10 Jan 2000, 14:12 UTC
AOL/T-W News
- From
- Scott Bolton scott.bolton@enron.com
- To
- Sue Nord, Susan M Landwehr, Jeff Dasovich, Marchris Robinson, Lisa Yoho, Aleck Dadson, dlassere@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 10 Jan 2000 06:12:00 -0800 (PST)
Broadband Fight Still On Despite Megamerger ?????The proposed merger between Internet giant America Online and entertainment behemoth Time Warner will do little to cool the ongoing fight over how to regulate new high-speed Internet services, industry watchers said Monday. ?????It is unclear how or whether AOL would allow competing Internet service providers access to its proposed cable network, said industry analyst Bill Whyman of the merger, currently valued at $350 billion. AOL has fought aggressively over the past year in Congress, the Federal Communications Commission and with local governments to force AT&T to open its high-speed cable network to competitors. ?????"It's one of the monster issues," said Whyman, who is a principal at Legg Mason's Precursor Group. AOL CEO Steve Case "said they're committed to consumer choice. What we don't know is whether other ISPs besides AOL will have nondiscriminatory access to Time Warner networks." ?????Whyman said the merger will likely turn the Internet into a video vehicle quicker than initially expected, which will ultimately put pressure on telephone companies to speed up their deployment of high speed digital subscriber lines (DSL). ?????Barbara Dooley, executive director of the Commercial Internet eXchange Association, said the merger proves that the marketplace is working, and that it's too early to determine which way broadband will grow. She added that smaller ISPs are still in a position to make deals with other broadband providers. ?????"There will be other alternatives to cable," she said. "An ISP in a particular area will not have to offer all options." ?????On the cable side, AT&T, a frequent sparring partner with AOL over broadband issues, said the merger reconfirms the importance of cable broadband. ?????"The proposed deal underscores the significance of broadband distribution and it reconfirms the value of AT&T's considerable broadband assets," a spokeswoman said. ?????And National Cable Television Association President and CEO Robert Sachs boasted in a statement that the deal proves that cable is the future of high-speed Internet service and that regulators have been wise to stay out of the broadband fight to date. ?????The Baby Bells remained adamant in their argument that they need regulatory relief to compete with the new mega companies like AT&T and now AOL. ?????"This new mega-company would be providing cable, Internet and telephony virtually regulation free," said David Bolger, spokesman for the United States Telecom Association, which represents the Bells. "We have the shackles and they don't." ?????The merger must pass muster with the Justice Department and the Federal Communications Commission. The FCC had no comment on the AOL-Time Warner announcement. ? - by Rebecca S. Weiner ? AntitrustAntitrust Anticipation Follows Merger Announcement ?????Opponents of the proposed merger of America Online and Time Warner raised antitrust concerns Monday about the monopolization of the market for high-speed Internet access and consolidation of content on the Web. ?????But proponents of the merger said the announcement underscored the marketplace ability,s to resolve competitive concerns, and noted a combined AOL-Time Warner would present a potent new competitor to Microsoft and to AT&T. ?????"Consumers do not want to be beholden to a giant media-Internet dictatorship, even if it promises to be a benevolent one," said Andy Schwartzman, president of the Media Access Project, which issued a joint statement with Consumers Union, the Consumer Federation of America, and the Center for Media Education expressing strong reservations about what would be the biggest corporate merger in U.S. history. ?????The groups are calling for the Federal Communications Commission to require cable and other high-speed Internet access providers to open their networks to competitors and asking that AT&T's ownership interests in Time Warner are severed. ?????But others dismissed those arguments, noting that "over the past two years, we have this phenomenon whereby a new merger or technology is announced and some company is immediately put forward as the media giant," said James Gattuso, vice president for policy and management at the Competitive Enterprise Institute, citing a string of prognostications about SBC, BellAtlantic, Microsoft, AT&T, and now AOL-Time Warner. ?????If consummated, the merger is also likely to benefit Microsoft,s defense against the Department of Justice,s antitrust lawsuit, said William Kovacic, an antitrust law expert at George Washington University Law School. "The fact that the industry environment is extremely turbulent and unpredictable and can change the position of companies in a real hurry makes it hard to prescribe remedies that won,t go into affect for two-and-a-half years." ?????A spokesman for Microsoft said the company had no comment on the merger. ?????Kovacic also said he anticipated a free-for-all among regulatory agencies seeking jurisdiction to review the proposed merger, including the Department of Justice, the Federal Trade Commission, the FCC, state attorneys general, municipalities, public service regulatory bodies and foreign governments. ?????The merger's critics are particularly concerned that AOL will reverse its long-standing argument to force broadband networks open. ?????"I think [AOL CEO] Steve Case is the Benedict Arnold of the digital age," said Jeff Chester, executive director of the Center for Media Education. "To me, what I heard today was a reversal of their public position," said Chester. ? - by Drew Clark ? On The Hill Lawmaker Calls For Antitrust Hearings ?????Senate Judiciary Antitrust Subcommittee Chairman Mike DeWine, R-OH, said Monday that the Judiciary Committee intends to hold hearings to scrutinize the proposed America Online-Time Warner merger. ?????"It seems that this deal could make sense for consumers by creating an organization that will deliver news and information more efficiently across the video/broadband spectrum," DeWine said in a statement. ?????"However, whenever a dominant Internet company merges with a leading media conglomerate, it raises a whole host of competition and public policy issues," DeWine said. "One concern in particular is the impact this may have on the so-called 'marketplace of ideas.' We need to examine the many implications of this deal." ?????"This merger also adds a new wrinkle to the broadband 'open-access' debate by potentially resolving it through private negotiation rather than by government regulation," DeWine concluded. ?????In a statement released Monday, Senate Judiciary Committee ranking member Patrick Leahy, D-VT, expressed more skepticism. "We will have to look closely at whether it makes public policy sense to consolidate control of content, cable and Internet service distribution channels," he said. "At some point, all of this concentration and convergence has implications for consumers because it will minimize competition and choice, giving us fewer voices and fewer pipelines in the marketplace." ?????Although Leahy said, "this merger between one of the largest owners of content with the largest provider of Internet services may have been inevitable," he added, "an element of caution is only prudent given the scope and impact of this planned merger." ?????"The great promise of the Internet has been to allow people a wide range of information sources and choices," said Leahy. "What we should do is make sure that all that information does not become funneled and controlled by just two or three sources." ?????A spokesman for Senate Commerce Committee Chairman John McCain, R-AZ, said he had no comment about the proposed merger.