25 Jan 2001, 12:27 UTC
Re: FW: Letter re: PG&E Advice letter 2073-E
- From
- Tamara Johnson tamara.johnson@enron.com
- To
- JBennett
- Date
- Thu, 25 Jan 2001 04:27:00 -0800 (PST)
Jeanne, I have some more background on the PX Credit issue that leads me to believe that we should still comment on PG&E's Advice Letter. The current PX credit calculation relies on the existence of a PX price The PX price does not consistently reflect market prices. Market prices are only reflected if: buyers and seller are willing to take on credit risk by transacting in the market the legalities of "who is liable for what" in case of default are unclear (according to a VP at EPMI), so the liquidity will not increase until there is certainty From our perspective, the market value as posted on the PX is better for PX credit calculations than a constrained ISO price. (There is no unconstrained ISO price available.) Although -- it's a risk. However, if the PX becomes so dysfunctional that prices, if any, do not reflect real market pricing at all, the CPUC cannot delay dealing with this issue because there will be no status quo for them to leave in place, there will be a void. I suggest that we support the CPUC decision to delay hearing the advice letter with a big HOWEVER. I think we should highlight the questionable viability of a PX price and bring forward the requirement that the CPUC must act if the PX becomes completely dysfunctional (we could ask Neil Bresnan for help in defining "dysfunctional"). /Tamara. JMB <JBennett@GMSSR.com> on 01/25/2001 10:54:38 AM To: "Tamara Johnson (E-mail)" <tjohnso8@enron.com>, "Harry Kingerski (E-mail)" <Harry.Kingerski@enron.com>, "Gordon Savage (E-mail)" <gsavage@enron.com> cc: Subject: FW: Letter re: PG&E Advice letter 2073-E Well, we do not have to worry about protesting PG&E's advice letter changing the PX credit. The Energy Division nixed it and told PG&E to take up the issue in the rate stabilization proceedings. Jeanne
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message----- From: Avendano, Nel [mailto:NCO1@pge.com] Sent: Wednesday, January 24, 2001 3:47 PM To: 'jbushee@sablaw.com'; 'kmccrea@sablaw.com'; 'rogerberliner@bcjlaw.com'; 'rcsstl@cdmnet.com'; 'mbrubaker@consultbai.com'; 'anchau@shellus.com'; 'keith-sappenfield@reliantenergy.com'; 'jsmollon@newwestenergy.com'; 'jlyoung@sempra.com'; 'napedersen@jonesday.com'; 'athomas@newenergy.com'; 'fchristi@arterhadden.com'; 'kmcspadd@milbank.com'; 'hchoy@isd.co.la.ca.us'; 'lgurick@calpx.com'; 'douglass@arterhadden.com'; 'randy_britt@mayco.com'; 'frank.cooley@sce.com'; 'glwaas@calpx.com'; 'uwua@worker.com'; 'fmo@sdcity.sannet.gov'; 'jleslie@luce.com'; 'julesan@aol.com'; 'mshames@ucan.org'; 'jparrott@sempra.com'; 'kmelville@sempra.com'; 'bill.mccallum@ci.fresno.ca.us'; 'btenney@landuselaw.com'; 'ronknecht@aol.com'; 'furutanj@efawest.navfac.navy.mil'; 'mdjoseph@adamsbroadwell.com'; 'rcosta@turn.org'; 'bfinkelstein@turn.org'; 'theresa_mueller@ci.sf.ca.us'; 'jjz@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'chrisw@greenlining.org'; 'joseh@lif.org'; 'jnnc@chevron.com'; 'jlondon@gralegal.com'; 'imoosen@gralegal.com'; 'phanschen@mofo.com'; 'epoole@adplaw.com'; 'rschmidt@bartlewells.com'; 'chilen@llgm.com'; 'lys@aelaw.com'; 'jsqueri@gmssr.com'; 'jbennett@gmssr.com'; 'bloomje@la.whitecase.com'; 'pbray@newpower.com'; 'rick.counihan@greenmountain.com'; 'thoulihan@mdbe.com'; 'mday@gmssr.com'; 'jmalkin@orrick.com'; 'edwardoneill@dwt.com'; 'smoss@hooked.net'; Huffman, Mark (Law); Edwards, William (Law); 'ssmyers@worldnet.att.net'; 'pat.williams@dhcmail.com'; 'wbooth@booth-law.com'; 'jerryl@abag.ca.gov'; 'mgomez1@bart.gov'; 'askaff@energy-law-group.com'; 'hf@energy-law-group.com'; 'pjpowerlaw@aol.com'; 'difellman@energy-law-group.com'; 'nryan@environmentaldefense.org'; 'psly@ebmud.com'; 'rrcollins@n-h-i.org'; 'patrickm@crossborderenergy.com'; 'tomb@crossborderenergy.com'; 'brbarkovich@earthlink.net'; 'pjmuller@ricochet.net'; 'pmcdonne@wenet.net'; 'berry@apx.com'; 'sberlin@mccarthylaw.com'; 'scottst@mid.org'; 'cmkehrein@ems-ca.com'; 'jweil@aglet.org'; 'abb@eslawfirm.com'; 'bpowers@seniors.org'; 'dcarroll@dbsr.com'; 'dkk@eslawfirm.com'; 'ed@clfp.com'; 'howens@seniors.org'; 'sgreenberg@realenergy.com'; 'smutny@iepa.com'; 'lmh@eslawfirm.com'; 'jtachera@energy.state.ca.us'; 'hodgesjl@pacbell.net'; 'rpernell@energy.state.ca.us'; 'kmills@cfbf.com'; 'rliebert@cfbf.com'; 'aorchard@smud.org'; 'mpa@aelaw.com'; 'jcpaine@stoel.com'; 'mhg@hetrading.com'; 'dws@keywaycorp.com'; 'hbd@gweiss.com'; 'gerhordt.herbert@msdw.com'; 'cread@steptoe.com'; 'jogg@jhenergy.com'; 'peter_fox-penner@brattle.com'; 'sdefrawi@efaches.navfac.navy.mil'; 'ad046@detroit.freenet.org'; 'bob_anderson@apses.com'; 'gdreed@sidley.com'; 'robert.d.schasel@fritolay.com'; 'georgeperrault@msn.com'; 'foxba@sce.com'; 'picketse@sce.com'; 'jsilva@edisonenterprises.com'; 'LVanWagenen@sempra.com'; 'jbarthrop@powersavers.com'; 'foothill@lmi.net'; 'kpoole@adamsbroadwell.com'; 'fosterbc@sce.com'; 'ljhubbard@sempra.com'; 'ktilton@gralegal.com'; 'paul.harris@bridge.com'; 'oshirock@pacbell.net'; 'natutt@duanemorris.com'; Migocki, Joe; 'cafield@pirg.org'; 'derkp@newsdata.com'; 'luluw@newsdata.com'; 'tom.oneill@abnamro.com'; 'mmattes@nossaman.com'; Peters, Roger (Law); Lucha, Ed; Frazier-hampton, Janice; Kjellund, Niels; Helgens, Ronald; 'ConsumersFirst@worldnet.att.net'; 'normkr@aol.com'; 'gtbl@dynegy.com'; 'joe.paul@dynegy.com'; 'honest@compuserve.com'; 'jyoung@ebmud.com'; 'emitchel@angnewspapers.com'; 'rbw@mrwassoc.com'; 'dmarcus@slip.net'; 'jeff@hmhresources.com'; 'ed@apx.com'; 'chrism@mid.org'; 'fwmonier@tid.org'; 'rmccann@cal.net'; 'blaising@braunlegal.com'; 'melanie_gillette@rmiinc.com'; 'twetzel@thermoecotek.com'; 'Slayman@energy.state.ca.us'; 'jdh@eslawfirm.com'; 'ddavie@hesinet.com'; 'karen@klindh.com'; 'cpeyton@sacbee.com'; 'thaines@smud.org'; 'huse@eesconsulting.com'; 'mer@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'ang@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'cmw@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'ctd@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'dlf@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'fua@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'jlo@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'kok@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'kth@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'kim@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'gig@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'rtf@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'raw@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'sfc@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'car@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'ztc@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'nevillm@hdcdojnet.state.ca.us'; 'dwrlegal1@water.ca.gov'; 'ath@cpuc.ca.gov'; 'LKristov@energy.state.ca.us'; 'randy.chinn@senate.ca.gov'; 'rtavares@energy.state.ca.us'; 'mschwebs@energy.state.ca.us' Cc: Shaw, Susan Subject: Letter re: PG&E Advice letter 2073-E Today the attached letter was received by PG&E from Paul Clanon, Director, Energy Division, pertaining to Advice 2073-E, filed January 18, 2001. (cc: Service List - A. 00-11-056) <<Letter_PGE_AL_2073-E.doc>> Thank You, Nel Avendano (nco1@pge.com) Rates (415-973-3529) - Letter_PGE_AL_2073-E.doc