3 Aug 2001, 22:15 UTC
California Receivables and FERC Proceedings
- From
- Jim Piro jim.piro@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 3 Aug 2001 15:15:00 -0700 (PDT)
The following is in answer to your question concerning our current assessment of our exposure related to the FERC proceeding looking at refunds for sales to the California PX and ISO. This information on the FERC process was provided by Ron Johnson who is actively representing PGE in these proceedings. For the period October through February we sold net power to the Cal ISO and PX for $82 million ($93 million of sales and $11million of purchases), of this amount approximately $34 million was for power sold under the DOE order to sell. All sales to the Cal ISO and PX in 2001 were done under the DOE order. To date we have received payments of $12 million which leaves a current outstanding receivable of $70 million. Sales under the DOE order are not subject to refund in the current proceeding, however there is a possibility of a separate proceeding in the future on these transactions. Of the $59 million of sales & $11 million of purchases that were not covered under the DOE order, FERC will determine based upon a pricing methodology how much these amounts should be reduced by. The reduction will be based upon the difference in the proxy price and the actual sales prices for each hour times the amount of KWH sold in that hour. The proxy price for each hour will be determined by FERC in a proceeding that will start in about two weeks and will end with a decision sometime in late September. The proxy price for each hour will be based on the heat rate of the marginal unit being dispatched in each hour in California times the hourly gas price for the area where the unit is located based upon a published index plus $6/MWH for O&M. FERC will not entertain any discussions on using each company's marginal cost to determine what their proxy price should be for its specific sales. Without the specific data on which plant was the marginal unit and what the gas price was on that hour for that unit we are not able to accurately predict what the refund amount might be. We have made some estimates of what the refund could be given a set of assumptions on heat rate and gas prices and we think it may be in the $25 million range (high of $30 and low of $20 million). We are continuing to work on this estimate and will have a better number next week. In addition, FERC has stated that we will receive interest on all unpaid balances, net of the refunds, at the FERC approved interest rate which will help offset this exposure. Since none of this forecasted exposure is for 2001 sales all of the refunds would be charged against earnings. Refunds related to sales under the DOE order (if they occur at all) would be mostly covered under our PCA to the extent the refunds apply to sales during January or February of 2001. We currently have reserved on our books $7 million for general credit exposure for wholesale trading and $13.4 million for the California receivables for a total pre-tax reserve of $20.4 million. Some of this might need to stay on the books for continuing trading credit reserves but I believe we could use most of this credit reserve to offset a write down of the receivable if necessary. In addition, we still have the outstanding issue of getting paid from the ISO and PX and the time frame for payment given the situation with PG&E and their own bankruptcy proceeding. No assessment of this risk has been made. FERC has also started a proceeding on potential refunds for transactions in the Northwest. A hearing was held on August 1 and at this point there appears to be very minimal interest by most of the big northwest parties to pursue this issue (at this point only Seattle City Light, Port of Seattle and Tacoma are pursuing refunds). The outcome of this proceeding is still unclear but there is a reasonable likelihood that this docket could be closed with no action. We have very minimal exposure to Seattle and Tacoma probably less than $2 million. The discussion above does not include the receivable from SCE for the terminated power contract. They are current on their payments of $2.667 million per month and the amount remaining due is $42.7 million. We will provide you an additional update as we get more information from FERC on the proxy price.