28 Nov 2000, 09:27 UTC
Let the witch hunt begin...
- From
- Jeffery Fawcett jeffery.fawcett@enron.com
- Date
- Tue, 28 Nov 2000 01:27:00 -0800 (PST)
CPUC sees market abuses, claims overcharges California regulators told FERC in a filing they have sufficient evidence of market power abuse to warrant additional investigation. In response to FERC,s request for comments on proposals to repair California, s wholesale power market, the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) also argued retail electricity consumers had been overcharged by up to $4 billion by independent generators. The CPUC did not name any specific generator. &The CPUC,s preliminary staff analysis * conducted under similar conditions of imperfect data and inadequate time * suggests that claims of tight supply and increased costs, while real, are overstated and explain less of the increased costs than FERC staff concludes,8 the CPUC says. The CPUC,s filing cites FERC,s own assertion that California,s wholesale market structure provided the opportunity and potential for market power abuses. However, the CPUC disagrees with FERC,s conclusion that insufficient evidence exists to prove actual abuses occurred. Claiming that FERC,s own investigation into market manipulation was incomplete, the California regulators charge &that market power played a much greater role in the summer,s prices than appears to be acknowledged in the [FERC] Staff Report.8 California regulators, conducting their own investigation into market power abuses, examined the impact of increased costs due to higher-than-normal natural gas prices, as well as increased expenses related to obtaining limited environmental permits. &The CPUC,s preliminary analysis shows that as much as $4 billion of [California Power Exchange] costs are attributable to market power for the period between June and September,8 the state regulators reported. &FERC should set hearings on this issue.8 More generally, the CPUC criticized FERC,s Nov. 1 order, claiming that it &fails to provide meaningful relief to Californians who ( have spent billions more for power in recent months than ever before, paying prices that are not justified on the basis of industry costs or any other measure.8 In addition, the CPUC,s comments on the major aspects of the FERC report were similar to those of other market participants also filed last Wednesday. The CPUC said FERC should take interim measures to allow for immediate price relief for California consumers, that the $150/ MWh &soft cap8 suggested in the order would not hold prices down effectively, and that fines on purchasers that do not forward contract the majority of their load were one-sided.