30 Apr 2001, 08:17 UTC
IEP News 4/30
- From
- Jean Munoz jmunoz@mcnallytemple.com
- To
-
Andy Brown, andy brown, Carolyn A Baker, rescalante@riobravo-gm.com, Robert Weisenmiller, curtis_l_kebler@reliantenergy.com, dean.nistetter@dynegy.com, dkk@eslawfirm.com, GTBL@dynegy.com, smutny@iepa.com, Jeff Dasovich, Joe Ronan
and 68 more
john.g.larrea@williams.com, Julee Malinowski-Ball, Kassandra Gough, kent.palmerton@williams.com, lale@dynegy.com, mmoretti@mccabeandcompany.net, Marty Wilson, rmcnally@mcnallytemple.com, nam.nguyen@powersrc.com, Kelli Norton, paula.hall-collins@williams.com, jackp@calpine.com, rwhyde@duke-energy.com, Roger Pelote, stephanie-newell@reliantenergy.com, smara@enron.com, Tom Ross, tcwillia@duke-energy.com, alex.sugaoka@uaecorp.com, william_carlson@wastemanagement.com, billw@calpine.com, bellery@spi-ind.com, bob.gates@enron.com, cody.carter@williams.com, curt.hatton@gen.pge.com, David Parquet, dean_gosselin@fpl.com, fernley.doug@epenergy.com, dnelsen@gwfpower.com, ed.tomeo@uaecorp.com, eileenk@calpine.com, eric.eisenman@gen.pge.com, frank.derosa@gen.pge.com, frazier_blaylock@ogden-energy.com, hap_boyd@enron.com, jack.hawks@gen.pge.com, elliottsa@earthlink.net, jgreco@caithnessenergy.com, jweisgall@aol.com, ccastillo@riobravo-gm.com, kellyl@enxco.com, khoffman@caithnessenergy.com, kfickett@usgen.com, Lynn.A.Lednicky@dynegy.com, marty_mcfadden@ogden-energy.com, paula_soos@ogden-energy.com, rjhickok@duke-energy.com, rskoebbe@powerworksinc.com, rllamkin@seiworldwide.com, ain@worldnet.att.net, siliff@riobravo-gm.com, steve_ponder@fpl.com, twetzel@thermoecotek.com, wfhall2@duke-energy.com, trusso@mcnallytemple.com, sadlersa@earthlink.net, mstultz@epsa.org, rtemple@mcnallytemple.com, Tracy Fairchild, megan.beiser@edelman.com, deborah.fiorito@dynegy.com, Lynne Church, Katie Kaplan, Thomas McMorrow, suzy.l.rodriguez@dynegy.com, ppitts@wiredworld1.com, mnobili@cal-lobby.com, scott.chavez@sen.ca.gov - Date
- Mon, 30 Apr 2001 01:17:00 -0700 (PDT)
Today's news, and some from the weekend, in the following order: A year later, energy crisis shows no signs of cooling off, By Ed Mendel , San Diego Union Tribune April 30, 2001 (Quotes ??? ???Smutny on behalf of IEP) The Daily News of Los Angeles, April 27, 2001 Friday, Valley Edition, NEWS; ????Pg. N9, 275 words, PROPOSED LAW PUTS BOUNTY ON ENERGY MANIPULATORS, Staff ????And Wire Services (Quotes Smutny on behalf of IEP) San Jose Mercury News, April 27, 2001, Friday, SJ-ELECTRIC-SUIT, 245 words, ????Santa Clara County, Calif., Joins Lawsuit against Electric Suppliers, By ????John Woolfolk (Quotes Smutny on behalf of IEP) FERC Considers Imposing a Fee on Electricity Sales in California ????? ???Updated: Monday, April 30, 2001 12:40 AM?ET ????-- Dow Jones News Wire? ? Los Angeles Times, April 30, 2001, Monday,, Home Edition, Page 3, 792 words ????, CAPITOL JOURNAL; ?CALIFORNIA AND THE WEST; ??How Sales Tax Is Falling ????Through a Loophole, GEORGE SKELTON, SACRAMENTO Los Angeles Times, April 30, 2001, Monday,, Home Edition, Page 3, 1808 ????words, CALIFORNIA AND THE WEST; ??THE CALIFORNIA ENERGY CRISIS; ??LIST OF ????PG&E CREDITORS SHOWS FIRM'S WIDE REACH IN BUSINESS; ??BANKRUPTCY: IT ????INCLUDES SMALL AND BIG COMPANIES, GOVERNMENT AGENCIES AND FORMER EMPLOYEES., ????TIM REITERMAN, TIMES STAFF WRITER, SAN FRANCISCO Los Angeles Times, April 30, 2001, Monday,, Home Edition, Page 3, 1228 ????words, CALIFORNIA AND THE WEST; ??THE CALIFORNIA ENERGY CRISIS; ??POWER WOES ????COMPLICATE DISCUSSIONS ON BUDGET; ??FUNDING: GOV. DAVIS' PLAN FOR NEXT YEAR ????FACES DEMANDS FOR BILLIONS AS A RESERVE AND TO CUSHION ELECTRICITY RATE ????HIKES., DAN MORAIN, TIMES STAFF WRITER, SACRAMENTO Los Angeles Times, April 30, 2001, Monday,, Home Edition, Page 7, 839 words ????, COMMENTARY; ??WILL THE FERC SEE THE LIGHT ON THE LAW?, FRANK A. WOLAK, ????Frank A. Wolak, an economics professor at Stanford University, is, chairman ????of the Market Surveillance Committee of the California, Independent System ????Operator The New York Times, April 30, 2001, Monday, Late Edition - Final, Section ????A; Page 1; Column 5; Business/Financial Desk, 1444 words, While a Utility ????May Be Failing, Its Owner Is Not, By By RICHARD A. OPPEL Jr. and LAURA M. ????HOLSON The San Francisco Chronicle, APRIL 30, 2001, MONDAY,, FINAL EDITION, NEWS;, ????Pg. A3, 1108 words, NEWSMAKER PROFILE; ???Nettie Hoge; ???Taking on power; ????Consumer advocate revels in uphill battle, Chuck Squatriglia The Washington Post, April 30, 2001, Monday, Final Edition, A SECTION; Pg. ????A03, 1669 words, Energy Forecast for Summer: No Blackouts but Price Spikes; ????Grid Managers Promote Conservation, Await New Plants, William Claiborne, ????Washington Post Staff Writer, CHICAGO The Associated Press State & Local Wire, April 30, 2001, Monday, BC cycle, ????9:49 AM Eastern Time, State and Regional, 594 words, Developments in ????California's energy crisis, By The Associated Press AP Online, April 29, 2001; Sunday, Domestic, non-Washington, general news ????item, 1313 words, Geothermal Plants Need More Steam, JENNIFER COLEMAN, ????MIDDLETOWN, Calif. The Associated Press State & Local Wire, April 29, 2001, Sunday, BC cycle, ????State and Regional, 413 words, Guns in schools, deregulation delay on ????lawmakers' agenda, By BRAD CAIN, Associated Press Writer, SALEM, Ore. Idaho Falls Post Register, April 29, 2001 Sunday, News; Pg. a1, 530 words, ????Plenty of blame to go around for West's power woes, PAUL MENSER Los Angeles Times, April 29, 2001, Sunday,, Home Edition, Page 6, 1312 ????words, THE STATE; ??HOW KILOWATT SOCIALISM SAVED L.A. FROM THE ENERGY CRISIS ????, JEFF STANSBURY, Jeff Stansbury is a PhD candidate in American history at ????UCLA. His, dissertation is on the role of the labor movement in the building ????of, L.A.'s infrastructure Los Angeles Times, April 29, 2001, Sunday,, Home Edition, Page 4, 558 words ????, CONSERVATION SANDBAGS; ??THE DAVIS ADMINISTRATION NEEDS TO LAUNCH A CRASH ????EDUCATION COURSE TO CONVINCE CALIFORNIANS OF THE SERIOUSNESS OF THE ????ELECTRICITY CRISIS AND THE NEED FOR FAR-REACHING ENERGY-SAVING MEASURES. Los Angeles Times, April 29, 2001, Sunday,, Home Edition, Page 27, 1316 ????words, BUSH: THE FIRST 100 DAYS; ??BUSH IS OFF TO A ROCKY START IN HIS ????HANDLING OF ALL THINGS CALIFORNIAN; ??POLITICS: BUT WHY WOO THE GOLDEN STATE ????WHEN HE CAN'T CARRY IT IN AN ELECTION 'NO MATTER HOW HARD HE TRIES,' ONE ????ANALYST POINTS OUT., RICHARD SIMON, TIMES STAFF WRITER, WASHINGTON Los Angeles Times, April 29, 2001, Sunday,, Home Edition, Page 2, 1290 ????words, WEEK IN REVIEW; ??TOP 10 STORIES / APRIL 23-27, Lisa Girion and ????Terril Yue Jones and Sallie Hofmeister and James Bates and Peter Pae and ????Jeff Leeds and Nancy Rivera Brooks and Peter Gosselin The New York Times, April 29, 2001, Sunday, Late Edition - Final, Section ????4; Page 17; Column 1; Editorial Desk, 756 words, Reckonings; The Real Wolf, ????By PAUL KRUGMAN Sacramento Bee, April 29, 2001, Sunday, Pg. A1;, 1323 words, Diesel plants ????spark concern They're expected to generate big air-quality problems when ????predicted summer blackouts hit., Chris Bowman and Stuart Leavenworth Bee ????Staff Writers Sacramento Bee, April 29, 2001, Sunday, Pg. A1, 1544 words, Why Edison, ????PG&E split on strategy, Dale Kasler Bee Staff Writer Sacramento Bee, April 29, 2001, Sunday, Pg. A3, 679 words, What will be ????fallout from California's energy meltdown?, Dan Walters The San Francisco Chronicle, APRIL 29, 2001, SUNDAY,, FINAL EDITION, ????INSIGHT;, Pg. D1, 1419 words, The energy crisis is good for you, Louis ????Freedberg Ventura County Star, April 29, 2001 Sunday, Editorials; Pg. B09, 704 words, ????Reality is what's needed for real policy ?GOVERNOR: Consumers deserve to get ????real facts from Davis., Dan Walters Los Angeles Times, April 28, 2001, Saturday,, Home Edition, Page 19, 679 ????words, OFFICIALS CALL PRICE STABILITY PLAN ILLEGAL; ??UTILITIES: AGENCY ????CHIEFS SAY THE FEDERAL PROPOSAL COULD ALSO CAUSE MORE BLACKOUTS THIS SUMMER. ????, NANCY VOGEL and MIGUEL BUSTILLO, TIMES STAFF WRITERS, SACRAMENTO Los Angeles Times, April 28, 2001, Saturday,, Home Edition, Page 19, 688 ????words, BILL COULD FOIL DAVIS' ELECTRICITY OFFENSIVE; ??POWER: CONGRESSMAN ????WANTS TO LET SMALL PRODUCERS SELL ON WHOLESALE MARKET. BACKERS SAY PLAN ????WOULD BOOST SUPPLY, BUT FOES SEE IT COSTING CALIFORNIA DEARLY., JULIE TAMAKI ????and MIGUEL BUSTILLO, TIMES STAFF WRITERS, SACRAMENTO Los Angeles Times, April 28, 2001, Saturday,, Home Edition, Page 2, 137 ????words, BRIEFLY / ENERGY; ??PUC ORDERS UTILITIES TO POST BLACKOUT DATA, Nancy ????Rivera Brooks Sacramento Bee, April 28, 2001, Saturday, Pg. A3;, 1109 words, Cities take ????new look at public power The state's uncertain electricity picture has local ????officials deciding it's time to revisit the idea of municipal utilities., ????Carrie Peyton Bee Staff Writer A year later, energy crisis shows no signs of cooling off By Ed Mendel San Diego Union Tribune April 30, 2001 SACRAMENTO -- The first anniversary of the California energy crisis is coming up next month, and as the Queen of England once remarked when the royal family seemed to deregulate, it's been an "annus horribilis." The horrible year for California began last May when electricity prices suddenly began to soar, triggering a debate about the cause of the mysterious price increase that is likely to continue for years. It started when a three-day heat wave, from May 21 to May 24, set records in some areas of the state and drove up the demand for electricity as Californians sought relief with air conditioning. More record heat June 14 in the San Francisco Bay Area strained the overloaded system of Pacific Gas & Electric and resulted in rolling blackouts, the planned temporary power outages that some fear may be routine this summer. The average price of electricity on the now-defunct Power Exchange soared to $120 per megawatt hour in June, five times higher than the same month the previous year, and remained roughly at that level until skyrocketing to $377 in December. San Diego sounded the statewide alarm last summer as San Diego Gas & Electric, the first utility to be deregulated, passed along much of the higher cost of electricity to its customers, until legislation rolled back and capped the utility's rates in September. The executive director of a San Diego consumers group, the Utility Consumers' Action Network, thinks the generators and the marketers of power, using sophisticated computer methods, learned something as the heat wave drove up the demand for power. "It was the first time the generators had an opportunity to see how high the price could go," said UCAN'S Michael Shames. "It was their primer. It was Gouge 101." State Sen. Steve Peace, D-El Cajon, who chaired a two-house committee that completed the deregulation plan in 1996, had seen routine monitoring data suggesting that the power market was being manipulated to drive up prices. Peace took the unusual step last June of personally urging the adoption of a much lower price cap by the board of the agency that makes last-minute power purchases to maintain the grid, the Independent System Operator. But the motion failed by a single vote. The consumer representative who cast the decisive vote against the lower cap resigned afterward with a blast at Peace, complaining of heavy-handed pressure. Peace is unapologetic. He believes that stronger action by the ISO last June would have sent a signal that might have discouraged market manipulation. "It's just like the Federal Reserve mis-timing an interest-rate move," Peace said. The former ISO chairman, who represents generators, cited an ISO report attributing the price increase last May to the heat wave, power plant outages, less hydroelectric power and higher prices for the natural gas used by power plants. "I think all of those things showing up at the same time resulted in significantly higher prices," said Jan Smutny-Jones of the Independent Energy Producers. Why power prices remained at high levels and even soared last winter, instead of dropping as usual, is more difficult to explain. The ISO contended last month that generators overcharged by more than $6 billion from last May through February. But federal regulators, who have their critics, have found only $125 million in overcharges, making it an "annus marvelous" for generators. Ed Mendel is Capitol bureau chief for the Union-Tribune. Copyright 2001 Union-Tribune Publishing Co. The Daily News of Los Angeles April 27, 2001 Friday, Valley Edition SECTION: NEWS; Pg. N9 LENGTH: 275 words HEADLINE: PROPOSED LAW PUTS BOUNTY ON ENERGY MANIPULATORS BYLINE: Staff And Wire Services BODY: ??California stepped up its war on the power industry Thursday as state legislators offered to pay millions of dollars to "bounty hunters" who provide information leading to the arrest and conviction of energy executives and others who manipulate the electricity market. ???California "is being plundered by an energy cartel," said Lt. Gov. Cruz Bustamente, who is promoting a bill that would level criminal penalties for exploiting energy markets. ?"If what they are doing isn't illegal, it ought to be." ???Bustamente was one of a crowd of state leaders who went before microphones. ???On the floor of the Assembly, Speaker Bob Hertzberg, D-Van Nuys, rallied his Democratic colleagues behind a bill to create a state power authority with equally blistering attacks on private power suppliers. ???But after Thursday's hearing before a Senate committee formed to investigate alleged price-fixing in the energy market, committee chairman Joe Dunn, D-Garden Grove, told a reporter: "I've never seen this much smoke when there wasn't a fire." ???Power generators insist they are operating fairly and say there is no evidence of them acting outside the law. ???Jan Smutny-Jones, executive director of the Independent Energy Producers Association, dismissed the harsh rhetoric as unproductive. "Putting people in prison isn't going to encourage more generation," Smutny-Jones said, warning that the political posturing would make energy generators think twice about investing in California. ???Also on Thursday, experts said federally ordered caps on wholesale electricity prices won't necessarily mean California will escape rolling blackouts this summer. Copyright 2001 San Jose Mercury News San Jose Mercury News April 27, 2001, Friday KR-ACC-NO: SJ-ELECTRIC-SUIT LENGTH: 245 words HEADLINE: Santa Clara County, Calif., Joins Lawsuit against Electric Suppliers BYLINE: By John Woolfolk BODY: ??Santa Clara County agreed Thursday to join a lawsuit against power suppliers, alleging they conspired to raise prices and boost profits while subjecting consumers to higher bills and rolling blackouts. ??The county is the first to join the suit originally filed by San Francisco in January. ?The suit seeks refunds for consumers of more than $ 1 billion in alleged excess electricity profits. ??"The San Francisco suit contains significant allegations of manipulation and collusion by the wholesalers, resulting in the disastrous consequences we're all familiar with," said lead deputy county counsel Alan Tieger. "We looked at the evidence on which those allegations were grounded and found they were indeed supported by the evidence, expert and otherwise." ??The suit names a dozen electricity generating and marketing companies, including Duke Energy and Enron Energy Marketing. ??Similar claims have been filed by three water districts in the San Diego area, and two class-action lawsuits by private attorneys on behalf of consumers are pending against power suppliers. ??The companies have vigorously denied the charges. ??"I don't think there will be any evidence of illegal activity by anyone," said Jan Smutny-Jones, executive director of the Independent Energy Producers Association, when asked about various government probes. ??----- ??To see more of the San Jose Mercury News, or to subscribe to the newspaper, go to http://www.sjmercury.com FERC Considers Imposing a Fee on Electricity Sales in California ???? Updated: Monday, April 30, 2001 12:40 AM?ET ????? ? Such a surcharge, at least in the short run, would fall hardest on the state of California, which since January has spent more than $5 billion buying power because the utilities have been unable to meet their obligations. For now, the idea is nothing more than a proposal that occupies one paragraph buried in a 39-page order issued Thursday concerning changes to California's flawed deregulated electricity market. The commission is seeking public comment on the surcharge proposal for 30 days. After that, it will decide whether to implement it. The fee was proposed by Commission Chairman Curt Hebert, a Mississippi Republican, as a way "to stabilize the market," he said Friday, "since part of the problem in California has to do with nonpayment of bills by the utilities." But the provision also has the potential to funnel billions of dollars to energy suppliers at a time when those payments are the subject of intense negotiation. One of the utilities, PG&E Corp.'s Pacific Gas & Electric Co. (PCG, news, msgs), filed for protection from creditors under U.S. bankruptcy law on April 6, hoping to settle its claims with power suppliers for something less than face value. Representatives of Pacific Gas & Electric and Edison International's (EIX, news, msgs) Southern California Edison declined to comment on the FERC proposal Friday. The surcharge idea faces stiff opposition from some state officials, one of whom said it amounts to an "unwarranted intrusion" into state jurisdiction. Loretta Lynch, president of the California Public Utilities Commission, said imposition of a surcharge would put pressure on wholesale-power costs that already are too high. Bulk power cost $7 billion in California in 1999 and topped $27 billion last year as prices careened out of control. Ms. Lynch said she opposes the surcharge provision and the entire order given Thursday, but that it will be up to the full commission to decide how -- or whether -- to file a challenge at FERC. A spokesman for Gov. Gray Davis said "the governor would be strongly opposed to any attempt to siphon money away from the state" and expects to lodge an objection. Los Angeles Times ?????????????????????April 30, 2001, Monday, Home Edition SECTION: Part A; Part 1; Page 3; Metro Desk LENGTH: 792 words HEADLINE: CAPITOL JOURNAL; CALIFORNIA AND THE WEST; How Sales Tax Is Falling Through a Loophole BYLINE: GEORGE SKELTON DATELINE: SACRAMENTO BODY: ??Dot-coms are in distress and laying off. Silicon Valley is a home buyer's bazaar. The Nasdaq is nauseous. So is this any time to be siccing the tax collector on Internet retailers? ??You bet. Coddling these techie traders with tax favors doesn't seem to be helping them much anyway. So why not treat e-tailers like everyone else, like brick-and-mortar merchants? Treat everybody evenhandedly. ??That's the view of Assemblywoman Carole Migden (D-San Francisco), assertive chair of the Assembly Appropriations Committee. For the second straight year, Migden is pushing a bill she says will close a loophole that benefits some Internet retailers. She insists it's about fairly enforcing existing law, not about a new Web tax, as critics claim. ??Present law requires Internet e-tailers to collect the sales tax if they have a physical presence in California, such as a traditional brick-and-mortar store. But some big outfits have created separate out-of-state subsidiaries to handle their Internet orders. Same goods, same ads--with a large tax loophole because the subsidiary ostensibly does not have a physical presence in California. ??Never mind that an unsatisfied customer of bookseller Barnes & Noble dot-com, for example, can return the Internet purchase to the local Barnes & Noble store. ??Many e-tailers with dual "bricks-and-clicks" operations do collect the sales tax from Internet customers. Migden cites Macy's, Wal-Mart, REI, Hewlett-Packard and Eddie Bauer. Others refuse, she says: Barnes & Noble, Borders Books, KB Toys, Gateway Computers, Radio Shack. ??Her bill simply "clarifies" that the sales tax applies when the e-tailer is affiliated with a California business, sells identical products, and they market jointly. ??"Right now," Migden contends, "certain big businesses blatantly violate the tax law and put hard-working, honest small business people at a disadvantage." ??* ??Gov. Gray Davis is miffed at Migden, she hears. He vetoed her bill last year, declaring "it would send the wrong signal about California's international role as the incubator of the dot-com community." Internet marketing "must be given time to mature," he maintained. ??Now Migden's at it again. "The governor's exercised. He thinks I'm jamming him," she says. "But I'm moving the bill. He can veto it if he wants. I'm putting it on his desk." ??It already has cleared the Assembly tax committee and will shoot out of her panel Wednesday, headed for the Assembly floor. Last year, Democrats backed the bill. Republicans opposed it, siding with the Democratic governor. ??Davis fears some future opponent will claim he signed a bill to tax the Internet. Migden is frustrated by that Internet tax tag, calling it "a lazy misinterpretation." ??"I'm not picking on e-commerce," she protests. "I'm picking on the multinationals who are arrogantly evading the law in complicity with the state Board of Equalization." ??That would be, in particular, Republican board member Dean Andal of Stockton. "It's the usual liberal nut case bill," Andal says. "Just a bill chasing no problem." ??* ??The BOE administers the sales tax. And Andal does agree that if an Internet purchase can be returned to a store, the e-tailer legally must collect the tax. "We've been looking into that," he says. ??The board shouldn't have to look far. Barnes & Noble tells e-customers right on its Web site that "you can return purchases to ANY Barnes & Noble store for in-store credit." ??But other than that, Andal contends, a company has a constitutional right to create an out-of-state subsidiary to avoid taxes. ??And, he notes, we're talking about relative pennies: $ 17 million annually, the BOE estimates, compared to $ 39 billion in total California sales tax collections. That lost revenue would cover only about seven hours worth of electricity the state now is buying for utilities. ??But e-tailing is bound to grow. Tax avoidance could become significant, benefiting dot-coms while discriminating against small retailers and the poor who cannot afford Internet access. ??Migden will be in a strong position to change sales tax policy if she wins her race next year for the five-member BOE. She's the early front-runner. ??Her concern--her reverence--is for the local booksellers, the mom-and-pop merchants, the neighbor shopkeepers who can be smothered by the big tax evaders. "The little guy with the books stacked in the back," she says, "sweeping the sidewalk, putting on extra locks, obeying the law and collecting taxes--trying to make a go." ??Davis wants to be seen as a futuristic, New Age pol, worthy of campaign donations from wealthy Web masters. But he can manage that without tromping on his Democratic roots as protector of the little guy. LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????13 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ?????????????????????April 30, 2001, Monday, Home Edition SECTION: Part A; Part 1; Page 3; Metro Desk LENGTH: 1808 words HEADLINE: CALIFORNIA AND THE WEST; THE CALIFORNIA ENERGY CRISIS; LIST OF PG&E CREDITORS SHOWS FIRM'S WIDE REACH IN BUSINESS; BANKRUPTCY: IT INCLUDES SMALL AND BIG COMPANIES, GOVERNMENT AGENCIES AND FORMER EMPLOYEES. BYLINE: TIM REITERMAN, TIMES STAFF WRITER DATELINE: SAN FRANCISCO BODY: ??It reads like a phone book: Able Auto Body, Able Building Maintenance, Able Fence Co., Able Printing, Able Termite & Pest Control. . . . ??These companies are among about 50,000 entries on Pacific Gas & Electric Co.'s roster of creditors recently filed in U.S. Bankruptcy Court. ??Another company, A&J Electrical Cable Corp. of Hayward, has supplied PG&E with utility cables since 1980. But now the unpaid bills are hitting the $ 100,000 mark--and that is a big deal to a relatively small business. ??"Who would ever think that PG&E would be in bankruptcy?" said owner Magdalene Reilly. "This is something affecting people. I've got a lot of paychecks on Friday. ??"We have orders for the rest of the year from PG&E ," she added. "It is a question: Do you decide to ship? . . . We probably will. They are a good customer." ??When PG&E filed for Chapter 11 protection from creditors April 6, businesses from California to Canada were caught by surprise. The names of the 20 biggest creditors, some with billion-dollar claims, were filed with the court. The utility also submitted a list of potential creditors--more than 3,500 pages worth. ??The roster speaks to the remarkable economic clout and reach of a company that prospered for almost a century before plunging into the third-biggest bankruptcy case in U.S. history. It provides a glimpse into the relationships between a giant utility--the state's largest--and businesses of all sorts and sizes. And it underscores the high stakes as a bankruptcy judge reorders PG&E's financial affairs and decides in the coming months, if not years, who should be paid and how much. ??The case, said U.S. bankruptcy trustee Linda Ekstrom Stanley, "has a ripple effect. . . . Creditors are affected, and they can't pay their bills either." ??There are small companies and conglomerates that sold power to PG&E. ??There are financial institutions from Wall Street to San Francisco's Montgomery Street that lent money or provided services. ??There are government agencies at all levels, even the California Public Utilities Commission. ??There are some retired PG&E employees and officers, including at least one of the company's former chief executive officers. ??But there also are vendors that have provided goods and services to PG&E for years: tree trimming around power lines, bodywork for the utility's truck fleet, fencing for its vast land holdings, calibration of meters, fans to cool electrical transformers, printing of brochures, signs for office doors, flight suits for aviators who patrol power lines, limousine service for traveling executives. ??No dollar amounts are attached to names on the master list. But records and interviews with dozens of creditors show that the sums owed range from hundreds of millions of dollars to very little--or nothing at all. Many of the smaller creditors were unaware they were on the roster until contacted by The Times. ??PG&E used to buy pump filters from California Pump & Supply in Sacramento. ??"We just closed out their account because they owed us $ 29," said office manager Lisa Giordano. "It's a hassle to get anyone over there. I just wrote it off." ??The utility bought $ 38 worth of plants from Forest Nursery in Los Osos, west of San Luis Obispo. "It's nothing to go to court about, especially since they paid it," said bookkeeper Lori Parsons. ??A wine wholesaler, an ice cream company and a coastal hotel are listed. So is Sing A Long Productions in Burlingame, which supples disc jockeys and karaoke. ??"I am sure we have done business with PG&E and other companies that have parties from time to time," said owner Nick Foster. "Maybe somebody forgot that we did not get paid." ??PG&E spokesman Ron Low said the list includes everyone to whom the utility wrote a check in the last two years, such as homeowners who received energy conservation rebates and retirees who received checks related to benefits. ??"It was an attempt to notify anybody who possibly could have a claim against the company and to cast the widest net possible," he said. ??Several PG&E retirees, such as Robert W. Oliver of Berkeley, were baffled by their inclusion on the list. "I draw a little pension," said Oliver, who was a personnel executive and left the company in 1980. "It's a vested pension." ??Another retiree on the list is former Chief Executive Richard A. Clarke. ??He and about 10 other former high-ranking PG&E executives or their survivors have retained an attorney to help ensure that their retirement benefits are protected during the bankruptcy case. ??"We don't want someone to get the idea that this is a bunch of well-heeled executives trying to get a piece of the action," said the attorney, John T. Hansen. "Some in our group are widows of former executives who depend on the pensions they receive as survivors." ??Hansen said some retired executives have deferred-compensation packages that might be considered a general unsecured bankruptcy claim. ??One concern, he said, is that PG&E Chairman Robert D. Glynn Jr. wrote recently in a San Francisco Chronicle op-ed article that health care plans and other benefits "for employees and most retirees" will continue. ??"We would want to know what 'most' is," Hansen said. "We want to sort it out." ??Low of PG&E said fewer than 100 retired employees, most former officers, "have a portion of their pension that is unsecured." That means their claims will be handled in Bankruptcy Court with those of other unsecured creditors whose debts are not backed by utility assets. ??The spokesman emphasized that ex-employees could be on the list because they received a check from the company for something. ??Companies and individuals on the list, PG&E said, will be contacted and given an opportunity to state their claims, which the utility will file with the court May 11. ??Meanwhile, the effects of the bankruptcy filing continue to ripple beyond the utility. ??PG&E's action hit AA Safe & Lock Co. in Santa Cruz particularly hard. The firm replaces keys and locks for PG&E offices and trucks. ??"We are a small business, and it is a big account," said owner Paul Bing, who declined to say what the utility owes. "We haven't been doing as much for them since the whole crisis started." ??A Hayward firm that conducts environmental testing when PG&E remodels or razes buildings is out money too. Ken Byk, president of Forensic Analytical, would not provide a figure but said: "I am obviously concerned. . . . They are a good customer, but any time you run into these problems, it's disappointing." ??California Steam Inc. of Sacramento services PG&E pressure washers and water recyclers at its truck-cleaning facilities. "I have just a couple of invoices out," said service manager Bruce Amlin. The debt, he said, is less than $ 500. ??A similar amount is owed to California Turbo Inc. in Ontario. Sales manager Cam Young said the utility has not paid for eight fans used to cool electrical transformers. "We're a small business," Young said, adding with a laugh: "We might have to eat peanut butter and jelly for four or five months." ??Within days of the bankruptcy filing, PG&E sent about 12,000 creditors letters that began: "Valued Goods and Services Provider: . . . Unfortunately, the bankruptcy code precludes payment for goods and services received prior to the date of filing. Payments on this pre-petition debt will be settled as part of the plan of reorganization." The company assured vendors that they will be paid for any future purchases. ??Some are not only forgiving, they are outspokenly loyal to PG&E. ??The relationship between the utility and AG Signs of Stockton spans two decades. When Tony Guebara was starting his company, PG&E gave him business. "They try to help the little guy," he said. "Just about everybody in town is a vendor. They have people here who paint their trucks." ??AG Signs now has five employees and supplies PG&E with door lettering for trucks, name plaques for office doors and signs and flags for construction sites. ??Guebara said the utility's debt does not worry him: "PG&E has treated me real well. If I lose a couple of bucks because of this adversity, that is OK. . . . I don't think we've seen the last of PG&E." ??Many businesses and individuals said they had no idea why the company believes it owes them money. ??Being included on the creditors list left the Vallejo Camp Fire Girls & Boys and other charitable organizations somewhat confused. Officials of one Berkeley church could only speculate that it was listed because PG&E stock was bequeathed to the congregation decades ago. ??Twylah Lemargie, manager of the Cancer Aid Thrift Shop in Grass Valley, said the utility is not even a customer. "PG&E did come in and replaced lots of our ceiling lights with the long tubes," she said. "But it was done free as an energy saver." ??A number of vendors said PG&E's account is paid up. ??The utility rented temporary housing units for workers on a hydroelectric project about two years ago, but California RV Rentals in Rio Lindo is still named as a creditor. "They don't owe me money," said Sandra Weaver, the manager. "If they want to give me some, it's OK." ??Many creditors are health clubs and health care providers: medical and dental offices, foot and joint specialists, pharmacies, chiropractors. ??When informed that the Castro Valley Chamber of Commerce was on the creditors list, the woman who answered the phone laughed uproariously. Then Executive Director Bonnie Dettmer came to the line. ??"I'm going to guess it's membership dues," she said. "They are a member and they have been very supportive. I would bet they belong to every chamber of commerce." ??One creditor is the state agency that PG&E says drove the company into insolvency by not allowing full recovery of its wholesale power costs. ??"They owe us $ 5.9 million . . . for environmental impact reports on PG&E projects," said Paul Clanon, director of the Public Utilities Commission's energy division. "It's a serious amount of money but currently is not having an impact." ??Top 10 Creditors ??The creditors owed the most money by Pacific Gas & Electric Co., according to the company's Chapter 11 filing: ???Creditor ???????????????????????????????????Money owed ???Bank of New York ????????????????????????$2.20 billion ???California Power Exchange ???????????????$1.96 billion ???Bankers Trust Co. ???????????????????????$1.30 billion ???California Independent System Operator ??$1.12 billion ???Bank of America* ?????????????????????????$938 million ???US Bank ??????????????????????????????????$310 million ???Calpine Gilroy Cogeneration LP ????????????$58 million ???Calpine Greenleaf Inc. ????????????????????$49 million ???Crocket Cogen ?????????????????????????????$48 million ???Calpine King City Cogen LLC ???????????????$45 million ??* Heading a group of banks ??Source: U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Northern DIstrict of California GRAPHIC: GRAPHIC: Top 10 Creditors, Los Angeles Times PHOTO: Magdalene Reilly, owner of A&J Electrical Cable Corp. of Hayward, says her company has supplied Pacific Gas & Electric with utility cables since 1980, and that their unpaid bills are now hitting the $100,000 mark. ?PHOTOGRAPHER: ROBERT DURELL / Los Angeles Times PHOTO: "They try to help the little guy," says Tony Guebara, owner of AG Signs in Stockton, of PG&E. He has been doing business with utility for two decades. ?PHOTOGRAPHER: ROBERT DURELL / Los Angeles Times LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????14 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ?????????????????????April 30, 2001, Monday, Home Edition SECTION: Part A; Part 1; Page 3; Metro Desk LENGTH: 1228 words HEADLINE: CALIFORNIA AND THE WEST; THE CALIFORNIA ENERGY CRISIS; POWER WOES COMPLICATE DISCUSSIONS ON BUDGET; FUNDING: GOV. DAVIS' PLAN FOR NEXT YEAR FACES DEMANDS FOR BILLIONS AS A RESERVE AND TO CUSHION ELECTRICITY RATE HIKES. BYLINE: DAN MORAIN, TIMES STAFF WRITER DATELINE: SACRAMENTO BODY: ??Jockeying over the state's next spending plan, a tradition that usually takes place in the summer, already is turning intense as the energy crisis casts a pall over what otherwise might have been relatively painless budget squabbles. ??A key state senator, worried about the slowing economy, is looking for places to pare as much as $ 4 billion from Gov. Gray Davis' proposed $ 104.7-billion budget. And Republicans are beginning to demand that the state spend billions in general tax money to cushion electricity rate hikes of up to 40% being imposed on consumers and businesses. ??Davis won't sign the budget for the 2001-02 fiscal year into law until late June at the earliest. But with California mired in the energy crisis and the economy slowing, the new budget is shaping up to be especially vexing. ??California's largest utility and a major private employer, Pacific Gas & Electric, is in bankruptcy. The state has spent $ 5.2 billion in general tax money to buy electricity, with no end in sight. Even before summer temperatures hit, Sacramento shelled out $ 90 million to buy electricity in a single day last week. ??And the Wall Street rating firm Standard & Poor's, unsure that the state will be reimbursed for the power purchases, lowered California's credit rating two notches for the first time since the recession of the 1990s. ??Brightening an otherwise cloudy situation, income tax payments are meeting or exceeding predictions. More than $ 8 billion in checks from April income tax returns have flooded into the Franchise Tax Board, said Department of Finance economist Ted Gibson. On one day last week, the state's haul was $ 3.6 billion, a record. ??"Receipts are very much on track, I'm relieved to tell you," Gibson said. ??But even as budget writers were exhaling, the payments merely offered proof that the economy was strong last year, back when then-President Bill Clinton was heralding the longest period of economic growth in U.S. history, and Californians' lexicon did not include the term "rolling blackout." ??State income and sales tax receipts softened in the first few months of 2001, an indication that people will be earning less this year--and paying less in taxes next year. ??Seeing trouble ahead, Senate Budget Committee Chairman Steve Peace (D-El Cajon) wants to boost the state's emergency reserve, which was $ 1.9 billion in January. To do that, Peace last week called on budget committee members to come up with a list of cuts totaling $ 2 billion to $ 4 billion. ??Without a larger reserve heading into 2002, Peace said, the slowing economy could force the state to make deep cuts or raise taxes next year, at a time when most legislators and Davis will be running for reelection. ??"The thing to be worried about is not the current year, but the trend line," Peace said. ??He adds a caveat for the spending plan that by law must be in place by July 1: There will be cuts if legislators fail to approve legislation that state Treasurer Phil Angelides says he needs to obtain short-term loans and market long-term bonds to finance electricity purchases. ??Davis and Angelides are preparing the largest bond sale--a way that government borrows money--in U.S. history, as much as $ 12.4 billion. The state would use the proceeds to ease the shock to utility customers of record high electricity prices this year. The bond debt would be paid off over a period of perhaps 15 years. ??Given the size and complexity of the bond issue, many legislators say Angelides may not be able to sell it for months. ??Davis, however, has an immediate need for money. The governor must release a revised state budget within weeks. So, he is pushing for legislators to approve legislation that would allow Angelides to obtain a short-term loan of as much as $ 6 billion. ??At least some of the proceeds of the long-term bonds would be used to pay off the short-term loan--sort of like using one credit card to pay the balance on a second piece of plastic. ??Republican legislators are balking at the idea. ??Back in December, before the state entered the power buying business, GOP legislators had called for $ 3.2 billion in tax cuts. With the energy crisis complicating the financial situation, some Republicans are contending that Davis should use as much as $ 5 billion from the budget surplus to soften the impact of electricity rate hikes. ??"That will be a de facto tax cut," said Senate Republican leader Jim Brulte of Rancho Cucamonga. "Our Democratic friends want to do the bridge financing so they can increase the size of government." ??Republicans are in the minority. But they have a significant voice, because state law requires that both houses of the Legislature approve spending decisions by a two-thirds vote. ??The state Constitution says the budget must be in place by the July 1 start of the new fiscal year. Davis signed his first two budgets on time. Given this year's uncertainties, however, some legislators are thinking twice about making July vacation plans. ??The sudden turnaround may come as a shock to many legislators and lobbyists who seek slices of the state budget pie. ??In recent years, legislators have grown used to the multibillion-dollar windfalls of tax payments, which allowed them to deliver new swimming pools, school programs, museums, parks, social and health care spending, and tax cuts to their constituents. Indeed, the budget in Davis' first two years grew 37%, even as the Democratic governor and legislators cut taxes by $ 3.9 billion. ??In a Legislature populated by term-limited newcomers, only a handful of current legislators were in the Capitol in the early 1990s, when the worst recession to hit California since the Great Depression caused the state budget to actually shrink. Then-Gov. Pete Wilson and the Legislature reacted to a $ 14-billion budget gap by raising taxes by more than $ 5 billion and slashing spending. ??"It is not going to be the pie-in-the-sky budget some of us thought it would be last year and even as late as January," said Sen. Jack O'Connell (D-San Luis Obispo). ??Veterans of the annual summer rite say there is no template for the coming budget fights. Jean Ross of the California Budget Project, a private budget watchdog and advocacy group, said Davis and legislators not only must pay attention to the economy. ??They also must take into account many unknowns: Will the judge overseeing PG&E's bankruptcy proceeding seek to raise rates further? Will federal energy regulators be able to effectively limit wholesale electricity costs? What will the economic impact be of summer blackouts? ??"It's a lot more complex and unpredictable than other years," Ross said. ??Legislators say they are lowering their sights. But letters from state senators requesting money for their favored projects fill five large red binders. "You wouldn't know there is a money shortage based on requests in appropriations," said Assembly Appropriations Committee Chairwoman Carole Migden (D-San Francisco), preparing for what she calls her "hatchet role" of blocking bills that require spending. ??For his part, Davis has not decided to significantly cut back on his proposals, ranging from a sales tax "holiday" timed for back-to-school shopping to plans to clean sewage from beaches. He won't reveal those decisions until he releases his revised spending plan. LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????15 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ?????????????????????April 30, 2001, Monday, Home Edition SECTION: Metro; Part B; Page 7; Op Ed Desk LENGTH: 839 words HEADLINE: COMMENTARY; WILL THE FERC SEE THE LIGHT ON THE LAW? BYLINE: FRANK A. WOLAK, Frank A. Wolak, an economics professor at Stanford University, is, chairman of the Market Surveillance Committee of the California, Independent System Operator BODY: ??Out-of-state firms selling into the California wholesale electricity market at exorbitant prices have been blamed for the current electricity crisis. They are, claim many observers, exercising their market power to raise wholesale electricity prices. ??Although it is not illegal under California or U.S. antitrust law for a firm to exercise its market power, it is illegal to do so under the Federal Power Act. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, or FERC, which regulates the California wholesale electricity market, is the entity charged with enforcing this law. Its refusal to take sufficient actions that would result in "just and reasonable" wholesale electricity rates is the fundamental cause of California's current energy crisis. It is highly unlikely that anything it has done in the last week has changed things at all. ??In 1935, Congress passed the Federal Power Act and required the Federal Power Commission (the predecessor to FERC) to set "just and reasonable" wholesale electricity prices. Just and reasonable prices are those that recover production costs, including a "fair" rate of return on the capital invested by the firm. Moreover, if the FERC finds that wholesale electricity prices are unjust and unreasonable, the Federal Power Act gives it wide-ranging discretion to take actions that result in just and reasonable prices. The FERC can also order refunds for any payments by consumers in excess of just and reasonable prices. ??Almost 10 years ago, the FERC began to allow generators to receive market prices instead of prices set through a cost-of-service regulatory process. However, there is no guarantee that market prices meet the just and reasonable standard required by the Federal Power Act. Markets often set prices substantially in excess of the production costs for significant periods of time. This occurs because one or more firms operating in the market have what economists call market power--the ability of a firm to raise market prices and profit from it. ??However, if no firm possesses market power, the market price should be very close to a price that only recovers production costs. In such a circumstance, the price set by the market satisfies the just and reasonable standard of the Federal Power Act. ??Before it allows any market participant to receive a market price rather than a cost-based price set through a regulatory process, the FERC requires each participant to demonstrate that it does not have market power. In other words, each market participant must submit sworn testimony to the FERC demonstrating it does not have the ability to raise market prices and profit from this behavior. ??Each of the out-of-state generators made these filings before they began selling into the California market, which started in April 1998. Each firm had its authority to receive market prices approved by the FERC for a three-year period that ends before this summer for several of the firms. It is virtually impossible to determine on a prospective basis whether a firm possesses market power. Moreover, the methodology used by the FERC to make this determination uses analytical techniques that have long been acknowledged by the economics profession as grossly inadequate. The events of the past 10 months have demonstrated that contrary to their filings stating otherwise, all of the out-of-state generators possess significant market power. ??A number of independent studies have shown that the market power exercised by these firms has resulted in unjust and unreasonable rates from May 2000, until now. Moreover, in its Dec. 15, 2000 report on the California electricity market, the FERC concluded that wholesale electricity prices during the summer and autumn of 2000 were unjust and unreasonable and reflected the exercise of significant market power. ??Despite its own conclusion, the FERC thus far has refused to set just and reasonable prices for wholesale electricity in California. Instead, the FERC implemented market rule changes that have enhanced the ability of these firms to set excessive wholesale electricity prices. In addition, it has refused to order refunds for any overpayment during the summer and autumn of 2000 for the prices that it deemed unjust and unreasonable. ??Fortunately for California consumers, the California Public Utilities Commission and Gov. Gray Davis refused to be accomplices in the FERC's decision not to enforce the Federal Power Act. They refused to pass on to California consumers prices that the FERC itself had determined were unjust and unreasonable. ??Because these out-of-state firms must apply for renewal of their market-based pricing authority before this summer, the FERC has one more opportunity to set just and reasonable prices for wholesale electricity in California. It has before it several proposals that would enforce all provisions of the Federal Power Act. The health of the California and national economies would be severely undermined if the FERC continues to ignore its legal obligations. LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????16 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 The New York Times Company ??????????????????????????????The New York Times ?????????????????April 30, 2001, Monday, Late Edition - Final SECTION: Section A; Page 1; Column 5; Business/Financial Desk LENGTH: 1444 words HEADLINE: While a Utility May Be Failing, Its Owner Is Not BYLINE: ?By By RICHARD A. OPPEL Jr. and LAURA M. HOLSON BODY: ??Pacific Gas and Electric, the giant California utility, may have just made one of the largest bankruptcy filings in history, but it has been a banner year for the rest of its parent company, the PG& E Corporation. ??In Bethesda, Md., far from the energy crisis in California, another PG& E subsidiary, National Energy Group, earned $162 million last year and ranked as the nation's third-largest power trader. Compensation for the unit's executives soared. Many investors now believe that the subsidiary, just a decade in the making, is by itself worth more than its 96-year-old utility sibling. ???How did National Energy get so big so fast? By using cash, partly generated by its sister utility, to buy unregulated power plants in the Northeast, expand trading-floor operations and sell power across the country. The exact numbers are in dispute, but much of Nationals Energy's profits last year came from California. ??Most other large utilities have done the same thing over the past decade, building national or even global power companies from roots in local monopolies. But nowhere is the success of these unregulated businesses more of an issue than in California, where PG& E's investments may be challenged in bankruptcy court. ??Still, such transfers of assets were fundamental to deregulation plans in two dozen states, and they were encouraged by federal rules designed to build a new wholesale marketplace in electricity. ??And today, the offspring of the nation's utilities dominate that market, after industry leader Enron. ?Eight of the nation's 10 largest power marketers are affiliates or spinoffs of regulated utilities, controlling about 42 percent of power trading. ??It is largely these unregulated power producers and traders whose sales of power in California have prompted accusations by state leaders of price gouging, and demands for the price caps that federal regulators took their first, halting steps toward embracing last week. ??The profitability of the utilities' unregulated operations is becoming clear as companies report earnings for the first three months of the year. ??For example, Reliant Energy reported that operating income at its unregulated wholesale energy business soared to $216 million in the first quarter, or 16 percent more than at its regulated utility, which serves Houston. This week, Reliant expects to spin off its unregulated businesses through an initial public stock offering that would put a market value on the new company of as much as $8.8 billion -- more than the rest of Reliant. ??A number of other major utility companies have spinoffs or trading and generation units that now earn nearly as much as, or more than, their core utility operations. These include Duke Energy in Charlotte, N.C.; Sempra Energy of San Diego; the Southern Company in Atlanta; the Constellation Energy Group in Baltimore; and Utilicorp United in Kansas City, Mo. ??In some places, the growth of the unregulated businesses continues to raise questions of fairness -- particularly where utilities have been permitted to transfer plants to the new units at deep discounts to their market value. Critics say that ratepayers, whose bills paid for the plants' construction, should benefit more when the plants are sold. ??In Florida, a commission on energy deregulation formed by Gov. Jeb Bush has proposed permitting such transfers on the grounds that they are needed to create a new wholesale marketplace. Opponents, including the Florida Municipal Electric Association, which represents utilities owned by local governments, say the plan would produce a $9 billion windfall that should go to ratepayers. ??In California, some creditors of Pacific Gas and Electric have signaled that they will want the bankruptcy court in San Francisco to review parent PG& E's efforts to keep its unregulated businesses out of creditors' reach. ??And the California Public Utilities Commission is investigating whether PG& E and Edison International, whose Southern California Edison utility unit is also near insolvency, have improperly transferred cash to their parents and to unregulated sister companies. ??A recent audit ordered by the commission showed that Pacific Gas and Electric transferred $4.1 billion to PG& E from 1997 to 1999. Most of that went to dividends and stock repurchases, but $838 million was invested in other subsidiaries, primarily its National Energy Group unit. Southern California Edison transferred $4.8 billion to its parent company between 1996 and November 2000, a separate audit showed; Edison International invested $2.5 billion in its unregulated Mission Group subsidiaries during the same period. ??Executives of the companies say the transfers were proper. Audits have shown that "we followed the rules and didn't do anything wrong," said PG& E's chief executive, Robert Glynn. "We did not ask consumers in California to support any of the losses that occurred in those businesses when we started them up," he said. Now, forcing the unregulated units to support their ailing sister utility, he said, "would be no different than calling up shareholders and saying, 'The California electric bills are pretty high; send some money in so we can give it back to them.' " ??Loretta Lynch, the president of the utilities commission, took a different view. "Should we look backward," she asked, "and say, 'Hey, wait a minute -- that corporate structure profited by all of our power payments to them in the past, and they should participate in helping us through to get to a solution in the future?' " ??The cornerstone deal of PG& E's unregulated energy business was struck four years ago, when it acquired the hydroelectric and fossil-fueled generation plants of New England Electric System for $1.6 billion. PG& E is now one of the largest generators in the Northeast, operating plants that can light up to five million average-sized homes. ??While California officials say Pacific Gas and Electric's woes have been caused, at least in part, by market manipulation by out-of-state generators, the Justice Department has been investigating possible market abuses involving PG& E and two other companies in New England. Mr. Glynn said that PG& E had done nothing wrong and that the company has responded to Justice Department requests for information. ??Overall, PG& E's National Energy Group has 30 power plants in 10 states, and others under development or construction that include one in Athens, N.Y., that is expected to begin supplying electricity to New York City in 2003. It also operates an energy trading operation in Bethesda and controls a natural gas pipeline into Northern California. ??To Wall Street, the utility companies' investments in unregulated businesses were a necessary survival tactic, as investors demanded faster-growing profits. ??"The stock market was going like gangbusters, and the utilities' returns of 11 percent weren't cutting it," said Richard Cortright, a utility analyst at Standard and Poor's, the bond rating agency. ??Moreover, as deregulation loomed, industry executives saw no choice but to make new investments. "It looked like the utility opportunity was going to start shrinking," Mr. Glynn said. ??Consumer groups question whether utilities would have invested more in improving basic service if they had not had the option of putting money elsewhere. ??Mike Florio, a lawyer with The Utility Reform Network, a consumer group in San Francisco, cited findings last year by state regulators that from 1987 to 1995, Pacific Gas & Electric spent nearly $550 million less on maintaining electric and gas facilities than had been factored into its rates. Separately, in 1999, the utility agreed to pay about $29 million to settle charges that consumers were endangered because it failed to trim trees near high-voltage power lines. ??"Several hundred million dollars didn't get spent for maintenance, and that ultimately falls to the bottom line as profit," Mr. Florio said. ??Mr. Glynn said the utility had always spent appropriate sums on maintenance, coming within one-half of one percent of the amount built into rates over a 20-year period. ??In the big picture, he said, it was hard to see how PG& E had been a winner in deregulation, even before its utility's humiliating bankruptcy. "If you look at what happened, the net of it was a loss," Mr. Glynn said, "because the value leaked out on the regulated utility side faster than we were able to build it on the nonregulated side." About This Report ??This article is part of a joint reporting effort with the PBS series "Frontline," which will broadcast a documentary about California's energy crisis on June 5. ??http://www.nytimes.com GRAPHIC: Charts: "The Biggest Power Marketers" Most of the biggest unregulated power marketers and traders are owned by the the country's biggest electric utilities or have been spun off by them. Here are the top 10, based on 2000 sales. Companies owned or spun off from utilities: Enron Power and affliliates MEGAWATTS SOLD IN 2000 (IN MILLIONS): 590.2 MARKET SHARE: 13.03% CHANGE FROM 1999: + 97% Companies owned or spun off from utilities: American Electric Power Service MEGAWATTS SOLD IN 2000 (IN MILLIONS): 401.3 MARKET SHARE: 8.86 CHANGE FROM 1999: +84 Companies owned or spun off from utilities: PG&E Energy and affiliates MEGAWATTS SOLD IN 2000 (IN MILLIONS): 282.6 MARKET SHARE: 6.24 CHANGE FROM 1999: +62 Companies owned or spun off from utilities: Duke Energy and affiliates MEGAWATTS SOLD IN 2000 (IN MILLIONS): 276.2 MARKET SHARE: 6.10 CHANGE FROM 1999: +226 Companies owned or spun off from utilities: Reliant Energy and affiliates MEGAWATTS SOLD IN 2000 (IN MILLIONS): 204.3 MARKET SHARE: 4.51 CHANGE FROM 1999: +166 Companies owned or spun off from utilities: Mirant Americas Energy and affiliates MEGAWATTS SOLD IN 2000 (IN MILLIONS): 202.6 MARKET SHARE: 4.47 CHANGE FROM 1999: +23 Companies owned or spun off from utilities: Aquila Energy Marketing MEGAWATTS SOLD IN 2000 (IN MILLIONS): 186.7 MARKET SHARE: 4.12 CHANGE FROM 1999: +4 Companies owned or spun off from utilities: Cinergy operating companies MEGAWATTS SOLD IN 2000 (IN MILLIONS): 166.4 MARKET SHARE: 3.67 CHANGE FROM 1999: +246 Companies owned or spun off from utilities: Constellation Power Source MEGAWATTS SOLD IN 2000 (IN MILLIONS): 162.3 MARKET SHARE: 3.58 CHANGE FROM 1999: +222 Companies owned or spun off from utilities: Williams Energy and affiliates MEGAWATTS SOLD IN 2000 (IN MILLIONS): 138.4 MARKET SHARE: 3.05 CHANGE FROM 1999: +127 (Source: Platt Power Markets Week)(pg. A17) "Outdoing Their Parents" Taking advantage of deregulation, many of the country's biggest power utilities have set up unregulated subsidiaries to trade and produce power. These subsidiaries have become extremely profitable, often outperforming their regulated corporate siblings. UTILITY: Duke Energy OPERATING INCOME (MILLIONS) 1Q '00: +$465 1Q '01: +460 UNREGULATED BUSINESS: North American Wholesale Energy OPERATING INCOME (MILLIONS) 1Q '00: +82 1Q '01: +348 RELATIONSHIP OF UNREGULATED BUSINESS TO UTILITY North American Wholesale Energy is a subsidiary of Duke Energy. UTILITY: Reliant Energy OPERATING INCOME (MILLIONS) 1Q '00: +$202 1Q '01: +186 UNREGULATED BUSINESS: Wholesale Energy OPERATING INCOME (MILLIONS) 1Q '00: -22 1Q '01: +216 RELATIONSHIP OF UNREGULATED BUSINESS TO UTILITY Reliant Energy plans to sell 18 percent of Reliant Resources -- mostly Wholesale Energy -- this week. UTILITY: Southern OPERATING INCOME (MILLIONS) 1Q '00: +$439 1Q '01: +483 UNREGULATED BUSINESS: Mirant OPERATING INCOME (MILLIONS) 1Q '00: +169 1Q '01: +279 RELATIONSHIP OF UNREGULATED BUSINESS TO UTILITY Southern completed the spinoff of Mirant on April 2. (Source: S.E.C. filings)(pg. A17) LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????17 of 103 DOCUMENTS ?????????????????Copyright 2001 The Chronicle Publishing Co. ?????????????????????????The San Francisco Chronicle ????????????????????APRIL 30, 2001, MONDAY, FINAL EDITION SECTION: NEWS; Pg. A3 LENGTH: 1108 words HEADLINE: NEWSMAKER PROFILE; Nettie Hoge; Taking on power; Consumer advocate revels in uphill battle SOURCE: Chronicle Staff Writer BYLINE: Chuck Squatriglia BODY: Given a choice, Nettie Hoge would rather be out in her garden right about now, digging in the dirt. ???Instead, the head of The Utility Reform Network is digging into California's energy mess, making sure the average Joe doesn't take it in the kisser as lawmakers, regulators and utility brass hats try to keep the lights on and utilities afloat. ???It's grueling work, full of long hours that leave precious little time for the gardening Hoge so adores. Not that she's complaining. Hoge, 50, honestly loves her job and insists she wouldn't do anything else. ???"I've got a mutant gene," she said with a laugh as she relaxed, for just a moment, in a spartan office littered with messy piles of paperwork. "I've always wanted to do this." ???TURN has been keeping tabs on companies like Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Pacific Bell for more than 25 years. Hoge and her crew lobby the Public Utilities Commission, counsel lawmakers, analyze reports and file the occasional lawsuit. They are, in short, professional gadflies who represent the public in a system that some say favors big business. ???"The biggest protector of the consumer, by far, has been TURN," said Bob Gnaizda, public policy director for the Greenlining Institute in San Francisco. "(Hoge) has made TURN into the leading consumer utility advocate in the nation." ???It's not glamorous work, nor is it particularly lucrative. Hoge, a lawyer by training, took a pay cut when she accepted the $75,000-a-year job in 1995. And, truth be told, most folks have no idea Hoge is in their corner. ???"There are other rewards," she said. "You don't get the adoration of Joe Citizen standing up and yelling, 'Yay TURN!' But there's an excitement about being involved in the discussions where the big decisions are made." ???The youngest of four children, Hoge bounced around the middle of the country as she grew up, following her career Army officer father from Kansas to Oklahoma to Texas. ???"All the places where you can shoot big guns," she joked. ???Hoge graduated from high school in Pullman, Wash. After a stint at the University of Southern California, she graduated Phi Beta Kappa from Washington State University and earned a law degree from the University of San Francisco. ???Hoge's entire career has been spent protecting the underdog. During a two-year stint as a law school graduate at Brobeck, Phleger & Harrison in San Francisco, "I got into trouble for doing too much pro bono work," Hoge recalled. "The partners would come around each month to check our billable hours. Mine were always zero." ???Since taking the helm almost six years ago, Hoge has led TURN to some impressive consumer victories. They include persuading the Public Utilities Commission to create a $352 million fund to underwrite rural telephone service and bringing an end to ratepayer subsidies of PG&E's Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant in 2002. ???Hoge, a stickler for detail, has a reputation for giving exhaustive answers to even mundane questions. ???"Everybody agrees she knows what she's talking about," said Harvey Rosenfield, president of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights. "In many respects, TURN is the intellectual force in this debate. Those of us who are deeply involved in this issue rely upon Nettie to lay out the facts for us." ???Hoge is surprised people think her wonkish, but admits she is circumspect. ???"My big fear is being marginalized and having people think we (at TURN) don't know what we're talking about," she said. "Maybe I overcompensate." ???Few doubt Hoge's smarts, but she has plenty of critics among the utilities, lawmakers and lobbyists she has crossed swords with over the years. However, none of them will say anything publicly. ???"We have no comment on her," said Shawn Cooper, a spokesman for Pacific Gas and Electric Corp., the parent company of the foundering utility. ???It was the same story with Southern California Edison and many of the legislators who have criticized Hoge and TURN in recent years. ???Hoge isn't surprised her adversaries are keeping mum. ???"There's nothing for them to gain by saying anything negative about us because the public is on our side," she said. ???Still, TURN has drawn criticism from Carl Wood, generally considered the most ardent consumer advocate on the PUC. ???"Frankly, I would have expected myself to be on the same page with (TURN) more than I actually am," Wood said. "I'm not sure they wholeheartedly believe in regulation, and I think it comes from a distrust of regulators. But maybe I'm taking it personally." ???Wood chastised TURN for supporting utility divestiture of generating plants as California's deregulation effort got under way. And he said Hoge places too much emphasis on the utilities' role in the energy mess instead of focusing on the profiteering of power generators. ???"The utilities have some culpability, but they are not the main driver behind the crisis," Wood said. "TURN's interventions do not reflect that reality." ???Still, he gave TURN high marks and credited Hoge with making it a far more effective advocate. ???Hoge admits she has had her hands full with the energy crisis, saying she and her staff "are trying to keep our health and sanity." ???Asked if she would have joined TURN if she had known how crazy California's energy market would become and how hard she would have to work, Hoge was characteristically wary. ???"I don't think anyone would want to sign up for this," she said after a moment's pause. "On the one hand, it's very serious, very rewarding work. But on the other hand, sometimes you're just beating your head against the wall." ???Still, Hoge doesn't plan to give up the fight anytime soon. ???"But at some point I'd like to retreat and spend some time contemplating the forest for the trees." ???Or the garden for the plants. ??----------------------------------------------- ??Nettie Hoge -- Age: 50. ???-- Residence: Oakland. ???-- Job: Executive director, The Utility Reform Network, October 1995 to present. The utility and telecommunications industry watchdog group in San Francisco represents consumers before the Public Utilities Commission, the Legislature and elsewhere. ???-- Education: Bachelor's degree in communications, Phi Beta Kappa, from Washington State University, 1976. Law degree, cum laude, from University of San Francisco, 1985. ???-- Background: Most of Hoge's 25-year career has been spent protecting the little guy, first as a social worker and later as an attorney with Consumers Union and the California Department of Insurance under Insurance Commissioner John Garamendi.E-mail Chuck Squatriglia at csquatriglia@sfchronicle.com. GRAPHIC: PHOTO, (1) Nettie Hoge is respected for her encyclopedic knowledge of regulatory issues., (2) Nettie Hoge has headed The Utility Reform Network for six years. "I've always wanted to do this," she says. / John O'Hara/The Chronicle LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????20 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 The Washington Post ?????????????????????????????The Washington Post ????????????????????April 30, 2001, Monday, Final Edition SECTION: A SECTION; Pg. A03 LENGTH: 1669 words HEADLINE: Energy Forecast for Summer: No Blackouts but Price Spikes; Grid Managers Promote Conservation, Await New Plants BYLINE: William Claiborne, Washington Post Staff Writer DATELINE: CHICAGO BODY: ??The rest of the United States is virtually certain to escape rolling blackouts this summer like the ones that have plagued California, but record price hikes for electricity are likely in many places, energy experts agree. ???Despite their confidence that they can survive everything but an extremely hot summer without power outages, managers of the nation's interconnecting electrical power grids are anxiously awaiting new power plants that are scheduled to come on-line. They are also promoting more frugal consumption by power customers and seeking ways to avoid distribution logjams during peak demand periods this summer. ???"We see a big distinction between California and the rest of the country," said David Costello, an economist in charge of short-term forecasting for the Energy Information Administration, the statistical arm of the Department of Energy. "We have no real reason to believe anyplace is unusually at risk." ???But record spikes in the price of electricity are a given for this summer, some industry analysts say, because a growing proportion of power plants now run on natural gas, which has doubled in price over the past year. ???The DOE estimates that electricity demand will grow 2.3 percent nationally this year, with much higher increases in the West and the South. At the same time, the reserve capacity margin that utilities try to build into their systems to handle the hottest days -- when use of air conditioners and other appliances taxes supplies -- has been falling in some regions to well less than the desired 15 percent above peak summer loads. ???That means utilities may have to import large volumes of electricity over transmission systems that were not designed to handle them. What power officials are hoping to avoid are critical shortfalls in generating capacity in some regions, followed by overwhelming strains on aging high-voltage transmission lines as power is bought and sold across the country in increasingly competitive electricity markets. ???Even though scores of new power plants have been built in the Northeast, South and Midwest in recent months and many more are on the drawing boards, the expected 15 percent increase in new generation will not be fully on-line for another two years. That leaves parts of the nation vulnerable to outages if there are prolonged heat waves this summer, or if utilities are unable to start up new or rebuilt gas-fired power plants as scheduled, according to energy experts. ???Despite all those potential problems, there is no reason to believe that California's power nightmares will spread to the rest of the country, officials said. ???This year, utilities have announced they are adding 40 to 50 gigawatts of new generating capacity to gas-fired plants across the nation, compared with only 22 gigawatts that were added last year, Costello said. He said that even if half of those announced plants never materialize, this year's new capacity is certain to be as great or greater than last year's, meaning that the predicted increased consumption can probably be met. A gigawatt is 1,000 megawatts, or enough to power about 1 million homes. ???"We don't know that [transmission] infrastructure has really been fixed, but my sense is they're in better shape overall as far as capacity is concerned," Costello said. ???The nation's 203,600-mile high-voltage network has undergone relatively few changes in 50 years, during which deregulation has prompted electricity wholesalers to sell power at even greater distances to reach more lucrative markets, adding to the pressure on the grid system. ???California, in a sense, has been serving as a stalking horse for other states, some of which also deregulated their electricity systems and are consciously avoiding doing anything that resembles the California model. ???Eugene Gorzelnik, spokesman for the North American Electric Reliability Council (NERC), which oversees the interlocking power grids, said: "Obviously, there will be problems in California and there's nothing that's going on that will solve those problems. But a lot of [utilities] people are looking at California and saying to themselves, 'Can I do this in a way they didn't?' That's a positive development." ???Apart from California, the worst problems are expected in adjoining western states, as Golden State electrical grid managers scramble to buy electricity at a time when power production at the region's hydroelectric dams is already being cut because of shrinking water levels in reservoirs. ???The Northwest Power Planning Council recently reported that the demand for electricity has grown 24 percent in the past decade while new generation has grown only 4 percent. ???NERC is not expected to issue its long-awaited pre-summer electricity reliability assessment -- a document that forecasts peak generation and consumption -- until next month. But in interviews, officials of many of the 10 regional reliability councils that comprise the national grid system appeared fairly sanguine about the prospect of avoiding widespread brownouts this summer. ???"Assuming normal weather and assuming our generating units come off maintenance on schedule, we don't anticipate any particular problems meeting our loads," said Bill Reinke, executive director of the Southeastern Electricity Reliability Council. ???Reinke said the region was adding 300 miles of new transmission lines, has 5,600 megawatts of new generating capacity -- enough to power 5.6 million homes -- and is seeking to identify potential transmission bottlenecks so it can take preemptive corrective measures against distribution failures. ???Outside the West, the greatest potential for blackouts may be in New York, where the near certainty of transmission logjams in an antiquated infrastructure prompted Consolidated Edison Co. to request approval for 11 combustion turbine mini-generators in case of a power shortage. Residents and conservationists are appealing court approval of the generators on environmental grounds. ???Stephen Allen, spokesman for the Northeast Power Coordinating Council said, "If the 400 megawatts the generators provide go on-line, it'll still be tight, but New York should be okay." He said Upstate New York should have surplus electricity to sell to New York City, although some experts say transmission bottlenecks could make it difficult for New York City to import power on abnormally hot days. ???New York City customers, who have already had their electricity rates increased 40 percent in the last two years, could see prices rise an additional 50 percent because of the deregulated power industry's dependence on gas-fired generation, according to some analysts. ???Allen said that since last June, New England has added mostly gas-fired plants that generate more than 1,000 megawatts and should have an additional 2,000 megawatts on-line before the end of the summer. He said the region should have a 15 percent to 18 percent capacity margin. ???The Mid-Atlantic Area Council, made up of Maryland, Virginia, the District of Columbia, Delaware, New Jersey and Pennsylvania, is expecting a reserve margin of more than 16 percent and an increase of 2,100 megawatts in generating capacity over last year, to about 60,000 megawatts, according to the council's president, Phillip G. Harris. Harris said the council met last year's peak of 49,288 megawatts with no problems, though the summer of 2000 was relatively cool. ???Harris cited several reasons "why we are not like California," including a decision to centralize all planning, which California did not; the creation of a regional market instead of a state-based marketplace like California's, and a policy of only slow, incremental changes in the grid. ???"A single misstep can have huge consequences," Harris said. "We're tinkering with something that has worked for 100 years, so you better do it right." ???In the Midwest, utilities expect a peak demand this summer of 55,221 megawatts, compared with 52,214 megawatts last summer, according to Richard Bulley, executive director of the six-state Mid-America Interconnected Network. But keeping pace with the nearly 6 percent increase in demand is the addition of 5,470 megawatts of capacity, Bulley said. ???"We do not anticipate any major limitations on the region's bulk transmission system, and we project a healthy reserve margin of more than 18 percent," he said. ???Since 1998, 33 companies have proposed projects in Illinois totaling 25,000 megawatts of gas-fired power. Although no one expects all of that to come on-line, the state's total generating capacity is just under 34,000 megawatts, meaning that even if only a modest amount of the anticipated power was added, the region would have a cushion, even in a hot summer. ???Officials of Commonwealth Edison Co., the biggest utility in Illinois, say that new or rebuilt electrical distribution facilities should prevent a repeat of the kind of disastrous power outages that crippled offices in Chicago's Loop last summer, when lines broke and transformers burst into flames. ???Few power grids are in as good shape as Texas's. The state anticipates a 23 percent power margin this summer and the addition of 9,188 megawatts of new generating capacity this year, according to Heather Tindall, spokeswoman for the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT). Texas utilities have 27 new power plants under construction and 31 more in the planning stages, she said. ???As a result, ERCOT is forecasting almost 70,000 megawatts of generating capacity this summer, compared with a peak demand of 57,600 megawatts on one 111-degree day last summer. ???Tindall said that after studying California's system, the Texas grid made a "concerted effort" to operate theirs differently. For example, she said, Texas supports utilities entering into long-term contracts for power, while in California, power companies did not enter into such contracts and were forced to pay exorbitant prices at peak times. LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????21 of 103 DOCUMENTS ???????????????????The Associated Press State & Local Wire The materials in the AP file were compiled by The Associated Press. ?These materials may not be republished without the express written consent of The Associated Press. ???????????????????????April 30, 2001, Monday, BC cycle ?????????????????????????????9:49 AM Eastern Time SECTION: State and Regional LENGTH: 594 words HEADLINE: Developments in California's energy crisis BYLINE: By The Associated Press BODY: ??Developments in California's energy crisis: ??MONDAY: ??- Members of the Assembly Subcommittee on Natural Gas Costs and Availability unveil legislation to cut natural gas prices. ??- The state remains free of power alerts as electricity reserves stay above 7 percent. ??FRIDAY: ??-Gov. Gray Davis calls a federal regulatory order "a Trojan horse" that will profit power generators at California ratepayers' expense. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is considering requiring the state's electric grid operator to add a surcharge on power sales to pay generators the money they are owed by the state's two large financially strapped utilities. ??- State power buyers have asked for another $500 million to buy electricity for the customers of three cash-strapped utilities. That brings the total amount authorized for power purchases to $6.2 billion since mid-January, when the state began purchases power for Pacific Gas and Electric Co., Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas and Electric. ??- Gov. Gray Davis says state office buildings cut energy use by an average of 20 percent in January and February, saving taxpayers $286,000 in utility bills. ??- State officials negotiating long-term power contracts for customers of three cash-strapped utilities have secured five more contracts. Four of the contracts signed in March by the Department of Water Resources will provide 466 megawatts of electricity during times of peak demand this summer, according to DWR documents. One megawatt is roughly enough power for 750 homes. ??- California Public Utilities Commission attorneys are advising state agencies to avoid submitting monetary claims against Pacific Gas and Electric Co. despite the company's bankruptcy. The PUC is trying to retain their electric rate-setting authority over the utility and says submitting claims could bring the state under the court's jurisdiction as a creditor, which could allow the judge to set electric rates. ??- Shares of Edison International closed at $9.90, up 15 cents. PG&E Corp. closed at $8.94, up 20 cents. ??-The state remains free of power alerts as reserves stay above 7 percent. ??WHAT'S NEXT: ??- Davis' representatives continue negotiating with Sempra, the parent company of San Diego Gas and Electric Co., to buy the utility's transmission lines. Davis says he expects to have an agreement within two weeks. ??THE PROBLEM: ??High demand, high wholesale energy costs, transmission glitches and a tight supply worsened by scarce hydroelectric power in the Northwest and maintenance at aging California power plants are all factors in California's electricity crisis. ??Edison and PG&E say they've lost nearly $14 billion since June to high wholesale prices the state's electricity deregulation law bars them from passing on to consumers. PG&E, saying it hasn't received the help it needs from regulators or state lawmakers, filed for federal bankruptcy protection April 6. ??Electricity and natural gas suppliers, scared off by the two companies' poor credit ratings, are refusing to sell to them, leading the state in January to start buying power for the utilities' nearly 9 million residential and business customers. The state is also buying power for a third investor-owned utility, San Diego Gas & Electric, which is in better financial shape than much larger Edison and PG&E but also struggling with high wholesale power costs. ??The Public Utilities Commission has raised rates as much as 46 percent to help finance the state's multibillion-dollar power buys. LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????22 of 103 DOCUMENTS ???????????????????????Copyright 2001 Associated Press ??????????????????????????????????AP Online ????????????????????????????April 29, 2001; Sunday SECTION: Domestic, non-Washington, general news item LENGTH: 1313 words HEADLINE: ?Geothermal Plants Need More Steam BYLINE: JENNIFER COLEMAN DATELINE: MIDDLETOWN, Calif. BODY: ???Geothermal plants in The Geysers area north of the Napa Valley have tapped steam fields to produce electricity since the 1960s. The 350-degree steam rushes more than 1,500 feet up from the earth, spinning turbines that create a constant flow of electricity. ??But mismanagement of the steam fields beneath the hilly northwestern California region that straddles the Sonoma and Lake county lines has led to a large decline of pressure and a drop of more than 50 percent in the amount of power the plants produce. ??The geothermal decline comes as California already faces short supplies of hydroelectricity from the drought-ridden Pacific Northwest and growing competition for megawatts from other power-starved states. ??State power grid managers estimate they're losing about 900 megawatts of geothermal electricity due to the gradual depletion of the steam fields. That's enough power for roughly 675,000 homes. ??''They just overproduced. It is a renewable source of power, but it's renewable over geologic time,'' says Katherine Potter, a spokeswoman for Calpine Energy, which owns 19 of the 21 geothermal power plants in The Geysers region, which incidentally has no geysers. ??The first electricity produced by tapping into pockets of steam trapped in the earth made its debut in 1904 in Larderello, Italy. That plant, rebuilt due to World War II damage, is still operating. The first U.S. geothermal plant was a small operation at The Geysers built in 1962. ??Steam fields are created when water flows through fissures in the rock deep in the earth and is heated by hot magma. Geothermal plants tap into that pressure and use it to spin turbines. The plants' cooling towers release plumes of white steam, which can be seen for miles on a clear day. ??While The Geysers is a unique geologic formation called a dry steam field, there is the potential for thousands of megawatts of geothermal power from other regions that could use the more common ''wet steam'' process, said Karl Gawell, executive director of the Geothermal Energy Association in Washington D.C. ??Wet steam plants tap into superheated water in the earth, separate the steam and use it to power generators. The water and the condensed steam is pumped back into the earth. ??CalEnergy Corp. owns 10 power plants in Imperial County that produce about 330 megawatts of power, enough for about 247,500 homes. Those plants and others like them haven't seen a decline in pressure like Calpine's plants. ??Geothermal energy is second only to hydroelectricity as a continuous, cheap source of power, said Jan Stewart, Calpine's public relations manager. ??The plants in The Geysers reached their peak power production in the 1980s, producing about 2,000 megawatts of electricity enough to power about 1.5 million homes. ??At that time, about 30 companies were involved in various geothermal ventures in the area and didn't work together, Stewart said. ??''The resource wasn't being managed properly. As a result, it was a very fractured environment,'' she said. ''If one plant shut down, the steam would be vented to the atmosphere, instead of being rerouted to another plant where it could be used.'' ??In the 1960s and '70s when The Geysers got started, there was ''a real wildcatter's mentality'' among power generators, said Rich Ferguson, energy chairman for Sierra Club California. ??''Basically, they took out the water in the form of steam faster than Mother Nature was putting it back in,'' he said. ??The available steam declined, and the area now puts out about 850 megawatts, sufficient power for roughly 637,500 homes. ??Since then, geothermal engineers have learned more about managing the resource, Ferguson said. ??The superheated, self-contained system at The Geysers has no ??ater running through it. ?''The Geysers is unique worldwide. There really aren't other dry steam fields,'' Gawell said. ''In effect, there was never a sustainable level of production, you always would have depleted it eventually. It's like a giant pressure cooker. As soon as you put the first straw in, you began to deplete the resource.'' ??Calpine is experimenting with replenishing the steam fields by pumping treated waste water back into the earth. It began three years ago, when Lake County stopped pumping its treated waste water into Clear Lake. ??Now, more than 8 million gallons of treated waste water is returned daily to the earth. The experiment appears to be working _ power output is up 68 megawatts. ??''People like the stewardship that Calpine provides now,'' Ferguson said. '' Calpine has taken on as a long-term goal to make that sustainable.'' ??Calpine is building a 50-mile pipeline to Santa Rosa and plans to pump another 11 million of treated waste water daily from that city. The company expects that will boost production another 85 megawatts. ??Even with the new project, power grid managers say they're planning for diminishing geothermal electricity. ??''We've lost a considerable portion of their output due to the decline in the output of the steam,'' said Jim McIntosh, director of grid operations for the Independent System Operator. ''All supplies are very important to us at this point.'' ??The plants are relatively low-maintenance once they're running _ only one engineer staffs each of the 19 Calpine plants in The Geysers. ??But geothermal plants are more expensive to build than natural gas-fired power plants, Gaywell said. ??''It's like choosing between two identical cars one is $10,000 and the other is $30,000, but the $30,000 car comes with a lifetime supply of fuel,'' he said. ''People are shortsighted on investments and it takes more money upfront to build geothermal.'' ??Most geothermal resources are on public land, lengthening the building process because more permits are needed, Gawell said. ??Two new plants are in the application process in California. ??Researchers estimate there are 2,500 megawatts of untapped geothermal resources in Nevada, Gawell said. Idaho, New Mexico and Oregon also have sites that could be tapped, he said. ??''Many of these sites were looked at in the '80s, but then nothing happened because in the '90s natural gas was too cheap to meter,'' he said. ??Ferguson said the state spent $540 million over the last four years on incentives for renewable energy projects, including geothermal, solar, wind and biomass, and he expects the plan will be renewed when it expires in December. ??''We think there will be an equivalent amount of money,'' he said. ''All the technologies have to compete against each other, but geothermal should do pretty good.'' ??___ ??There are three types of geothermal power plants. Here's a look at how they work: ???Dry steam: Such plants are rare, producing steam and not hot water. The Geysers region is the world's largest dry steam field. Steam from the earth is piped to the power plant, where it spins turbines to create electricity. After the remaining steam condenses back to liquid, it is returned to the earth. ???Wet steam: This type of geothermal plant is more common. There are several such plants in Southern California. Hot water and steam are brought to the surface, separated and the steam is used to power turbines. The water is returned to the earth as is the condensed steam. ???Binary: These plants use hot water and steam from the earth to heat another liquid, such as isobutane, which has a lower boiling point than water. That liquid's steam is used to power turbines to make electricity. When the steam cools and becomes liquid it's returned to the tank and reused. This type of system is self-contained and has no emissions. ??___ ??On the Net: ??Geothermal Education Office: http://geothermal.marin.org ??California ISO: http://www.caiso.com ??Calpine Corp.: http://www.calpine.com ?????(PROFILE ?????(CO:Calpine Corp; TS:CPN; IG:ELC;) ?????) LOAD-DATE: April 29, 2001 ?????????????????????????????24 of 103 DOCUMENTS ???????????????????The Associated Press State & Local Wire The materials in the AP file were compiled by The Associated Press. ?These materials may not be republished without the express written consent of The Associated Press. ???????????????????????April 29, 2001, Sunday, BC cycle SECTION: State and Regional LENGTH: 413 words HEADLINE: Guns in schools, deregulation delay on lawmakers' agenda BYLINE: By BRAD CAIN, Associated Press Writer DATELINE: SALEM, Ore. BODY: ??Backers of a bill to prevent holders of concealed handgun licenses from bringing their weapons onto school property will spend the coming week trying to force a Senate vote on the issue. ??Also this week, House Speaker Mark Simmons is planning to schedule a hearing on his bill to pull the plug - at least for now - on a key part of an electric deregulation law that's due to take effect this fall for large businesses. ??The guns-in-schools bill has been on life support for weeks, with a key Senate committee chairman refusing to schedule a hearing on the bill on grounds that it is overly contentious and wouldn't pass anyway. ??The sponsor of the bill, Sen. Ryan Deckert, D-Beaverton, and other supporters aren't giving up, however. ??They are hoping to use a parliamentary maneuver that would enable them to move the school guns issue to the full Senate for debate by attaching it to another education-related bill. ??Gun owner groups say SB508 is unnecessary because there have been no documented cases of law-abiding carriers of concealed handguns causing any problems at schools. ??But a key supporter of the bill, Sen. Ginny Burdick, D-Portland, says she is convinced the measure would pass in both the House and Senate - if it can be brought up for vote. ??"I don't think we should wait to have dead children before we ban guns in schools," said Burdick, who was a chief sponsor of a measure passed by voters last fall expanding background checks at gun shows. ??California's power woes that were precipitated by that state's move to deregulation are giving Oregon lawmakers second thoughts about their decision to approve a phased-in deregulation of the electricity market in Oregon. ??A bill passed by the 1999 Legislature is supposed to open Oregon's electric markets to industrial and large commercial customers, beginning this October. ??The 1999 law is supposed to free large businesses to buy power on the open market, and does not deregulate electric rates for residential customers. ??Still, Simmons says that drought conditions and the power market turmoil caused by California's energy crisis require reconsideration of the law. ??For that reason, the House speaker is planning hearings this week on his proposal to enact a 15-month delay in Oregon's electricity restructuring efforts. ??"This just gives the opportunity for the energy markets to settle for a while," the Elgin Republican said. ??Similar legislation is pending in the Senate. LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????25 of 103 DOCUMENTS ???????????????????????Copyright 2001 The Post Register ??????????????????????????Idaho Falls Post Register ????????????????????????????April 29, 2001 Sunday SECTION: News; Pg. a1 LENGTH: 530 words HEADLINE: Plenty of blame to go around for West's power woes BYLINE: PAUL MENSER BODY: ??When it comes to power, the West is a mess. ??Because of its botched deregulation attempts, California bears a lot of the blame - but not all of it, said Susan F. Tierney, a former assistant secretary in the Energy Department, now a consultant for Lexecon, a Cambridge, Mass., consulting firm. ??Like planets lining up to usher in an age of hysteria, a combination of unforeseen circumstances have put the Northwest behind the eight ball. In addition to California's self-created tangle, oil and natural gas prices are rising and a drought is stymieing the region's hydropower production. ??The situation is less volatile in other parts of the country. In the Northeast, South and Midwest, where growth has been modest and generating capacity has been more stable, there's less discrepancy between supply and demand. ??Undergirding the West's situation was some serious lack of foresight, Tierney said. ??When it looked like California power customers would be able to get electricity from whoever offered it at the cheapest price, utilities worried about recovering the money they'd spent building plants and transmission lines in the '70s and early '80s. So they sold off their power plants and bought power on the wholesale market, where it was cheap and plentiful. ??Not trusting the marketplace, California legislators capped the rates utilities could charge residential customers. When wholesale power prices went up, they couldn't pass those increases on to consumers. ??"At the time, they did not realize that in a couple of years there would not be an adequate power supply," Tierney said. ??California's economic explosion of the late '90s, coupled with a failure to build any new plants, brought the crisis to a head. Computers are not by themselves big energy consumers, but the factories that make them are. The Internet, with all its server farms and data hotels, also became a heavy power user. ??When demand in California finally caught up with supply, "all of a sudden, utilities had to buy power, and it became a seller's market," Tierney said. ??But most of the Northwest's power comes from hydroelectric dams, and there has to be water in the rivers to power the turbines at the dams. In a drought year like this, the power has to come from somewhere else, most likely oil- and natural gas-fired plants, which fire up when demand is high. ??Because demand is so high this year, generators can charge exorbitant prices, knowing that California and the Northwest have nowhere else to buy power. ??Also, natural gas prices have gone through the roof in the last 18 months and aren't likely to come down until next year at the earliest. Until 18 months ago, the price of natural gas had been at a prolonged low, so companies weren't interested in expensive drilling projects. ??The problem is not likely to be permanent. As exploration and extraction pick up, prices will come down. The public has already begun to hear a conservation message, and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is being deluged with applications for new power plant construction. ??Staff writer Paul Menser can be reached at 542-6752, or via e-mail at pmenser@idahonews.com. LOAD-DATE: April 29, 2001 ?????????????????????????????26 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ?????????????????????April 29, 2001, Sunday, Home Edition SECTION: Opinion; Part M; Page 6; Opinion Desk LENGTH: 1312 words HEADLINE: THE STATE; HOW KILOWATT SOCIALISM SAVED L.A. FROM THE ENERGY CRISIS BYLINE: JEFF STANSBURY, Jeff Stansbury is a PhD candidate in American history at UCLA. His, dissertation is on the role of the labor movement in the building of, L.A.'s infrastructure BODY: ??Why is Los Angeles an island of tranquillity in the electric-power crisis that has rocked California and threatens to spread across the nation? ??News stories have repeatedly told us that the city's ownership and operation of its own generating stations is the principal reason. By staying clear of the state's 1996 deregulation scheme for private utilities, the Department of Water and Power was able to hold onto its power plants. ??So far, so good. But when we ask how Los Angeles came to enjoy public power in the first place, the answer commonly given makes a hash of history. ??Most historians and political scientists credit the city's progressive reform movement of 1890-1915 for having wisely settled on a municipal utility. True, some of the entrepreneurs, lawyers and reform-minded professionals who called themselves "the best men" during that era agitated for the city-built Owens Valley aqueduct and its generating stations. But many reformers opposed the city's effort to distribute its own power. Because they had allied themselves with railway magnate Henry Huntington, who owned an electric company, or because they favored regulation over municipal ownership, they wanted L.A.'s three private electric companies to sell and profit from aqueduct power. Meyer Lissner, a reform attorney often portrayed as a champion of public power, opposed the holding of a decisive 1911 citywide straw poll on the subject because he knew most Angelenos would cast their ballots for municipal ownership. That, he said, would be "unfair" to the three utilities. ??The most steadfast partisans of public power were not progressive reformers like Lissner but the city's much-maligned labor unions, and for a simple reason. While mistrust of oligopoly ran through nearly all sectors of society, it burned hottest in working-class wards. Without organized labor's dogged campaign for "gas and water socialism," as well as its willingness to hand control of these resources to the anti-union regimes of Mayors George Alexander and Henry Rose, there would be no DWP today. ??Organized labor played a key role in the city's original decision to municipalize its water distribution system. On Oct. 24, 1892, 700 union members met to demand that the city build a small neighborhood waterworks as a step toward public control of the entire water supply. From that day on, L.A.'s unions never wavered in their call for a public water supply publicly managed. They mobilized the rank and file for the water-company buyouts of 1901-04, and, in 1906, the Public Ownership Party's citywide campaign primed voters to pour $ 23 million into construction of the Owens River aqueduct a year later. The aqueduct was the sine qua non of public power. At a time when most progressive reformers were mute on the subject, organized labor insisted that the aqueduct be used to generate electricity for the city's streets, homes and businesses. ??A broad consensus backed the city's construction of hydroelectric plants while the aqueduct was being built, but most of the city's politicians and corporate lobbyists were committed to public subsidies, not public ownership, of aqueduct power. The 1911 straw poll, in which city voters declared their support for municipal ownership and distribution of Owens River power, upset their plans. ??The most consistent fighters for public power during the decades after the straw poll were the Central Labor Council, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers, other unions and city employees who stuffed campaign envelopes, canvassed precincts and got out the vote. Voters who favored municipally owned power and initiatives bolstering the DWP tended to be working class and Democratic; those opposed were mainly middle and upper class and Republican. ??In this polarized political climate, Mayor Alexander called for a $ 6.5-million bond issue to complete the aqueduct-power distribution network; he left open the question of who would sell the power to consumers. Unions and socialists tied their support for the bonds to a city charter reform that would guarantee them a long-sought role in city government through proportional representation. When the reform failed at the polls, they withheld support from the power bonds, and these, too, went down to defeat in 1913. Much of the rancor workers felt was aimed at progressives like Lissner, head of the Good Government Organization, who fought labor's charter plank because it would bring socialists onto the City Council. ??The labor movement's dedication to public ownership soon reasserted itself, however. With a citywide election coming up that June, five unionists seeking council seats on the Socialist Party ticket revived labor's long-standing demand for city operation of all public utilities at cost. They urged the City Council to hold a new power-bond election with a clear public ownership mandate. They attacked the power companies' efforts to buy aqueduct power from the city and sell it to Angelenos at a profit. Soon, the great majority of unions in the Central Labor Council were locked in what turned out to be a decisive struggle against the power oligopoly made up of Southern California Edison, Pacific Light & Power and Los Angeles Gas & Electric. ??An unprecedented event brightened the bonds' chances. A machinist, Fred C. Wheeler, won a seat on the City Council, the first unionist to do so in the 20th century. Wheeler led a successful fight against an attempt to split the power-bond issue into two separate ballot propositions, one to complete the aqueduct's generating stations, the other to create a city-owned distribution system. Such a division would probably have doomed public power. ??The large majority of unionists who favored public power had little time to savor Wheeler's victory. While pressing the attack on the three electric companies, they faced a small but angry split in their own ranks. Dissenters in the Building Trades Council and a few of its unions argued that labor's grievances against the progressive regimes of 1909-14 had turned the argument for municipal ownership on its head. What good was municipal ownership in the hands of a council and mayor who had caused the arrest of hundreds of peaceful picketers during the citywide strikes of 1910, had underpaid aqueduct workers and fed them bad food and had denied unionists influential city jobs? The final blow was the council's rebuff of a petition signed by thousands of workers for a "living wage" law. Was it not folly to reward labor's foes with control of the aqueduct's power? ??Union activists who favored the bonds conceded that the dissenters were correct in their assessment of "progressive" city government. But the progressive star was fading. What counted in the long run was whether Los Angeles could wrest the city's electric power system from the grasp of private utilities. The Central Labor Council's unions took this challenge to heart and voted, 60-4, for a resolution favoring the bonds. ??On its own, as well as in coalition with other groups, the labor movement marshaled its rank and file on behalf of public power. It turned out hundreds of poll-watchers and canvassers on election day. The pro-bond unions never did win over the dissenting faction; rather, they overwhelmed it at the polls. On May 8, 1914, L.A.'s voters emphatically endorsed the power bonds by a hefty 71%-29%, with the city's working-class wards providing by far the largest margin of victory. ??Within a year, Los Angeles sold its bonds and began buying out the three investor-owned utilities. The first public power flowed into local homes and businesses in 1916. Two decades later, the DWP eliminated the last of its private competition and consolidated the working-class legacy of kilowatt and water socialism that has served the city so well in the current energy crisis. GRAPHIC: GRAPHIC-DRAWING: (no caption), JENNIFER HEWITSON / For The Times LOAD-DATE: April 29, 2001 ?????????????????????????????27 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ?????????????????????April 29, 2001, Sunday, Home Edition SECTION: Opinion; Part M; Page 4; Editorial Writers Desk LENGTH: 558 words HEADLINE: CONSERVATION SANDBAGS; THE DAVIS ADMINISTRATION NEEDS TO LAUNCH A CRASH EDUCATION COURSE TO CONVINCE CALIFORNIANS OF THE SERIOUSNESS OF THE ELECTRICITY CRISIS AND THE NEED FOR FAR-REACHING ENERGY-SAVING MEASURES. BODY: ??Natural disasters and crises can be devastating but are relatively simple and easy to grasp. A brush fire you fight with shovels. An earthquake, you clean up the rubble afterward and strengthen buildings in anticipation of the next. But California's energy crisis is far different and more complex. It's a quiet disaster on scattered, invisible fronts. Most people see it only when their own lights go out. ??There also is no precedent for this crisis in California and no accurate way to forecast how bad it can get, either the blackouts or the financial consequences. But as May approaches, it's certain that most Californians are not adequately informed about the severity of the problem or what they can do to limit its impact. ??Gov. Gray Davis, the utilities and others need to engage in a crash education program that will convince Californians of the seriousness of the problem and motivate them to undertake their own conservation programs in homes and businesses. California has been a pioneer in power conservation, and its citizens will listen to persuasive reasoning. ??As the chairwoman of the state Senate's Energy Committee, Sen. Debra Bowen (D-Marina del Rey) deals with problems ranging from utility company insolvency to rate "gaming" by energy producers. "But I'm really worried about this summer," she said last week, referring to the potential for day after day of rolling blackouts. She told of one businessman in her district who reported he will lose an estimated $ 30,000 every time his power is cut. Why not at least schedule blackouts so people can plan for them? she asked. Why not? ??In San Francisco, the Bay Area Economic Forum released a study indicating that power woes could deliver a $ 17-billion blow to the state's economy in lost production, the cost of rate increases and increased product prices. That may be conservative. The study did not include the $ 5.1 billion the state has spent so far to buy power for the insolvent private utilities. ??Republicans in the Legislature are stalling bills that would float a $ 10-billion revenue bond issue to finance power purchases and keep the state fiscally above water. They have latched onto a powerful issue, Davis' unwillingness to detail how he's spending the taxpayers' billions. Davis says he needs secrecy for competitive reasons as he bargains with power companies, though he is letting out a slightly wider trickle of figures. ??Wall Street, already wary about the credit-worthiness of the state, thinks poorly of the delay in issuing the bonds. Republicans should put a temporary hold on their battle with Davis and get the measure to the governor's desk this week. ??Lawmakers were slow in passing an $ 850-million conservation program, Bowen acknowledges. But Davis put the new program on a fast track Friday and made a smart choice in S. David Freeman, former chief of the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, to run the conservation effort. ??Freeman, 75, is a canny veteran of electric power politics. Davis may abhor giving out bad news, but Freeman need not shrink from it. Freeman should be on radio and television every day telling California just how bad the problem is and what they can do about it. If this were a flood, we'd be stacking sandbags. Our sandbags are conservation programs. We need to start stacking them now. LOAD-DATE: April 29, 2001 ?????????????????????????????28 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ?????????????????????April 29, 2001, Sunday, Home Edition SECTION: Part A; Part 1; Page 27; National Desk LENGTH: 1316 words HEADLINE: BUSH: THE FIRST 100 DAYS; BUSH IS OFF TO A ROCKY START IN HIS HANDLING OF ALL THINGS CALIFORNIAN; POLITICS: BUT WHY WOO THE GOLDEN STATE WHEN HE CAN'T CARRY IT IN AN ELECTION 'NO MATTER HOW HARD HE TRIES,' ONE ANALYST POINTS OUT. BYLINE: RICHARD SIMON, TIMES STAFF WRITER DATELINE: WASHINGTON BODY: ??So what if President Bush has opposed electricity price controls sought by California officials? Or that he has proposed cutting aid to states for incarcerating illegal immigrants convicted of crimes? Or that he has visited 26 states in his first 100 days in office--but not the most populous? ??Bush really does care about California, the White House insists, even if the state preferred Al Gore on election day. Administration officials said they have done a lot and plan to do more to lessen the electricity turmoil expected this summer. ??"I don't think he's treated California any differently than any other state," said Rep. George P. Radanovich (R-Mariposa). ??Some Californians feel otherwise. ??"The Bush administration's treatment of California started at indifference, moved to neglect and has now reached actual harm," complained Phil Schiliro, chief of staff for Rep. Henry A. Waxman (D-Los Angeles). ??Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) has asked three times for a meeting with Bush to discuss the energy crisis. Her response from the White House: a form letter with her name misspelled. ??Bush has called for requiring public agencies to buy costly earthquake insurance, a measure opposed by California lawmakers of both parties. He has proposed cutting an earthquake preparedness program. And he provided no money in his proposed budget to clean up a pile of uranium processing waste in Utah leaking into the Colorado River. ??"That's our water supply," political analyst Sherry Bebitch Jeffe said. "What kind of message is that?" ??John J. Pitney Jr., associate professor of government at Claremont McKenna College, said Bush's apparent indifference makes political sense. ??"It's hard to argue that Bush should spend any political capital in California," he said. "The 2000 election suggested that he cannot carry the state no matter how hard he tries. The Republicans have already lost several House seats and have probably hit rock bottom. . . . From a purely political angle, there's little point in giving California any money or attention that could otherwise go to more competitive states, such as Florida." ??But Jeffe, senior scholar at USC's School of Policy, Planning and Development, said Bush's failure to visit the state is hurting GOP efforts to rebuild itself in California. "We are ground zero for the kind of Latino outreach that he said he wanted to do." ??And veteran California Republican political strategist Kenneth L. Khachigian said Bush at least needs to prepare for the electricity problems predicted for summer. ??"If you get three or four days of successive blackouts, air conditioners going out, traffic lights going out, a second bankruptcy--whether he wants it or not--it's his problem," Khachigian said. "It would be wise for him to have a proactive stance, not just reactive." ??Tough Act to Follow ??Some political analysts have suggested that if Bush becomes too involved in California's troubles, what is now Democratic Gov. Gray Davis' problem could become Bush's. But, Khachigian said, "there's a fine line between taking responsibility for a problem and claiming that California isn't part of the United States." ??In dealing with heavily Democratic California, Bush has made this much clear: He is no Bill Clinton. ??Bush has a hard act to follow. When Clinton was president, he visited California often and rewarded it with federal largess. And California in return showered him with buckets of campaign dollars and electoral votes. ??But Rep. Ed Royce (R-Fullerton) said California will benefit from Bush's presidency too. "As Californians bear a disproportionately higher tax burden, they stand to benefit greatly from the president's tax relief plan." ??While House spokeswoman Claire Buchan assured that Bush will visit California soon. His wife already has done so. ??As proof that California is on their mind, administration officials point to the three Californians in the Cabinet--Ann M. Veneman of Agriculture, Norman Y. Mineta of Transportation and Anthony J. Principi of Veterans Affairs--and others in top White House jobs. ??Bush also has appointed California Latinos to high-level posts: Huntington Park Councilwoman Rosario Marin as treasurer, Los Angeles entrepreneur Hector V. Barreto Jr. as head of the Small Business Administration and former San Mateo County Supervisor Ruben Barrales as deputy assistant for intergovernmental affairs. ??Critics said that a Californian at the top does not guarantee that the Cabinet departments will develop California-friendly policies. The proposed Agriculture budget, for example, provides only $ 5 million--not the $ 15 million that California lawmakers said they need--to fight the glassy winged sharpshooter, an agricultural pest that threatens the state's wine industry. ??A spokesman for Veneman assured that additional funding will be considered, if requested by California lawmakers. And Rep. Mike Thompson (D-St. Helena), who assailed Bush for missing opportunities to help California, nonetheless expressed confidence in Veneman. "She's going to keep pounding away to make sure that the California wine industry gets what it needs." ??Some Good News ??Though he has proposed cuts in some programs that are important to California, Bush has taken some actions that please state officials. He has proposed a permanent research and development tax credit--an action that would particularly benefit Silicon Valley. ??His proposed budget includes additional money to crack down on illegal immigration and drug smuggling and unsafe trucks crossing into California from Mexico. And he has proposed increased funding to reduce backlogs at immigration offices. ??In one area, Bush even bested Clinton. He proposed $ 14 million to clean Lake Tahoe, more than the $ 3 million recommended by Clinton last year. ??And although he has drawn flak for proposing cuts in programs to promote energy efficiency and alternative fuels, his proposal to boost assistance to low-income families for insulating their homes and reducing their utility bills would nearly double California's allocation, to $ 8 million next year. ??No Bush policy has been more criticized in California than his approach to the state's energy woes--particularly his adamant opposition to price controls. Steve Maviglio, a spokesman for Davis, said Bush and his aides "got off to a strong start" by extending federal orders sought by the state to keep power flowing into California. ??"Since then . . . they've been AWOL," Maviglio said. In a reference to price controls, he added: "They're skirting around the edges of the problem without taking the bold action they need to take." ??"The feds are the only ones who can step in and bring some sanity to the cost of electricity in California," Thompson said. ??Administration officials said they have taken steps "from our first hours in office" to address the energy crisis. They said they have responded favorably to all the state's requests except price controls, which Bush contends would discourage the building of power plants. ??While some seek to portray Bush's opposition to price controls as unsympathetic to California's plight, a number of California's House Republicans also oppose price controls. And even those who support them argue that the issue misses the larger point. ??Rep. Randy "Duke" Cunningham (R-San Diego), an advocate of price controls, nevertheless said: "I agree with the administration that the state alone remains responsible for solving this crisis." ??Added Rep. Mary Bono (R-Palm Springs): "I don't believe Bush should bear the brunt of responsibility that the Clinton administration left over." ??Tim Ransdell, executive director of the California Institute for Federal Policy Research, doubted that Bush would ignore California. "California represents one-eighth of the nation. One in eight Americans can't be ignored." LOAD-DATE: April 29, 2001 ?????????????????????????????29 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ?????????????????????April 29, 2001, Sunday, Home Edition SECTION: Business; Part C; Page 2; Financial Desk LENGTH: 1290 words HEADLINE: WEEK IN REVIEW; TOP 10 STORIES / APRIL 23-27 BYLINE: Lisa Girion and Terril Yue Jones and Sallie Hofmeister and James Bates and Peter Pae and Jeff Leeds and Nancy Rivera Brooks and Peter Gosselin BODY: ??1. Economic Growth a Welcome Surprise: The U.S. economy grew at an unexpectedly strong 2% annual rate in the first three months of the year, thanks largely to buoyant shopping by American consumers. The gross domestic product--the country's total output of goods and services--expanded at twice the pace it did in the final three months of 2000 and at twice what analysts had expected, the government said Friday. Although many analysts said the economy remains balanced between strong growth and recession, economic optimists exulted over the report. Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan added to the celebratory mood by saying that a key trend behind the economy's strong performance of the last decade--its ability to improve productivity--is likely to resume despite the current slowdown. ??(Peter Gosselin) ??* ??2. Stocks Rise on Good News: The GDP report boosted stock prices, which already had gotten a lift from better-than-expected home sales figures earlier in the week. The Dow Jones industrial average rose 117.70 to close at 10,810.05 on Friday, up 2.2% for the week, while the S&P 500 index climbed 18.53 to 1,253.05. The Nasdaq, which had fallen Thursday on concerns over weak technology profits, rose 40.80 to 2,075.68, finishing the week down 4.1%. Meanwhile, the yield on the benchmark 10-year Treasury note rose to 5.33% from 5.19%. ??(Times Staff Writer) ??* ??3. Power Crisis Zaps State Bond Rating; Price Controls OKd: The mounting cost to the state general fund of buying electricity for California consumers prompted Standard & Poor's Corp. to downgrade $ 25 billion of California's general obligation bonds. S&P lowered California's bond rating by two notches, to A-plus from AA. The move could add hundreds of millions of dollars to the state's borrowing costs, bond experts said. Separately, federal regulators approved a plan to control electricity prices in California during times of supply shortages. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission tied prices during power emergencies to the cost of natural gas and emission controls, among other things, with the least efficient generator setting the market price. Critics said the order contains loopholes that will allow market manipulation. ??(Nancy Rivera Brooks) ??* ??4. FTC Pans Music Industry Marketing: A much-anticipated sequel to last year's Federal Trade Commission report on the marketing of violent entertainment to children slammed the record industry for failing to heed regulators' recommendations. Though it gave some credit to the film and video-game industries for revising the way they marketed to young audiences, the FTC found the five major record conglomerates continued to advertise "explicit-content" albums on popular teen shows such as MTV's "Total Request Live" and BET's "Top 10 Live." Just before the release of the first report, the Recording Industry Assn. of America had blunted some of the criticism by introducing a policy against ads for such albums on TV shows or in publications whose audience is mostly 16 years old or younger. But the RIAA said it rescinded the policy in September. ??(Jeff Leeds) ??* ??5. Gas Prices Continue Upward Spiral: The average price of self-serve regular gasoline spurted higher again in California and around the nation on an increase in demand and a switch by refiners to the more costly summer gasoline blend required in parts of the country by air-quality regulations. Prices in California got an extra boost from a fire at a Los Angeles-area refinery owned by Tosco Corp. and by a change in Tosco's pricing strategy. In late March, Tosco increased wholesale prices to its dealers in Southern California and Arizona and tied prices to the cost of gasoline in the spot market. Some other major suppliers have begun matching the Tosco increase, market experts said. Some market watchers foresee gas at $ 3 a gallon or more. ??(Nancy Rivera Brooks) ??* ??6. General Dynamics Renews Newport News Bid: General Dynamics Corp. agreed to acquire Newport News Shipbuilding Inc. in a $ 2.1-billion deal that would create the nation's largest military shipbuilder and leave only one maker of U.S. aircraft carriers and submarines. The proposed merger, which the Pentagon had rejected two years ago, marks the latest in a renewed wave of consolidations in the defense industry and would again make General Dynamics one of the largest private employers in San Diego. General Dynamics executives said they are confident of receiving the necessary approvals because this time they will be dealing with the Bush administration, which may view the takeover differently. ??(Peter Pae) ??* ??7. Disney Earnings Beat Estimates: Walt Disney Co.'s second-quarter operating results exceeded Wall Street's expectations as the company's studio and consumer products units improved, although Disney did post a net loss stemming largely from a one-time charge related to the restructuring of its Internet portal. Disney also confirmed that it will shrink its venerable animation unit, with a union official estimating as many as 300 jobs of about 1,000 in Burbank could be cut. Separately, President Robert Iger confirmed that layoffs will be needed to reach Disney's previously announced goal of cutting 4,000 jobs companywide. Disney's studio and consumer products groups showed improved results in the quarter, while earnings were flat in its theme parks and softer in broadcasting. ??(James Bates) ??* ??8. New FCC Chief Vows Deregulation: Repudiating decades-old media ownership rules, Federal Communications Commission Chairman Michael K. Powell said he envisions a broad rollback of restrictions, which could bring about a tidal wave of consolidation. In his most candid remarks about the role of the FCC since taking office, Powell said he would move in early May to eliminate regulations that prevent one company from owning a newspaper and a television station in the same city. Powell also told broadcasters meeting in Las Vegas that Viacom Inc. was likely to prevail in its challenge of federal rules that prevent any broadcaster from owning stations that reach more than 35% of the nation's television viewers. ??(Sallie Hofmeister) ??* ??9. Ford Takes More Heat Over Explorer Tires: Ford Motor Co. came under the most direct criticism leveled against it yet regarding last year's massive Firestone tire recall. Two prominent consumer safety groups issued a report saying that the auto maker was largely to blame for accidents in which Ford Explorer sport-utility vehicles, equipped with Firestone tires, spun out of control after the tires lost their treads. Though they blamed Bridgestone/Firestone for producing tires prone to failure, Public Citizen and Safetyforum.com said Ford bore the bulk of the responsibility for dictating an insufficiently robust tire design and designing the Explorer so it would overly stress the tires and tip over too easily once a tire blew. ??(Terril Yue Jones) ??* ??10. American Airlines Sued Over Health Coverage: A flight attendant filed a complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission in Los Angeles, charging that American Airlines discriminated against some employees by refusing to offer insurance coverage for birth control, Pap tests and infertility treatments. The case could test the position the EEOC took in December that the federal Pregnancy Discrimination Act forbids employers from excluding contraceptives from prescription drug plans. ??(Lisa Girion) ??* ??These and additional stories from last week are available at http://www.latimes.com/business, divided by category. Click on "Money and Investing," "Entertainment Business" and other topics. ??* Please see Monday's Business section for a preview of the week's events. GRAPHIC: PHOTO: Though Disney's second-quarter profit beat Wall Street predictions, its theme-park earnings were flat. ?PHOTOGRAPHER: Associated Press LOAD-DATE: April 29, 2001 ?????????????????????????????30 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 The New York Times Company ??????????????????????????????The New York Times ?????????????????April 29, 2001, Sunday, Late Edition - Final SECTION: Section 4; Page 17; Column 1; Editorial Desk LENGTH: 756 words HEADLINE: Reckonings; The Real Wolf BYLINE: ?By PAUL KRUGMAN BODY: ??Recently I received a letter from an economist I respect, chiding me for my "Naderite" columns on the California energy crisis. He just didn't believe that market manipulation by power companies could possibly be an important issue; it sounded too much to him like the sort of thing one hears from knee-jerk leftists, who blame greedy capitalists for every problem, be it third-world poverty or high apartment rents. The left has cried "Wolf!" so many times that sensible people have learned to discount such claims. ??But now a bona fide wolf has arrived, whose predatory behavior is doing terrible damage to our most populous state -- and nobody will believe it. ???True, California would be heading for a summer of power shortages even if it had never deregulated. And even if there was workable competition in the wholesale electricity market, prices in that market would spike during periods of peak demand, transferring billions of dollars from either taxpayers or consumers to the generators. ??But the evidence is now overwhelming that there isn't workable competition in California's power market, and that the actions of generators "gaming the system" have greatly magnified the crisis. The key fact is that California has somehow remained in a state of more or less continuous power shortage and very high wholesale prices regardless of the level of demand. A rash of outages has kept the electricity market conveniently -- and very profitably -- short of supply even during periods of low demand, when there ought to be lots of excess capacity. ??As Frank Wolak, the Stanford economist who also advises the state's power grid, has pointed out, an outage at a power plant is a lot like an employee calling in sick. You can't tell directly whether he is really sick or has chosen to take the day off for other reasons, but you can look for circumstantial evidence. And such evidence has convinced Mr. Wolak that "generators use forced outages strategically to withhold capacity from the market" -- a view shared by a growing number of other researchers. ??Which brings us to the latest move by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. On Wednesday, the commission apparently decided to offer California some relief, and put new price caps in place on the California electricity market. I say "apparently" because the more you look at the plan the less likely it seems to be any help at all. Indeed, the measure was passed on a 2-to-1 vote, with William Massey -- the one commissioner who has been sympathetic to calls for price controls -- voting against it on the grounds that it would be ineffectual. ??What's wrong with FERC's plan? First, it caps prices only in emergency conditions -- ignoring the fact that electricity prices have stayed at hard-to-explain levels even when there is no emergency. In effect, the plan is laid out as if the electricity market were really competitive, in spite of all the evidence that it is not. ??Second, even those emergency price caps are full of loopholes, offering extensive opportunities for what Mr. Wolak calls "megawatt laundering" -- selling power to affiliated companies that for one reason or another are exempted from the price controls (for example, the controls do not apply to "imports" from neighboring states), then selling it back into the California market. Severin Borenstein of the University of California Energy Institute adds that because the allowed price depends on the cost of generation at the least efficient plant, generators will have a clear incentive to produce inefficiently: "I predict we will find some plants we never heard of before that are suddenly operating again, and they will be pretty inefficient." ??The general verdict seems to be that this is not a serious plan. There are serious proposals to mitigate the crisis out there -- indeed, last fall Mr. Wolak submitted a proposal that was well received by other experts -- but FERC has ignored all of them. ??The charitable interpretation is that FERC still doesn't get it, that it just can't bring itself to believe that this time the wolf is real. The uncharitable interpretation is that last week's action was meant to fail. The Medley Report, an online newsletter, calls the FERC plan "a grand exercise in posturing without substance . . . a very clever temporary move by the Bush administration to deflect any political fallout" from the looming disaster. ??Whatever the explanation, the plain fact is that FERC and the administration have yet to offer California any significant relief. ??http://www.nytimes.com LOAD-DATE: April 29, 2001 ?????????????????????????????35 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 McClatchy Newspapers, Inc. ????????????????????????????????Sacramento Bee ??????????????????April 29, 2001, Sunday METRO FINAL EDITION SECTION: MAIN NEWS; Pg. A1; POWER CRUNCH LENGTH: 1323 words HEADLINE: Diesel plants spark concern They're expected to generate big air-quality problems when predicted summer blackouts hit. BYLINE: Chris Bowman and Stuart Leavenworth Bee Staff Writers BODY: ??When blackouts roll across California in the coming months - as captains of the crippled electricity grid say they surely will - tens of thousands of miniature powerhouses will whine, cough and rumble to the rescue. ??These backup plants will ignite the same fuel that powers locomotives, ships and 18-wheel trucks. And they'll be spewing the same pollution - only more so, because most are old, with little or no emissions controls. ??They are diesel-powered generators, the dirtiest of internal combustion engines. And unlike trucks and other vehicles, they've largely escaped 30 years of air pollution restrictions because they were intended only for emergencies, as when a storm or earthquake knocks out power. ??But, now, as a season of multiple planned blackouts appears imminent, many California businesses are expected to fire up the old stogies more often than was ever imagined. ??And the generators will kick in when their expelled gases can do the most harm. The hot weather that taxes air conditioners and drains electricity supplies also accelerates the conversion of engine exhaust to ozone gas, the ingredient in smog that inflames airways and impairs breathing. ??"That is why we think this is going to be the most challenging summer ever for air quality," said Luna Salaver, spokeswoman for the Bay Area Air Quality Management District, a nine-county region with thousands of unregulated standby generators. ??"On those hot days when we want people to stop driving and doing things that pollute the air, the generators will kick in, and air quality will worsen," Salaver said. ??No one knows how many diesel generators are scattered around the state at hospitals, universities, factories and businesses. But air districts report there are at least 641 in Sacramento; up to 5,000 in the Bay Area; 1,200 in the San Joaquin Valley; and thousands more in the smog-plagued valleys of Southern California. ??Some are relatively clean, particularly if they have been built or retrofitted in the last few years. But most are tiny pollution factories, and were intended only to be run for short periods following natural disasters. ??According to the state Air Resources Board, a typical diesel generator emits about 50 to 100 times more smog-forming compounds per unit of energy than a typical gas-fired power plant. When the plants run for hours, people downwind can get a heavy dose of the tiny, toxic particles contained in diesel exhaust. ??"Go down to the Greyhound bus station and have them turn on their engines and hang around there - that's what it's like," said Michael Scheible, deputy executive officer of the state Air Resources Board, which regulates engines and fuels. ??Environmentalists say generators should be cranked up only during power outages. But in recent months, farmers and manufacturers have pressured regulators to redefine an emergency and allow generators to be used well before a blackout is ordered. ??Business groups say regulators need to be sensitive to data centers, chip makers and other manufacturers that can't afford even a one-second interruption in power. ??"We would like some kind of statewide policy on when and where we can use the diesel generators," said Gino DiCaro, a spokesman for the California Manufacturers and Technology Association. "Obviously, we would like to use them more than we can now." ??"We need to basically let go of this air-quality issue," said Mike Jennings, a Fresno energy consultant whose clients include members of the food-processing and dairy industries. ??State air and energy regulators are pushing energy conservation as the best way to avoid power outages. Nonetheless, the California Energy Commission has been compiling a list of generators statewide to see how their use could be coordinated, a move that stirs hope from business groups. ??"Six months ago, nobody wanted to talk about this because diesel was a big, bad word," DiCaro said. "Now, at least we have agencies like the Energy Commission and the Public Utilities Commission talking about how diesel generators can fit into our electrically unreliable world." ??Environmentalists worry that, as the summer drags on, Gov. Gray Davis will allow unrestricted use of the diesels. ??So far, the governor's staff has "held firm," said Gail Ruderman Feuer, an attorney with the Natural Resources Defense Council, a national environmental group. "But if blackouts start happening in a big way, they could change their tune." ??Along with other forecasters, officials with the California Independent System Operator, manager of the state's electricity grid, expect a flurry of blackouts in coming months. The next two months could be critical, because most new power plants under construction won't go on line before July. In addition, California will be losing one of its largest generators of electricity today when one of two units at the Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant is taken off-line for 35 days of scheduled refueling. ??"You should be ready for the worst-case scenario," said Del Evans, Pacific Gas and Electric Co.'s head of power load management, at a media briefing last week. ??For sellers and makers of diesel generators, the gloomy predictions are a gold mine. Small businesses, farmers, manufacturers - all are rushing to buy generators before the blackouts hit. ??"We are busier than we have ever been," said Rob Bly, president of Tuban Industrial Products Co., which assembles about 300 generators a year at its plant in Sacramento. "We are twice as busy as we were in the height of the Y2K madness." ??Bly says the generators he makes are "10 times cleaner" than ones of a decade ago. Still, he acknowledges, diesel is diesel. ??"If you are a hospital and you want standby power, you can't use propane. The fire marshall won't let you," said Bly. "That leaves you with just one thing, and that is diesel." ??Responding to such concerns, state Sen. Rico Oller, R-Andreas, introduced a bill this year to exempt thousands of backup generators from pollution controls whenever any power alert is called. The bill, however, was blocked by a Senate committee, and environmentalists say air districts have already relaxed their rules enough. ??"One of the big concerns is the cancer risk," Ruderman Feuer said. Air board studies, she noted, have found that a person's lifetime cancer risk increases 50 percent if he or she lives near a big diesel generator that runs 250 hours a year. ??In January, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency allowed air districts to loosen their restrictions on generators. In turn, the South Coast Air Quality Management District extended the number of hours that diesel generators could be operated each year. The San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District went even further, allowing businesses to run generators when state power reserves drop to 1.5 percent or when the ISO predicts blackouts anywhere in the Valley. ??The Sacramento Metropolitan Air Quality Management District still requires businesses and public agencies to wait for blackouts before generators are fired up. Altogether, the district has permits for 641 generators, including major clusters at data centers and companies such as Intel. ??In the Bay Area, regulators are even more uncertain of what could happen this summer. Unlike other regions of the state, the Bay Area never required permits for diesel generators smaller than 250 horsepower. (In Sacramento, the threshold is 50 horsepower.) ??As a result, only 12 of the region's estimated 5,000 generators are subject to pollution controls. ??Salaver, the district's spokeswoman, said officials assumed the generators would be used only during earthquakes, and therefore didn't need any regulation. ??"Now, we find people are operating generators even if we are in a Stage Two alert," Salaver said. "That is not what emergency generators are for." ??* * * ??The Bee's Chris Bowman can be reached at (916) 321-1069 or cbowman@sacbee.com. GRAPHIC: Sacramento Bee / Jay Mather Mark Karakas checks a newly assembled diesel generator at Tuban Industrial Products in Sacramento. Sacramento Bee / Sheldon Carpenter Lights out, generators on Diesel-powered generators can save lives during emergencies, but they spew far more pollution per unit of energy than other power sources and could significantly degrade air quality during the blackouts expected in the next six months. Smog-forming compounds Power source / Pounds of nitrogen oxides per megawatt-hour of electricity Existing diesel generator / 25 to 30 Diesel generator wiht latest pollution controls / 7 Uncontrolled gas-fired power plant / 2 to 4 Controlled older gas-fired power plant / 0.1-0.15 New "combined cycle" gas-fired power plant / 0.05 Cancer causing particulates (PM) Power source / Pounds of PM per megawatt-hour of electricity Existing diesel generator / 1 to 3 Diesel generator wiht latest pollution controls / 0.1 to 0.5 Gas-fired power plant / 0.03 to 0.07 Snapshot of generators Number of emergency diesel generators in selected air districst: Bay Area Air quality Management District Generators: 3,000 to 5,000 Sacramento Metropolitan Air Quality Management District Generators: 641 San Joaquin Valley Air Pollution Control District Generators: 1,200 South Coast Air Quality Management District Generators: 5,000 Sources: California Air Resources Board, regional air quality districts LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????36 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 McClatchy Newspapers, Inc. ????????????????????????????????Sacramento Bee ??????????????????April 29, 2001, Sunday METRO FINAL EDITION SECTION: MAIN NEWS; Pg. A1 LENGTH: 1544 words HEADLINE: Why Edison, PG&E split on strategy BYLINE: Dale Kasler Bee Staff Writer BODY: ??One utility was more entrepreneurial, accustomed to the rough-and-tumble of free markets - and apparently believed only a radical remedy would cure its ills. ??The other was a more political animal, conversant with the language of Sacramento - and confident that negotiations and compromise with state officials could fix its problems. ??Different cultures and different circumstances sent Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas and Electric Co. on separate paths this month. Edison, run by a former president of the Public Utilities Commission, negotiated a rescue package with Gov. Gray Davis. PG&E, with fewer ties to government and possessed of an independent streak, walked away from Davis and straight into U.S. Bankruptcy Court. ??As California's energy crisis hurtles toward a summer of blackouts and higher rates, experts are debating which company found the best solution for digging its way out of billions in debt. ??"We now have two models; it'll be interesting to see who recovers the quickest," said Mitch Wilk, a former PUC president who is now an energy consultant in San Francisco. ??At first blush, Edison and PG&E had plenty in common. Both utilities were afflicted with the same problem: runaway wholesale electricity costs they weren't able to recover from customers because of a state-mandated rate freeze. Both had been teetering on the edge of bankruptcy since January, when their losses depleted their cash reserves and credit. ??But PG&E was far sicker financially than Edison. Its debts from the state's flawed deregulation scheme reached $6.6 billion vs. $3.5 billion for Edison. That's because Edison serves a smaller territory and has more long-term supply contracts, so it was buying far less electricity than PG&E on the horrendously expensive spot market. ??Faced with a comparatively manageable loss, Edison was receptive to selling its share of California's transmission grid to the state, a deal that would generate $2.76 billion. The proceeds, along with funds from a proposed long-term bond sale, would pay off Edison's debts, according to the terms of the deal. ??Although PG&E says it was willing to sell its transmission lines, too, there was a crucial difference in the two companies' backgrounds that ultimately would influence their approach to the financial crisis. ??Unlike Edison, PG&E is a natural gas company as well as an electric company. PG&E, a subsidiary of PG&E Corp., had survived the bruising wars of natural gas deregulation in the late 1980s and early 1990s. The experience took PG&E out of the cozy world of the regulated monopoly - in which the utility had exclusive rights to its service territory but was subject to state price controls - and into the world of competition. ??The experience gave PG&E more of a free-market bent, said a former PUC staffer who requested anonymity. ??So even though Davis' aides say the governor offered PG&E a plan that would have paid off its debts - including $3 billion to $4 billion for its share of the grid - the utility balked at a key provision. While the original deregulation called for the cap on customer prices to end in 2002, Davis was insisting the utility remain regulated for a decade. ??PG&E wanted an immediate end to Public Utilities Commission regulation, and would agree only to a cursory review of rates through "a jury-rigged arbitration," Davis said last week. ??"I believe PG&E was in denial," Davis said in an interview with Bee editors and reporters. ??PG&E says it wasn't demanding an end to regulation. Rather, what it wanted - and what Davis' negotiator Michael Peevey agreed to in principle - was to let the utility charge ratepayers for all its costs of buying wholesale electricity, said PG&E spokesman Ron Low. ??In that same deal, reached Feb. 25 in Los Angeles, PG&E made a "handshake agreement" to sell its transmission grid, Low said. He wouldn't reveal the price. ??In the weeks that followed, the governor's team reneged, Low said. "The discussions and negotiations broke down because they would not agree to the basic principles that were reached by (PG&E Chairman) Bob Glynn and Michael Peevey," Low said. ??PG&E also became disgusted with a series of PUC rulings in late March and early April that it believed would seriously hinder its ability to recover its debts. ??Things came to a head April 5 when Davis proposed a rate increase and outlined his rescue plan in a televised address. A few minutes later, Joseph Fichera, a Wall Street financier advising Davis, and other Davis advisers held a conference call in which they fleshed out the details for investors. Edison officials and directors listened in, but PG&E didn't, Fichera said. ??"They had made up their minds," Fichera said, referring to PG&E officials. ??The next morning, with Glynn dismissing Davis' speech as "a lot of words," the utility filed for bankruptcy protection. ??That afternoon, Davis called PG&E "selfish" and pointedly went into a negotiating session with John Bryson, the chairman and chief executive of Edison's parent Edison International. ??For Davis, the meeting was crucial. Although Edison had tentatively agreed in February to sell its transmission lines, the deal wasn't sewn up and Davis was nervous the PG&E bankruptcy would prompt Edison's creditors to "jerk Edison into bankruptcy," Davis said last week. ??That afternoon, "conceptually we reached an agreement," Davis said. The deal was announced the following Monday. ??Consumer advocates and some legislative leaders blasted the agreement as a giveaway, and said Davis hastily sweetened the terms for Edison because he needed to show progress on the energy crisis in the wake of the PG&E imbroglio. ??Not true, Davis said; the basic terms were already on the table before PG&E filed for bankruptcy. Either way, Edison was receptive to negotiating with Davis. ??Edison's background is different from PG&E's. Because it isn't in the natural gas business, it doesn't have the track record PG&E does with free markets. It is more comfortable in the regulatory and political realm, experts say. ??Notably, Bryson was president of the PUC in the 1970s - when Davis was Gov. Jerry Brown's chief of staff. ??"He knows Gray Davis," said ex-PUC President Wilk. "He may feel a higher level of comfort in dealing with a very adversarial process. He felt he could rely on the governor." ??Politically savvy, Edison is one of the utility industry's biggest contributors to national political campaigns, and it usually spends more than PG&E on California campaigns. Edison International's board of directors includes Los Angeles attorney Warren Christopher, the former U.S. secretary of state and an elder statesman of the Democratic Party. ??Though it's open to negotiations, Edison isn't a pussycat. To the contrary, experts say. ??"It was usually Edison that was more combative than PG&E," said Tom Willoughby, a retired PG&E lobbyist. ??Wilk agreed, adding: "I find it curious that PG&E's being painted as the confrontational, aggressive company and Edison as the get-along, let's-work-with-the-regulators company." ??Edison hasn't been shy about going to Sacramento for favors; last year, for example, Edison wanted some changes made in the operation of the state's power grid. Instead of talking to the grid manager, the Independent System Operator, Edison went to the Legislature, a source said. Lawmakers then pressured the ISO to make the changes. ??One more factor may have played into Edison's willingness to deal with the governor. ??Last year it became involved in a protracted dispute with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which oversees the transmission grid, over how much profit Edison could earn from the grid. ??Edison eventually won its point, but the case influenced the utility's thinking when Davis offered to buy the grid. According to industry consultant Barbara Barkovich, Edison figured, why wrestle with the federal government over profits when it simply could raise billions through a cash sale? ??Besides, Edison has a back-up plan if the Legislature scraps the grid purchase, as many lawmakers have threatened. The company has said it would follow PG&E's lead and file for bankruptcy. ??But its willingness to negotiate with the governor will have served it well, even if it goes into bankruptcy, said Nancy Day, a utility industry veteran consulting for the Legislature. ??Day said she believes the governor's appointees on the PUC will "punish" PG&E for its behavior. If Edison winds up in bankruptcy court, it "won't be punished for it," Day said. ??PUC President Loretta Lynch couldn't be reached for comment. ??Energy companies at a glance Edison Main subsidiary: Southern California Edison Headquarters: Rosemead, Los Angeles County Customers: 4.2 million in Southern California Chairman: John Bryson Performance: Lost $1.94 billion in 2000 on revenue of $11.72 billion Stock ticker symbol: EIX ??PG&E Main subsidiary: Pacific Gas and Electric Co. Headquarters: San Francisco Customers: 13 million in Northern, Central California Chairman: Robert Glynn Jr. Performance: Lost $3.36 billion in 2000 on revenue of $26.23 billion. Stock ticker symbol: PCG ??* * * ??The Bee's Dale Kasler can be reached at (916) 321-1066 or dkasler@sacbee.com. GRAPHIC: Bryson Glynn LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????37 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 McClatchy Newspapers, Inc. ????????????????????????????????Sacramento Bee ??????????????????April 29, 2001, Sunday METRO FINAL EDITION SECTION: MAIN NEWS; Pg. A3 LENGTH: 679 words HEADLINE: What will be fallout from California's energy meltdown? BYLINE: Dan Walters BODY: ??No one knows for certain how - or when - California's energy crisis will conclude. It is an inordinately complicated four-dimensional chess game that has so far defied politicians' simplistic - perhaps simple-minded - efforts at resolution. ??That said, one may speculate reasonably on the financial, social and political consequences for California in the months and years ahead. ??Financially, Californians - especially the 70 percent who are served by private electric utilities - will feel the pinch for years, if not decades, to come. Before the crisis hit, California's power rates were already among the highest in the nation. Given the nearly $20 billion in power purchase debts that the utilities and the state have accumulated so far, the stubbornly high wholesale prices and other data, it's not unreasonable to project that Californians in private utility areas will see their rates double, or rise even higher. ??Politicians have been laying the rhetorical groundwork for big increases, although they've been disingenuous about the outer parameters. The burden will fall most heavily on business customers and, coupled with doubts about power reliability and rising natural gas prices, will damage the state's ability to attract job-creating investment. States with low and stable energy prices already are using the crisis as a recruiting tool. In February, Intel President Craig Barrett told the Wall Street Journal: "As long as California is a Third World country, we won't build $2 billion manufacturing plants here." ??The inevitable escalation of utility rates will create distortions within the state as well, since utility rates for the 30 percent of Californians served by publicly owned utilities are not likely to rise by more than token amounts. The municipal utilities' rates were roughly a third lower than private utilities' rates prior to the crisis. By the time the dust settles, they may be just half as much. It will contribute to the balkanization of California that was already being defined by such factors as housing prices, ethnicity and income levels. Low-cost regions will become magnets for people and jobs while high-price regions will be shunned. ??The energy crisis will certainly be the defining issue of the 2002 elections, and perhaps for others to follow. Gov. Gray Davis' popularity has plummeted since he took charge of the crisis, laying waste to his intentions to seek an easy re-election next year as a middle-of-the-road, business-friendly, tough-on-crime education reformer. ??With his popularity waning, Davis may be compelled to turn left, shoring up his base by catering to demands of labor unions, environmentalists, trial lawyers and other liberal elements of the Democratic Party. That, in turn, would undermine the triangulating strategy he has pursued, in which he took Democratic voters for granted and cultivated business executives and social conservatives. Business interests are worried, for example, that Davis may now feel compelled to sign union-friendly legislation, such as boosts in workers' compensation and unemployment benefits, that he vetoed in the past. ??Davis' relations with fellow Democrats in the Legislature have turned from cool to poisonous, with lawmakers openly trashing his leadership and management of the energy crisis and worrying that he'll try to shift the blame to them if the crisis turns to disaster. If Democratic leaders fear that voters will be in a throw-the-bums-out mood next year, they may throttle back on intentions to maximize their party strength in drawing new legislative districts. Such maximization would require spreading Democratic voters out among many districts, and such margin-thinning could make Democrats vulnerable in an energy crisis-spawned voter rebellion. Democrats may well strive for fewer but safer seats. ??These are but a few of the potential effects that California will experience long after the immediate crisis has faded, whenever that may be. ??* * * ??The Bee's Dan Walters can be reached at (916) 321-1195 or dwalters@sacbee.com. LOAD-DATE: April 30, 2001 ?????????????????????????????38 of 103 DOCUMENTS ?????????????????Copyright 2001 The Chronicle Publishing Co. ?????????????????????????The San Francisco Chronicle ????????????????????APRIL 29, 2001, SUNDAY, FINAL EDITION SECTION: INSIGHT; Pg. D1 LENGTH: 1419 words HEADLINE: The energy crisis is good for you SOURCE: Insight Senior Writer BYLINE: Louis Freedberg BODY: Here's a message for pampered and overindulged citizens of the Golden State who complain unceasingly about high energy bills and the day-to-day prospect of rolling blackouts: Stop whining. ???It's not a crisis -- it's an opportunity. The energy "crisis" is good for us. ???For decades, we burned lights whenever we wanted, bought more and more energy-guzzling appliances, bigger and bigger television sets. Today, as citizens of the richest state in the world's only superpower, who is going to tell us when to stop? ???"We talk about having to hit mules over the head with a 2 by 4 to get their attention, but I don't think human beings are much more responsive or foresighted. I hate to see people suffering, but on the other hand, if that is the way we learn, so be it," says Ernest Callenbach, the Berkeley author of the futuristic 1975 novel, "Ecotopia." Callenbach's work was a major influence on the alternative energy policies of former Gov. Jerry Brown. ???Nowhere has the ethic of unlimited consumption been more out of control than in the Bay Area, where the energy demands of high tech outstripped what the electricity grid could supply. Aside from the energy needs of the industry itself, the wealth it generated encouraged avaricious lifestyles that include power-swilling mansions and freeways clogged with monster sport utility vehicles. ???Perhaps the 34 days of blackouts some experts predict for this summer will bring the discipline that eludes us. Except for the hardships the crisis has inflicted on the poor, Californians still enjoy a sybaritic lifestyle that, in ways, would put to shame the pharaohs of Egypt or the court of Louis XIV. Lights still burn when they're not needed. Except for very occasional blackouts, electricity still flows 24 hours a day. Our daily routines have barely been affected. A visitor from another state or country would have a hard time finding signs of our highly publicized "crisis." ???As we brace for deregulated electric bills courtesy of the state Public Utilities Commission, imagine what life was like for Native Americans who lived for millennia in a bounteous Bay Area without microwaves, waffle irons, air conditioning or 24-cubic-foot refrigerators. No one is suggesting that we revert to those days. But let's consider the thought that we may actually be better off without the piles of appliances whose tangle of cords clogs our homes and offices. ???Smug Californians love to point to the state's ranking as a miserly consumer of energy -- only three other states consume less per capita -- to rebut accusations that we have become greedy energy hogs. Tougher efficiency standards have helped, but so has our great weather. "California has a uniquely good climate to be efficient," says Dan Kammen, director of the Renewable and Appropriate Energy Laboratory at the University of California at Berkeley. "Compared to countries with much harsher climates, we have not done enough." ???There's no denying the sudden, sharp pain caused by the crisis -- from threats of sky-high electric bills to fears that California's economic engine is near collapse. But if we handle it right, all kinds of positive energy will result. Potential benefits extend from the spiritual (a revival of the conservation ethic) to the curative (making the state immune to power-problem overloads) to the liberating (throwing off for good our dependence on the Texas energy overlords). ???Consumers, shocked into action by tripled or quadrupled energy bills, are already rushing to Bay Area hardware stores, snapping up setback thermostats, hot water heater blankets, insulating window film and outdoor clotheslines. Alan Ginsberg of Satco Products in Hayward, who imports from China container-loads of squiggly shaped energy-saving fluorescent bulbs, says, "They're flying out the door." ???More significantly, the crisis impels the state to move ahead with the construction of badly needed power plants. It puts on the agenda of public debate the fundamental question of whether our energy system should be in the hands of giant utilities or run by municipalities or by the state. It certainly unveiled the greed of out-of-state energy producers who have sucked billions of dollars from California. ???The crisis has also made us focus on fundamental flaws in our energy grid, such as the 4,500-megawatt electricity shortage that emerged in the 1990s while we were all reveling in California's boom times. ???By exposing those who got us into this predicament -- producers, utilities, regulators and politicians -- there's a chance we'll get out of it with a more rational and efficient energy grid and be better prepared to deal with challenges down the road. If that happens, Gov. Gray Davis might yet confound critics who say his political prospects are sinking faster than you can say "megawatt." ???The ease and convenience of modern life fools us into thinking that power, water and food are infinite. Flip a switch and the lights magically go on. Turn a faucet and water flows. These days, the biggest challenge in gathering our daily bread is the hunt for a space in the supermarket parking lot. ???And we want it all, leading us straight into denial. We want instant, abundant power -- but we don't want any new power plants, especially in our backyards. Coal is dirty. Natural gas is expensive. Dams kill salmon. Nuclear power? Forget about it. The contradictions haven't mattered -- so long as an endless supply of electrons flowed from our wall outlets. But that mindless ease, the crisis taught us, is history. ???The energy crisis warns us that we must become more self-sufficient or risk slipping toward oblivion if we continue to spend billions of dollars on shrinking non-renewable energy sources such as coal and natural gas. ???The Roman Empire fell because of the decadence of its ruling elites. And the British empire, dependent on raw materials from the colonies, began to collapse when it became too expensive to import goods across oceans. ???A new consciousness about where electricity comes from is the first step toward using less of it. It could also translate into a greater awareness of other environmental causes. ???If we get the message, "the net outcome (of the energy crisis) will be a quite profound shift in consciousness in energy conservation," predicts Michael Lerner, executive director of Commonweal, a health and environmental institute in Bolinas. ???Such a turnaround is no snap. ???During the last energy crisis in the 1970s, there was a similar rush toward conservation. President Jimmy Carter installed solar panels on the White House roof. President Ronald Reagan took them down. He also phased out tax credits and other inducements to encourage development of renewable energy sources. ???Closer to home, one of former Gov. George Deukmejian's first acts was to abolish the Office of Appropriate Technology established by Gov. Jerry Brown to move us away from our dependence on non-renewable fossil fuels. ???Since then, we have regressed further. Even record high gasoline prices have done nothing to depress the sales of SUVs, which now account for the largest share of automobile and light truck sales (20 percent at last count). ???But today's crisis could lead to permanent changes in behavior, if only because the technology needed to harness sun, wind and other renewable energy sources has become far more cost effective than a generation ago. California already gets 12 percent of its energy from these "alternative" sources, and the market incentives to develop them further has never been higher. ???Stratospherically high electricity bills could finally force on us the technological changes and the discipline that Europeans -- who use two-thirds as much energy per capita as we do -- and the Japanese -- who use only half as much -- have had to embrace. ???This difficult moment in California's history has already yielded some ecological epiphanies, like those experienced by Ernest Callenbach's neighbors. They installed solar photovoltaic cells on their roof. The installation now puts surplus electricity back into the energy grid, instead of sucking more out of it. ???"The magical moment is the idea that by having a photovoltaic cell on your roof, you can make your electric meter run backward," said Callenbach. "Instead of it going to the right, you actually see it going in the other direction. You say to yourself, 'Oh Lord, Oh Lord, I have seen the future.' " ??Email Louis Freedberg at lfreedberg@sfchronicle.com GRAPHIC: GRAPHIC, Don McCartney/The Chronicle LOAD-DATE: April 29, 2001 ?????????????????????????????44 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 Ventura County Star ?????????????????????????????Ventura County Star ????????????????????????????April 29, 2001 Sunday SECTION: Editorials; Pg. B09 LENGTH: 704 words HEADLINE: Reality is what's needed for real policy GOVERNOR: Consumers deserve to get real facts from Davis. BYLINE: Dan Walters BODY: ??Gov. Gray Davis is continuing to tell Californians that he's on top of the state's energy crisis and, as he said at one gathering last week, "in three years this problem will be a distant memory." Fat chance. All major aspects of the situation are growing worse, not better, minute-by-minute. ??Politicians took over the crisis in January as the state's major utilities exhausted their cash reserves and lines of credit. Davis began what he said then would be a short-term, emergency program of power purchases to keep electrons flowing into homes and businesses. ??From that moment forward, the situation has steadily deteriorated, moving toward a three-pronged disaster: severe summer blackouts, the bankruptcy of the utilities and sharply escalating power bills. With the bankruptcy filing by Pacific Gas & Electric Co. and decisions by Davis and the Public Utilities Commission to begin ratcheting up utility rates, two of the three negative scenarios are now in place. And everyone involved in the crisis expects blackouts this summer as demands for power soar and supplies dwindle. ??The Davis strategy, if there is one, is to continue the state's massive power purchases while negotiating longer-term and presumably cheaper supply contracts, encourage conservation, help utilities pay off their debts by selling their intercity transmission system to the state and tapping ratepayers, and build more power plants to ease the supply crunch. ??Currently, the governor is touting his deal with Edison International, parent company of Southern California Edison, to sell its portion of the grid and is working on a similar deal with Sempra, the parent of San Diego Gas and Electric. But PG&E's bankruptcy casts doubt on the viability of the cash-for-grid concept and legislators, particularly Davis' fellow Democrats, are very skeptical of the Edison deal. ??Clearly, Davis rushed into the Edison deal just three days after PG&E filed bankruptcy, in hopes of erasing the political stain of the latter action, but its provisions are being labeled a "bailout" by critics. It places only a token financial burden on Edison International while guaranteeing the profitability of its utility subsidiary by charging its customers whatever is required to cover its costs and past debts. ??Meanwhile, the state is spending -- by Davis' own account -- about $70 million a day or $2-plus billion a month on spot power purchases, paying roughly five times what consumers are being charged at the retail level. And the current futures market for power indicates that wholesale power prices will jump by another 50 percent by mid-summer; higher prices and greater purchases could increase the drain on the state treasury to as much as $5 billion a month. ??State Treasurer Phil Angelides is desperately trying to arrange a "bridge loan" to relieve pressure on the state's rapidly vanishing reserves, but Wall Street is reluctant to lend without a fuller explanation of what's happening and a specific authorization from a suspicious Legislature. ??He said Tuesday that Davis, who has maintained secrecy on power purchases, must offer a comprehensive and public plan for dealing with the financial squeeze. ??Meanwhile, bankers are sending strong signals that the state government is becoming as poor a lending risk as the utilities. ??Davis, for some reason, is unwilling to declare this situation the emergency that it is truly becoming -- one that could take a toll of human life if major blackouts shut down air conditioners, respirators and traffic lights. He insists on issuing his periodic -- and wholly unrealistic -- assurances that things will turn out all right, even declaring to reporters this past Tuesday that "we think we'll have this thing licked by the end of fall." ??It's time for someone -- the governor, preferably, but someone -- to lay out for Californians exactly what's happening, the downside financial and power supply risks, and what's being done to deal with the looming disaster facing this state. ??It's time for politicians to treat us as adults who can face reality, not as children to be fed sugarcoated sound bites and slogans. ??-- Dan Walters writes for the Sacramento Bee. LOAD-DATE: April 29, 2001 ?????????????????????????????49 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ????????????????????April 28, 2001, Saturday, Home Edition SECTION: Part A; Part 1; Page 19; Metro Desk LENGTH: 679 words HEADLINE: OFFICIALS CALL PRICE STABILITY PLAN ILLEGAL; UTILITIES: AGENCY CHIEFS SAY THE FEDERAL PROPOSAL COULD ALSO CAUSE MORE BLACKOUTS THIS SUMMER. BYLINE: NANCY VOGEL and MIGUEL BUSTILLO, TIMES STAFF WRITERS DATELINE: SACRAMENTO BODY: ??Two top state energy officials said Friday that a federal plan to stabilize electricity prices in California could increase the odds of blackouts this summer and most likely is illegal. ??In a barrage of complaints attacking the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, the state's top power regulator and the head of the board overseeing California's transmission grid said they might challenge the federal order in court. ??The order was approved on a 2-1 vote Wednesday and released to the public late Thursday. ??"We're going to take whatever actions we can to oppose this to the extent our lawyers tell us it's illegal," said Michael Kahn, an attorney named by Gov. Gray Davis to head the board overseeing the California Independent System Operator. Cal-ISO manages the transmission grid reaching three-quarters of the state. ??In a conference call with reporters, Kahn and Loretta Lynch, president of the California Public Utilities Commission, said the order also seems to indicate that FERC is unwilling to force power sellers to rebate any of the extraordinary profits earned before last October in California's market, where wholesale electricity prices began soaring last May. ??And, according to Kahn, the federal order illegally ties limits on power prices to a requirement that California link its transmission grid with those of other states. ??"It's not within their authority to have this kind of linkage," he said. ??The federal order is scheduled to take effect May 29. Though it is not clear how the order will play out in the state's electricity market, Lynch and Kahn said they do not believe it will bring down power costs or help the state avoid blackouts, as intended. ??"They're creating a whole new, wholesale blackout system," said Lynch, referring to a section of the order that allows large customers, such as steel mills and food processors, to get paid to shut down when grid operators are struggling to find enough electricity to meet demand. ??Though a somewhat similar program has helped California avoid blackouts, the federal order requires state power buyers to name the price to which electricity must rise before they shut down customers. ??The requirement of naming a price could lead to more blackouts, said Stanford University economist Frank Wolak, because it prevents power buyers from paying more if that's what it takes to keep electricity flowing. ??"Stating your price and sticking to it means that somebody could call your bluff," Wolak said. "The generators just say, look, we can't supply all you want at the price you want to pay. ??"So they supply everything they can at the price we're willing to pay--and no more--and we have rotating blackouts," he said. ??Lynch said that no matter how this aspect of the FERC order unfolds, "it ain't for Washington bureaucrats to decide when the lights go out in California. " ??Grid operators at Cal-ISO must quickly buy batches of electricity to constantly match supply and demand on the transmission system serving most of the state, excluding the city of Los Angeles. When Cal-ISO cannot find enough power, it must order Southern California Edison, Pacific Gas & Electric and San Diego Gas & Electric to trigger rotating blackouts. ??The state suffered such controlled outages on four days in January and March, and many such days are predicted for this summer as air conditioning drives up demand for power. ??In other energy news Friday, Gov. Gray Davis announced in Los Angeles that electricity use in California state office buildings dropped by an average of 20% in the first two months of this year, compared to the same months of 2000. State workers have been under orders since late last year to turn off nonessential lights, computers, printers and other electrical appliances. Some agencies have even changed workers' schedules, eliminating "flextime" so that everyone works the same hours and the offices can open later and close earlier, shortening the energy-using day. ??* ??Times staff writer Mitchell Landsberg in Los Angeles contributed to this story. LOAD-DATE: April 28, 2001 ?????????????????????????????50 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ????????????????????April 28, 2001, Saturday, Home Edition SECTION: Part A; Part 1; Page 19; Metro Desk LENGTH: 688 words HEADLINE: BILL COULD FOIL DAVIS' ELECTRICITY OFFENSIVE; POWER: CONGRESSMAN WANTS TO LET SMALL PRODUCERS SELL ON WHOLESALE MARKET. BACKERS SAY PLAN WOULD BOOST SUPPLY, BUT FOES SEE IT COSTING CALIFORNIA DEARLY. BYLINE: JULIE TAMAKI and MIGUEL BUSTILLO, TIMES STAFF WRITERS DATELINE: SACRAMENTO BODY: ??A Texas congressman plans to introduce legislation next week that would allow California's small power producers to sell their supplies on the wholesale market--a move that could threaten Gov. Gray Davis' plan to end the state's energy crisis. ??The proposal by Republican Rep. Joe Barton, the influential chairman of the House energy and air quality subcommittee, would permit producers of alternative and renewable energy to suspend their contracts with the state's two biggest investor-owned utilities and sell their supplies to a third party. ??Proponents say the bill could dramatically bolster the state's electricity supplies by luring producers whose plants have been shut down by payment disputes to restart them in time for summer, when supplies are expected to be tight and blackouts are feared. ??But allowing producers to sell to a third party would essentially devastate Davis' plan to rescue the utilities and get the state out of the business of making emergency electricity purchases. ??The governor's plan is based on California locking down the costs of electricity from the utilities and small power producers for several years, at a reduced cost. ??During that time, the state would buy the remaining portion of the electricity the utilities need to serve their customers. Meanwhile, the utilities would regain their financial footing by selling assets to the state in exchange for being allowed to recover a portion of their back debt through a surcharge on electricity bills. ??If the alternative producers were allowed to sell their power on the wholesale market, the state could be forced to purchase much more electricity on the expensive open market. ??That would dramatically increase California's already massive power costs, forcing the state to further raise electricity rates and borrow even more than the record $ 12 billion in bonds it is planning to finance the plan. The state has spent more than $ 5 billion buying electricity that the utilities cannot afford, and Davis expects to spend $ 15 billion by year's end. ??"It is a way of busting the budget for the state of California," said Joseph Fichera, a Wall Street energy consultant hired by the Davis administration. He called the potential release of the small producers a "disaster scenario" for the state. ??Added Stephen E. Frank, chairman, president and chief executive of Southern California Edison: "Releasing them from their contractual obligations will simply exacerbate the problem, because they would then be selling into the market at additionally higher rates and just compound the state's problems." ??But Eugene Peters of the Electric Power Supply Assn. disputed that contention. The state, he said, is already buying replacement supplies on the open market because of reduced output by small producers. ??"If 3,000 megawatts are made available again, it will have a potentially profound effect on what people pay for power by bolstering overall electricity supplies," Peters said. ??Utility executives contend that only 1,200 megawatts are offline because of payment problems. ??California is home to nearly 700 small energy producers, which generate more than a quarter of the electricity consumed in the state. They differ from their big out-of-state counterparts, which have been getting paid by the state. ??The Barton proposal will be the subject of public hearings Tuesday and Thursday, and could move to the full House Energy and Commerce Committee for a vote the next week. Barton could not be reached for comment Friday. ??The alternative-energy provision is one of several in his emergency energy bill. Others designed to help the West through a difficult summer of price spikes and energy shortages range from offering federal aid to relieving a bottleneck in the transmission system to permitting governors to secure waivers from environmental rules to boost power supplies. ??The provisions dealing with waivers of environmental rules have been among the most controversial, drawing opposition from environmentalists. ??* ??Times staff writer Richard Simon in Washington contributed to this story. LOAD-DATE: April 28, 2001 ?????????????????????????????51 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????????Copyright 2001 / Los Angeles Times ??????????????????????????????Los Angeles Times ????????????????????April 28, 2001, Saturday, Home Edition SECTION: Business; Part C; Page 2; Financial Desk LENGTH: 137 words HEADLINE: BRIEFLY / ENERGY; PUC ORDERS UTILITIES TO POST BLACKOUT DATA BYLINE: Nancy Rivera Brooks BODY: ??Responding to customer complaints, the California Public Utilities Commission ordered Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric to tell customers more about when they will be blacked out during times of extreme power shortages. The PUC told Edison and SDG&E to begin listing on electricity bills by June 1 the "outage block" into which each customer falls. ?The utilities then must use their Web sites to tell customers which blocks are slated for blackouts should more rotating outages be required. Pacific Gas & Electric Co. already lists outage block numbers on its customer bills. A pop-up box on PG&E's Web site shows which blocks are next in line for blackouts. Edison and SDG&E said they have been working on implementing such notification on their own and will comply with the PUC ruling. LOAD-DATE: April 28, 2001 ?????????????????????????????53 of 103 DOCUMENTS ??????????????????Copyright 2001 McClatchy Newspapers, Inc. ????????????????????????????????Sacramento Bee ?????????????????April 28, 2001, Saturday METRO FINAL EDITION SECTION: MAIN NEWS; Pg. A3; POWER CRUNCH LENGTH: 1109 words HEADLINE: Cities take new look at public power The state's uncertain electricity picture has local officials deciding it's time to revisit the idea of municipal utilities. BYLINE: Carrie Peyton Bee Staff Writer BODY: ??From the shipwreck of California's electric industry, Albert Vera sees a chance to build a life raft. ??"This is an opportunity that shall never come again," the former Culver City mayor told city and county officials gathered this week in Sacramento. ??Every rate hike, every blackout, every corporate bonus is more evidence for believers that it's time for local government to get into the power business. They pin their hopes on municipal utility drives in San Francisco, Corona, San Diego County and beyond. ??Over the past few years, however, only a handful of cities have set up their own electric departments, and they are mostly limited entities that fall short of full-fledged utilities. More commonly, cities - including Davis, Lincoln and Culver City - have studied the idea and rejected it, at least temporarily. ??They all face the same question, said Santa Rosa City Manager Jeffrey Kolin: ??"Is the investment worth the risk? Most of us would say we don't know yet." ??Kolin's city, like scores of others across the state, has decided it is time to study the issue anew, motivated by the prospect of soaring electric bills, repeated blackouts, and Pacific Gas and Electric Co.'s bankruptcy filing. ??"All their citizens are screaming," said Yvonne Hunter, a lobbyist for the League of California Cities. ??The highest visibility fight will likely come in November, when San Franciscans go to the polls to decided whether to create their own utility in a city that houses PG&E's corporate headquarters. ??"We will take it very seriously," PG&E spokesman John Nelson said. ??Shortly after deregulation in 1996, several drives for ratepayer-owned utilities stumbled or stalled. An effort in the far north state to create a multicounty public power agency was rejected by state regulators because some local governments objected. ??Now, with a bill to create a state power authority moving through the Legislature, some believe the climate may be changing. ??"One of the things this crisis has proved is the value of local control," said Jerry Jordan, head of the California Municipal Utilities Association. ??Since January, the cities of Hercules in the Bay Area and Corona in Southern California have formed utilities to deliver electric service to new neighborhoods - a strategy that sidesteps potential condemnation fights with the existing utility. The county of San Diego is trying to get special legislative authority to create a regional power agency without a popular vote. ??"We could produce power better, cheaper and faster than the private sector," county Supervisor Dianne Jacob said. ??Not so, say PG&E and Southern California Edison. ??"There's been much more talk of it, but as soon as most folks sit down and take a look at the realities ... they realize that they would have to buy on the same market, at the same outrageous prices that we and the state have been paying," Nelson said. "The talk quickly evaporates." ??For-profit utilities have long argued that government shouldn't usurp the role of private industry in delivering electricity. PG&E contends that the factors that once made public power attractive - such as access to low-cost electricity from federal dams - have evaporated. ??In addition, cities that try to withdraw from PG&E or Edison now probably would still have to funnel money their way for years to come, to pay off still-unsold state bonds that will stretch out a single year's power costs for up to 15 years. ??With so many unknowns, the next few years are likelier to produce more studies than new utilities, said a number of city officials who attended a seminar in Sacramento this week, sponsored in part by the American Public Power Association. ??Former New York state Sen. Al Coppola told the group the session should have been titled: "Independence from the greedy robber baron utilities." ??Public power backers share three key beliefs: ??* They can charge customers less because they don't have to pay dividends to investors or pay taxes on their sales; they can respond to local preferences on issues like which customers pay the lowest rates and how blackouts are staged; and existing utilities will do everything in their power to oppose them. ??"Edison did the right thing - (use) fear," to discourage Culver City from creating an electric arm in 1995, Vera, the city's former mayor, told the group. ??And Glenn Prentice, head of the newly created Corona electric utility, said in an interview that a half-dozen other cities have contacted him for more information, but he declined to name them. ??"If I do, Edison will start the attack on them. We're talking about a lot of money," he said. "We're here to serve the public. They're here to make money." ??PG&E sees new utilities as "competition for our business," and it has a policy of lobbying hard against them, Nelson said. ??Less than 18 months ago, it warned residents of the Placer County town of Lincoln that a city power enterprise would be costlier and less dependable than PG&E, and its officials labeled the effort a "tax dodge." ??But by January of this year, PG&E barely blinked when Hercules set up a utility to deliver power and telecommunications service in new neighborhoods. ??"We got more resistance from AT&T and PacBell," said Raj Pankhania, assistant to the city manager of Hercules. ??Pankhania has been researching utility drives across the state and has seen no groundswell for public power, although he believes it can bring cities added revenue and more local control. ??That could change this summer, Prentice said. ??"It really depends on how bad the blackouts are." ??A blackout that left one city councilmember's daughter at a darkened school was part of what led the Riverside County city of Corona to vote April 4 to form its own electric arm, he said. Heavy industry became anxious, too. ??"They said to the city council, 'Do something!' " Prentice said. ??Skipping detailed studies, Corona quickly decided to create a utility that will build small power plants, under 50 megawatts, to serve city operations and new neighborhoods in the city of 127,000 east of Disneyland. ??In time, said Hercules' Pankhania, cities like his could become the living laboratory for whichever system can deliver better service and lower rates. ??Hercules' plans calls for the older two-thirds of its homes and businesses to retain their PG&E service and the newest third to be served by the city utility. ??"The existing homeowner will definitely compare five to 10 years down the road," he said. "Then let the people decide which way they want to go." ??* * * ??The Bee's Carrie Peyton can be reached at (916) 321-1086 or cpeyton@sacbee.com. LOAD-DATE: April 29, 2001