11 Jul 2001, 15:26 UTC
EdF's voting rights in Italenergia - and interests in Germany and Spain
- From
- Peter Styles peter.styles@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 11 Jul 2001 08:26:00 -0700 (PDT)
Thanks Neven. Please keep my four colleagues copied as we go forward on this potential notification. You will have seen that DG COMP are keen to find a reason to force EdF to notify to the EC, even though Italenergia as a vehicle would not have enough turnover (certainly outside Italy) to trip over the EU Merger Regulation criteria. If notification were to the Italian competition authority, remedies inside France or at the French borders could not be targetted. Separately, I am in touch with the Cabinet of Mario Monti to pursue proper implementation of remedies granted in the EdF/ EnBW case (VPP auctions) and to drive home our submissions in the the EnBW/ Hidrocantabrico investigation. My contact there confirmed the proactive stance on competition issues in the power and gas sectors resolved upon at the Commission session of 20 June, and implied that DG COMP is "out to get" EdF by any legitimate means. I have the impression resources are being freed up for this purpose and our support is welcome. From: Neven Dujic@ENRON COMMUNICATIONS on 07/05/2001 02:38 PM CDT To: Peter Styles/LON/ECT@ECT@ENRON cc: Subject: Re: News on EdF's voting rights in Italenergia Definitely...I read through few research reports and finally managed to understand who has placed what in Italenergia. Fiat has contributed its 600 MW of generation capacity and 3,000 MW of developable brownfield sites for capacity. If one was to price the assets using the prices paid in the most recent trade sales of comparable assets the value assigned should have been between ?400m and ?600. However the value implied by Montedison's current price and Fiat's stake in Italenegia (and consequently Montedison) is ?1,200 million. Pretty valuable "Italian goodwill" I have compiled a very summary of the most recent developments: Neven Dujic Enron Broadband Investments Tel. +44 (0)20 7783 4750 Fax. +44 (0)20 7783 9211 Mob. +44 (0)777 570 3509 Peter Styles@ECT 05/07/2001 18:58 To: Neven Dujic/Enron Communications@ENRON COMMUNICATIONS@ENRON cc: Eric Shaw/LON/ECT@ENRON COMMUNICATIONS@ENRON, Brendan Devlin/EU/Enron@Enron, Nailia Dindarova/LON/ECT@ECT, Bruno Gaillard/Enron@EUEnronXGate, Alfredo Huertas-rubio/Enron@EUEnronXGate, Ross Sankey/Enron@EUEnronXGate Subject: Re: News on EdF's voting rights in Italenergia So....our speculation yesterday that, because of Agnelli family influence, the law would not be written/ amended to fix upon secondary shareholdings, turned out to be correct. I suppose that the 100% overpayment EdF seems to have made for its holding in Italenergia is accounted for by the "Italian goodwill" and some free options. From: Neven Dujic@ENRON COMMUNICATIONS on 05/07/2001 16:31 To: Eric Shaw/LON/ECT, Peter Styles/LON/ECT@ECT cc: Subject: News on EdF's voting rights in Italenergia Fiat-EdF raid on Montedison passes first parliamentary hurdle. The hostile bid launched by the Fiat-EdF alliance on Italian agro-energy group Montedison has easily passed its first parliamentary test. The Senate's Industrial committee has unanimously approved without modifications the government decree of 24 May which freezes EdF's voting rights in Montedison to 2% on acccount of the French giant being 100% state controlled. The same decree is of no relevance now that Fiat owns 38.61% and EdF 18.03% of their energy joint venture, Italenergia. Therefore, the approval of the decree in its totality, without amendments, is the first political nod to the Franco-Italian operation. The decree however may still be challenged by the European Commission, which will make a ruling by the end of July. EdF's voting rights not frozen in Italenergia-Min. ROME, July 5 (Reuters) - Italian Industry Minister Antonio Marzano said on Thursday a government decree freezing Eletricite de France's voting rights in Montedison to two percent did not apply to Italenergia, a Fiat-led group bidding for control of Montedison. Asked whether the decree on EdF froze the French company's voting rights to two percent also in Italenergia, Marzano told Reuters: "No, no. (It applies only) to the companies which are in the conditions described by the decree". Neven Dujic Enron Broadband Investments Tel. +44 (0)20 7783 4750 Fax. +44 (0)20 7783 9211 Mob. +44 (0)777 570 3509