2 May 2001, 12:18 UTC
Re: BEA - ENRON: NONDISCLOSURE AGREEMENT/LETTER]
- From
- Mark Greenberg mark.greenberg@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 2 May 2001 05:18:00 -0700 (PDT)
Steve -
Thanks for the response. I wanted to focus on the non-solicitiation
provisions as this is as important to us as it is to BEA. I have attached
below a copy of more "standard" language that we would like to see in a
mutual non-solicitation situation. Please take a look at this and let me
know your thoughts.
There is an internal process that must be followed in approving a mutual
non-solicitation provision. Accordingly, if this language is acceptable,
please let me know as soon as possible so that I can initiate the process.
I will be out of the office for the next few days, but will be getting my
e-mail messages (usually at night).
Thanks for the cooperation.
Mark
Senior Counsel, EWS
Phone: 713-345-8897
Facsimile: 713-646-3490
E-Mail: Mark.Greenberg@enron.com
Steve Howarth <steve.howarth@bea.com>
05/01/2001 06:59 PM
To: Mark.Greenberg@enron.com
cc: Tana.Jones@enron.com, Mike Thack <mike.thack@bea.com>, Francis Minor
<fminor@bea.com>
Subject: BEA - ENRON: NONDISCLOSURE AGREEMENT/LETTER]
Mark,
Thanks for the feedback. I think that the only open issue is the Section
5
nonsolicitation provision. BEA has a corporate policy against
nonsolicitation commitments,
primarily because of the administrative burden in keeping track of such
obligations. Of
course, it would be extremely short sighted of BEA to target a customer's
employees. The
only way that BEA could consider any such commitment would be to make the
provisions
mutual. As a practical matter, BEA is more at risk of having a customer
solicit its
employees - who are experts with the BEA software in which a customer is
interested - than
is our customer whose employees are experts at the customer's business in
which BEA is not
engaged.
I have attached a revised draft of the NDA letter in which I have
incorporated your
feedback and added in a mutual nonsolicitation provision.
Does this work for you?
Regards,
Steve
Mark.Greenberg@enron.com wrote:
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> Steve - > > Thanks for the comments. Here are my responses: > > 1. Introductory Paragraph - Section (a) is unacceptable as this places an > administrative burden on Enron that currently does not exist. Section (b) > is acceptable. > > 2. Paragraph 3 - Changes are acceptable. > > 3. Paragraph 4 - Changes in this section are acceptable, however, it is > Enron's strong preference that no indemnity language be included. > > 4. Paragraph 5 - Deletion of this provision is unacceptable. > > 5. Paragraph 6 - This deletion is fine. > > 6. Paragraph 7 - This change is acceptable. > > 7. Paragraph 9 - This change is acceptable. > > If we still need to discuss the above items, please call me. Otherwise, > please confirm that we can move forward based upon your changes and Enron's > responses. > > Thanks. > > Mark > Senior Counsel, EWS > Phone: 713-345-8897 > Facsimile: 713-646-3490 > E-Mail: Mark.Greenberg@enron.com > > > Steve Howarth > <steve.howart To: mark.greenberg@enron.com > h@bea.com> cc: > Subject: [Fwd: BEA - ENRON: NONDISCLOSURE > 05/01/2001 AGREEMENT/LETTER] > 11:52 AM > > > > Mark, > > Sorry, but I misspelled your name when I first sent the following > message this morning. > > Regards, > > Steve > > X-Mozilla-Status2: 00000000 > Message-ID: <3AEEE8FB.2FBD727D@bea.com> > Date: Tue, 01 May 2001 10:48:59 -0600 > From: Steve Howarth <steve.howarth@bea.com> > X-Mailer: Mozilla 4.61 [en] (Win98; I) > X-Accept-Language: en > MIME-Version: 1.0 > To: mark.greenburg@enron.com > CC: Francis Minor <fminor@bea.com>, Mike Thack <mike.thack@bea.com>, > Chuck Hixson <chuck.hixson@bea.com> > Subject: BEA - ENRON: NONDISCLOSURE AGREEMENT/LETTER > Content-Type: multipart/mixed ; boundary=" > ------------2161B611D0F97A4065FF80B8" > > Mark, > > I have been asked to review the proposed NDA/letter submitted by > Enron to BEA. Attached are redlined and clean versions of Rev2 of the > letter showing our proposed modifications. If this Rev2 is acceptable, > I will be pleased to print, sign and return to you the clean version on > BEA's behalf. > > Please feel free to contact me at 720.528.6007 if you have any > questions. > > Regards, > > Steve > > (See attached file: ENRON NDA 01 05 01, rev2redline.doc) > (See attached file: ENRON NDA 01 05 01, rev2clean.doc) > (See attached file: steve.howarth.vcf) > (See attached file: steve.howarth.vcf) > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > Name: ENRON NDA 01 05 01, rev2redline.doc > ENRON NDA 01 05 01, rev2redline.doc Type: Winword File (application/msword) > Encoding: base64 > > Name: ENRON NDA 01 05 01, rev2clean.doc > ENRON NDA 01 05 01, rev2clean.doc Type: Winword File (application/msword) > Encoding: base64 - ENRON NDA 01 05 01, rev3redline.doc - ENRON NDA 01 05 01, rev3clean.doc - steve.howarth.vcf