20 Jul 2000, 03:13 UTC
Re: Meeting with Kim & Chang - EOL Korean legal survey
- From
- John Viverito john.viverito@enron.com
- To
- Matthias Lee
- Date
- Wed, 19 Jul 2000 20:13:00 -0700 (PDT)
Matt- I am unsure as to what Mike Dahlke is referencing when utilizing the term "Business Model Patent". If you believe it appropriate, perhaps you could clarify this with him. I note, that yesterday I was requested by Mike Grimes to join in on a conference call that was in progress. The question that Jae Moo had raised was as to whether we could state to the Korean authorities that the Japanese authorities had arrived at the conclusion that weather derivatives should be categorized as a commodity derivative, as opposed to a financial derivative. I informed the participants on the call that in Japan, weather derivatives are considered financial in nature, most analagous under the Japanese regulatory framework to FX and interest rate transactions. The basis for this, is that there can be no physical delivery with a weather derivative, as would be possible in a commodity type transaction, therefore resulting in the classification of a financial derivative. If I may be of further assistance, please contact me. My office phone number in Tokyo is 81-3 5219-4578. Cheers, John Matthias Lee@ECT 07/20/2000 02:32 AM To: Alan Aronowitz/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mark Taylor/HOU/ECT@ECT, David Minns/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Edmund Cooper/LON/ECT@ECT, John Viverito/Corp/Enron@Enron cc: Angeline Poon/SIN/ECT@ECT Subject: Meeting with Kim & Chang - EOL Korean legal survey Alan, Mark,David, John, Edmund I had a telephone conference with Kim & Chang/Enron Korea this afternoon. The meeting was initiated by Mike Dahlke (APACHI Regulatory Affairs) and Jae Moo Lee (Enron Korea). Attendence: Mike Dahlke (Enron) Jae Moo Lee (Enron) Michelle Lee (Enron) Matt Lee (Enron- by telephone) SK Hong (Kim & Chang) Summary of issues discussed: 1. Whether Weather Derivatives will be classified as a Commodity Derivative or a Financial Derivative, since Korea has no experience with such a product. 2. Commodity Derivatives are defined in the FETR but does not seem to capture Weather Derivatives as reference is made to products that can be delivered or received. Financial Derivatives are not defined. 3. Commodity Derivatives require a prior reporting the the Bank of Korea for each trade. Financial Derivatives require prior approval from the Bank of Korea for each trade. Failure to make report or obtain approval means the Counterparty would not be able to remit funds to make payment. 4. Bank of Korea has informally advised K&C that, for Commodity Derivatives, the report can be made by the foreign counterparty (ie. Enron) and, notwithstanding it ought to be a prior report, can be done as soon as possible after the trade confirmation. However, Bank of Korea has the discretion to reject any report made. This would make a trade effectively unperformable or unenforceable. 5. Bank of Korea took on the role to receive such reports in April 1999 and informally informed K&C that they have yet to receive a single report. Prior to April 1999, reports were made to certain designated banks. 6. K&C advised that if the report is made by a Korean counterparty, it would have to declare why it is entering into the transaction and the risk it is hedging, but this requirement would not be applicable if the foreign copunterparty makes the report. I am of the opinion that this statement should be viewed with caution, especially since there is really no expereince in Korea of such reports being filed with the Bank of Korea. 7. For Financial Derivatives, prior approval is required before a trade is done and may take 3 to 5 days. 8. The reporting and approval requirements apply only to onshore Korean entities. 9. In order to determine how Weather Derivatives would be classified, K&C recommends approaching the Bank of Korea to make a detailed presentation. The Ministry of Finance and Economy (which is the legislative authority) may have to be approached if Bank of Korea is unable/unwilling to make a decision. Such lobbying is likely to be protracted. I have asked K&C to make informal enquiries as to whether Bank of Korea would likely classify Weather Derivatives as Commodity Derivatives or Financial Derivatives, and whether it would be receptive to presentation on Weather Derivatives. 10. K&C also advised that it would be preferred if the overtures to Bank of Korea can be made by Korean companies with a real interest in doing Weather Derivatives. K&C was of the view that Bank of Korea is conservative and may view Enron with some suspicion as a foreign company "out to make lots of money". 11. Mike Dahlke also brought up the issue of Business Model Patent in Japan which he had spoken with John V. about. John - could you fill me in, in case applicable to Korea? It seems to me the main obstacle is the issue of reporting to/approval from Bank of Korea. The reporting requirement applies to Liquid Fuel Derivatives, and the approval requirement would apply to the Financial Derivatives potentially offered out of Enron Japan. The Korean regulations do not seem to accomodate prompt telephone derivative trading, let alone instantaneous online derivative trading. Please advise next steps, in particular, do the commercial guys want to proceed with approaching Bank of Korea and how would it be coordinated. Meanwhile, I attach my comments and queries of K&C's memorandum for your review. Please let me know as soon as possible if you have other comments for me to revert to K&C. Regards Matt