1 Dec 2000, 12:17 UTC
Re: Governor's Response to FERC
- From
- Alan Comnes alan.comnes@enron.com
- Cc
- skean@enron.com, Richard Shapiro, Karen Denne, mpalmer@enron.com, Sandra McCubbin, Joe Hartsoe, Mary Hain, Sarah Novosel, Susan J Mara, Mona L Petrochko, Paul Kaufman, James D Steffes
- Bcc
- skean@enron.com, Richard Shapiro, Karen Denne, mpalmer@enron.com, Sandra McCubbin, Joe Hartsoe, Mary Hain, Sarah Novosel, Susan J Mara, Mona L Petrochko, Paul Kaufman, James D Steffes
- Date
- Fri, 1 Dec 2000 04:17:00 -0800 (PST)
I assume that Jeff D. will give us his reactions but in the mean time here's the proposal: December 1, 2000 Honorable James Hoecker Chairman Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 888 First Street, N.E. Washington, D.C. 20426 Dear Chairman Hoecker: I told you on November 14 in San Diego that, by December 1, I would respond to your plan with my suggestions to protect the interests of the people and businesses of California by providing reliable electricity supplies at the lowest reasonable cost. Obviously, a complete plan by the State of California must await your review of my suggested changes to your proposed order, and final action on that order on December 13. This letter outlines the first steps toward a plan that my administration is developing based on extensive, ongoing discussions with legislative leaders, consumers, business, utilities, generators, environmentalists, labor, agricultural interests and other California stakeholders. This emerging plan will indicate to you that I am prepared to act with the concurrence of the Legislature in California to fulfill our obligations to assure reliable service at reasonable costs to the consumer. The free market applied to electricity can work, but only if market conditions allow for real competition, and if all parties act responsibly. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) has found that the wholesale market in California is dysfunctional and that the wholesale prices charged by generators in your jurisdiction are unjust and unreasonable. For that reason, I renew my call for the FERC to undertake the actions that are critical -- and clearly within your jurisdiction -- to order retroactive refunds to the consumers who have been harmed this year, and to establish hard price and bid caps that will protect consumers until the energy marketplace becomes truly competitive. I do not believe that your proposed $150/MW clearing price limit will provide any real protection. I again ask you to impose real price and bid caps in the $100/MW range on a transitional basis over the next 36 months. If you do your job of protecting consumers by rectifying the wholesale markets, the steps I have to take can be transitional in nature and limited in scope. I cannot in good conscience, however, forego any measure that would serve to protect the people of California until I am satisfied that the sellers in the wholesale markets will not victimize Californians again. Since our meeting in San Diego, several things have occurred which influence my current thinking. On November 20, 2000 the California Energy Commission (CEC) published the results of a detailed bottom-up study of available electricity supply for 2001. It shows that -- taking into account expected load growth, firm and dynamically scheduled imports, and new supply already under construction or under contract -- California should be able to avoid emergencies if supplies are properly managed and scheduled. This presumes, of course, no gaming or withholding by sellers in wholesale markets and an absence of panic buying. But the CEC study also shows that supplies are sufficiently tight that market power will exist and will need to be mitigated during periods of high demand. The same opportunity for wholesale price gouging through the exercise of market power and withholding that existed in summer 2000 will exist in 2001. You must take decisive action to preclude such behavior. During the week of November 13-19, while you and regulatory commissioners from around the country were in San Diego, California was subjected to several Stage 2 Alerts, reflecting severe shortages of generation, even though these are the lowest load months of the year. Prices were astronomical. More than 12,000 megawatts of generation were off-line at the same time, including over 5,000 megawatts for "unscheduled outages." I will recommend steps to assure that existing resources in California are available to meet California,s local energy needs, and that information and the authority necessary to prevent a recurrence of such events are available to state and local officials. On November 22 the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) and Electricity Oversight Board (EOB) filed comments with you that summarize the current status of their ongoing investigations. They confirm the conclusions of the independent market monitors that California has been victimized by the exercise of market power by merchant generators and marketers during summer and fall 2000. The state agencies have been hampered in their investigations by the refusal of merchant generators to provide information that will both assist in the understanding of last summer,s prices and in the fashioning of remedies to assure that we are not victimized again. I urge you to compel the necessary disclosure of information to complete these investigations. On November 21 the CPUC issued an Environmental Impact Report (EIR) on the proposal by PG&E to move its hydroelectric facilities out of the regulated utility. The EIR concludes that such a project would cause significant unmitigated harm to the environment and recommends retention as the preferred alternative. This suggests that California,s course of generation divestiture by utilities may be slowed or stopped. With these events as background, I want to describe the steps I have taken and plan to take to begin to address the energy problems in California. Increase Supply and Expand Infrastructure During the 10 years preceding my administration, virtually no power plants were built in California. Since April 1999, six power plants representing 4,700 MW of new generation have been approved by the CEC. Five of these plants are under construction and the sixth will begin construction no later than April 2001. Twenty more applicants have completed pre-filing and have active applications under review by the commission staff. Eleven more applications are in the pre-filing stage. This represents a significant change in policy and performance and responds to the fact that we must increase supply as rapidly as possible without abrogating our commitment to state and federal public health and environmental protection. Much has been made about the difficulty of siting and permitting generation in California. With enactment of AB 970 and the creation of the Governor,s Clean Energy Green Team this September, California has aggressively committed itself to continue to accelerate the siting and permitting of generation and to coordinate local, state and federal government agency review and action. Federal and state air quality requirements present unique challenges to the construction and operation of new power plants. Through the Green Team, we are developing new and creative approaches to meet these challenges, working with local air quality districts, the California Air Resources Board and the United States Environmental Protection Agency. These might, for example, expand upon the case of the proposed Otay Mesa power plant, where mobile emissions credits are being used to offset stationary source emissions that will be generated by the new facility. If necessary, I will seek legislation to enable these new approaches. I am also calling on the CPUC to aggressively reduce barriers and to otherwise encourage the locating of distributed generation and co-generation where it is viable, cost effective and environmentally sound. The CPUC has already initiated action that will provide a forum for expediting certificates for transmission facilities, including environmental review. Finally, I believe it is important to assure that all supplies of electricity are available when emergency conditions exist, to avoid interruptions such as those experienced last summer and as recently as last week. Suggestions we are considering for achieving this include new means of coordinating power-plant maintenance and operations activities. Forward Contracting by Utilities Many parties, including the FERC, have recommended expanding the use of forward contracting by the utilities including multi-year bi-lateral contracts as a way of reducing exposure to volatile spot market prices. The contracts, as a part of a larger utility energy portfolio, represent an important tool to moderate price volatility and ensure reliability. I am asking the CPUC to expeditiously develop benchmarks to assure the reasonableness of these contracts without unfairly "second guessing" these decisions in later years. This process should be in place early in 2001 to provide adequate opportunity for contracts to be negotiated and in place before Summer 2001. Coupled with the forward contracting issue is the question of the obligation of utilities to buy and sell all of their electricity through the California Power Exchange (PX). This issue requires careful consideration since these transactions through the PX are currently subject to full disclosure, and safeguards are in place to assure delivery. These protections for consumers and business must not be lost. Among the suggestions that have been made to ensure that utilities have a cost-effective portfolio of energy is the proposal that utilities retain their existing generation, as was recommended in the CPUC's environmental impact report regarding PG&E's hydroelectric facilities. There is growing consensus around this matter. I would hope that the paramount objective in this series of regulatory decisions will be the protection of the interests of consumers. Invigorating the Demand Side Conservation and efficiency are the cornerstones of California,s energy future. Under my Executive Order, the State of California has achieved more than 180 MW of load reduction earlier this year during Stage 2 alerts, and is moving quickly to add another 250 MW of demand reduction for summer 2001. The federal government is following suit for federal facilities. The state and federal governments should set an example for similar voluntary load reduction initiatives in the private sector. I was pleased to work with the California Grocers Association this summer to develop a voluntary 10 percent demand reduction program during peak hours for more than 2,000 groceries statewide. This program must be duplicated in other areas where feasible and the business community in California has pledged to work cooperatively toward that end. I am calling on the CPUC to expedite its investigation of the state,s demand reduction programs for commercial and industrial users, including the interruptible programs. Those that are successful should be expanded. Those that require change should be modified. And new opportunities should be developed to reduce and shift loads during peak hours and short supply. These programs must be in place no later than March 2001, to provide adequate opportunity for private sector planning and participation. I am also calling on the CPUC and CEC to coordinate efforts to demonstrate and implement programs which provide real-time price signals and energy-reduction systems to sophisticated commercial electricity users, and to recommend a process for voluntary participation by consumers and small businesses. In September, I signed historic urgency legislation that provides $50 million for demand reduction programs that can be implemented by Summer 2001. I also signed legislation that provides approximately $500 million annually for the next 10 years for energy efficiency, research and development and renewable resource support. The CPUC and CEC are aggressively pursuing innovative demand reduction programs using these funds. Institutional Reform As I testified at the FERC hearing on November 14, I agree that the stakeholder boards of the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) and California Power Exchange present inherent conflicts of interest for their members and must be replaced. The composition of these boards is specified by state law, both as to size and as to qualifications for directors. I will propose legislation to replace the stakeholder boards with independent boards that are accountable for their actions, and that will consider both the need to assure reliability and the most economic method to do so. I intend to move quickly on this aspect of the problem. Your concurrence in this effort is extremely important. It will little serve the consumers, utilities, merchant generators or other parties to become embroiled in litigation over exactly what powers Congress conferred on the FERC in 1935, or what traditional state powers, if any, Congress meant to circumscribe or override. Recognizing that there may be a need for more extensive reconstitution of these entities, as some have suggested, I do not intend to let the status quo continue while those debates are carried on. California will alter the composition and membership of the boards so that the entities are in position to contribute to achieving the paramount objectives of both state and federal law -- protection of the consumers' interests. In 1996 Governor Pete Wilson and his CPUC reposed a great deal of trust in the FERC in moving California,s electricity system into an unbundled, federalized mode. Now is the time for you to justify that trust. I want to cooperate with you in transitioning to a market-based approach to provide this essential service. However, first and foremost, I want you to do your job and to let me do mine. Together we can protect the electricity consumers of California and work to restore their confidence. Sincerely, GRAY DAVIS