12 Apr 2000, 00:31 UTC
Pipeline Reform Coalition Notes
- From
- Shelley Corman shelley.corman@enron.com
- Date
- Tue, 11 Apr 2000 17:31:00 -0700 (PDT)
Based on discussions with Jeff Keehler, Dave Johnson and Mike Terraso last week, we agreed that it would not be prudent for individual pipelines representatives to attend the coalition meetings Sunday & Monday. The tone of the meeting announcements made it clear that this grass roots group is not receptive towards receiving information on pipeline safety records. Terry Boss of INGAA attended the meeting. Included in the audience were the parents of the Bellingham?victims and members of Safe Bellingham, and the speeches were not surprisingly political in tone -- the inadequacy of OPS and the need for funds for state safety measures; OPS should be restructured: FERC should be restructured; the EIS process is a joke. Here are samples of some newspaper articles that INGAA forwarded. Just because we didn't take an active role in the Coalition meeting doesn't mean we aren't moving forward at developing our legislative Enron & recommended INGAA strategy. Dave, Phil, Jeff and I met on Monday. Jeff reports that while pipeline oversight legislation is unlikely this year, we will absolutely have to deal with the appropriations issue (added user fees). Jeff is outlining a compromise position that he thinks could be politically feasible -- something along the lines that we can live with added user fees directed towards one call and public education programs. We'll get this outline out shortly. I want to get it in Bob Hill's hands before the INGAA Board meeting. Pipeline officials hear hard questions SUMMIT: Parents of Wade King, Stephen Tsiorvas speak to panel. Stephen Power, The Bellingham Herald WASHINGTON, D.C. -- The nation's top pipeline regulator and a White House environmental aide came under sharp questioning Monday when the parents of two children killed in a Bellingham pipeline blast confronted them at a conference of safety activists. With more than four dozen audience members watching, one of the parents, Frank King, handed a picture of his 10-year-old son, Wade, to White House aide Gabrielle Tenzer and asked her to deliver it to President Clinton. "Ask him what he would have done if Chelsea had been standing by that creek," King said, referring to Whatcom Creek, where his son was playing last June 10 when the explosion occurred in the pipeline of Olympic Pipe Line Co. Another parent, Katherine Dalen, drew applause when she stood and told federal pipeline regulator Richard Felder that the concept of safety "means something different to me than it does to you." She later handed Tenzer a funeral program with the picture of her 10-year-old son, Stephen Tsiorvas, who died along with Wade and 18-year-old Liam Wood. The tense exchanges occurred on the second day of the National Pipeline Safety Reform Conference, a gathering of environmentalists, local government leaders and citizens who want tougher regulations on underground fuel pipelines. Administration officials who attended the conference Monday -- Tenzer, Felder and Assistant Attorney General Lois Schiffer -- outlined their efforts to prevent pipeline accidents and told participants that the federal Transportation Department planned to propose safety reforms. But audience members chortled at some of the panelists' remarks and expressed frustration with the performance of the U.S. Office of Pipeline Safety, the federal agency that regulates the nation's pipelines. "We're really chagrined that there was no one here (from the administration) the past two days taking notes," said Susan Harper, executive director of Cascade Columbia Alliance, a Seattle group that helped block Olympic Pipe Line's proposed cross-Cascades fuel pipeline in Washington last year. "That was a big oversight on your part." As part of the U.S. Transportation Department, the Office of Pipeline Safety regulates more than 157,000 miles of hazardous liquid lines and more than 2.2 million miles of natural gas lines throughout the country. But with only 55 inspectors to cover more than 2 million miles of pipe nationwide, critics have questioned the agency's effectiveness. The agency has also drawn attention for sharply limiting the role states can play in policing interstate pipelines -- a trend that delights oil and gas interests but worries some local governments. Felder said his agency has allowed Olympic Pipe Line to continue operating because the company has performed "appropriate testing" of its lines. But he acknowledged the agency wouldn't know the cause of the Bellingham accident until the National Transportation Safety Board completes its probe. The board's investigation has stalled in recent months because some Olympic employees have refused to cooperate, fearing their testimony could be used by prosecutors in a potential criminal case. "We'd also like to know more about how (the Bellingham) accident occurred. ... In the end, we will have some of these answers," said Felder, who is the pipeline office's associate administrator. But, he said, "the less information we have, the more cautious we are and the more conservative we are." Felder's comments drew an angry response from Frank King, who waved a newspaper clipping about a day-care center in his state that was shut down immediately when a child in its custody died of undetermined causes. "I find it outrageous," King said. "This is the only time I've ever seen where one person is allowed to continue operating after murdering three children." Felder said he is encouraging states to focus on intrastate lines, such as natural gas lines that heat homes. The vast majority of pipeline accidents -- about 80 percent -- involve such intrastate systems, according to federal records. He also said most accidents occur as a result of third parties, such as construction crews that dig without checking for fuel lines. "We're very interested in state input," he said. "But you've got to look at where the risks are. They aren't in the big lines. They're in the small lines." Tenzer did not respond directly to King when he approached her, but told a reporter afterward that she would make sure Clinton received the picture. She declined to answer when a reporter asked her for the White House's view of the Office of Pipeline Safety's performance. Reach Stephen Power at spower@gns.gannett.com or call (703) 276-5806. ? Pipeline Reform Summit in Washington, D.C. Industry lobbyist takes notes for OPS GOVERNMENT: Official shrugs off potential conflict of interest. Khurram Saeed, The Bellingham Herald WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Just when it looked like it couldn't get any worse for the federal Office of Pipeline Safety, it did. The head of OPS told a reporter Monday that a lobbyist for a natural gas association had been taking notes about pipeline safety reform on OPS' behalf for the past two days at a national pipeline conference. OPS, the agency responsible for overseeing the nation's interstate pipelines, has been at the center of fierce criticism by pipeline activists over the years for being too close to the fuel industry. That cozy relationship has put corporate profits above public safety, pipeline reformers contend. Some conference speakers laughed out loud and shook their heads in disbelief when told that Richard Felder was relying on the Interstate Natural Gas Association of America for information about the conference. "It's perfect," said Virginia attorney Jim Pates, an outspoken and longtime critic of OPS. "It reflects not only the closeness of the relationship, but the insensitivity of how it appears to the public." Felder dismissed any potential for conflict of interest even though his agency monitors companies that belong to the gas association. He said he knew half of the 50 people in the room and was familiar with their concerns, thus the notes wouldn't tell him something he didn't already know. "I'm not worried about getting the issues, because there's a roomful of people who'll send them to me," Felder said after speaking at the conference. Earlier in the day, several speakers publicly questioned why OPS hadn't sent a representative, such as a note taker or public relations person, to the meeting that covered such topics as improving pipeline safety standards, protecting whistleblowers and granting more authority to local governments. "It's a professional organization that should be listening to us," said Susan Harper, head of a Puget Sound environmental group that fought Olympic Pipe Line Co.'s proposed Cascade pipeline. "Whether they like us or not, they should be here." Terry Boss, vice president of safety and operations for the natural gas association, said he was taking notes on his organization's behalf and offered to share them with OPS. "I'm just doing a favor," Boss said. "Would it be better for OPS to have someone here or for OPS not to have someone here?" Frank King, whose 10-year-old son was killed in last June's Bellingham pipeline explosion, said it was ironic that officials from the agency that needs to learn about pipeline safety the most weren't there in person for the two-day conference. "Their arrogance is evident everywhere we go," he said. "It's perfect. It reflects not only the closeness of the relationship, but the insensitivity of how it appears to the public." ? Chances dim this year for pipeline laws POLITICS: Keep pushing, pipeline activists at conference are told. Khurram Saeed, The Bellingham Herald WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Two congressional bills seeking to reform the nation's pipeline industry might not become law until next year, two Washington state pipeline reformers said Monday. In itself, the announcement wasn't all that surprising, given that change comes slowly here -- particularly for industries with powerful connections and lots of money to spend on lobbying. What was unexpected was the concession from pipeline reformers, who have stated in the past that the current political climate -- an election year with lingering shockwaves from the Bellingham tragedy and pending reauthorization of the federal Office of Pipeline Safety -- was ideal for immediate change. Two proposed laws -- Senate Bill 2004, introduced by Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash., and House Bill 3558, brought forward by Rep. Jack Metcalf, R-Langley -- would impose strict standards on pipeline operators. Both bills are still in committee. The committee chair must support the bill to send it for a full vote. That's not likely to happen this session, considering there are 47 bills ahead of Murray's bill in the Senate Commerce Committee. And Metcalf said he is having a hard time getting colleagues interested in buried pipelines. "The phrase out of sight, out of mind, certainly applies when pipelines are concerned," he told conference attendees in a speech. "Even if we don't get a bill out this year, we need to keep working on this," said Carl Weimer, executive director of SAFE Bellingham, a local pipeline activist group that has gained national stature. David Bricklin, the Seattle attorney who has represented several cities, including Bellingham, against Olympic Pipe Line Co., said the delay could be a blessing in disguise. "Sometimes in a rush to get any bill through, you settle for less than if you waited a little bit longer," he said. Although people attending the national pipeline conference here agree either bill would be an improvement, they are proposing several changes. The pipeline reformers want to amend the two congressional bills in order to: Broaden a state's power so OPS could reject safety regulations and environmental protection programs only if they compromise safety. Mandate use of leak-detection devices. Require water-pressure testing of pipelines every five years. Require use of fail-safe pipeline devices that don't rely on computers or human intervention. Upgrade safety management rules. Create pipeline oversight committees made up of citizens and local elected officials. Rick Kessler, an aide to Rep. John Dingell, D-Mich., long a champion of pipeline reform, said the national pipeline coalition has provided an impetus never before seen in Washington, D.C. Momentum for the bills won't wane if activists remain vigilant, he said. "Don't stop pushing," Kessler said. "Once you do, there'll be a void on one side. There are people here full-time paid to keep pushing on the other side." Weimer said pipeline reformers need to come up with the cash to hire their own lobbyist to track pipeline happenings in the nation's capital. "When we all go away, we need someone here in D.C. to tell us what's going on," he said. The Associated Press contributed to this article. ?