25 Sep 2000, 19:28 UTC
DO YOU FEEL SORRY FOR PG&E
- From
- Roger Yang roger.yang@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 25 Sep 2000 12:28:00 -0700 (PDT)
The following is a summary of PG&E's CTC recovery: So do you still feel sorry for PG&E. Through July 2000, PG&E ratepayes have paid for $3.9 billion in CTCs and PG&E shareholders face the risk of $1.1 billion. Even if the ratepayers number gets reduce to $2.5 billion and the shareholders number increases to $2.5 billion, should Californians feel bad that they paid off half of PG&E's CTCs in exchange for frozen rates through 2001? Although procurement costs are increasing, so are generation revenues for hydro, nuclear, and QF contracts. Additionally, what is the correct value of hydro and nuclear assets. If nuclear and hydro are valued correctly and PG&E locks in next years prices, perhaps PG&E's shareholder may only be at risk for $0 to 1 billion? Would an 80/20 split between ratepayers and shareholders for CTC liability be unreasonable? Afterall, (1) PG&E has delayed hydro valuation with its antics when they expected to overcollect CTCs, (2) PG&E has been requesting astonishing increases to its T&D rates which has resulted in squeezing headroom, and (3) PG&E chose the timing and its assets to divest without hedging the risks; not to mention things like irresponsibly telling customers to expect rate decreases despite their GRC request. Roger