12 Nov 2001, 14:27 UTC
FW: POWER POINTS: Does Dynegy Know What It's Getting Into?
- From
- Chris H. Foster h..foster@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 12 Nov 2001 06:27:48 -0800 (PST)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Onukogu, Ernest [mailto:Ernest.Onukogu@dowjones.com] Sent: Friday, November 09, 2001 11:59 AM To: undisclosed-recipients Subject: POWER POINTS: Does Dynegy Know What It's Getting Into? > POWER POINTS: Does Dynegy Know What It's Getting Into? > By Mark Golden > A Dow Jones Newswires Column > > NEW YORK (Dow Jones)--If I were an executive with Dynegy Inc. (DYN), I > would > want to know who was buying up my stock Thursday and Friday, encouraging > me that > Enron is a steal at $9.50 a share. > After all, the market's initial reaction to the Dynegy/Enron Corp. (ENE) > talks > was negative. Dynegy's share price fell 9% to $33 on the Wednesday, the > day that > Dynegy was negotiating a possible acquisition of Enron were disclosed by > CNBC. > But Dynegy's stock rebounded sharply Thursday to recover that loss and > then > some, and it's up another $3 to near $40 Friday. > Is this a case of average investors approving Dynegy's "steal" of > formerly > formidable Enron? Or were Wall Street banks, holding a lot of Enron debt, > trying > to encourage Dynegy to do a deal? About 75% of the 12 million Dynegy > shares > bought Thursday were purchased in a few hundred large blocks. > Some usually talkative Wall Street bank sources refuse to say a word > about > Enron or Dynegy, even off the record. Wall Street may be biting its > collective > lip in the hopes that Dynegy signs the contracts to buy Enron and brings > in a > critical injection of cash. That cash would come from ChevronTexaco Corp. > (CVX), > which owns about a quarter of Dynegy. According to the Wall Street > Journal, the > terms of the deal call for ChevronTexaco to inject $1.5 billion > immediately and > another $1 billion into the combined companies if the deal goes through. > Wall Street holds billions in Enron debt, which Dynegy is fully aware > of. But > Dynegy might be getting more than it's bargaining for, particularly > regarding > Enron's numerous obligations to deliver its own shares in the future at > minimum > values. > > SEC Probe Complicates Deals Based On Stock > > Any company that acquires Enron may have to make good on those > commitments to > issue stock pegged to values much higher than $9.50 a share, or perhaps to > make > up the difference in cash. > In a publicly disclosed example, an Enron off-balance-sheet financial > affiliate - Whitewing Associates - owns 250,000 shares of Enron > convertible > preferred stock, which are good upon conversion in January 2003 for 50 > million > shares of Enron common stock at a guaranteed minimum value of $48.55 a > share. > Enron's stock is currently trading below $9 a share. According to the > terms of > Whitewing's convertible preferred holding, Enron would have to deliver far > more > shares at current prices - 1,080 - for each of the 250,000 convertibles. > But Enron can't issue new stock now because it's under investigation by > the > U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, so it would be obliged to come up > with > the $40-per-share difference in cash. Since Enron owns 50% of Whitewing, > it > could tear up most of the convertibles, but not all of them. A rough > estimate is > that Enron - or Dynegy - would still owe the dozens of mutual funds that > invested in Whitewing around $500 million cash. > Dynegy is surely familiar with that deal, but highly leveraged Enron has > similar share-settled arrangements floating around that haven't been so > fully > disclosed. The lesser-known deals are similarly troublesome due to the > combination of Enron's stock-price crash and its inability to issue lots > of new > stock to make up the difference. > Another Enron-related partnership, the Marlin Water Trust II, is part of > Enron's disastrous venture into water companies through its Azurix > affiliate and > the later refinancing of huge losses related to the water investments. > Enron has > marked down the value of its direct holdings in Azurix, but not the assets > of > Marlin, even though Marlin's primary asset is supposed to be its half of > Azurix. > Prominent Enron short-seller Richard Grubman of Highfields Capital > Management > has asked Enron why Marlin's assets are still valued at $1 billion, when > 50% of > Azurix would seem to be a worth a fraction of that amount. Enron has > declined to > answer Grubman's question fully. > > Is Wall Street Short? > > Fitch credit rating agency said this July that Marlin's debt is > ultimately > supported by "an equity commitment from Enron in the form of mandatorily > convertible preferred stock." Neither the number of shares nor the > guaranteed > minimum value for those shares has been disclosed. If Enron can't deliver > those > shares, it is obliged to make up the difference in cash, Fitch said. > "In the event that the issuance of the preferred stock yields less than > the > amount required to redeem the senior notes, Enron is required to deliver > additional shares," Fitch said. "If Enron cannot or does not deliver on > this > obligation, then the amount of the deficiency becomes a payment obligation > of > Enron, representing a general unsecured claim." > In another partnership, disclosed in Enron's 2000 annual report but not > named, > Enron invested "the right to receive up to 18 million shares of > outstanding > Enron common stock in March 2003 (subject to certain conditions)." > Do those conditions include a share value much higher than $9.50? Did > Enron > prudently purchase puts on its own stock from Wall Street to cover some of > its > positions? As part of that same deal, Enron paid $123 million to purchase > unspecified options on 21.7 million shares of its common stock. > Because these deals are done through private placements of debt, Enron > doesn't > have to answer questions, and it has declined to do so. Dynegy also > refused to > answer questions on the issue. > One Wall Street equity derivatives trading manager indicated that all > the > banks have found themselves "unexpectedly short in-the-money puts" on > Enron. > Unexpectedly, perhaps, not just because Enron stock has fallen so far, but > because the SEC investigation prevents Enron from issuing additional > shares. > Wall Street has been sweating for weeks, and millions don't make Wall > Street > sweat. Billions do, and the concern has to do with liabilities beyond > Enron's > fully disclosed traditional debt. The banks have told Enron they don't > expect to > get clobbered on a technicality that wouldn't have arisen without the SEC > investigation Enron brought on itself, a person at a bank involved in the > talks > said. Enron agreed in principle, but the negotiations to make Wall Street > whole > were put on hold for the Dynegy talks. > If Dynegy buys Enron, it may be stepping into the middle of those > arrangements, letting Wall Street off the hook. > Dynegy competitor El Paso Corp. (EPG) and ChevronTexaco rival Royal > Dutch/Shell (RD) reportedly took a look at acquiring Enron last week and > passed. > Is Dynegy smarter than El Paso? Is Chevron smarter than Shell? > True Dynegy believers better hope so. > -By Mark Golden, Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-4604; > mark.golden@dowjones.com > > (END) Dow Jones Newswires 09-11-01 > 1948GMT(AP-DJ-11-09-01 1948GMT) >