23 Aug 2000, 06:55 UTC
Monthly Briefing: A Shoulder Month Without Shoulder Prices - CERA Alert
- From
- Lorna Brennan lorna.brennan@enron.com
- To
-
Julie McCoy, Steve Klimesh, Sarabeth Smith, gary.sova@enron.com, Rob Wilson, Lon Stanton, rockey.storie@enron.com, Kent Miller, John Dushinske, Dave Neubauer, Bill Fowler, Michael Bodnar
and 69 more
Joni Bollinger, david.badura@enron.com, Janet Bowers, Craig Buehler, Bob Burleson, allen.cohrs@enron.com, John Fiscus, Steve Gilbert, Morgan Gottsponer, Stephen Herber, Dana Jones, stephanie.korbelik@enron.com, bill.mangels@enron.com, Penny McCarran, Vernon Mercaldo, Larry Pavlou, eileen.peebles@enron.com, tony.perry@enron.com, loren.penkava@enron.com, Ken Powers, Chris Sebesta, Frank Semin, neal.shaw@enron.com, Larry Swett, Kay Threet, mike.ullom@enron.com, lisa.valley@enron.com, Chuck Wilkinson, Jim Wiltfong, Jo Williams, karen.lagerstrom@enron.com, Ray Stelly, Bob Stevens, Sue Neville, Mike Barry, Martha Janousek, Kimberly Watson, Don Powell, Steve Weller, michael.stage@enron.com, Tim Johanson, laura.lantefield@enron.com, Frank Oldenhuis, Jeff Nielsen, tracy.schwartzkopf@enron.com, Robert Mason, Sean Bolks, miriam.martinez@enron.com, Lee Ferrell, John Williams, Reyna Cabrera, Lynn Blair, Rick Dietz, Steven January, Sheila Nacey, Mary Kay Miller, Michel Nelson, Mike McGowan, Julia White, Drew Fossum, Steven Harris, Jeffery Fawcett, Lorraine Lindberg, Kevin Hyatt, Christine Stokes, TK Lohman, Michelle Lokay, Lindy Donoho, Bill Cordes - Date
- Tue, 22 Aug 2000 23:55:00 -0700 (PDT)
September Forecast
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Lorna Brennan/ET&S/Enron on 08/23/2000 06:52 AM --------------------------- webmaster@cera.com on 08/22/2000 10:28:10 PM To: Lorna.Brennan@enron.com cc: Subject: Monthly Briefing: A Shoulder Month Without Shoulder Prices - CERA Alert ********************************************************************** CERA Alert: Sent Tue, August 22, 2000 ********************************************************************** Title: Monthly Briefing: A Shoulder Month Without Shoulder Prices Author: Zenker, Snyder, Moritzburke E-Mail Category: Alert Product Line: Western Energy , URL: http://www.cera.com/cfm/track/eprofile.cfm?u=5526&m=1320 , Alternate URL: http://www.cera.com/client/ce/alt/082200_18/ce_alt_082200_18_ab.html ********************************************************************** As western markets continue to struggle through high August demand and prices for both power and natural gas, September looms as the start of the fall shoulder season. The shoulder season historically has brought the possibility of a break in weather and a demand drop in both power and gas prices from summer levels. CERA expects this shoulder season to differ from years past, however, with power and gas markets producing strong year-over-year prices and little relief from summer levels, even with normal September weather. West-wide power loads will decline but will remain similar to those in June, a month with high power prices. In addition, compared with June levels hydroelectric capacity has dropped owing to reduced stream flows, leaving more expensive gas-fired generation to replace declining hydroelectric output. CERA expects occasional hot weather and higher gas prices to push on-peak prices in the West to 244 percent over September 1999 levels. Continued strong use of gas-fired generation in the West, as well as low US storage inventories and tight supply demand balances, will keep the pressure on gas prices. Topock prices are expected to average $4.45 per million British thermal units (MMBtu) in September. These high September gas and power prices are driven by * Declining hydroelectric output. The months of September through November represent the low point for hydroelectric output in the West, with rainfall historically boosting output in December. Approximately 16,400 average megawatts (aMW) will be available from hydroelectric facilities during the three-month period. This represents a net reduction in capacity of 6,900 aMW when compared with the recent June-August summer months and a reduction of 3,600 aMW when compared with September 1999 levels. * Higher, more variable power demand. The Southwest and Southern California still experience hot weather in September, and regional utilities typically consider it possible that a year's peak load event will occur in September. Spiking loads, however, can quickly retreat with a return to cooler weather. Thus, power loads and power prices are expected to experience a high degree of variability during September. * High levels of gas-fired generation. Load growth and a declining hydroelectric resource base will require gas-fired resources to serve approximately the same level of demand as in June 2000, a month with similar average demand and monthly average on-peak power prices in the $150-$178 per megawatt-hour (MWh) range, depending on the region. This strong pull on gas-fired plants will push deep into the generation resource base, driving prices upward. An additional 1.7 billion cubic feet (Bcf) per day will be required for gas-fired generators in the US West compared with September 1999 levels. * Strong North American gas prices. Natural gas prices are expected to retain most of this summer's peak levels, as North American supplies remain tight. A market anxious about winter demand and price levels will also limit a price retreat this fall. As a result, average September Henry Hub prices are expected to trade around $3.95 per MMBtu. An active storm season could keep Henry Hub prices near the $4.50 mark. * Strong western basis differentials. The strong demand for gas to serve gas-fired generation and storage concurrently will maintain western basis differentials at high levels, especially in the California markets. CERA expects a Topock-to-Henry Hub differential of $0.40 per MMBtu during September. Extended operational problems associated with El Paso's pipeline rupture would raise that outlook. Regional Power Market Drivers Hotter-than-normal August weather, transmission and generator outages, high natural gas prices, and declining hydroelectric output all contributed to a rise in power price levels during August. Southern California average power prices in August have thus far exceeded July levels by an average of $90 per MWh during the on-peak period and by $14 per MWh during the off-peak period. Mid-Columbia power prices, bearing the brunt of fire-induced transmission outages, experienced a jump from July price levels of $114 per MWh for the on-peak period and $20 per MWh in the off-peak period. Off-peak prices, which have averaged above $60 per MWh during the June-August period, are clearly defined by the production cost of gas-fired resources. On-peak prices during this same period, at over $100 per MWh in all regions in all months, have reflected a significant premium at times over the cost of the marginal system generator (see Table 1). A return to normal weather should drive West-wide loads down by 8,300 aMW in September from August levels. However, load growth and a return to normal weather are expected to push loads up by 5,400 aMW when compared with September 1999 levels. These greater loads, coupled with a reduction in hydroelectric generation of 3,600 aMW from last September's levels, will create supply tightness during September (see Tables 2 and 3). Hydroelectric, coal, and nuclear generation together will be insufficient to serve West-wide demand in September, even during much of the off-peak periods, requiring gas-fired resources to meet a significant portion of the load. Gas demand for power generation is expected to average 5.2 Bcf per day in September, down from over 5.9 Bcf per day in August but up by a dramatic 1.7 Bcf per day compared with levels in September 1999. September power prices will be defined by a floor set by the incremental cost of gas-fired generation, approximately $50 per MWh, with prices frequently higher as demand increases. As this summer has clearly demonstrated, prices rise in a nonlinear fashion as supplies grow very tight. Hot weather-induced loads should provide additional examples of this relationship. * Cooler- or hotter-than-normal weather in September, coupled with the inherent high variability of September loads, will produce a wide range of price outcomes. Under normal weather, on-peak power prices are expected to fall in the $113-$123 per MWh range, depending on location, representing a 244 percent premium to year-ago September prices (see Figure 1). The latest revision of the California Independent System Operator's (ISO's) imbalance energy market cap down to $250 per MWh is expected to depress market prices during any weather events in September. CERA expects the ISO price cap to limit prices outside of California as well. Pacific Northwest Although demand levels in the Pacific Northwest are expected to retreat in September by at least 1,100 aMW compared with those in the hotter-than-normal month of August, the loss in available capacity from hydroelectric resources will amount to 1,900 aMW over the same period (see Table 4). Thus, the Pacific Northwest will be in an even more limited position to export power to other regions. With transmission interties operating at below rated capacity during this period, power prices in the Pacific Northwest will maintain their tight relationship with those in Northern California. These price levels will continue to support the operation of the region's limited quantity of gas-fired generation. Mid-Columbia on-peak price levels are expected to average $118 per MWh in September. Off-peak power price levels in the Pacific Northwest will also receive a boost from the strong markets to the south. The expected September level of $54 per MWh represents the opportunity cost of power sales in surrounding markets. California The fall months initiate a seasonal shift in price differentials that separates the West into markets that lie north of transmission Path 15 and those to the south. As in years past, hydro-depleted Northern California should experience demand levels that must be served by generation resources within the region. Exports from the Pacific Northwest dwindle, and energy from the nuclear and coal-rich Southwest is constrained from entering Northern California by Path 15 import limitations. This condition, which is expected to persist from September through November, allows Northern California to price at a premium. The expected monthly average on-peak Northern California price of $123 per MWh incorporates this dynamic. Notably, the California ISO is completing a process to remap the zones in California, in part to capture locational price differences more effectively. Southern California, like the Southwest, will typically experience hot weather episodes in September. During these high demand periods, prices will rise to peak levels as experienced this summer. In addition, California as a whole should see average loads in September that are 4,600 aMW higher than those of September 1999. Occasional cooler weather will sharply but temporarily reduce daily prices. Southern California benefits from the abundant export capacity of the Southwest during cooler weather in that region, allowing prices to fall well below those in Northern California. An $8 per MWh differential between the north and south portions of the state is expected, with Southern California on-peak prices averaging $115 per MWh. Off-peak prices of $53 and $47 per MWh for Northern and Southern California, respectively, reflect the continued need for gas-fired resources to support September off-peak loads. Rockies and Southwest An extended period of hot weather in July and August has boosted demand in the Rockies, a region with growing saturation of residential air conditioning. Limited transmission capacity and a dearth of cheaper exports from surrounding regions have allowed the Rockies to price temporarily at a premium to all other regions in the West. A return to normal weather in September should restore the previously tight relationship of Rockies prices to those in the North. Rockies prices are expected to fall with loads, with a September monthly on-peak price average of $113 per MWh and an off-peak price average of $43 per MWh. CERA expects Southwest prices to be tightly connected to prices in Southern California on a monthly average basis. The two regions generally experience the same September weather patterns, and a strong 7,600 MW transmission link between the two market centers allows them to balance loads with each other. Strong gas prices and occasional market tightness-induced price run-ups will maintain on-peak prices at the $115 per MWh level in September. Off-peak prices will, like those in Southern California, be buoyed by the high cost of gas-fired generation. A price level of $47 per MWh is expected for off-peak prices. Regional Gas Market Drivers The summer competition for gas supply between power and storage continues in North America, with gas prices reflecting the intensity of that competition. Even as the summer power peak subsides in September across the United States, the need to continue strong storage injections and the threat of storms in the Gulf will keep prices high and volatile. The storage deficit now stands at approximately 350 Bcf, and US storage inventories look likely to head into winter at historically low levels. This critical storage situation will keep prices high despite overall declines in power loads in September. CERA expects a Henry Hub price of $3.95 per MMBtu during September. In the West strong power loads and the potential for power peaks persist through September, especially in California. Overall, total demand for gas is expected to decline across the West from 10.1 Bcf per day during August to 9.8 Bcf per day during September (see Table 5). This load will tend to keep intraregional differentials wide throughout the West during the month. The recent price disconnects between the supply-rich Rocky Mountains and San Juan Basin and demand-charged California will persist. October should bring some change in this dynamic as heating loads in the Rockies begin to increase. In general, winter will bring a dramatic shift in regional pricing differentials throughout the West. The summer pressure on Rocky Mountain supplies caused by high utilization rates on most export pipelines will be relieved somewhat by regional heating loads. Declines in flows into the San Juan Basin from the Rockies will take some downward pressure off prices in the San Juan. On the other hand, healthy California storage inventories should limit price premiums at Topock through the heating season. The start-up of the new Alliance pipeline, which will draw gas to the Midwest, will support prices in the Pacific Northwest and California. California Topock continues to be the premium pricing point in North America, although differentials between Southern California and the Henry Hub subsided somewhat from peak levels near $1.00 per MMBtu before this weekend's pipeline explosion. Total imports into California reached record levels during July; total imports of 5.8 Bcf per day eclipsed the previous high by 300 million cubic feet (MMcf) per day (see Table 6). Pipeline capacity into the state during the month ran at 83 percent utilization. So far in August, pipeline capacity utilization is exceeding even that high rate, running at 85 percent. These high rates of capacity utilization are putting pressure on gas prices in Southern California, and the pressure should continue during September. Total demand in California is expected to decline somewhat during September, but continued strong power loads and low seasonal hydroelectric generation will provide support. Total demand in the state should average 6.6 Bcf per day, down only slightly from August's total of 6.8 Bcf per day. Flows into the state between August and September are not likely to change significantly, but price pressure should decline somewhat with demand. The Topock differential to the Henry Hub should average approximately $0.50 per MMBtu for September (see Table 7). Storage inventories in the West are still healthy relative to levels in the rest of the United States, but the storage surplus in the region has eroded. In California, inventories are running lower than last year, and the deficit in the state looks likely to widen during September. The end of injection season storage inventories will determine the vulnerability of Topock differentials to winter price spikes. Pacific Northwest Malin prices this summer have shown neither the strong premiums that Topock prices have shown nor the wide discounts that supplies in the Rocky Mountains and San Juan Basins have shown. So far this month, prices at Malin are averaging a $0.25 per MMBtu discount to the Henry Hub. Pipeline capacity into the region from the Rocky Mountains is running nearly full; flows on PGT out of Alberta have averaged nearly 2.2 Bcf per day this month. Export capacity out of the region on PGE GT NW is running close to capacity, and pipeline constraints to the south combined with strong California demand are driving the wide Malin-to-Topock differentials. Continuing strong demand in the South will likely keep Topock prices strong, and the wide north-south differentials within the West will likely hold through September. In the Pacific Northwest demand is expected to climb through September to 1.5 Bcf per day from 1.4 Bcf per day in August. This demand level should keep Malin differentials from widening from current levels. For September CERA expects Malin prices to average $0.10 per MMBtu below the Henry Hub price. Southwest Prices in the San Juan Basin this summer have been left behind by rising California demand. Although the westward pull on supplies is strong, bottlenecks between California and the San Juan have led to disconnects between San Juan prices and Topock prices. Pipeline capacity utilization rates on Transwestern and the northern leg of El Paso reached 93 percent during July, with less than 200 MMcf per day of excess pipeline capacity. Increased flows from the Rockies on TransColorado and Northwest are contributing to downward pressure on San Juan Basin supply, and in general, the San Juan has followed Rocky Mountain prices rather than following prices at Topock or the Permian Basin. Unlike in the past two summers, the bottleneck has not allowed power demand on the West Coast to support San Juan prices relative to Permian prices. The differential between San Juan and Permian has averaged $0.50 per MMBtu so far this month and $0.30 per MMBtu since June. Additional imports from the Rockies into the San Juan have increased supply by 200 MMcf per day relative to last summer, but these higher flows do not fully explain the disconnect. Without much change in Southwestern or Rocky Mountains local demand, the San Juan should continue to price at a wide discount during September. The San Juan-to-Henry Hub differential is expected to average $0.60 per MMBtu. As in the Rockies, differentials should narrow substantially in October. Rocky Mountains Downward pressures on Rocky Mountain prices intensified over the past month as utilization rates on pipelines out of the region continued to climb. Record heat and power generation levels have done little to boost gas demand within the region; generation is still largely coal-based, and the demand impact on gas of the additional load is minimal. CERA expects the heavy discount-current Rocky Mountain-to-Henry Hub differentials are around $0.90 per MMBtu-to persist through September. Local area demand is not expected to change during September. Substantial gain in local demand comes in October with heating loads; October demand should average 1.4 Bcf per day, up from August and September averages of around 1.2 Bcf per day. Although the winter heating season will relieve pipeline pressures in the Rockies, winter differentials are expected to stay in the $0.25 to $0.40 per MMBtu range. Strong storage inventories will limit the connection with broader North American markets this summer. Next summer, pressures on Rockies supplies will likely intensify relative to this summer. Although pipeline expansion projects have been announced-Trailblazer and Williams announced expansion plans this summer-the new capacity will not be online to relieve constraints next summer. CERA expects supplies within the Rocky Mountains to increase by 300 MMcf per day next year. Western Canada After widening to over US$1.50 per MMBtu, the AECO-Henry differential has begun to narrow somewhat; maintenance that has restricted flows has largely been responsible for the jump from $0.84 per MMBtu in July. With current supply able to fill the contracted pipe capacity and incremental volumes having to pay full cost to flow, differentials are likely to persist in the mid-US$0.70s per MMBtu for September. AECO is expected to be US$3.25 per MMBtu (C$4.53 per gigajoule) for September. Even with the start-up of the Alliance project, the contract nonrenewal on TransCanada is likely to continue the two-tiered pricing dynamics of contracted versus uncontracted pipeline costs. This will result in differentials that will range between US$0.60 and US$0.75 per MMBtu throughout the winter. Supply build in western Canada continues to languish behind last year's levels. The pace of drilling (over 9,000 gas wells are expected this year) should provide growth in the fourth quarter and into 2001. Supply is expected to be flat with 1999 on an annual basis for this year and up at least 350 MMcf per day in 2001. Sumas prices have been quite volatile, driven by both weather in the Pacific Northwest and maintenance on the Westcoast system. For September, Sumas is expected to be slightly more stable and to price at a modest premium to AECO of US$0.05 per MMBtu. **end** Follow URL for PDF version of this Monthly Briefing with associated graphic and tables. ********************************************************* CERA's Autumn 2000 Roundtable event dates and agendas are now available at http://www.cera.com/event ********************************************************* ********************************************************************** Account Changes To edit your personal account information, including your e-mail address, etc. go to: http://eprofile.cera.com/cfm/edit/account.cfm This electronic message and attachments, if any, contain information from Cambridge Energy Research Associates, Inc. (CERA) which is confidential and may be privileged. Unauthorized disclosure, copying, distribution or use of the contents of this message or any attachments, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited. Terms of Use: http://www.cera.com/tos.html Questions/Comments: webmaster@cera.com Copyright 2000. Cambridge Energy Research Associates