27 Sep 2000, 11:12 UTC
Re: Risk Management 101
- From
- Susan J Mara susan.mara@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 27 Sep 2000 04:12:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Susan J Mara/SFO/EES on 09/27/2000 09:12
AM ---------------------------
Susan J Mara
09/27/2000 11:11 AM
To: Douglas Condon/SFO/EES@EES
cc: Martin Wenzel/SFO/HOU/EES@EES, James M Wood/HOU/EES@EES, George
Waidelich/SFO/EES@EES, Gary Mirich/HOU/EES@EES, Mona L Petrochko/SFO/EES@EES,
Jeff Dasovich/SFO/EES@EES, John Woodman/SFO/EES@EES, Edward Hamb/HOU/EES@EES,
Dennis Benevides/HOU/EES@EES, Lyle White/HOU/EES@EES, James D
Steffes/NA/Enron@Enron
Subject: Re: Risk Management 101
Don't you love Bob Glynn referring to AB 1890 as providing "Mutually Assured
Destruction"?
Douglas Condon
09/27/2000 10:33 AM
To: Martin Wenzel/SFO/HOU/EES@EES, James M Wood/HOU/EES@EES, George
Waidelich/SFO/EES@EES, Gary Mirich/HOU/EES@EES, Mona L Petrochko/SFO/EES@EES,
Susan J Mara/SFO/EES@EES, Jeff Dasovich/SFO/EES@EES, John
Woodman/SFO/EES@EES, Edward Hamb/HOU/EES@EES, Dennis Benevides, Lyle
White/HOU/EES@EES
cc:
Subject: Risk Management 101
Where were these discussions when AB1890 was being created?
California Utilities' Losses
On Electricity Pose Risk
By REBECCA SMITH
Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
California's two biggest utilities are losing so much
money buying electricity
in the state's deregulated market that they have run up
deficits equivalent to
half their net worth in just four months.
If the cost of wholesale power continues to exceed the
price these utilities
are allowed to bill their customers, as currently seems
likely, they could
become technically insolvent sometime next year. That
would put pressure
on regulators to orchestrate a multibillion-dollar public
bailout, similar to
the "too big to fail'' response that in the past pushed
governments to rescue
banks.
Such a scenario is quietly being discussed by bond-rating
concerns that
recently reduced their credit outlooks for Pacific Gas &
Electric Co., a unit
of San Francisco-based PG&E Corp., and Southern California
Edison, a
unit of Edison International of Rosemead, Calif. Bond-
rating concerns say
they aren't sure how much additional debt can be borne by
the two
affected utilities before they will have difficulty paying
their bills.
"If this is just a seasonal
aberration, the utilities
can get through it," says Lori
Woodland,
analyst for Fitch IBCA. "If it goes
on for six or
nine months, it's a very serious
situation."
Adds A.J. Sabatelle, senior credit
officer at
Moody's Investors Service Inc.: "At
some
point, you have a financial crisis."
The utilities say they are having no
difficulty
meeting expenses and don't envision
problems
in servicing their debts. But they
are vigorously
lobbying state and federal regulators to change the rules
of the game,
hoping somehow to raise rates to make up for the
shortfall. The California
utilities' experience may be a harbinger of what could
happen in other
states where wholesale power prices have surpassed the
amount that
utilities are allowed to charge their ratepayers.
For now, utilities are making ends meet by going to the
financial markets to
borrow money. PG&E, a giant utility that serves one out of
every 20
Americans, is seeking approval to increase its debt
capacity by $1.4
billion. It is borrowing $200 million, while Edison is
tapping $250 million
from the commercial paper market. "This is going to be a
long, tough
road," says Jim Scilacci, chief financial officer for
Southern California
Edison.
Today's situation represents a complete turnabout from
what was expected
when California deregulated its energy market on March 31,
1998, which
opened electricity pricing to competition. California
tried to give its utilities
a competitive edge nationally by deregulating faster than
other states and
by creating a mechanism to allow investor-owned utilities,
such as PG&E
and Edison, to quickly pay down debts incurred to serve
customers under
the old regulatory system.
To do this, the state legislature set
retail rates at high levels, which, at
first, generated fat surpluses for the
utilities. As the money piled up,
utilities used it to pay down debts for
generation facilities that were
otherwise unprofitable in the new
deregulated world. By the end of this
June, PG&E and Edison together
had collected more than $12 billion
and were on track to finish paying
down debts well ahead of the March
31, 2002, deadline set by the
legislature. At that point, rate freezes
were to end and retail prices were to
fluctuate with the market.
But all that went out the window in June, when wholesale
power prices
surged, topping the rates the utilities were allowed to
charge retail
customers. Average prices at state-sanctioned energy
markets were four
to five times the prices of a year earlier, and three to
four times the level
utilities could charge customers.
The accumulated shortfall has been so enormous at PG&E,
that analysts
expect its deficit to exceed $3 billion by Oct. 31, more
than half its
shareholder equity of $5.7 billion, which is defined as
assets minus
liabilities. Southern California Edison finished August
with a deficit of $2
billion, equivalent to almost two-thirds its net worth of
$3.2 billion. The
utilities, though they have been accumulating deficits,
aren't required to
report these as losses on their earnings statements.
That leaves utilities in a bind. They want to end the rate
freeze to be able to
pass on the real cost of electricity to consumers. But
should the freeze end
before the statutory deadline of 2002, they get clobbered.
That is because
they will immediately have to book a loss on their
power-purchase deficits.
What's more, they can't use the proceeds from planned
power-plant sales
to cover those losses; instead, should the freeze end,
they will be obliged
to refund some of the proceeds to ratepayers. In PG&E's
case, the refunds
could total $500 million, while in Edison's case, the
amount is $254 million.
Publicly at least, utility executives insist a mechanism
will be found to let
them recoup the money spent on electricity.
Consumer advocates are gearing up for the fight. Nettie
Hoge, executive
director for San Francisco consumer group Utility Reform
Network, says
ratepayers shouldn't end up footing the bill for a deal
cut by utilities that
benefited them before prices shot up.
Utility executives are now distancing themselves from the
legislation that
got them into such a mess, which was drafted with their
assistance. PG&E
Chairman Robert Glynn says it is best not to "overanalyze"
the "old deal."
Instead, he says, regulators and legislators should sit
down with utilities and
construct a new agreement, since "it's in the broad
interests of the state not
to have critical energy infrastructure look like a leper."
Mr. Glynn says the current deal offers "mutually assured
destruction" to
both utilities and ratepayers. Something must be done, he
says, or
consumers throughout most of the state will experience "a
San Diego-style
rate shock." The utility serving that city, San Diego Gas
& Electric Co.,
ended its freeze a year ago and began passing wholesale
power costs
directly through to ratepayers. Legislators intervened
this summer,
however, and temporarily capped retail rates when monthly
power bills
nearly tripled. The utility, a unit of Sempra Energy, is
also accumulating a
deficit as a result.
So long as banks and bond markets believe the utilities
will be repaid, they
will be able to borrow, analysts say. "Until we hear
politicians of
consequence state otherwise, our position is that we
believe the utilities will
be made whole," says Richard Cortright, a director at
Standard & Poor's
corporate ratings group.
But that opinion could change if it looks like the
utilities will have to
swallow a big loss. The result: lower credit ratings that
would raise
borrowing costs and could trigger a downward spiral.
"You're talking
about top-rated companies, though," said Ms. Woodland of
Fitch IBCA.
"To get to insolvency, a lot would have to happen."
In the meantime, utilities are doing all they can to
control the hemorrhaging.
They have gotten authority from regulators to buy more
power under
long-term contracts at fixed prices, reducing their
vulnerability to
spot-market volatility. And they have petitioned federal
regulators to
declare California's market so badly flawed that
generators should be
denied market pricing and, even, ordered to pay refunds.
Nevertheless, several forces are working against them.
Although they can
sign bilateral contracts, prices remain high for those as
well. What's more,
they can't buy less power than their customers need. If
they don't buy
enough, the California Independent System Operator, the
organization
responsible for reliability, will step in and make
purchases for them and
send them the bill.
Perhaps the biggest problem facing PG&E and Edison,
though, is one of
timing. The California legislature is out of session until
December, and
regulators haven't even really started to address the
issue formally. In the
meantime, the utilities' deficit is growing by tens of
millions of dollars daily.
Write to Rebecca Smith at rebecca.smith@wsj.com