11 May 2000, 12:23 UTC
Re: Enron Online Japan - Tax Issues
- From
- David Forster david.forster@enron.com
- To
- Susan Musch
- Date
- Thu, 11 May 2000 05:23:00 -0700 (PDT)
So, basically we're OK for current plans - although credit should be aware of A3? Dave
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Susan Musch@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT 05/11/2000 10:47 AM To: Mario Parra Cardoso/Corp/Enron@ENRON cc: Jeff Blumenthal/HOU/ECT@ECT@ENRON, Stephen H Douglas@ECT, Mark Taylor@ECT, Alan Aronowitz@ECT, David Forster@ECT Subject: Enron Online Japan - Tax Issues I received advice today from our outside law firm in Tokyo regarding their final conclusions on the Japanese tax issues relating to the non-Japanese trading offices trading with Japanese counterparties. The following is a summary of their advice: A. Cash Settled Derivatives Transactions 1. Swap, Options and Other Financial Derivative Transactions Based on the current practice of the Japanese tax authorities, standard swaps, options and similar financial transactions with symmetrical payment flows should not be subject to withholding tax. However, to the extent that Enron transactions involve asymmetrical payments, concern exists that imputed interest from the imbedded loan could be subject to interest withholding tax. 2. Consumption Tax (VAT) and Excise Taxes Although Japan imposes a 5% consumption tax (VAT), financial transactions are generally not subject to the consumption tax, so cash settled derivative transactions should generally not be subject to consumption tax. Japan imposes various excise taxes, some of which apply to commodities that are the subject to Enron Online transactions, such as petroleum excise tax. Such excise taxes generally apply to physical importation and domestic sale and delivery of covered products and should generally not apply to purely financial derivatives transactions which reference commodity prices. 3. Collateral for Derivatives Transactions If Enron entities will take collateral from Japan-based customers in connection with derivative transactions, depending upon the specific arrangements, withholding tax liability might arise. For example, if an Enron trading entity takes cash collateral from a Japan-based customer and pays interest on it, such interest payments could be subject to local withholding tax when paid to the Japanese resident customer. B. Physically Settled Transactions 1. Consumption Tax Japan imposes consumption tax (VAT) on the importation of tangible goods and on domestic transfers of tangible goods. Consumption tax should be applicable to imports of all physical commodities indicated at the Enron Online website, including natural gas, LNG, petroleum and derivatives, coal and pulp and paper. Consequently, commodity contracts for physical settlement should provide that ownership of the commodity will pass outside Japan to the Japan-based customer. As owner of the products upon import, the Japan-based customer would act as importer for consumption tax purposes and in that capacity would handle formalities upon import, pay import consumption tax and then credit or seek a refund for the resulting input consumption tax. If, instead, the title to the commodities is transferred after such commodities enter Japan, each Enron entity that sells to Japan would be required to register as a taxpayer for consumption tax purposes, pay consumption tax upon import and file consumption tax returns. While such an arrangement is feasible, in practice, other industries have encountered resistance from customs authorities (who administer the import consumption tax system) to the designation of a non-resident entity as formal importer. 2. Excise Tax Japan imposes an excise tax on the importation and transfer of various commodities, including natural gas, LNG, crude oil, and refined petroleum products. Petrochemicals may also be subject to excise tax depending upon the specific product. Other commodities listed at the website, including coal, plastics (except if a specific product were characterized as a petrochemical subject to excise tax), and pulp and paper, are not subject to excise tax. Again, Enron entities should transfer ownership of commodities before they reach Japan so that the Japan-based customer acts as importer and has responsibility for payment of excise taxes. C. Tax Representations The trading offices considered were those located in the US, the UK, Singapore, Australia, Canada, Spain and Norway. Japan has tax treaties in force with all of these countries. Consequently, with respect to GTCs entered into with these trading offices, the tax payor and payee representations may provide that: (1) the counterparty agree and represent that withholding tax will not apply and will not be deducted from payments it makes to Enron entities, and (2) with respect to payments the counterparty will receive from Enron entities, it is eligible to claim relief under the business profits article of an applicable tax treaty and does not have a permanent establishment in the paying Enron entity,s jurisdiction. Please let me know if you have any questions, need any additional information or would like me to forward our outside advisor,s memo on this subject to you. Best regards, Susan