18 Aug 2000, 13:15 UTC
Re: Label Calculation
- From
- Stacey Bolton stacey.bolton@enron.com
- Cc
- cholmes@energy.state.ca.us, Drake Johnson, kgriffin@energy.state.ca.us, mjones@energy.state.ca.us
- Bcc
- cholmes@energy.state.ca.us, Drake Johnson, kgriffin@energy.state.ca.us, mjones@energy.state.ca.us
- Date
- Fri, 18 Aug 2000 06:15:00 -0700 (PDT)
Bob: We appreciate your counsel's review of our proposal, and will proceed either with your recommendation below (2 product labels - one for commercial customers receiving 100% renewable energy and the other label for our larger users comprised of a percentage renewable and fossil fuels) or, as was discussed with Drake Johnson, distributing one aggregated label with a percentage renewable resources and fossil fuel. Thank you for taking into account our timing constraints and responding to our request so promptly. Best regards, Stacey Bolton Manager, Environmental Strategies Enron 713-853-9916 "Robert Grow" <Rgrow@energy.state.ca.us> on 08/18/2000 11:15:28 AM To: <sbolton@enron.com> cc: <Cholmes@energy.state.ca.us>, <DJohnson@energy.state.ca.us>, <Kgriffin@energy.state.ca.us>, <Mjones@energy.state.ca.us> Subject: Re: Label Calculation Stacey: Our counsel has reviewed your proposal. We find that it doesn't meet our regulations, but it appears to represent a good faith effort to comply. We cannot give official approval to labeling that is not in accord with the regs, but counsel says we will not consider any sanction or punitive action in this case. The problem with your proposal is that the product is represented by two labels, not one. You could consider splitting the product into multiple products, only one of which is 100% renewable. Even so, we think consumers should be able to understand the product as you have described it. I hope this response is timely for your September billing. Bob Grow Program Manager Power Source Disclosure CA Energy Commission (916) 654-5180
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
>>> "Stacey Bolton" <sbolton@enron.com> 08/15/00 04:58PM >>> Bob: Pursuant to our phone discussion today, outlined below is Enron Energy Service's (EESI) proposed label calculation for review by your counsel. EESI's product is a 100% renewable product for the first 5,000 kilowatt hours per month. (The renewable energy in this product may exceed the 5,000 kwh per month depending upon available renewable supply and the level at which the customer credit is set.) For any customer that exceeds 5,000 kilowatt hours of renewable energy per month, the remainder of their product would be comprised of the California System Mix. Because the percentage of renewable energy that the end use customer receives is dependent upon their size, (i.e. smaller commercial customer might actually be receiving 100% renewable energy whereas larger customers might be receiving only a little more renewable energy than is contained in the CA system mix), this makes the label calculation difficult. It is EESI's proposal to have two separate labels for this one product. The first label (label A) would be 100% renewable energy (representing the first 5,000 kwhs per month). The second label (label B) would be the California System Mix. EESI would explain to customers that depending upon the customer size, some customers would be receiving "label A", provided they are 5000 kwhs per month in usage or less. For those customers that exceed 5,000 kwhs per month, the power they receive would look closer to "label b" (the California System Mix). EESI is under a tight deadline and is intending to notify customers of this product in the September billing. We would like to confirm with your counsel if this arrangement is agreeable to the CEC and meets the standards set forth in SB 1305. Please feel free to contact me with any questions regarding the label calculation. We greatly appreciate your assistance in this endeavor. Sincerely, Stacey Bolton Manager, Environmental Strategies Enron 713-853-9916