15 May 2001, 16:19 UTC
Modifications to RECLAIM Approved by SCAQMD Board
- From
- Mary Schoen mary.schoen@enron.com
- To
- Alan Comnes, Robert Badeer, Jeff Richter, Tim Heizenrader, Stephen Swain, Chris H Foster, Tim Belden, John Massey II, Adam Siegel, Heather Mitchell, Chris Holmes, samuel.wehn@enron.com
- Date
- Tue, 15 May 2001 09:19:00 -0700 (PDT)
On Friday, May 11th, the SCAQMD approved several significant changes to the RECLAIM Program. The key elements of these modifications are as follows: For existing large power plants (greater than 50MW): bifurcation from the rest of the RECLAIM market, requiring installation of Best Available Retrofit Control Technology (BARCT) through compliance plans (to be installed no later than 2003 for boilers and 2004 for turbines), and a temporary mitigation fee program. Any emissions in excess of their allocation can be offset by the payment of a mitigation fee of $7.50 per pound ($15,000 per ton) to the District, which will in turn invest the money in NOx emission reduction projects to mitigate the air pollution effects. These rule changes include an environmental dispatch provision which requires prioritization of the use of cleaner emitting equipment first; Initiation of a temporary, limited, pilot RECLAIM Air Quality Investment Program (AQIP) for new power plants and structural buyers, allowing access to mobile and area source credits; Development of four new pilot credit generation rules which are voluntary and are applicable to a specific type of mobile or area source emission reduction project, as summarized below: - Rule 1631 applies to diesel-fueled captive marine vessels where the existing marine engine is repowered or replaced with a new diesel-fueled marine engine. - Rule 1632 applies to marine vessels that are anchored in district harbors or ports that use electric power in lieu of auxiliary diesel engines to provide power for lights, ventilation, loading, offloading, and other "hotelling" operations. - Rule 1633 applies to truck or trailer refrigeration units that are mounted on a truck body or trailer container that use electric power in lieu of auxiliary diesel engines while at distribution centers. - Rule 2507 applies to diesel-fueled engines that are replaced with electric motors that are used to power agricultural pumps. Summary of Impact of Modifications: The South Coast Air Quality Management District (SCAQMD) introduced these new rules to reduce the impact of CA's electricity crisis ( the need to increase generation) on the RECLAIM trading credit (RTC) market and to do their part to facilitate increased electricity supply. These amendments are intended to stabilize RTC prices by increasing supply, reducing demand, and increasing trading information and accuracy. There is one major "IF" built into these rules. It involves the mitigation fee program for existing large power plants. IF the AQMD fails to produce adequate reductions for the mitigation fee program, power producing facilities would have allowances deducted from future year allocations to cover their emissions. In otherwords, they would be able to run at higher levels this year, but may face severe curtailments in future years. I do think there are a couple of noteworthy precedence within these rules. One is the increased validity and recognition of need of alternate source of emission offsets. This rule development had active participation by CARB and the USEPA, who bought off on these provisions The second is the use of the mitigation bank for generators. CARB has developed a similar bank for new peaking turbines, but this program has much broader application. And, finally, this is the first time I've seen environmental dispatch provisions codified. For those of you that want more details see below. I also have summaries of the rules and comments on the rules. Please give me a call if you have questions or want the documentation. Please forward this to anyone I've missed. Mary Schoen Environmental Strategies 713.345.7422 Power Producing Facilities The proposed rule changes will separate power producing facilities from the rest of the RECLAIM market while energy supply issues are being addressed. Existing power plants will not rejoin the full RECLAIM program unless the Governing Board, in a public hearing prior to July 2003, determines that their re-entry will not result in any negative impact on the remainder of the RECLAIM universe or California,s energy security needs. The proposed rules would require a compliance plan for power producing facilities with capacity
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> 50 megawatts and require installation of best available retrofit control technology at the earliest feasible date, but no later than 2003 for boilers or 2004 for turbines. In addition to the initial compliance plans, power producing facilities are required to update information annually for 2001 through 2005 Compliance Years. Annual update reports provide AQMD with the necessary information to access the impacts of emissions from these facilities on the RECLAIM program and anticipate future demands of credits from the Mitigation Fee Program. The proposed rules also include environmental dispatch, which requires prioritization of the use of cleaner emitting equipment first. Trading would also be limited to isolate the rest of the market from credit demands from power producing facilities. RTC purchases after January 11, 2001 could only be used to reconcile facility emissions if the RTCs are from facilities under common ownership or have been generated from approved mobile source credit generation programs. Power Producing Facilities could sell credits back to the District for a price not to exceed $7.50 per pound. Any emissions in excess of their allocation can be offset by the payment of a mitigation fee of $7.50 per pound ($15,000 per ton) to the District, which will in turn invest the money in NOx emission reduction projects to mitigate the air pollution effects. ??????? Compliance Plans and Forecast Reports for other Facilities For facilities other than large power producing facilities, compliance plans are proposed for facilities with 1999 or any subsequent year emissions greater than or equal to 50 tons per year (tpy). These compliance plans provide flexibility by including options for installing controls or purchasing credits. The plans are being designed to allow as much flexibility as possible, while requiring timely, enforceable commitments to be made to ensure compliance. Facilities may provide several options in their original plan submittal and can amend their compliance plans at any time. The Board resolution directs staff to expedite review and approval of compliance plans and plan modifications (60 days for plans and 30 days for modification). Facilities between 25 and 50 tpy emissions in 1999 will be required to submit informational forecast reports and update forecasts annually. Compliance plans and forecast reports from the large and medium facilities will help ensure adequate advance planning by facilities to meet the overall RECLAIM program emission targets. ??????? Mitigation Fee Program A temporary mitigation fee program through compliance year 2004 is proposed for power producing facilities that exceed their RTC holdings. The facility would pay $7.50 per pound of NOx to the District, which uses the funds to achieve emission reductions from a variety of mobile source or other credit generation avenues. The current rules require that excess emissions be deducted from the subsequent year allocation to ensure that the environment is not impacted by additional emissions. In this proposed amendment, staff recommends the deduction of excess emissions from the second year to account for the lead time necessary for installation of control equipment at the power producing facilities. When emission reductions are secured for the Reserve by the District, the deduction would be credited back to the facility. In addition, if the mitigation fee program achieves emission reductions equal to at least 75 percent of those requested, in aggregate, by the second compliance year, an additional year can be granted to generate reductions, thereby minimizing the need to further deduct future year allocations. ??????? RECLAIM Air Quality Investment Program (AQIP) Another short-term credit assistance program, the RECLAIM AQIP, is being proposed for use by certain facilities through the 2004 compliance year. This program would be available for structural buyers, such as new facilities and small facilities with installed controls at a minimum of BARCT. The RECLAIM AQIP would provide structural buyers additional compliance options to reduce the overall demand for RTCs from the RECLAIM trading market. Facilities that request participation would pay $7.50 per pound of NOx to use the RECLAIM AQIP, if reductions are available. No deduction from allocations is proposed for this program since emission reductions must be available prior to use. The District is pre-funding the AQIP program with emission reduction credits. The Governing Board has allocated $2 million from the AES Settlement Fund to use to obtain emission reductions from marine vessels. ??????? Other Rule Changes To help improve trade information, the proposed rules would require identification of both the seller and buyer of RTCs after the completion of a trade. The rule includes registration requirements for pooled trading and contractual agreements for future transfer of RTCs. In addition, timely filing of trades is proposed to help facilitate market information.