12 Jun 2000, 12:15 UTC
FW: Suggestions to improve SEMPRA core aggregation program
- From
- Michael Rochman rochmanm@spurr.org
- To
- anchau@shellus.com, bdingwall@unitedgas.com, ben.reyes@utility.com, Daniel Douglass, david.bayless@utility.com, gworster@txuenergy.com, jdasovic@enron.com, MDay, Rick Counihan
- Date
- Mon, 12 Jun 2000 05:15:00 -0700 (PDT)
FYI, this relates to the SoCal Gas / SDG&E Settlement Workshop to be held on Wednesday in San Francisco. Will any of you be attending or sending representatives? Michael Rochman ?-----Original Message----- From: ? Michael Rochman? Sent:?? Monday, June 12, 2000 12:10 PM To:???? Nancy W McVay (E-mail) Cc:???? Alethea Imperial; Brian Cherry (E-mail) Subject:??????? Suggestions to improve SMEPRA core aggregation program Nancy, Per our conversation, I will ask Alethea Imperial of our office to hand this out at the meeting on Wednesday, since I will not be able to attend: Customer migration to transport-only service will occur in significant numbers, and the benefits of a competitive commodity market will accrue, only if (a) the Utility Distribution Company exits the merchant function (as in California noncore, Atlanta Gas & Light examples), or (b) non-regulated suppliers have a realistic opportunity to "beat" the UDC price. Over time, as customers migrate from bundled service, the emphasis on beating the UDC price will fade (as it has in telecom), and end-users will actually get a lower price, as the competitive suppliers' risk premiums associated with targeting the price of a specific dominant competitor (the UDC) is removed from prices. Examples of methods to beat the price include: shopping credits (as in New Jersey); regulatory actions (as in the temporary price advantage due to core interstate unbundling if the SoCal Gas Comprehensive Settlement is approved); or UDC monthly commodity price includes all actual retail-related costs calculated on an account-average basis, such as billing, customer service, marketing, etc., without reliance on economies of scale due to UDC performance of transportation function. Currently, the UDC prices tend to give wholesale, rather than retail, price signals and costs remain covered in local transportation rates. Suggestions for SEMPRA in this regard include: Include the current "pipeline credit" ($0.0282 /MMBtu) as a component of the posted core procurement rate, rather than as a deduction from local transportation rates. Establish a well-publicized fund to be paid to those who switch to transport service on a first-come, first-serve basis. (This is John Leslie's "prime-the-pump-and-get-good-publicity-for-the-UDC" suggestion.) Commit to pricing for a 6 to 24 month period to be expressed as NGI SoCal CityGate plus or minus, so long as it is computed to include all retail, fully-delivered cost components. Compute core procurement price to send retail price signal, either by re-allocation of costs, by actual separation of procurement function to a separate, regulated utility under the SEMPRA umbrella, or by outsourcing procurement function to third party(ies). Post a (projected or actual) "standard offer" price in advance for a 6 to 24 month period, so long as it is computed to include all retail, fully-delivered cost components. Make a clear policy statement that SEMPRA wishes to exit the merchant function, even if only at some date to be determined in the future. To help educate consumers, all SEMPRA invoices should show core procurement price as applied to prorated therms consumed during the meter read cycle, rather than current practice of simply stating the monthly procurement price(s) but only showing the total, bundled price for each cycle on the invoice. For example, show "100 therms at April price of $0.25 = $25.00, plus 50 therms at May price of $0.30 = $15.00, plus transport fee of $50.00, equals $90.00"; rather than the current practice of showing "usage of 150 therms from April 10 to May 10 equals $90.00.") All SEMPRA materials regarding core aggregation should emphasize advantages of transport-only service: the availability of fixed or other pricing plans to more closely meet end-user risk management needs (emphasizing that SEMPRA has only a one-size-fits-all pricing option), the availability of customized bill presentment and delivery (potentially saving multi-site end-users thousands of dollars per year and reducing paper for all end-users), availability of discounts on other goods or services not offered by SEMPRA, etc.