28 Nov 2000, 12:18 UTC
Turbine assignment clause
- From
- Kay Mann kay.mann@enron.com
- Date
- Tue, 28 Nov 2000 04:18:00 -0800 (PST)
Please print and fax this to Sheila. You don't need to print the attachment. Thanks, Kay
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Kay Mann/Corp/Enron on 11/28/2000 12:20 PM --------------------------- Kay Mann 11/28/2000 11:47 AM To: Roseann Engeldorf/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Sheila Tweed/HOU/ECT@ECT, Lisa Bills/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Ben Jacoby/HOU/ECT@ECT, Scott Dieball/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENt cc: Subject: Turbine assignment clause Hi there, I made some revisions to the language Rose proposed. Here are some questions/comments: I deleted the references to changing any delegation of rights/obligations. I'm not yet clear as to what the agency language will look like, and what rights we need/want to change (i) the identity of the agent (ii) the role of the agent (iii) whether the agency can be terminated. I'm just not that familiar with the structure yet, but if I can get that information, I'll work on it. I suggest we consider using a credit rating instead of "substantially similiar" comparison. Just easier to decipher. Rose/Lisa, I've added some SPV language. I'm added receipt of final payment as an exception to the credit rating standard. In other words, if they have received their final payment, they can't use credit as a reason to not give consent. I don't think we should agree to provide a list of power projects done by the assignee in the past 5 years. I also think 3 years is a bit much on audited financials, but I didn't comment there. I don't like their language that an affiliate must be intending to own/operate the plant. I've just bracketed the langauge and added "construct", since I don't know if this point has already been agreed. Enough explanation, here it is (with Word file attached below): Except for as described in Section ___ [ next paragraph], neither Party shall assign any or all of their duties or rights under this Contract without prior written consent from the other Party; such consent not to be unreasonably withheld, conditioned or delayed. Notwithstanding the foregoing: (i) either Party [Agent, too?] may assign any or all of its duties or rights to any Affiliate or subsidiary without the other Party,s consent; (ii) Purchaser may assign any or all of its duties or rights to any Affiliate of Enron Corp., without Seller,s consent, [provided that such assignee shall construct, own or operate the [Units] for the purpose of generating electric power for revenue], and (iii) Purchaser may assign any or all of its rights and obligations without Seller,s consent following [delivery/substantial completion?]. In each instance the assignment shall be effective as of the time the assignor delivers notice to the other party in accordance with [Section ]. [form to be agreed now?] Seller shall only be deemed to be reasonable in withholding its consent if the proposed assignee: (i) does not have [a credit rating of ___] [substantially the same or better credit quality than Agent] unless (a) the proposed assignee provides appropriate guaranties, letters of credit or other assurances of payment issued by an entity or person with [a credit rating of ___] [substantially the same or better credit quality than Agent], or (b) the assignor agrees to remain liable for all liability under this Agreement until [delivery/substantial completion], or (c) is a party participating in or providing financing or financing structures, including, without limitation, structures related to leasing arrangements and project financing, including a special purpose vehicle receiving financing to develop and/or construct the project for which Purchaser [or Agent] purchased the Equipment [add requirement of delivery of &rep letter8 from Enron regarding financing sufficiency], or (d) final payment (except for the retention amount) has been made to Seller; (ii) is a direct competitor of Seller in the turbine manufacturing business, (iii) is an adverse party to Seller in any material litigation, or (iv) if purchasing the Equipment, such assignee is not purchasing such Equipment (or rights thereto) as part of a transaction in which Purchaser, Agent or their Affiliates is providing related goods and/or services to such assignee. Purchaser or Agent shall have the right to assign or pledge, from time to time, all or any portion of their respective right, title and interest in, to and under the Agreement as collateral for financing of this Facility without Seller,s consent. In the instances where consent is required, the party requesting consent shall request such consent in writing, including the following: (a) the legal name and address and the form and place of incorporation or organization of the proposed assignee; (b) the current published annual report of the proposed assignee, or if no such report is published three years of audited financial statements and a description of the proposed assignee,s business, if available; and (c) [a descriptive list of power generation projects completed by the assignee during the preceding five years]. Seller shall respond to any request for consent within thirty (30) days following its receipt of such request. Seller,s consent if granted shall be in the form of Appendix __ hereto. Any failure to respond in writing within the foregoing period shall be deemed to constitute consent. When duly assigned in accordance with this Article, (including, following any collateral assignment, upon foreclosure by any collateral assignee), (i) this Agreement or the rights and/or obligations so assigned shall be binding upon and shall inure to the benefit of the assignee (and all rights and/or obligations so assigned, including, without limitation, any and all warranty rights, shall be assigned to the assignee as if such assignee were an original party hereto), (ii) the assignor shall be irrevocably relieved of and forever discharged from all liability under this Agreement so long as the assignee executes an assumption of this Agreement and such liabilities and obligations herein, and (iii) Seller shall look only to such assignee for the performance of the obligations so assigned. Any assignment other than as permitted herein shall be void and without force or effect.