24 Jan 2001, 18:44 UTC
Re: Protest to PG&E Advice Letter re PX Credit -- Privileged Attorney Work Product
- From
- Tamara Johnson tamara.johnson@enron.com
- To
- JBennett
- Cc
- jdasovic@enron.com, tjohnso8@enron.com, Harry Kingerski, gsavage@enron.com, smara@enron.com, MDay
- Bcc
- jdasovic@enron.com, tjohnso8@enron.com, Harry Kingerski, gsavage@enron.com, smara@enron.com, MDay
- Date
- Wed, 24 Jan 2001 10:44:00 -0800 (PST)
Jeanne, It seems that we are suggesting that the price of energy be representative of PG&E's avoided cost. The previous decisions seem to mix up the use of "avoided cost" and the real "market price" that the PX was intended to portray. If we stress the "avoided cost" aspect, it seems that we would be agreeing with PG&E's use of the soft-capped-ISO price -- or even with the use of something as low as embedded cost. I think we might stress using a substitute for what the PX was intended to portray -- the price that buyers and sellers are really transacting upon. We could refer to some of the good words in the "Preferred Policy Decision": "From the perspective of both wholesale and retail customers the most critical contribution of the Exchange lies in the auction determination of real time pricing of electricity and the transparent manifestation of these price signals. In the absence of such an institution the market will be hidden and the price signals obscured or subject to selective, discriminatory dissemination" (page 12) Another point might be the fact that implementing PG&E's proposed change would, in effect, be a selective rate increase for Direct Access with no notice. Note to Internal people: I'm still working on our discussion document -- I will forward as soon as I can. /Tamara.