19 Oct 2000, 13:59 UTC
Re: Fwd: Email Glitch
- From
- Jeff Dasovich jeff.dasovich@enron.com
- Date
- Thu, 19 Oct 2000 06:59:00 -0700 (PDT)
Got it. The sure-fire way to get me is at "jdasovic@enron.com." Thanks. Best, Jeff "Daniel Douglass" <douglass@ArterHadden.com> 10/19/2000 10:37 AM To: <Jeff_Dasovich@enron.com> cc: Subject: Fwd: Email Glitch Jeff, let me know if you receive this message. Sue Mara asked me to copy you on all emails to the WPTF Board, but I have recently been having everything returned for you. Hope all is well. Dan ----- Message from "Daniel Douglass" <douglass@ArterHadden.com> on Thu, 19 Oct 2000 11:32:55 -0400 ----- To: "Barbara Klemstine" <Barbara_Klemstine@apsc.com>, "Bob Anderson" <Bob_Anderson@apses.com>, "Robert Berry" <berry@apx.com>, "Denice Cazalet" <dcazalet@apx.com>, "Bill Ross" <billr@calpine.com>, "Jack Pigott" <jackp@calpine.com>, "Gene Waas" <glwaas@calpx.com>, "Ken Czarnecki" <Ken_Czarnecki@calpx.com>, "Carolyn Baker" <cabaker@duke-energy.com>, "Randy Hickok" <rjhickok@duke-energy.com>, "Greg Blue" <GTBL@dynegy.com>, "Kent Wheatland" <KEWH@dynegy.com>, "Jeff Dasovich" <j_dasovi@ect.enron.com>, "Roger Pelote" <rpelote@energy.twc.com>, "Susan Mara" <susan_j_mara@enron.com>, "Curt Hatton" <curt.Hatton@gen.pge.com>, "Gary Ackerman" <foothill@lmi.net>, "CHARLES A MIESSNER" <camiessn@newwestenergy.com>, "Corby Gardiner" <jcgardin@newwestenergy.com>, "Rob Nichol" <rsnichol@newwestenergy.com>, "Curtis Kebler" <curtis_l_kebler@reliantenergy.com>, "Rob Lamkin" <rllamkin@seiworldwide.com>, "Carl Imparato" <cfi1@tca-us.com> Subject: Email Glitch Have just discovered that some emails sent to the board earlier this week did not go through and got hung up in cyberspace. Most dealt with the emergency petitions for modification filed by Edison and PG&E and the data request for financial information which ALJ Minkin issued. This is the first, which went out on Monday: SDG&E has filed an initial response to ALJ Minkin's Ruling which first requests that the utility should not be subject to the information request which stemmed from the SCE and PG&E emergency petitions. If the Commission is unwilling to do so, the utility next informs the Commission of its intention not to respond fully to the request. The crux of the opposition is as follows: "However, neither Rule 1 nor the Public Utilities Code require SDG&E to waive certain fundamental due process rights pertaining to its discovery obligations. Specifically, simply because the information is requested in an ALJ ruling as opposed to alternative discovery mechanisms does not require SDG&E to produce confidential, proprietary, competitively sensitive information belonging to its affiliates which information is neither pertinent to a transaction between SDG&E and an affiliate nor in the possession of SDG&E. A number of the informational demands in the ALJ Ruling fall squarely within this context and therefore are not appropriate for discovery purposes." The utility then states that: "In an effort to cooperate with the Commission and the ALJ to provide for Commission inspection relevant information reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence, SDG&E will provide affiliate information responsive to the ALJ,s informational demands to the extent that the information relates to a transaction with SDG&E (i.e. falls within the scope of PUC section 314(b)), the information is public information (not confidential and proprietary to the affiliate), or the information is a matter of public record." SDG&E responses to information demands a, b, c, d, f, g, i, k, q, and bb were attached to the filing and will be provided to other parties who request them (I have requested a copy be sent to us) [Note...it has arrived]. Finally, the utility then itemizes the following items of information which it will not provide: "m. An itemization of funds paid to and amounts billed by the California PX by each utility affiliate for each month in 2000; n. An itemization of funds paid to and amounts billed by the California ISO by each utility affiliate for each month in 2000; p. An itemization of funds paid to and amounts billed by any entity other than the California ISO or PX for power purchased in California by each utility affiliate; [under the assumption that "any entity" includes SDG&E, the information related to any SDG&E transaction(s) will be provided] r. An itemization of revenues received from the California PX for power purchase sales in California by utility affiliates for each month in l999 and 2000; t. Revenues received from the California ISO for power purchase sales in California by utility affiliates for each month in l999 and 2000; v. An itemization of revenues received from entities other than the California PX and the California ISO for power purchase sales in California by utility affiliates for each month in l999 and 2000; [under the assumption that "any entity" includes SDG&E, the information related to any SDG&E transaction(s) will be provided] x. Revenues received for power purchase sales in any state other than California by each utility affiliate for each month in l999 and 2000; y. A description of all utility affiliates, activities in California electric markets, including marketing, scheduling, selling, or purchasing electricity either independently or jointly with other entities; [under the assumption that "any entities" includes SDG&E, the information related to any SDG&E transaction(s) will be provided; we will also provide public information related to those "activities" such as press releases, etc.; since no time frame has been provided related to this information request, we will respond concerning activities beginning January 1, 1998] z. A description of each energy facility purchased wholly or in part by the utility or any of its affiliates in l997-2000, including its purchase price and location; [we will provide any public information addressing affiliate purchases as well as all information, including confidential, proprietary information related to a transaction with SDG&E] aa. A description of each energy facility or portion thereof sold by the utility or any of its affiliates in l997-2000, including its sale price and location; [we will provide any public information addressing affiliate sales as well as all information, including confidential, proprietary information related to a transaction with SDG&E] cc. A copy of the most recent business plan for itself, its holding company and each of its affiliates. [we will provide copies of those portions of affiliate or holding company business plans that discuss or describe transactions with SDG&E] The basis of SDG&E,s objection to produce the foregoing information is that the information exceeds the scope of the Commission,s statutory authority to require production of affiliate information under PUC section 314(b); the information is not relevant to any proceeding currently before the Commission; the information is not reasonably calculated to result in the discovery of admissible evidence in any Commission proceeding; and the information is not in the possession of, nor is it proprietary to, SDG&E." After doing a comparison of the list of items for which responses are being provided with the list for which objections are raised, I noted that items e, h, j, l, o, s, u and w are simply not mentioned. I have sent an email to their counsel asking for the status of those requests. Let me know if you want a copy of the SDG&E filing. Dan