions on prices. The fact that HSbert opposes price caps but yet supports FERC's investigation into the "unjust and unreasonable" prices charged by power suppliers may seem like somewhat of a contradiction to some observers. Earlier this month, FERC put 13 California power sellers on notice that they must either make refunds for certain power sales or provide further justification of their prices. Total potential refunds or offsets in the ISO and PX markets are approximately $69 million for January 2001 transactions. Further, FERC established a price screen of $273/MWh that would be justified during periods of a Stage 3 alert, and that anything above this price would be considered excessive. In addition, the commission will determine a top wholesale power price for each month through April, and then formulate a permanent plan for monitoring prices in California for transactions taking place after May 1. FERC is utilizing a methodology to determine the price screen, and scarcity pricing is a very important factor in the equation. The commission uses a model that takes different factors into account (for instance, weighted gas, weighted NOX, etc.) to determine a price of electricity when the lights are about to go out (Stage 3 alert time). That is the price that FERC uses to determine scarcity prices. Therefore, it can and will change month to month. One may wonder how HSbert can reconcile the use of a market price screen and yet remain so opposed to price caps. However, it is important to realize that, for the most part, FERC is not prohibiting that power generators sell power above the price screen. Rather, FERC will simply demand that any company selling power above this price report to the commission and justify the higher-than-average price. That is an important but subtle difference between a price screen and a price cap, which prohibits generators from exceeding a certain price. As noted, HSbert spoke earlier this week at a conference in Santa Fe entitled "Current Issues Challenging the Utility Industry" sponsored by the Center for Public Utilities. HSbert spoke about a variety of topics, including the current status of RTO applications and new technologies related to pipelines and generation. However, one thing that HSbert said related to the wholesale market in California struck me as particularly interesting. HSbert said that last fall wholesale power suppliers offered California utilities long-term power contracts in the range of $55/MWh. The general consensus among the utilities and Gov. Gray Davis was that the price was excessive and that they should wait to sign long-term deals until wholesale prices decreased (or until the state could negotiate lower prices on behalf of the utilities). HSbert's point was that California utilities could have saved approximately $5 billion had they signed on for long-term deals at that time. Most of the contracts that the California Department of Water Resources is now signing with power suppliers are confidential and thus we do not know how the fixed prices of the contracts compare to the average $55/MWh that was offered last fall. However, most reports indicate that the state of California already has spent $4 billion to procure power and is expected to pay $14 billion for power over the course of this year. Meanwhile, California and other western lawmakers continue to urge the Bush administration and FERC to enact temporary price caps in the West. In fact, bipartisan lawmakers from California, Oregon and Washington met with Vice President Dick Cheney, head of the Bush administration's energy task force, to assert that soaring electricity prices in the West could lead the entire country into a recession. Cheney responded that the White House opposes any price controls on energy as they would discourage new power plants from being built. At the Santa Fe conference HSbert said that, "Washington doesn't do temporary very well." What he meant by this statement was that, although lawmakers are putting pressure on the federal government to put a temporary price cap into place, if one were to be enacted it would most likely remain in place for some time. Clearly, HSbert will continue to oppose wholesale price caps in the West (unless someone can make the case to him that price restrictions will lower demand or increase supply). Yet, at the same time, just this week HSbert said that he was "open" to a request from New York City Mayor Rudolph Giuliani to enact wholesale power prices in the Northeast. Giuliani asked FERC to impose a temporary $250/MWh cap on wholesale electricity prices to ensure that New York City gets through tight summer power supplies without large price spikes. How FERC as a whole will rule on the larger issue of price caps across the country (and particularly in California) once the new commissioners come on board remains to be seen. In any event, FERC (along with state regulators) still faces the challenge of finding some long-term solution that will stabilize the market in California and the Pacific Northwest. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.ConsultRCI.com Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily email, send a message to IssueAlert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.