Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

1 Sep 1999, 15:17 UTC

Pastoria

From
Barton Clark barton.clark@enron.com
To
Sara Shackleton
Cc
Sean Black
Bcc
Sean Black
Date
Wed, 1 Sep 1999 08:17:00 -0700 (PDT)
Regarding the Summary of Proposed Agreement Between Enron and Catalytica that 
accompanied the Confirmation for the spark spread derivative appended to Sean 
Black's E-Mail forwarded to you earlier today, please note that the Summary 
has been revised ( see attachment below ). However, Attachment 1 to the 
revised Summary, which sets forth the general terms and conditions of the 
spark spread option, is unchanged from Attachment 1 to the previously 
delivered Summary. In addition, I've found no other indication in my files or 
E-Mail messages that the Confirmation you initially furnished was modified 
when it was sent to Catalytica or otherwise modified to date. By copy hereof 
I'm requesting Sean confirm that fact so we are sure we are still working 
from the same page.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Barton Clark/HOU/ECT on 09/01/99 01:30 PM 
---------------------------


Sean Black
08/31/99 11:11 AM
To: Barton Clark/HOU/ECT@ECT, Dale Rasmussen/HOU/ECT@ECT
cc: Brad Nebergall/HOU/ECT@ECT, Chris Holmes/HOU/ECT@ECT, Samuel 
Wehn/HOU/ECT@ECT, David Parquet/SF/ECT@ECT 
Subject: Pastoria

Dale/Bart,

Attached below is the latest revision of the proposed agreement between Enron 
and CCSI concerning the 10 mm prepayment.  The CCSI board gave preliminary 
approval of the agreement yesterday and their accountants are also on board, 
so we need to get a draft of a legally binding agreement together that we can 
resend to Catalytica for review and approval.

Regarding the Enron/GE Agreement, we are still awaiting GE's formal revisions 
to the agreement.  However, we spoke with them last week about their main 
concerns.  From my notes, the following is a summary of the comments that GE 
had and the areas where we expect that they will revise the language (refer 
to the agreement sent to GE on 8/13/99): As you will note, the two key issues 
GE is concerned with are (1) assignability and (2) the definition of the 
'purchase option.'

Comments from GE conference call:

Recital Section:

Item K - GE has not agreed to fund total remaining cost; GE and CTAL have 
agreed to seek out additional funds and will, themselves, commit some 
additional funds.  However, their concern is the extreme event where they 
have grossly underestimated the costs to develop XONON and they do not want 
to be committed to funding a 'limitless' gap if CTAL will not cough up money 
or some other form of value and/or no other external source of funding can be 
found.  In this case, we need to be covered through both agreements in the 
sense that GE would need to provide us a XONON credit (which may be worthless 
if the technology has not been developed for any one of the three product 
lines) and we would pass the credit through to CTAL in exchange for the spark 
spread (in otherwords, CTAL needs to take on this risk, not Enron).  In sum, 
GE feels that  they will only fund XONON if they get an order for Pastoria.

Item N - GE will revise this language because they feel we should be at least 
committed to purchasing GE equipment, assuming that Pastoria goes through and 
this item, as written, implies to them that we should have no obligation to 
purchase GE equipment, even if Pastoria goes ahead (e.g., implies to them 
that we could go back and purchase ABB or Westinghouse, etc. if Pastoria goes 
ahead, at our discretion)

2.3 - Change date to March, 2001 for a 2003 COD and March 2002 for a 2004 COD.

3.4 - Same revision as for 2.3

3.6 - Related to Item N of the recitals; GE wants to revise or clarify the 
meaning of "Purchase Option" to mean an intent by Enron to purchase equipment 
from GE if Pastoria goes ahead.

3.8 - Limit GE's participation to providing information and/or documentation 
on XONON for the permitting process

3.11 - OKAY with the concept but want to revise it to relate to XONON 
technology rather than turbines.

5.3 - Want to define a configuration for 750 MW here, in the event that this 
is the size that is chosen by the developers.

9.2 - This is the big issue with GE; they don't want such 'broad' 
assignability for this agreement, as they have previously agreed to at 
Pittsburg and other projects because the language is so broad.  They are 
going to revise this language and I expect the definition to be 'narrower'.


Our plans for reaching closure on the agreement with GE are the following:

1.  Receive revised agreement from GE (hopefully by the end of today)

2.  Incorporate your recent comments to the GE Agreement (the comments 
received after 8/13)

3.  Brad and Chris to travel to SF to meet with Dave Parquet and Sam Wehn to 
review revised document in person and incorporate their final comments.

4.  Send agreement back to GE for final review and comment.


At this point, we need to begin revising the Enron/CTAL Agreement below into 
a legally binding document.  Bart, if you have not already done so, could you 
begin revising this agreement accordingly.

If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to call.

Regards,