2 Apr 2001, 07:04 UTC
FW: S&P News on California
- From
- Michael Tribolet michael.tribolet@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 2 Apr 2001 00:04:00 -0700 (PDT)
fyi: this is rather out of the ordinary for S&P
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Conwell, Wendy Sent: Sunday, April 01, 2001 10:08 AM To: Bradford, William S.; Ngo, Tracy; Tribolet, Michael Subject: S&P News on California Research: Return to Regular Format California Power Crisis: Bring In the Feds Publication Date: 30-Mar-2001 Analyst: Todd A Shipman, CFA, New York (1) 212-438-7676 In one of the Sherlock Holmes stories, the key clue in solving the mystery was a dog that did not bark. In a similar vein, as analysts analyze and experts pontificate on the electricity crisis in California, as well as its causes and solutions, there seems to be an obvious point that few, if any, are mentioning. That is, that the problem is not really confined to California, but is at the very least a regional issue and, in reality, is tied to a national industry. As such, the whole question of the current and future direction of electricity deregulation is a federal matter with important economic, environmental, and even national security implications, and therefore Standard & Poor's believes it ought to be addressed at the federal level. Instead, just like the dog that did not bark, no one in Washington, D.C. seems to be willing to step in and take the lead in resolving the California crisis, or the bigger issue of electric restructuring. This state versus federal jurisdictional issue did arise in early discussions of electric deregulation, and there were some calls for a larger role by the federal government. But the states were able to protect their long-standing place as the primary regulators of the electric industry, and so Congress and the FERC backed off, and let the states take the lead in directing the restructuring of the electric utility industry, even though they started the whole deregulation ball rolling with the Energy Policy Act of 1992. The establishment of the act contrasted greatly with the introduction of more competition into utility industries overseas, and the natural gas industry here in the U.S., where a more centralized approach was taken. After some sporadic attempts by Congress to address some electric utility issues, they seemed to have given up trying to fashion a comprehensive solution to deregulation of the electric utility industry. Their inaction is echoed nicely by the desultory and curiously laissez-faire attitude displayed by the FERC, where even something as important and clearly jurisdictional as the transmission grid has been handled with all the speed and dispatch of a tortoise race. Why should the administration or Congress (both, ironically, in the hands of Republicans) presume to step in and usurp the states? As the situation in California has revealed, the electric industry is very much connected, both figuratively and literally, and the actions of one state can and most likely will affect its neighbors. In other words, California sneezed and the rest of the western grid caught the cold. And it is not just the initial design of the restructuring scheme that can lead to lower credit quality and other problems. In California, we were treated to the spectacle of that state steadfastly refusing to timely deal with its problems (the Public Utilities Commission only last week belatedly raised retail rates) while the rest of its neighbors were forced to pass through significant rate hikes to keep their own utilities whole to deal with price spikes caused partly by California. Despite the increases, the situation has had negative implications for the credit ratings of several of those utilities. The precedent for a strong federal role, and a good analogy as well, is securities regulation. The prominent, and almost exclusive role of the federal SEC in monitoring and regulating the securities industry came about in the 1930s, after the severe economic downturn that was preceded by the Crash of 1929. It was recognized that despite the presence of state regulators, the nature of the industry and the need for uniformity across the nation meant that Washington had to get involved and take the lead. The banking industry is another example of where the economic stakes are high, and a nationwide perspective is needed to protect the common good. We are faced with the same type of situation with electric utilities. The California crisis has shown us that strong and active oversight is needed, a comprehensive approach to both the restructuring and the subsequent degree of regulation must be taken, and that the states are not willing or capable of organizing their activities to achieve the necessary coordination. The initiative should now come from either the Bush administration or Congress to take control of the process, and develop a thorough plan for industry restructuring. Copyright , 1994-2001 Standard & Poor's. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy