Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

6 Mar 2001, 09:02 UTC

AB31X - Response Needed

From
Harry Kingerski harry.kingerski@enron.com
To
Susan J Mara, Jeff Dasovich, James D Steffes, Paul Kaufman
Cc
Fred L Kelly, Dave Roberts, gary.weiss@enron.com, Scott Stoness, Jubran Whalan, Neil Bresnan, Leslie Lawner, Robert Frank, Scott Gahn
Bcc
Fred L Kelly, Dave Roberts, gary.weiss@enron.com, Scott Stoness, Jubran Whalan, Neil Bresnan, Leslie Lawner, Robert Frank, Scott Gahn
Date
Tue, 6 Mar 2001 01:02:00 -0800 (PST)
Mike Day left me a message saying in discussions yesterday on AB 31X 
(Wright's load curtailment bill), the utilities were making the point that 
31x should only address bundled customers since the utilities were making the 
incentive payments out of funds that would otherwise go to pay DWR  (in 
effect, the curtailments are reducing the utility net short position).  They 
were ok with having ESPs aggregate the loads of bundled customers (which will 
be a very significant win, if we get it).   They think DA customers can get 
curtailment benefits through existing (and new) ISO programs.

The dilemmas are:
the ISO programs may or may not be finalized for this summer and may or may 
not give incentives that are as beneficial as AB31X
the utility plan discriminates against DA 
preferably, the ISO would administer the programs described by AB31X for all 
customers but that puts the ISO in the position of having to get approvals 
from FERC for a CA-legislated program (they will have to do this anyway)
(nearly) all of our customers will be bundled this summer anyway, so there's 
no immediate loss from going with the utility's position


We owe Mike an answer today.  Any thoughts?  My suggestion at this point is 
to stick with the high road and argue for non-discriminatory treatment with 
equal incentives paid to bundled and DA customers.

Background:  AB31X would give $500/mwh incentives for day ahead curtailment, 
$750/mwh incentives for day-of curtailments, and incentives to be determined 
for scheduled load reductions.  The ISO would invoke the programs based on 
system conditions.

The ISO so far has put in place the equivalent of a scheduled load reduction 
program, with specific payments, but has not finalized any day ahead or day 
of programs.