15 Mar 2001, 12:00 UTC
President Bush Reverses Position on CO2 Emissions
- From
- SCIENTECH IssueAlert issuealert@scientech.com
- Date
- Thu, 15 Mar 2001 04:00:00 -0800 (PST)
Today's IssueAlert Sponsors: [IMAGE] Switch Rates, Predictions and Analysis in Retail Energy Foresight. Rely on Retail Energy Foresight for current and projected switch rates and thoughtful analysis on restructured energy markets and related issues. Download FREE trial copies at www.xenergy.com/xensecure.nsf or contact Susan Weber at 781.273.5700 or via e-mail at sweber@xenergy.com. Retail Energy Foresight is a bimonthly publication from XENERGY, a leader in energy consulting and strategic information since 1975. www.xenergy.com/xensecure.nsf [IMAGE] Rapidpartsmart is the newest, most powerful online parts search engine in the power industry. Rapidpartsmart is the complete source to locate, buy and sell engineered parts worldwide. Rapidpartsmart integrates over 5 million supply items into asset management and work management systems to ensure that you know all supply sources, all the time. Rapidpartsmart increases supply options, reduces outage risks and cuts inventory investment. Contact John Kelly at (727) 669-3006 for more information or go to www.rapidpartsmart.com [IMAGE] The most comprehensive, up-to-date map of the North American Power System by RDI/FT Energy is now available from SCIENTECH. [IMAGE] IssueAlert for March 15, 2001 President Bush Reverses Position on CO2 Emissions by Will McNamara Director, Electric Industry Analysis [News Item from The Washington Post, March 14] President Bush has decided not to seek reductions in the carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions of the nation's power plants, reversing himself on a campaign pledge after encountering strong resistance from the coal and oil industries and from Republican allies on Capitol Hill. In a letter to four Republican senators, Bush cited a recent Energy Department study showing that restrictions on CO2 emissions would result in a shift from coal to natural gas and lead to higher energy costs. "I do not believe(that the government should impose on power plants mandatory emissions for carbon dioxide," Bush said. Analysis: The sudden change in President Bush's position on CO2 emissions naturally has elicited strong reactions from both sides of the debate. The extent to which CO2 contributes to the nation's pollution, and whether or not the government should take an active role in restricting CO2 emissions, has become an intensely politicized issue. Democrats and environmental groups responded with outrage to what they perceive as a betrayal by the president, while coal and oil industry officials believe that Bush's decision will ensure a more balanced energy and environmental policy. I won't attempt to debate the political aspects of the president's decision. Rather, I will analyze Bush's current position impacts the energy industry, and whether or not the lifting of CO2restrictions does indeed contribute to a sound energy policy. It is true that during his campaign, the president made promises to limit CO2 emissions. In a speech in late September, Bush said, "With the help of Congress, environmental groups and industry, we will require all power plants to meet clean air standards in order to reduce emissions of sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxide, mercury and carbon dioxide within a reasonable period of time." Yet, while many critics have claimed that Bush's refusal to place limits on CO2 is a philosophical turnabout, White House spokesman Scott McClellan said that carbon dioxide "should not have been included as a pollutant" in Bush's campaign position because it is not classified as one in the Clean Air Act. Further, the White House has said that Bush's original promise was a "mistake" inconsistent with the president's broader goal of increasing domestic energy production. In fact, although many scientists believe that CO2 is a key contributor to global warming, it has not been proven to have any direct effect on human health. Consequently, CO2 has never been classified as a pollutant under the Clean Air Act because, in the eyes of those determining Clean Air classifications, it has no detrimental human health or environmental impact, except as it applies to concerns about global warming. In his decision to abstain from placing any restrictions on CO2 emissions, Bush noted "the incomplete state of scientific knowledge of the causes of, and solutions to, global climate change and the lack of commercially available technologies for removing and storing carbon dioxide." The president maintains that he is committed to an energy policy that would seek to improve air quality emissions of NOx, SO2 and mercury, which are already regulated as pollutants, but not CO2. Bush also said that he would work with Congress to reduce emissions from power plants specifically, but that any such strategy would include phased-in reductions and market-based incentives to help the industry meet the targets. Moreover, the president apparently cannot reconcile any possible restrictions on CO2 emissions with ramifications that the restrictions might have on domestic power supply. Clearly, any limits on CO2 emissions would have tremendous impact on coal-burning power plants. By some estimates, coal, a relatively cheap and plentiful fuel which accounts for more than 50 percent of the electricity generated in the United States, produces about 40 percent of the nation's CO2 output (more than any other fuel). Yet, industry officials have warned the president that any effort to restrict CO2 emissions would compromise efforts to increase domestic energy production. Since Bush took office as president in January, it has become increasingly clear that a major component of the president's imminent energy plan will be efforts to increase domestic power supply through a diverse fuel mix that includes coal, natural gas and nuclear. The president has maintained that he sees a supplemental role for renewable energies such as wind and solar. However, according to reports out earlier this week, Bush is proposing to cut the DOE's renewable fuels and energy efficiency budget by 30 to 40 percent. In any case, establishing this diverse fuel mix will take time, and the president realizes that the country faces an immediate energy crisis resulting from a growing supply / demand imbalance. Aside from power supply concerns, the president also acknowledged the current high prices for natural gas, and how a reduction in coal-fired generation would most likely keep prices at their high levels. In fact, the president said that conclusions made in a recent DOE report led to his decision to back away from CO2 restrictions, more than any pressure he might have received from oil and coal lobbying groups, as has been reported in many recent news articles. Bush noted that the DOE study had concluded that regulating CO2 emissions would have led to "significantly higher electricity prices." The translation of this is that, if restrictions were to be placed on coal-burning plants, many power suppliers would turn to natural-gas production as an alternative. Natural-gas supplies are already compromised in this country due to increasing demand, which has driven prices up to unprecedented levels. Bush's decision reflects the concern that, if power suppliers begin turning from coal to natural gas in larger numbers, this will continue to exacerbate the supply shortage and keep prices alarmingly high. "This is important new information that warrants a re-evaluation, especially at a time of rising energy prices and a serious energy shortage," President Bush said. The DOE report also indicated that because coal-fired power plants are the major power sector emitters of CO2, compliance with the emission caps would be expected to have a major impact on coal consumption and production, both nationally and regionally. If CO2caps were to be put into place, substantial reductions in coal consumption would result, according to the DOE, with corresponding drops in the projections for coal production. Further, because coal has a carbon content more than 70 percent higher per Btu than that of natural gas, the DOE report said that the carbon allowance fees related to CO2 caps would make the continued operation of many existing coal plants uneconomical. In addition to the DOE report, Bush continues to be counseled by an energy advisory team, including Vice President Cheney and Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham, as well as having the ear of other members of the Republican Party. Many Republican senators, including Jesse Helms (North Carolina) and Chuck Hagel (Nebraska) expressed alarm over Bush's campaign promises to reduce CO2 emissions out of concern that the promises were a step closer to ratifying an international treaty regarding pollution control. The Kyoto Protocol, negotiated and signed by the Clinton administration but still not ratified, would commit 38 industrialized countries to ongoing cuts in CO2 (along with SO2 and NOx) emissions. Negotiations over the Protocol broke down last November, but are expected to resume this July. If ratified, the Protocol would limit CO2 emissions below 1990 levels. Currently, CO2 emissions in the United States are about 12 percent over 1990 levels. Reportedly, Sens. Helms and Hagel oppose ratification of the Kyoto Protocol because they believe it could adversely impact the economy and allow American energy policy to be directed by an international treaty. It is important to note how the president's new stand on CO2 emissions relates to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). Just two weeks ago, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the EPA has the power to issue new standards designed to reduce the levels of smog and soot in the air. However, the EPA does not currently regulate CO2 emissions. EPA Administrator Christine Whitman, in a series of public statements, had vehemently defended and supported President Bush's previously espoused commitment to controlling CO2 emissions. Meanwhile, the president's change in policy precedes several bi-partisan bills that are expected to be introduced in the House and Senate this week. The measures reportedly will provide incentives and set requirements to modernize power plants and reduce emissions of CO2, SO2 and NOx. Given the president's new stance, however, the prospects for these bills gaining much momentum may diminish. In summary, President Bush apparently felt the need to give priority to short-term resolutions to the nation's energy crisis over long-term environmental concerns. Given the fact that coal presently generates more than half of the nation's energy needs, the fossil fuel*despite its debated environmental impacts*is a critical component of the U.S. energy supply. Realizing that growing demand continues to compromise the country's power supply, it appears that Bush made the unpopular decision to allow the heavy reliance on coal to continue, at least for the near term. While some will continue to say that the president reneged on his original campaign promises and was unduly influenced by oil and gas lobbyists, an argument can be made that the nation's supply problems have worsened since last fall when the president was campaigning. After examining the mix of current factors* including consistently high natural-gas prices, demand that remains on the rise and a continued reliance on coal, which remains comparatively inexpensive*it is understandable that the president would take this position. However, the general consensus among scientists is that CO2 emissions contribute to global warming, and that a long-term solution to curb CO2 emissions must be enacted. As President Bush unveils his energy plan over the next few weeks, it will be interesting to see how or if he addresses the issue of CO2 emissions from a long-term perspective. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.ConsultRCI.com Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily email, send a message to IssueAlert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.