11 Dec 2000, 12:34 UTC
The Storm Arrives - CERA Alert
- From
- Lorna Brennan lorna.brennan@enron.com
- To
-
rockey.storie@enron.com, Kent Miller, John Dushinske, Dave Neubauer, Bill Fowler, Michael Bodnar, Joni Bollinger, david.badura@enron.com, Janet Bowers, Craig Buehler, Bob Burleson, allen.cohrs@enron.com
and 59 more
John Fiscus, Steve Gilbert, Morgan Gottsponer, Stephen Herber, Dana Jones, stephanie.korbelik@enron.com, bill.mangels@enron.com, Penny McCarran, Vernon Mercaldo, Larry Pavlou, eileen.peebles@enron.com, tony.perry@enron.com, loren.penkava@enron.com, Ken Powers, Chris Sebesta, Frank Semin, neal.shaw@enron.com, Larry Swett, Kay Threet, mike.ullom@enron.com, lisa.valley@enron.com, Chuck Wilkinson, Jim Wiltfong, Jo Williams, karen.lagerstrom@enron.com, Bob Stevens, Sue Neville, Mike Barry, Martha Janousek, Kimberly Watson, Don Powell, Steve Weller, michael.stage@enron.com, Tim Johanson, laura.lantefield@enron.com, Frank Oldenhuis, Jeff Nielsen, Robert Mason, Sean Bolks, miriam.martinez@enron.com, Lee Ferrell, John Williams, Reyna Cabrera, Theresa Branney, Jan Moore, Mike McGowan, Lynn Blair, Rick Dietz, Steven January, Sheila Nacey, Donna Scott, Steven Harris, Jeffery Fawcett, Lorraine Lindberg, Kevin Hyatt, Christine Stokes, TK Lohman, Michelle Lokay, Lindy Donoho - Date
- Mon, 11 Dec 2000 04:34:00 -0800 (PST)
Update from CERA on pricing and rest of the season.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Lorna Brennan/ET&S/Enron on 12/11/2000 12:30 PM --------------------------- webmaster@cera.com on 12/08/2000 09:05:36 PM To: Lorna.Brennan@enron.com cc: Subject: The Storm Arrives - CERA Alert ********************************************************************** CERA Alert: Sent Fri, December 08, 2000 ********************************************************************** Title: The Storm Arrives Author: N. American Gas Team E-Mail Category: Alert Product Line: North American Gas , URL: http://www.cera.com/client/nag/alt/120800_16/nag_alt_120800_16_ab.html ********************************************************* Cold Weather Path Colder-than-normal weather through November and forecasted cold for the first half of December throughout the Midwest and Northeast have driven gas prices well into record territory, with the January Henry Hub price trading near $9.00 per MMBtu and closing above $8.00 on the New York Mercantile Exchange December 6. This six-week cold period and the quick depletion of already low storage inventories has established prices at or above CERA's cold weather path for the remainder of the winter and in all likelihood beyond. If December storage withdrawals are as high as CERA now expects, the gas market will remain on the cold weather path through 2001 as well, even if weather returns to normal during the second half of December. The enormous increase in storage injections that is likely to be required next summer would keep the pressure on gas markets throughout the year. So long as weather remains cold (or even normal) this winter, a new market dynamic is in effect in which gas prices interact more with distillate fuel oil prices rather than with those of residual fuel oil. In addition, gas is likely to have an increasingly direct influence on power prices in the growing number of regions in which gas-fired generation is now on the margin in winter. This winter, the gas market is likely to rediscover for the first time in decades which end users value natural gas most highly, and which ultimately do not. The gas market is also rediscovering the value of firm pipeline capacity, particularly into market areas. Both the West Coast and the Northeast have experienced even more extreme price spikes, with daily prices in both regions peaking above $20.00 per MMBtu. Indeed, the shortage of gas in California is so acute that prices above $40.00 per MMBtu have been reported. If sustained, these price levels will induce a political reaction that will reverberate throughout the industry. Storage Update-Even High Seems Low Panic in the market yesterday was eased somewhat as storage withdrawals for the week ending December 1, at 73 billion cubic feet (Bcf), proved to be less than expected. This withdrawal was half the previous week's rate, and in CERA's view actual withdrawals for both weeks probably lie between these two readings. (In some cases successive weeks smooth out volatile readings in the AGA survey.) But even the 73 Bcf figure, though a significant retreat from the previous week's rate, is high by historical standards. One would have to go back to 1994 to find a higher reading for a comparable week in the AGA survey. Inventories as of the beginning of December, at an estimated 2,466 Bcf (see Table 1), were 525 Bcf below the year-earlier level, and this deficit is likely to increase substantially during December. If weather forecasts indicating colder-than-normal weather through mid-December in key heating markets hold true, storage withdrawals for the month will average approximately 20.0 Bcf per day. This rate is an increase from CERA's normal weather estimate of 17.0 Bcf per day, and even this rate depends on weather returning to normal in mid- December. This level of withdrawals would leave only 1,846 Bcf in storage on January 1, an inventory 663 Bcf below the year-earlier level. Assuming normal weather, such an inventory would place storage on track to reach a March minimum of 488 Bcf, 270 Bcf below the 1996 record low. At a US inventory level this low, many storage operators would be dipping into base-load gas in order to support service even to firm gas customers. * Physical deliverability from storage fields will be significantly lower this year in midwinter, forcing a greater reliance on pipeline gas and peaking facilities during January and February. The actual reduction in field deliverability is impossible to quantify, but storage inventories cannot be withdrawn at steady rates throughout the winter; withdrawal rates decline with inventory as field pressure is reduced. * Pressure in the market will be reinforced and extended through 2001 and probably into 2002. During the past two summers, high prices have been required to discourage demand and allow overall US storage injections to reach barely 1.6 trillion cubic feet (Tcf). If normal weather holds for the remainder of this winter, 2.2 Tcf of injections-which would be nearly impossible to achieve-would be required during 2001 if inventories are to recover to 2.7 Tcf at peak. If weather this winter is merely normal from mid-December through March, going into winter next year the United States will have considerably less gas in storage. Reaching even the 2,362 Bcf level, according to CERA estimates (see Table 1), would require an additional 275 Bcf of injections next year, and that alone would prove challenging. Price-The Cold Weather Path The weakness of storage inventories and the demand pressure in both core and power generation markets created by the cold weather have caused prices to move onto and even above CERA's cold weather path for this winter (see Table 2). Storage inventories would become perilously low if the current forecast for cold weather through mid-December proves accurate, and the injections required next summer would keep pressure in the market intense. For these reasons CERA's outlook for prices for January and throughout 2001 now reflects the cold weather path. Prices could take an even higher path, particularly if colder-than-normal weather endures beyond mid-December or returns on a sustained basis in January or February. Several forces that could weaken prices during 2001 will begin to enter the market during the winter, but these are offset by demand volatility in the winter and the requirement to rebuild storage inventories once the winter is over. Such factors include a building US supply capability, growing imports, softening oil prices (allowing a lower floor for prices once the winter ends), and potentially weakening economic growth. Although the influence of these factors will increase, it is unlikely to match the huge injection requirement that appears more and more certain next summer. Demand-The Difficult Next Round of Switching With gas prices hitting new record highs, CERA expects some additional demand to be priced out of the market. Because gas has priced above residual fuel oil for most weeks since May, however, the easiest fuel switching in the power generation and industrial sectors has already occurred. Even though gas prices are currently above the level of distillate (approximately $7.23 per MMBtu in New York), switching from gas to distillate requires changes in long-standing consumer habit, will occur only over time, and is likely limited in volume. Significant switching to distillate would quickly raise the price of distillate itself. There are four major sources of additional demand response in industrial markets: * Additional switching to resid in industrial boilers. The next increment of demand to come out of the market is likely to be in the industrial sector, through additional fuel switching to resid (and to some extent to distillate). These markets will continue to show some flexibility but will not represent a large volume. CERA estimates that the industrial boiler market has probably already begun to lose small amounts (less than 0.5 Bcf per day) in switching to resid, given the consistency of gas price premiums greater than $0.50 per MMBtu. * Investment in restoring switching capability. As premiums move far beyond this level, industrial end users can be expected to take a closer look at reinvigorating their switching capability beyond their initial short-term levels. However, such a change would require investment by industrial end users and the availability of resid in oil markets. CERA estimates that with focused investment over the course of a number of months to perhaps a year, switching to resid could eventually reach as high as 1.3 Bcf per day. There is already some movement here; given the impact of high gas prices on earnings, energy prices have already begun to receive management attention. * Switching to distillate. US Department of Energy data suggest that industrial end users have a theoretical capability of switching nearly 1.3 Bcf per day to distillate in the short term. This switch would represent additional distillate demand of over 200,000 barrels per day (bd) in a US market of 3.8 million barrels. This marginal demand would move the distillate price in tandem with gas price, and any additional switching among power generators to distillate would reinforce this price correlation. In addition, the availability of distillate inventories on site should restrict the quick switching to short periods of time and will not offer a long-term solution to tight markets. * Shutting down industrial plants. Also offering some flexibility is the shutdown of manufacturing plants that use gas as a feedstock. The major feedstock consumers are the ammonia and methanol industries, and, not surprisingly given the tight margins available, manufacturers of ammonia and of methanol continue to show suppressed gas demand. However, in the short term only a portion of ammonia production is at risk. Whereas the production needs of merchant facilities along the Gulf Coast is relatively readily replaced by imports, substitution becomes more difficult away from the coast (because of transportation logistics) and for facilities whose production is linked to value-added fertilizer products. Hence, CERA still estimates that even with nonexistent margins, substantial ammonia production would continue, with additional losses of perhaps 200 million cubic feet (MMcf) per day of potential demand in addition to the facilities that have already closed. Extraordinarily high gas prices will also hasten the shuttering of North American methanol capacity, putting at risk another 100 to 200 MMcf per day of gas demand for that sector. Switching that could occur in boiler use is concentrated in the chemicals, paper, and refining sectors in the South and the food products sector in the Midwest. Continuing feedstock losses would be concentrated in the South Central region. For process users, even extraordinarily high gas prices are expected to have little impact on the use of gas in the short term. Energy costs are not the dominant component of production costs for these users, and a physical changeover would be time-intensive and elemental in its impact on end-use product quality. The Northeast-Cold Weather Operations Begin All of the Northeast pipelines have issued notices to customers that they either have imposed, or are highly likely to need to impose, transportation restrictions of various types. The most common restriction is to nonprimary firm services (secondary and interruptible type services), which will be scheduled for the next several days on many pipelines. Other pipelines have issued balancing requirements whereby receipts and deliveries must match. Even hourly flow orders have also been implemented. These actions are normal for winter operations when a cold period is expected. Whereas the firm market for natural gas is rarely affected by these restrictions, the spot market becomes much more volatile as interruptible supplies dry up. The spot market, primarily made up of nonfirm customers, has had a dramatic reaction to the diminished availability of delivered spot gas into the market area, as has been reflected by the volatility of the cash market this week. The result of these restrictions of nonprimary firm services has been an expansion of basis to Henry Hub. At one point, gas for next-day delivery to New York traded near $24.00 per MMBtu delivered, although the average price was closer to $14.20. These high spikes are the result of very thinly traded volumes of gas. Although these restrictions will likely ease as temperatures return closer to normal, CERA now expects basis into the New York citygate to average $1.31 per MMBtu for December and $1.36 per MMBtu for January. **end** Follow URL for PDF version of this Alert with associated tables. ********************************************************* Come Shoot the Rapids with us at CERAWeek2001, "Shooting the Rapids: Strategies and Risks for the Energy Future" in Houston, February 12-16, 2001! For more information and to register, please visit http://www.cera.com/ceraweek/ ********************************************************* ********************************************************************** This electronic message and attachments, if any, contain information from Cambridge Energy Research Associates, Inc. (CERA) which is confidential and may be privileged. Unauthorized disclosure, copying, distribution or use of the contents of this message or any attachments, in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited. Terms of Use: http://www.cera.com/tos.html Questions/Comments: webmaster@cera.com Copyright 2000. Cambridge Energy Research Associates