26 Jan 2001, 14:02 UTC
Tennessee Hourly Firm Service conference
- From
- Drew Fossum drew.fossum@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 26 Jan 2001 06:02:00 -0800 (PST)
pls print. thanks. df
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Drew Fossum/ET&S/Enron on 01/26/2001 02:06 PM --------------------------- Nancy Bagot 01/26/2001 09:55 AM To: Shelley Corman/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Mary Kay Miller/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Drew Fossum/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Robert Kilmer/FGT/Enron@ENRON, Janet Butler/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Dari Dornan/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Glen Hass/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Bambi Heckerman/NPNG/Enron@ENRON, Frazier King/FGT/Enron@ENRON, Teb Lokey/FGT/Enron@ENRON, Dorothy McCoppin/FGT/Enron@ENRON, Ray Neppl/NPNG/Enron@ENRON, Maria Pavlou/ET&S/Enron@ENRON, Janet Place/NPNG/Enron@ENRON, Michele Winckowski/ET&S/Enron@ENRON cc: Subject: Tennessee Hourly Firm Service conference Tennessee Tech. Conference on Order 637 including Hourly Firm Service January 24, 2000 Though the conference was billed as a combo of Order 637 and Hourly Firm Service (FT-H rate schedule), Order 637 issues were not discussed. Tennessee did a recap of where they are in that proceeding and explained how proposed changes to daily balancing impact FT-H. Basic Description of FT-H ? The target audience of the FT-H is combined cycle base load generation, not necessarily peaker plants, though the service is available to all shippers. ? FT-H will be generally available capacity subject to an NPV open season. Contractual rights assigned to FT-H are firm daily quantities that can be nominated hourly as 1/18 to 1/4 of the daily quantity. ? FT-H shippers must specify a 12-hour daily service period for MHQ eligibility (i.e., 7:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.) and daily receipt quantities have e to match delivery quantities on a contract basis (not necessarily on a flow basis). ? Nominations have a one hour start-up and shut-down time. ? Balancing is the same as regular firm with no hourly balancing charges ? Rates are analogous to storage charges, with three components: deliverability rate (hourly, 70%), capacity rate (daily, 30%), commodity charge (based on flow). Summary With only lukewarm support of the proposal at the conference, Tennessee will gather and send some clarifying material out to parties, but will also think about pulling the service at this time. If they do continue with the FT-H proposal, the pipeline will file a modified proposal in two weeks with comments due in mid-March. There may be a follow up conference to be scheduled at a later date. A FERC order on the filing must be issued by mid-May. FERC Staff stated that they prefer to keep Tennessee,s order 637 proceeding (RP00-477) separate from FT-H (RP01-81). Tennessee met with customers on 637 issues the following day (Jan. 24th) and will file a letter on their process going forward in RP00-477 by January 31st. Discussion After Tennessee,s explanation of the FT-H service, Staff asked questions about the impact of hourly service on other services, and began by asking if Tennessee could make public any modeling or service studies done to determine the impact of FT-H on other points (Staff noted that this analysis or transparent modeling should be filed for transparency). This opened the debate about &historical operation,8 which is the focal point of existing shipper concern. Shippers define historical operation as that they,ve received over time; Tennessee maintains that current tariff entitlements as contracted define current service, excluding enhanced services that may have been offered when available. LDCs are concerned with losing these &enhanced8 historical services and argue that their contracts were signed so long ago that many of the services they use now were not available or defined then, and some, such as pressure, wouldn,t be acceptable today as written in their contracts. At the heart of the matter, LDCs have become accustomed to access to more than 1/24 of their MDQ in an hour and do not want their capacity to be defined as such. Also, there is concern over nomination priority using NPV to compete with FT-H. Other LDC concerns: ? Preferences to secondary rights to FT-H over FT-A, ? Ability of FT-A to get MDQ on peak, ? NPV will bias against FT-A (Tennessee explained that a max rate FT-A shipper wins over FT-H because of total hourly capacity). Generators, the alleged primary customer for this service, were lukewarm in their responses. Calpine and Dynegy said that they,d likely stick to FT-A for their plants. Though they encouraged FERC to accept the service, they were not convincing that they,d sign up for it today. Dynegy detailed a list of concerns and issues with the service: ? Dynegy,s not interested in the 12-hour designated block of time, they need more flexibility, ? Ramp up time isn,t adequate, ? Rates are too heavily weighted toward demand side, ? Service needs to be somehow standardized for capacity release and e-commerce, ? Penalty rates should not be based on power prices, ? Third parties should be able to offer this in competition with Tennessee ? Offer FT-H as a seasonal service.