17 Oct 2000, 12:48 UTC
Re: ToaRe - Weather deal - Long form confirmation - Japanese law
- From
- Alan Aronowitz alan.aronowitz@enron.com
- To
- Jane McBride
- Date
- Tue, 17 Oct 2000 05:48:00 -0700 (PDT)
Jane:
Typically, we have been widely successful in convincing counterpaties
(wherever located) to agree to either NY or English law to govern ISDA's
because NY and England have well developed bodies of financial law and the
courts are more likely to understand derivatives transactions. I also have
understood from Terry Taneka at IBJ (and an ISDA director) that Japanese
financial institutions regularly agree to NY and English law. I realize here
we are talking about a Japanese insurance company counterparty.
I think, in this instance, it is ok to agree to Japanese law and courts to
get this first Japanese Weather deal documented, but I would like for us to
strongly reserve with this company the right to discuss further the choice of
law/jurisdiction since I presume we will be negotiating a Master Agreement
with them. Also, the submission to jurisdiction clause should be
non-exclusive. My previous understanding from Jeremy Pitts of B&M was that
ISDA's (and the subject derivative transaction) are enforceable under
Japanese law (and that netting is also generally enforceable). I also have
understood from B&M that Japanese courts are very preferable to Japanese
arbitrations. Please confirm these points with Jeremy before finalizing the
document.
We will need to finalize our thoughts about the markets we are trying to
develop and what the best approach should be to choice of law/jurisdiction
going forward. This would be a good topic for Mark E., David, you and I to
discuss at our first group meeting.
Alan
Jane McBride@ENRON
10/17/2000 02:21 AM
To: Alan Aronowitz/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mark Evans/Legal/LON/ECT@ECT
cc:
Subject: ToaRe - Weather deal - Long form confirmation - Japanese law
Dear Alan and Mark,
If B&M says OK to go with Japanese law / courts, I will agree this tomorrow
unless either of you have any objections.
Thanks.
BTW, John Sheriff will be in our office tomorrow and we are all giving
presentations. Mine will be on aspects of Japanese law.
Jane
Ps. Thanks Alan for all the emails over night.
Jane McBride
Senior Legal Counsel
Enron Japan Corp.
Otemachi 1st Square Bldg.
West 11th Floor
1-5-1 Otemachi, Chiyoda-ku
Tokyo 100-0004
Japan
Tel.: 81-3-5219-4500 (Main)
81-3-5219-4553 (Direct)
Fax: 81-3-5219-4510
Assistant (Maggy Yamanishi)
Tel.: 81-3-5219-4554
Email: Yo.Yamanishi@enron.com