16 May 2001, 16:55 UTC
State Bar of Michigan e-Journal - 5/17/01
- From
- bounce-ejournal-255481@lists.michbar.org bounce-ejournal-255481@lists.michbar.org
- Date
- Wed, 16 May 2001 09:55:00 -0700 (PDT)
If you cannot read today's e-Journal, please visit this link:? http://www.michbar.org/e-journal/051701.html Or to receive a plain text version, please send an e-mail to lyris@lists.michbar.org? In the body, type:? unsubscribe ejournal and on the next line type:? subscribe ejournal-text [IMAGE] Ad 1 [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] [IMAGE] The e-Journal is available to members of the State Bar of Michigan at no additional charge thanks in part to the generous support of our advertisers. Please be sure to support these State Bar partners and visit their Internet sites frequently for information about their products and services. ? [IMAGE] State Bar of Michigan e-Journal for Thursday, May 17, 2001 ?qlink ?Use our specifically designed hypertext links --Quicklinks -- to jump to the desired area of today's e-Journal ?cases Cases affecting the following practice areas are summarized in today's e-Journal: Administrative Law Civil Rights Constitutional Law Construction Law Corrections Criminal Law Employment & Labor Law Family Law Litigation Municipal Negligence & Intentional Tort Real Property Special Notes: Today's e-Journal includes summaries of four Michigan Supreme Court opinions and six Michigan Court of Appeals published opinions in the following practice areas: Administrative Law, Civil Rights, Constitutional Law, Construction Law, Employment & Labor Law, Family Law, Litigation, Negligence & Intentional Tort, and Real Property. Due to technical difficulties, a summary of the Supreme Court decision in Bolt v City of Lansing will appear in tomorrow's e-Journal. [IMAGE] ?editorial Please click here to read today's Other Editorial [IMAGE] Tell Us What You Think Visit Our New Townhall Forum Electronic Bulletin Board Amendment of Local Court Rules 2.100 and 8.108 of the Wayne Circuit Court, and Repeal of Local Court Rules 2.301, 2.401 and 2.503 ?classified Listings in the following areas are in today's Classified Section: Confidential Records Destruction Expert Witness Lawsuit Financials Legal Research Office Space Available Positions Available Services ?fieldspractice Need to refer a case? See today's Fields of Practice Listings: ADR/Arbitration/Mediation Administrative Law Adoption Alternative Dispute Resolution Antitrust/Advertising/Trade Regulation Appeals Appellate Law Automotive Warranty Law Business & Taxation Construction Law Copyrights Criminal Law Environmental Law Family Law Federal False Claims (Qui Tam) Actions Health Law Hospital & Medical Negligence Immigration & Naturalization Immigration Law Insurance Law Intellectual Property Law Labor & Employment Law Litigation Medical Malpractice Real Estate Special Education Law Tax Litigation & Disputes Transportation Law Worker's Compensation ?newsandmoves See this week's News & Moves for information about your colleagues: barevents? See today's Bar Events section for news about upcoming programs and activities: Criminal Law Brown Bag "Therapeutic Drug Court" Eighth Trailblazers Dinner case summaries Administrative Law Back to Quicklinks Issues:? Registration fees for interstate motor carriers under the 1991 Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act (ISTEA); Whether effect of reciprocity agreements must be considered in determining amount of fee charged or collected on November 15, 1991; Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) Court:? Michigan Supreme Court Case Name:? Yellow Freight Sys., Inc. v. State of Michigan e-Journal Number:? 10238 Judge(s):? Weaver, Corrigan, Taylor, Young, Jr., and Markman; Dissent ) Kelly; Dissent ) Cavanagh In an issue of first impression in any state court, the court held that under the plain language of the ISTEA, reciprocity agreements were irrelevant in determining what registration fees were charged or collected as of November 15, 1991. Plaintiff alleged that defendants collected registration fees in excess of the amount allowed under ISTEA, contending that Michigan could not alter its reciprocity agreements because these were frozen at their November 15, 1991 levels. The court declined to defer to the ICC,s interpretation banning states from charging registration fees in excess of preexisting reciprocal discounts. The court determined that the plain meaning of the ISTEA was clear and applied the statute as written without reaching the agency interpretation. The ISTEA itself referred only to the fees collected or charged, and contained no reference to reciprocity agreements. The court concluded that it must look at the generic fee Michigan charged or collected from carriers as of November 15, 1991, not at the fees paid by plaintiff in any given year. Reversed and remanded. Justice Kelly, dissenting, disagreed with the conclusion that reciprocity agreements were not relevant to determining the registration fees that Michigan charged and would have affirmed the decisions of the Court of Appeals and Court of Claims in favor of plaintiff. Justice Cavanagh, also dissenting, likewise found the statutory language ambiguous and that the ICC permissibly construed it in taking into account reciprocity agreements. Full Text Opinion Civil Rights Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Employment & Labor Law Issues:? Whether an alleged adverse employment action against an employee on the basis of her former intimate relationship with her supervisor presented a cognizable claim of sex discrimination under the CRA; Quid pro quo sexual harassment; Hostile work environment; Respondeat superior; Sex discrimination; Breach of contract; Intentional infliction of emotional distress Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Published) Case Name:? Corley v. Detroit Bd. of Educ. e-Journal Number: 10218 Judge(s):? Neff, Holbrook, Jr., and Jansen In an issue of first impression regarding whether alleged adverse employment action against an employee on the basis of her former intimate relationship with her supervisor presents a cognizable claim of sex discrimination under the CRA, the court held that it does. Therefore, summary disposition of plaintiff,s sexual harassment claim in favor of defendants was improper. Plaintiff alleged that she was subjected to a hostile work environment, sexual harassment, disparate treatment, and unlawful termination because of her sex and her prior relationship with defendant-Smith. Plaintiff established sufficient facts to survive a motion for summary disposition under either quid pro quo sexual harassment or hostile work environment. Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Employment & Labor Law Issues: Alleged discrimination based on race and marital status; The CRA statute of limitations; Wrongful discharge; Failure to timely initiate an appeal of an administrative agency's final decision to the circuit court; Constitutional issues not within the agency's jurisdiction may be raised in the circuit court through the Administrative Procedures Act (APA) review procedure Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Published) Case Name: Womack-Scott v. Department of Corrections e-Journal Number: 10219 Judge(s): Per Curiam - Doctoroff, Hoekstra, and Markey Since the plaintiff-former employee failed to bring her CRA claims within three years of the date of her initial discharge for violation of one of defendant's work rules, the trial court properly granted summary disposition to defendant. Plaintiff argued that the trial court used the wrong date when calculating the limitation period and should have used the last day she was employed by defendant. Although plaintiff was technically reinstated for a period of time as a result of administrative decisions and again discharged, the court disagreed that the second and final discharge should apply for purposes of calculating the limitations period. Accordingly, plaintiff's race and marital status discrimination claims accrued on the date of her initial discharge that was for allegedly discriminatory reasons. Plaintiff's wrongful discharge claim was also properly dismissed by the trial court because plaintiff failed to appeal the final administrative decision to the circuit court within the 60-day time limitation provided by the APA. Affirmed. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Employment & Labor Law Issues:? Age, gender, and race discrimination; Retaliation Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? Jones v. Wayne State Univ. e-Journal Number: 10195 Judge(s): Per Curiam ) Bandstra, Zahra, and Meter Plaintiff,s claims of age, gender, and race discrimination were properly dismissed. Plaintiff, a 55-year old African-American female, alleged that her reassignment was motivated by defendant-employer,s administrators, desire to assemble a young, Caucasian male staff. Plaintiff alleged that a statement by defendant,s manager was direct evidence defendant discriminated against her based on age. However, at most, plaintiff,s testimony established that defendant,s manager observed that the department was made up of young, inexperienced employees. Further, plaintiff,s subjective impressions of her reassignment as a dead-end job were insufficient to establish a prima facie case of discrimination. Plaintiff,s discriminatory replacement arguments based on gender and race failed because she was not replaced by a nonmember of the protected class. Summary disposition in favor of the defendant was affirmed. Full Text Opinion Constitutional Law Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Real Property Issues: The constitutionality of the Opening of Private Roads and Temporary Highways Act (the Private Roads Act (MCL 229.1 et seq.)); Whether the act authorizes a taking primarily benefiting a private rather than a public purpose; Overruling Bieker v. Suttons Bay Twp. Supervisor and McKeighan v. Grass Lake Twp. Supervisor II Court: Michigan Supreme Court Case Name: Tolksdorf v. Griffith e-Journal Number: 10240 Judge(s): Kelly, Corrigan, Cavanagh, Weaver, Taylor, Young, Jr.; Not participating - Markman The court struck down the Private Roads Act (allowing a private landowner to petition a township supervisor to open a private road across another landowner's property) as providing for an unconstitutional taking under art. 10, o 2 of the Michigan Constitution of 1963, because it authorizes a taking that primarily benefits a private rather than a public purpose. Plaintiffs owned landlocked property and defendants owned a neighboring parcel. Defendants refused plaintiffs' requests seeking a paved road across their parcel and an easement for utility lines. Plaintiffs sued requesting a writ of mandamus compelling the township supervisor to proceed under the act. The trial court ruled against plaintiffs and the Court of Appeals found error in the refusal to issue the writ. The court concluded that since the act gives individuals a permanent and continuous right to pass over another's property, it allowed a permanent physical occupation of private property by means of government action, and was a taking. The taking authorized by the act appeared to merely be an attempt by a private entity to use the state's powers to acquire what it could not get through arms' length negotiations with defendants, and the primary benefit inured to the landlocked private owners, rather than the public. Reversed and the trial court's ruling for defendants was reinstated. Full Text Opinion Construction Law Back to Quicklinks Issues:? Statute of limitations for civil claims brought under the Michigan builder,s trust fund act; Accrual of civil claims under builder,s trust fund act Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Published) Case Name:? DiPonio Constr. Co., Inc. v. Rosati Masonry Co., Inc. e-Journal Number:? 10217 Judge(s):? Smolenski, Zahra, and Gage In an issue of first impression, the court ruled that the six-year statute of limitations found in MCL 600.5813 applies to civil claims brought under the Michigan builder,s trust act therefore, the trial court erred in dismissing plaintiff-subcontractor,s action on the basis it was time-barred. Applying analysis found in case precedent, the court concluded that when a statute itself does not provide a limitation period, a cause of action arising from a statutory violation is subject to the six-year limitation period found in o 5813. Plaintiff,s claim accrued when defendants were paid on the project and defendants failed to pay plaintiff the amounts due on that project. Reversed. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Negligence & Intentional Tort Issues:? Retained control over the construction project; Immunity under the exclusive remedy provision of the WDCA; Reliance on the Supreme Court,s plurality opinion in Bitar v.Wakim; Expert,s testimony on the vibration from a bulldozer theory; Duty to warn Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? Piraine v. BDP Dev. e-Journal Number: 10192 Judge(s):? Per Curiam- Griffin, Holbrook, Jr., and Murphy The court corrected a clerical error and ordered that the final paragraph of the earlier opinion (see e-Journal # 10080 in the 5/3/01 edition) be stricken and replaced with the following language: &The lower court,s orders denying summary disposition are affirmed and the matter is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion. We do not retain jurisdiction.8 The opinion remained the same in all other respects. The earlier release date was vacated. Full Text Opinion Corrections Back to Quicklinks Issues:? Parole; Legitimate reasons for parole board to deny parole to a prisoner assessed with only an average probability of parole Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? Searles v. Parole Bd. e-Journal Number:? 10210 Judge(s):? Memorandum ) Gage, Cavanagh, and Wilder Defendant-parole board did not abuse its discretion in denying parole to plaintiff, a prisoner assessed with only an average probability of parole, and the trial court erred in reversing the parole board,s decision. The parole board identified several legitimate reasons for denying plaintiff parole, including (1) the type of crime (CSC II), (2) the identity of the victim, (3) plaintiff,s unstable domestic and employment histories, and (4) her inability to follow rules, reflected in her misconduct record. The trial court,s order was reversed and the parole board,s decision denying parole was reinstated. Full Text Opinion Criminal Law Back to Quicklinks Issues:? Sufficiency of evidence to support conviction of third-degree fleeing or eluding a police officer; Alleged police brutality Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? People v. Buchanan e-Journal Number: 10198 Judge(s):? Per Curiam ) Gage, Cavanagh, and Wilder There was sufficient evidence to support defendant,s conviction of third-degree fleeing or eluding a police officer. Defendant argued that the evidence failed to show that he refused to obey a clear signal to stop his vehicle. The evidence showed that defendant continued to drive at a high rate of speed, even after a marked police vehicle activated its overhead lights, and that defendant only pulled into a parking lot because two police vehicles blocked his path. The evidence also demonstrated that defendant was driving with an unlawful blood alcohol level, had a suspended license, and was a parole absconder, which supported an inference that he was intentionally trying to evade the police. Affirmed. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks Issues: Whether the trial court's refusal to give the requested instruction on the lesser included offense of larceny from a person was harmless error; The Carines/Olano plain error rule Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name: People v. Davidson e-Journal Number: 10187 Judge(s): Per Curiam - Holbrook, Jr. and McDonald; Dissent - Wilder Since the erroneous unarmed robbery instructions seriously affected the fairness, integrity, or public reputation of judicial proceedings independent of the defendant's innocence and the error was not harmless, defendant's conviction of two counts of unarmed robbery was reversed and the case remanded for a new trial. The prosecution conceded that the trial court erred in refusing to give the requested instruction on the lesser included offense of larceny from a person, but argued that the error had a negligible effect on the outcome of the case and was harmless. The court disagreed because the jury was improperly instructed on the crime of unarmed robbery, the crime for which defendant was convicted, and specific intent. The court could not conclude that the jury's verdict would have been the same had it been given the proper instruction for unarmed robbery. The court also concluded that the instructions given by the trial court conflated the crime of unarmed robbery and accessory after the fact. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks Issues:? Motion for a new trial; Whether complainant,s recanting affidavit was newly discovered evidence; Whether defendant demonstrated a miscarriage of justice; Whether constitutional rights were violated; Waiver of trial by jury Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? People v. Felder e-Journal Number: 10201 Judge(s):? Per Curiam ) Hood, Doctoroff, and Kelly Defendant,s motion for a new trial was properly denied because complainant, s affidavit recanting her testimony was unreliable. The record relating to the circumstances immediately preceding complainant,s recantation supported the trial court,s finding that defendant engaged in inappropriate and harassing behavior toward complainant, which indicated that defendant coerced the complainant,s recanting testimony. The record indicated that defendant contacted the complainant four times by telephone, followed her in her vehicle, confronted her in the presence of her children, and drove by her home. The complainant testified that she was afraid, that she agreed to recant her trial testimony because she wanted no further contact with defendant, and wanted him to stop harassing her. Defendant,s conviction of assault with a dangerous weapon was affirmed. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks Issues: Whether defendant revoked his waiver of rights and unambiguously requested an attorney; Sufficiency of evidence to support convictions of second-degree murder and felony-firearm; Whether defendant had a constitutional right to present witnesses at the preliminary examination Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name: People v. Harris e-Journal Number: 10202 Judge(s): Per Curiam - Gage, Cavanagh, and Wilder Since conduct and silence do not constitute an assertion of the right to remain silent, the trial court did not err by admitting defendant's statements made after he placed his hand over a question on the police officer's statement form and told the officer, "don't write that". After being informed of his Miranda rights before questioning began, defendant chose to voluntarily answer questions. Defendant answered the first nine questions, however after initially answering the next question, he put his hand over the question on the form and asked the officer not to write down his response because it was untruthful. Defendant did not answer two more questions he was asked, then informed the officer he would not answer any more questions, and wanted an attorney. Defendant claimed that his act of placing his hand over the statement form and telling the officer not to write down his response constituted an assertion of the Fifth Amendment right to remain silent and revoked his previous waiver of that right. The court disagreed because it was not until after the officer asked two subsequent questions, that defendant verbally and unambiguously invoked his right to an attorney. Affirmed. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks Issues: Sufficiency of evidence to convict of first-degree felony murder and felony-firearm; Failure to instruct on lesser included offenses; Distinction between lesser included offense and a cognate lesser included offense; Prosecutorial misconduct; Jury instructions on stricken testimony; Ineffective assistance of counsel Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name: People v. Williams e-Journal Number: 10193 Judge(s): Per Curiam - Kelly, Smolenski, and Meter Even in the absence of direct evidence identifying defendant as the perpetrator, the circumstantial evidence and reasonable inferences from it were sufficient for the jury to conclude that defendant knew the victim's daily routine of leaving for work about 5:00 a.m., knew of the victim's habit of carrying large sums of money, and thus shot and ultimately killed the victim while attempting to rob him. At 5:03 a.m., the victim's widow heard a gunshot, discovered her husband outside with a gunshot in the neck, and that his wallet was missing. A neighbor saw defendant leave her house, where he lived, just before the shooting. Another neighbor saw defendant walking very fast down the street right after the shooting. A gunshot residue test performed about three hours after the shooting revealed that defendant had residue on his hands and that the residue came from a gun being fired. Affirmed. Full Text Opinion Employment & Labor Law Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Family Law Issues:? Whether certain categories of payments made by defendant to its employees constituted &earnings8 within the meaning of the Federal Consumer Credit Protection Act (CCPA); Support and Parenting Time Enforcement Act (SPTEA) Court:? Michigan Supreme Court Case Name:? Genesee County Friend of the Court v. General Motors Corp. e-Journal Number: 10241 Judge(s):? Per Curiam ) Corrigan, Cavanagh, Weaver, Kelly, Taylor, Young, Jr., and Markman The court held that all categories of payments (profit-sharing, recognition awards, and signing bonuses) made by defendant to its employees constituted &earnings8 within the meaning of CCPA and are subject to a limitation on the amount that may be captured by income withholding orders under SPTEA. The lower courts held that profit-sharing payments and recognition awards were not earnings, but that signing bonus payments were. After receiving the income withholding orders, defendant paid to the Friend of the Court 50% of the disposable earnings because it believed that the category of payments at issue were subject to the federal percentage limits on garnishment. The judgments of the Court of Appeals and the circuit court were reversed in part, and remanded. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Civil Rights Issues:? Whether an alleged adverse employment action against an employee on the basis of her former intimate relationship with her supervisor presented a cognizable claim of sex discrimination under the CRA; Quid pro quo sexual harassment; Hostile work environment; Respondeat superior; Sex discrimination; Breach of contract; Intentional infliction of emotional distress Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Published) Case Name:? Corley v. Detroit Bd. of Educ. e-Journal Number: 10218 Judge(s):? Neff, Holbrook, Jr., and Jansen In an issue of first impression regarding whether alleged adverse employment action against an employee on the basis of her former intimate relationship with her supervisor presents a cognizable claim of sex discrimination under the CRA, the court held that it does. Therefore, summary disposition of plaintiff,s sexual harassment claim in favor of defendants was improper. Plaintiff alleged that she was subjected to a hostile work environment, sexual harassment, disparate treatment, and unlawful termination because of her sex and her prior relationship with defendant-Smith. Plaintiff established sufficient facts to survive a motion for summary disposition under either quid pro quo sexual harassment or hostile work environment. Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Civil Rights Issues: Alleged discrimination based on race and marital status; The CRA statute of limitations; Wrongful discharge; Failure to timely initiate an appeal of an administrative agency's final decision to the circuit court; Constitutional issues not within the agency's jurisdiction may be raised in the circuit court through the Administrative Procedures Act (APA) review procedure Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Published) Case Name: Womack-Scott v. Department of Corrections e-Journal Number: 10219 Judge(s): Per Curiam - Doctoroff, Hoekstra, and Markey Since the plaintiff-former employee failed to bring her CRA claims within three years of the date of her initial discharge for violation of one of defendant's work rules, the trial court properly granted summary disposition to defendant. Plaintiff argued that the trial court used the wrong date when calculating the limitation period and should have used the last day she was employed by defendant. Although plaintiff was technically reinstated for a period of time as a result of administrative decisions and again discharged, the court disagreed that the second and final discharge should apply for purposes of calculating the limitations period. Accordingly, plaintiff's race and marital status discrimination claims accrued on the date of her initial discharge that was for allegedly discriminatory reasons. Plaintiff's wrongful discharge claim was also properly dismissed by the trial court because plaintiff failed to appeal the final administrative decision to the circuit court within the 60-day time limitation provided by the APA. Affirmed. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Civil Rights Issues:? Age, gender, and race discrimination; Retaliation Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? Jones v. Wayne State Univ. e-Journal Number: 10195 Judge(s): Per Curiam ) Bandstra, Zahra, and Meter Plaintiff,s claims of age, gender, and race discrimination were properly dismissed. Plaintiff, a 55-year old African-American female, alleged that her reassignment was motivated by defendant-employer,s administrators, desire to assemble a young, Caucasian male staff. Plaintiff alleged that a statement by defendant,s manager was direct evidence defendant discriminated against her based on age. However, at most, plaintiff,s testimony established that defendant,s manager observed that the department was made up of young, inexperienced employees. Further, plaintiff,s subjective impressions of her reassignment as a dead-end job were insufficient to establish a prima facie case of discrimination. Plaintiff,s discriminatory replacement arguments based on gender and race failed because she was not replaced by a nonmember of the protected class. Summary disposition in favor of the defendant was affirmed. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Litigation Issues: Whether the trial court erred in affirming the arbitration award because the arbitrators? exceeded their authority; Whether defendants breached the employment agreement (EA); Interpretation of the EA and related documents; Whether the trial court erred in refusing to award statutory interest from the date of the arbitration award; Whether plaintiffs were entitled to 12% interest because the arbitration award was rendered on a written instrument; Economic development commission (EDC) Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name: Young v. Sault Ste. Marie Tribe of Chippewa Indians e-Journal Number: 10190 Judge(s): Per Curiam - Collins, Jansen, and White The arbitrators did not exceed their authority when they issued the arbitration award against the defendant-tribe EDC for breach of plaintiff's EA, therefore the trial court did not err in confirming the award. Defendants argued that the joint venture master agreement, which was signed by the tribe EDC, contained an arbitration provision and a waiver of sovereign immunity, but contended that the arbitrators did not have authority to decide whether the tribe EDC breached the EA because the tribe EDC did not sign the EA and was not a party to it. The court concluded that when the various documents, which referred to each other, were read together the parties intended that the documents be construed as one agreement. Accordingly, a breach of the EA constituted a breach of the joint venture master agreement, the claim was subject to arbitration, and the tribe EDC could be held liable for the breach. Affirmed, but remanded for modification of the judgment to include post-arbitration award interest at 12%. Full Text Opinion Family Law Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Employment & Labor Law Issues:? Whether certain categories of payments made by defendant to its employees constituted &earnings8 within the meaning of the Federal Consumer Credit Protection Act (CCPA); Support and Parenting Time Enforcement Act (SPTEA) Court:? Michigan Supreme Court Case Name:? Genesee County Friend of the Court v. General Motors Corp. e-Journal Number: 10241 Judge(s):? Per Curiam ) Corrigan, Cavanagh, Weaver, Kelly, Taylor, Young, Jr., and Markman The court held that all categories of payments (profit-sharing, recognition awards, and signing bonuses) made by defendant to its employees constituted &earnings8 within the meaning of CCPA and are subject to a limitation on the amount that may be captured by income withholding orders under SPTEA. The lower courts held that profit-sharing payments and recognition awards were not earnings, but that signing bonus payments were. After receiving the income withholding orders, defendant paid to the Friend of the Court 50% of the disposable earnings because it believed that the category of payments at issue were subject to the federal percentage limits on garnishment. The judgments of the Court of Appeals and the circuit court were reversed in part, and remanded. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks Issues:? Divorce; Judicial review of property division award rendered pursuant to binding arbitration; Alimony in gross as property division; Arbitration award providing that if sum certain awarded to spouse is not paid it shall be considered spousal support and nondischargeable in bankruptcy; Arbitrator,s factual findings; Whether arbitrator violated Michigan law Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Published) Case Name:? Krist v. Krist e-Journal Number:? 10220 Judge(s):? Per Curiam ) Hood, Doctoroff, and Kelly Defendant-spouse did not satisfy the exacting &manifest disregard of the law8 standard required for judicial intervention in a property division award issued after binding arbitration and incorporated into the parties, divorce judgment. Defendant argued that the arbitration decision contained an award of spousal support in contravention of the settlement agreement. The offending paragraph in the award actually provided for a lump sum payment, or alimony in gross, which was in the nature of the division of property and was completely consistent with the parties, binding arbitration and settlement agreement. The court also found no error with the arbitrator, s provision that if the sum certain awarded to plaintiff was not paid, that amount would be considered spousal support and nondischargeable in bankruptcy. The language employed in the award was a mechanism to frustrate any attempt by defendant to circumvent the property division by filing for bankruptcy and discharging the obligation owed to plaintiff. Affirmed. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks Issues:? Divorce; Marital assets; Whether the trial court invaded defendant's separate property; Pre-marital agreement; Spousal support; Whether plaintiff's first husband should share in the burden of the spousal support award Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? Cowen v. Cowen e-Journal Number: 10204 Judge(s):? Per Curiam ) Wilder, Cavanagh, Hood The trial court properly held that the parties, home and Florida condominium were part of the marital estate. It was undisputed that both the home and condominium were purchased after the parties married. Defendant testified that plaintiff was a joint owner of the marital home and that he intended the condominium to be owed jointly between them, which showed that defendant intended that plaintiff be the joint owner of the properties. By adding plaintiff,s name to each deed of title, defendant willingly included both properties in the marital estate, therefore whether plaintiff helped acquire, improve, or accumulate the property was irrelevant. Affirmed. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks Issues: Termination of parental rights; Alleged denial of right to jury trial Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name: In re Curry e-Journal Number: 10212 Judge(s): Memorandum - McDonald, Smolenski, and Kelly Since the respondent-father had notice of the proceedings but chose to remain uninvolved until after the adjudication, and waited until the termination hearing to request a jury, the trial court did not err in denying his request for a jury trial. The trial court's order terminating respondent's parental rights was affirmed. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks Issues: Termination of parental rights; Whether release of parental rights should be revoked; Failure to petition the family court to revoke release Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name: In re Kelly e-Journal Number: 10211 Judge(s): Memorandum - McDonald, Smolenski, and Kelly Since the respondent-mother failed to petition the family court to revoke her release of parental rights, the issue was not properly before the court. The court affirmed the family court's order terminating respondent's parental rights to one of the children following her voluntary release of parental rights pursuant to MCL 710.29. Full Text Opinion Litigation Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Negligence & Intentional Tort Issues:? Alleged negligence by violating state and local law in providing alcohol to minors; Jury instruction regarding the impairment defense; Failure to strike plaintiff,s testimony regarding her percentage of fault; Failing to cure the violation of plaintiff,s substantial rights when defense counsel improperly referred to a fee agreement and improperly elicited testimony from police officers that had been excluded Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Published) Case Name:? Piccalo v. Nix e-Journal Number: 10215 Judge(s):? Hood and McDonald; Dissent ) Zahra The trial court erred in instructing the jury regarding the impairment defense because it would be absurd to allow the defense of impairment to an individual who caused or created the impairment of the injured person. Due to the cumulative effect of errors regarding the trial court,s rulings there was cumulative prejudice. Plaintiff, a passenger in a van where there were only two seats, laid or sat in the back of the van and was injured by tires inside the van, when the driver, an underage drinker, who was served alcohol at defendant,s home, failed to manipulate a slight curve in the gravel road and drove the van into a tree. The case was reversed and remanded for a new trial. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Employment & Labor Law Issues: Whether the trial court erred in affirming the arbitration award because the arbitrators? exceeded their authority; Whether defendants breached the employment agreement (EA); Interpretation of the EA and related documents; Whether the trial court erred in refusing to award statutory interest from the date of the arbitration award; Whether plaintiffs were entitled to 12% interest because the arbitration award was rendered on a written instrument; Economic development commission (EDC) Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name: Young v. Sault Ste. Marie Tribe of Chippewa Indians e-Journal Number: 10190 Judge(s): Per Curiam - Collins, Jansen, and White The arbitrators did not exceed their authority when they issued the arbitration award against the defendant-tribe EDC for breach of plaintiff's EA, therefore the trial court did not err in confirming the award. Defendants argued that the joint venture master agreement, which was signed by the tribe EDC, contained an arbitration provision and a waiver of sovereign immunity, but contended that the arbitrators did not have authority to decide whether the tribe EDC breached the EA because the tribe EDC did not sign the EA and was not a party to it. The court concluded that when the various documents, which referred to each other, were read together the parties intended that the documents be construed as one agreement. Accordingly, a breach of the EA constituted a breach of the joint venture master agreement, the claim was subject to arbitration, and the tribe EDC could be held liable for the breach. Affirmed, but remanded for modification of the judgment to include post-arbitration award interest at 12%. Full Text Opinion Municipal Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Real Property Issues: Circuit court order compelling city to approve site plan for a fast food restaurant; Writ of mandamus; Superintending control; Decision involving discretionary authority; Decision based on competent, material, and substantial evidence; Insufficient stacking spaces to support drive-through windows; Traffic study report; Absence of clear right to legal performance Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? Kanakry v. City of St. Clair Shores e-Journal Number:? 10194 Judge(s):? Per Curiam ) Hood, Doctoroff, and Kelly The court could not uphold the trial court,s order compelling defendants to approve plaintiffs-property owners, site plan for a McDonald,s restaurant because the decision to deny approval of the plan involved discretionary authority and was supported by competent, material, and substantial evidence. The trial court erred by issuing a writ of mandamus instead of an order for superintending control, but this was not the basis for reversal. Plaintiffs, site plan only provided for 9 stacking spaces, but 14 were required for plaintiffs to have two drive-through windows. This nonconformance with the zoning ordinance alone was sufficient for defendants to deny the site plan. Defendants also found that the deficient number of stacking spaces would create a traffic hazard and cause an unduly harmful impact on the city as a whole. Reversed and remanded. Full Text Opinion Negligence & Intentional Tort Back to Quicklinks Issues:? Premises liability; Whether the volunteer doctrine barred plaintiff, s premises liability action Court:? Michigan Supreme Court Case Name:? James v. Albert e-Journal Number: 10239 Judge(s):? Taylor, Corrigan, Cavanagh, Weaver, Kelly, Young, Jr., and Markman The court abolished the volunteer doctrine and agreed, but for different reasons, with the Court of Appeals that this doctrine did not bar plaintiff, s claim, and affirmed reversal of the trial court,s grant of summary disposition for defendant. The court returned this area of the law to traditional agency and tort principles, because it believed that they will better resolve the matters to which the doctrine might have applied. Plaintiff incurred injuries while assisting defendant in digging a trench on defendant,s property. The parties disagreed about whether defendant invited plaintiff to assist him in digging the trench. Affirmed, and remanded. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Litigation Issues:? Alleged negligence by violating state and local law in providing alcohol to minors; Jury instruction regarding the impairment defense; Failure to strike plaintiff,s testimony regarding her percentage of fault; Failing to cure the violation of plaintiff,s substantial rights when defense counsel improperly referred to a fee agreement and improperly elicited testimony from police officers that had been excluded Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Published) Case Name:? Piccalo v. Nix e-Journal Number: 10215 Judge(s):? Hood and McDonald; Dissent ) Zahra The trial court erred in instructing the jury regarding the impairment defense because it would be absurd to allow the defense of impairment to an individual who caused or created the impairment of the injured person. Due to the cumulative effect of errors regarding the trial court,s rulings there was cumulative prejudice. Plaintiff, a passenger in a van where there were only two seats, laid or sat in the back of the van and was injured by tires inside the van, when the driver, an underage drinker, who was served alcohol at defendant,s home, failed to manipulate a slight curve in the gravel road and drove the van into a tree. The case was reversed and remanded for a new trial. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks Issues:? Premises liability; Whether plaintiff,s premises liability action was preempted by the dramshop act; Instructing jury with both SJI2d 19.03 and SJI2d 19.05; Additur; Application of collateral source rule; Offset for payment by a codefendant insurer Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? Mann v. Shusteric Enters., Inc. e-Journal Number:? 10188 Judge(s):? Per Curiam ) Kelly, White, and Wilder Plaintiff,s premises liability action against defendant for injuries sustained in a slip and fall in the parking lot of defendant,s bar was not preempted by the dramshop act. Defendant,s service of alcohol was only implicated as it related to defendant,s knowledge of plaintiff,s condition and whether defendant,s conduct in failing to inspect or clear the parking lot and failing to warn plaintiff was reasonable. The trial court did not err in instructing the jury with both the general duty to business invitee instruction and the duty regarding natural accumulation of ice and snow instruction, because the instructions are not inconsistent. The jury,s verdict, denying all noneconomic damages, was inadequate because the jury ignored an entire category of damages for which plaintiff produced uncontroverted evidence. The trial court abused its discretion in denying plaintiff,s motion for additur. Affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Construction Law Issues:? Retained control over the construction project; Immunity under the exclusive remedy provision of the WDCA; Reliance on the Supreme Court,s plurality opinion in Bitar v.Wakim; Expert,s testimony on the vibration from a bulldozer theory; Duty to warn Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? Piraine v. BDP Dev. e-Journal Number: 10192 Judge(s):? Per Curiam- Griffin, Holbrook, Jr., and Murphy The court corrected a clerical error and ordered that the final paragraph of the earlier opinion (see e-Journal # 10080 in the 5/3/01 edition) be stricken and replaced with the following language: &The lower court,s orders denying summary disposition are affirmed and the matter is remanded for further proceedings consistent with this opinion. We do not retain jurisdiction.8 The opinion remained the same in all other respects. The earlier release date was vacated. Full Text Opinion Real Property Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Constitutional Law Issues: The constitutionality of the Opening of Private Roads and Temporary Highways Act (the Private Roads Act (MCL 229.1 et seq.)); Whether the act authorizes a taking primarily benefiting a private rather than a public purpose; Overruling Bieker v. Suttons Bay Twp. Supervisor and McKeighan v. Grass Lake Twp. Supervisor II Court: Michigan Supreme Court Case Name: Tolksdorf v. Griffith e-Journal Number: 10240 Judge(s): Kelly, Corrigan, Cavanagh, Weaver, Taylor, Young, Jr.; Not participating - Markman The court struck down the Private Roads Act (allowing a private landowner to petition a township supervisor to open a private road across another landowner's property) as providing for an unconstitutional taking under art. 10, o 2 of the Michigan Constitution of 1963, because it authorizes a taking that primarily benefits a private rather than a public purpose. Plaintiffs owned landlocked property and defendants owned a neighboring parcel. Defendants refused plaintiffs' requests seeking a paved road across their parcel and an easement for utility lines. Plaintiffs sued requesting a writ of mandamus compelling the township supervisor to proceed under the act. The trial court ruled against plaintiffs and the Court of Appeals found error in the refusal to issue the writ. The court concluded that since the act gives individuals a permanent and continuous right to pass over another's property, it allowed a permanent physical occupation of private property by means of government action, and was a taking. The taking authorized by the act appeared to merely be an attempt by a private entity to use the state's powers to acquire what it could not get through arms' length negotiations with defendants, and the primary benefit inured to the landlocked private owners, rather than the public. Reversed and the trial court's ruling for defendants was reinstated. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks Issues: Whether plaintiff's prior recorded judgment lien had priority over defendants' subsequent mortgage interest Court: Michigan Court of Appeals (Published) Case Name: Graves v. American Acceptance Mortgage Corp. e-Journal Number: 10216 Judge(s): Gage, Sawyer, and Jansen Since the subsequent mortgage constituted a purchase money mortgage, which takes priority over earlier creditors' interests even though the earlier interest was duly recorded, the trial court erred in concluding that plaintiff's earlier recorded judgment lien had priority over defendants' mortgage interest. The divorce judgment granted plaintiff a lien on the property to the extent of Diaz' (her ex-husband) then existing equitable title interest in the property as the land contract vendee. The mortgage Diaz granted American Acceptance constituted a purchase money mortgage because Diaz, who had defaulted on the land contract payments, utilized the mortgage proceeds to obtain legal title to the property by paying off the land contract vendors. Accordingly, notwithstanding that plaintiff filed her judgment lien before the execution of the Diaz mortgage, the purchase money mortgage by which Diaz secured legal title to the property, had priority over plaintiff's judgment lien which arose against Diaz prior to his acquisition of title to the real estate. The trial court failed to accord defendants' purchase money mortgage interest the priority to which it was entitled by law. Reversed and remanded. Full Text Opinion Back to Quicklinks This summary also appears under Municipal Issues: Circuit court order compelling city to approve site plan for a fast food restaurant; Writ of mandamus; Superintending control; Decision involving discretionary authority; Decision based on competent, material, and substantial evidence; Insufficient stacking spaces to support drive-through windows; Traffic study report; Absence of clear right to legal performance Court:? Michigan Court of Appeals (Unpublished) Case Name:? Kanakry v. City of St. Clair Shores e-Journal Number:? 10194 Judge(s):? Per Curiam ) Hood, Doctoroff, and Kelly The court could not uphold the trial court,s order compelling defendants to approve plaintiffs-property owners, site plan for a McDonald,s restaurant because the decision to deny approval of the plan involved discretionary authority and was supported by competent, material, and substantial evidence. The trial court erred by issuing a writ of mandamus instead of an order for superintending control, but this was not the basis for reversal. Plaintiffs, site plan only provided for 9 stacking spaces, but 14 were required for plaintiffs to have two drive-through windows. This nonconformance with the zoning ordinance alone was sufficient for defendants to deny the site plan. Defendants also found that the deficient number of stacking spaces would create a traffic hazard and cause an unduly harmful impact on the city as a whole. Reversed and remanded. Full Text Opinion fields of practice listings ADR/Arbitration/Mediation ASHER N. TILCHIN, a member of the American College of Civil Trial Mediators and Michigan Arbitration and Mediation Association provides mediation for pre, early, and matured lawsuits. He has been a successful mediator since 1991. Tilchin also provides arbitration services as a single or multi-panel arbitrator. Cases involving construction, real estate, commercial transactions, and legal malpractice invited. Asher N. Tilchin, 31731 Northwestern Hwy., Suite 106, Farmington Hills, MI 48334, (248)855-0995 or Fax (248) 855-0850, e-mail antilchin@aol.com Back to Quicklinks Administrative Law JAMES R. VIVENTI, James R Viventi PLLC, 3670 Powderhorn Drive, Okemos, MI 48864-5924, Phone: (517) 381-0670, FAX: (517) 381-0671. Back to Quicklinks Adoption MONICA FARRIS LINKNER, Sommers, Schwartz, Silver & Schwartz, PC, 2000 Town Center, Suite 900, Southfield, MI 48075-1100, Phone: (248) 746-4011, FAX: (248) 936-1976, e-mail: mlinkner@s4online.com. Back to Quicklinks Alternative Dispute Resolution DONNA CRAIG, Donna Craig & Associates PLC, 999 Haynes Street, Suite 245, Birmingham, MI 48009, Phone: (248) 682-7750, FAX: (248) 682-2376, e-mail: craigassoc@earthlink.net. Visit www.adr-resource.com Back to Quicklinks Antitrust/Advertising/Trade Regulation DAVID G. CHARDAVOYNE specializes in the regulation of business competition, including: antitrust law, unfair competition, and the regulation of advertising, labeling, and other trade practices. Former Chairperson of State Bar antitrust and trade regulation section, more than 15 years' experience in this field. Will consult regarding antitrust issues (monopolies, mergers, price fixing, exclusive dealing, tying arrangements, price discrimination, dealer termination, market allocation); premerger notice filings under Hart-Scott-Rodino Act; discussions with State and Federal regulatory agencies (FTC, Justice Department, Attorney General); compliance with laws regulating advertising (substantiation of claims, product labels, consumer price displays); and all other matters relating to business competition. David G. Chardavoyne, 26755 La Muera Ave., Farmington Hills, MI 48334-4613, (248) 477-6308, e-mail chardavoyne@aol.com Back to Quicklinks Appeals LAURIE S. LONGO, 214 South Main, Suite 210, Ann Arbor, MI 48104-2122, Phone: (734) 913-5619, e-mail: 42203@msn.com. Visit http://michiganappeals.com. Back to Quicklinks Appellate Law SAFFORD & BAKER, PLLC, 40900 Woodward Avenue, Suite 110, Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304, Phone: (248) 646-9100, FAX: (248) 646-9102. Visit www.saffordbaker.com Back to Quicklinks Automobile Warranty Law LIBLANG & ASSOCIATES: Specializing in "Lemon Law", UCC, Magnuson-Moss, Odometer Fraud and Consumer Protection Act. Available for trials, consultations or referrals. Cases accepted statewide. Over 17 years and 5,000 cases. Michigan's most experienced lemon law attorneys, Dani K. Liblang and Scott J. Sinkwitts. Please call (248) 540-9270 or e-mail NoLemons@aol.com Back to Quicklinks Business & Taxation LAW OFFICES OF RALPH W. PEZDA. Oakland County practitioner with an LL.M. degree in taxation from New York University will assist your clients or firm with taxation, business, interdisciplinary, and white collar criminal matters. Referrals paid. 27700 Northwestern Hwy., Suite 411, Southfield, MI 48034. (248) 352-5632. E-mail address: rwp@cdlcorp.com Back to Quicklinks Construction Law JOHN V. TOCCO, attorney, construction engineer, and civil engineering professor, with over twenty years experience in the construction industry, provides mediation and arbitration services for all construction matters. Also provides litigation support and claims analysis. Cases accepted statewide. Call (313) 406-2040 for CV, or review Profile at www.johntocco.com E-mail john@johntocco.com Back to Quicklinks Copyrights CAROL R. SHEPHERD, Arborlaw Associates, PLLC, 320 S Main St, PO Box 8403, Ann Arbor, MI 48107-8403, Phone: (734) 668-4646, FAX: (734) 822-4646, e-mail: shepherd@arborlaw.com. Back to Quicklinks Criminal Law F. RANDALL KARFONTA, Attorney @ Law, 113 North Main, PO Box 565, Leland, MI 49654, Phone: (231) 256-2200. Visit http://www.leelanau.com or http://www.leelanau.com/professional/karfonta. Back to Quicklinks RAYMOND A. CASSAR, Law Offices of Raymond A. Cassar, 30665 Northwestern Hwy, Suite 100, Farmington Hills, MI 48334, Phone: (248) 855-0911, FAX: (248) 855-9523, e-mail: rcassar@aol.com. Additional offices located in Oakland County (248) 855-0911, and Wayne County (313) 278-8811. Visit www.crimlawattorney.com. Back to Quicklinks TALPOS & ARNOLD PC, 2855 Coolidge Road, Suite 109, Troy, MI 48084-3215, Phone: (248) 643-4515, FAX: (248) 643-4797, e-mail: jctalpos@aol.com. Visit www.Mich-Lawyer.com. Back to Quicklinks Environmental Law DEAN & FULKERSON, PC, Richard A. Barr, rbarr@dflaw.com or James K. O'Brien, jobrien@dflaw.com, 801 W Big Beaver, Suite 500, Troy, MI 48084-4767, Phone: (248) 362-1300, FAX: (248) 362-1358. Back to Quicklinks Family Law JOHN G. MAKRIS, 802 E Big Beaver Rd, Troy, MI 48083-1404, Phone: (248) 528-1811, FAX: (248) 524-0973, e-mail: jgmakris@altavista.com. Back to Quicklinks Federal False Claims (Qui Tam) Actions HaronDAVID HARON represents whistleblowers in civil false claims actions and works with referring attorneys nationwide who specialize in employment law and other fields. Under the federal False Claims Act, private individuals with knowledge of fraud against federal programs can file suit on behalf of the United States and receive a substantial share of any recovery. Representing such claimants, Mr. Haron has recovered millions of dollars in Medicare and Medicaid funds that had been fraudulently obtained by health-care providers, primarily through abusive billing practices. To learn more, visit his qui tam web site at www.QuiTamOnline.com or contact him directly by e-mail at dharon@fsh-law.com or phone (248) 952-0400 at Frank, Stefani, Haron & Hall in Troy http://www.fsh-law.com/ Back to Quicklinks Health Law KENNETH R. MARCUS, representing provider organizations and professionals since 1984 in Blue Cross/Medicaid/Medicare Audit Defense, Payment Appeals, Stark Act Compliance, Managed Care Contracting, Physician Transactions, Corporate Law. I work collaboratively with general counsel. Phone 888.865.9955, fax: 248.865.9956, e-mail: krmarcus@aol.com. Visit www.lawyers.com/kenmarcus. Back to Quicklinks Hospital & Medical Negligence THE LAW OFFICES OF JOHN S. HONE, P.C., representing victims of hospital and medical negligence resulting in serious injury, permanent cognitive and physical disability and wrongful death. Millions won, available for consultation and referral, cases accepted statewide. Phone Hone: (248) 888-7585; Toll Free: 888-HMO-1010; Fax: (248) 473-8895; E-mail to mmhmolawsuit@aol.com Back to Quicklinks Immigration and Naturalization NAHIL PETER ANTONE, N. Peter Antone, PC, 16445 West Twelve Mile Road, Suite 100, Southfield, MI 48076, Phone: (248) 559-0707, FAX: (248) 559-0790, e-mail: Peter@Antone.com. Visit http://Antone.com. Back to Quicklinks ROGER R. RATHI, Attorney at Law, 29777 Telegraph Road, Suite 2500, Southfield, MI 48034, Phone: (248) 539-8421, FAX: (248) 353-2786, e-mail: rrathi@yahoo.com. Back to Quicklinks STEVEN N. GARMO, Law Offices of Garmo & Garmo, 28230 Orchard Lake Road, Suite 201, Farmington Hills, MI 48334, Phone: (248) 626-0050, FAX: (248) 626-0051, e-mail: steve@garmo.com. Visit: www.garmo.com. Back to Quicklinks Immigration Law MARSHAL E. HYMAN & ASSOCIATES. All aspects of immigration law including employment-based immigration for professionals and skilled workers. Labor certifications. Family-based immigration. Immigration from Canada. Political asylum, all waivers and appeals. Corporate transfers for multinational employees. Representation in Immigration courts and Federal courts since 1981. 3250 West Big Beaver, Suite 529, Troy, MI 48084. (248) 643-0642, Fax: (248) 643-0798. E-mail: marshalhyman@msu.com Back to Quicklinks Insurance Law STUART A. SKLAR, Fabian, Sklar & Davis, PC, 31800 Northwestern Hwy, Suite 205, Farmington Hills, MI 48334, Phone: (248) 855-2110, FAX: (248) 855-0209. Additional office located in West Michigan (616) 451-9900, e-mail: ssklar-firelaw@tir.com. Back to Quicklinks Intellectual Property Law GIFFORD, KRASS, GROH, SPRINKLE, ANDERSON & CITKOWSKI, P.C., 280 North Old Woodward, Suite 400, Birmingham, MI 48009-5392, Phone: (248) 647-6000, FAX: (248) 647-5210, e-mail: info@patlaw.com. Back to Quicklinks RADER, FISHMAN & GRAUER, PLLC, Bloomfield Hills (248) 594-0600; Grand Rapids (616) 742-3500; Washington, DC (202) 955-3750; Englewood, CO (303) 991-1200. Visit www.intelprop.com. Back to Quicklinks Labor & Employment THE LAW OFFICE of Gregory T. Gibbs is an AV rated firm with years of experience in employment law advice and litigation. We can answer questions about: handbooks, sexual harassment, wrongful discharge, discrimination, family medical leave, collective bargaining, wage-hour issues or any other employment related matter under state or federal law. We work with you and your clients under referral fee arrangements. 328 S. Saginaw St., Ste. 9001, Flint, MI 48502. (810) 239-9470, fax (810) 235-2468, e-mail: bakerlak@tir.com Back to Quicklinks DAVID D. KOHL, 39500 Orchard Hill Place, Suite 110, Novi, MI 48375, Phone: (248) 347-6666, FAX: (248) 348-8707, e-mail: daviddkohl@juno.com. Back to Quicklinks Litigation FINK, ZAUSMER & KAUFMAN, PC, 31700 Middlebelt Rd #150, Farmington Hills, MI 48334, Phone: (248) 851-4111, FAX: (248) 851-0100. Additional offices located in Detroit (313) 963-3873, and Lansing (517) 374-2735. Visit http://www.lawsite.com Back to Quicklinks STEPHEN K. VALENTINE, JR, Valentine & Associates, 5767 West Maple Road. Suite 400, West Bloomfield, MI 48322, Phone: (248) 851-3010, FAX: (248) 851-1553. Back to Quicklinks Medical Malpractice WANT A SECOND OPINION ON A MEDICAL MALPRACTICE CASE? The law offices of Anthony M. Malizia, P.C., is a statewide firm that handles only medical malpractice cases. I am Martindale-Hubbell "AV-rated." I sit as a plaintiff's medical malpractice mediator. I have 20 years experience in the review and development of these cases, many trials to jury verdict, and many more settlements. Over the years, upwards of 20% of my case inventory has consisted of meritorious cases initially rejected by others, including "name firms." Oftentimes these cases were subjected to incomplete analysis because of the firm's lack of in-depth, medico-legal background. Sometimes medical sleuthing or a new perspective was required. Send me your rejected case for a "de novo" review. We also welcome the referral of "new" cases. Anthony M. Malizia, P.C., 37000 Grand River, Suite 340, Farmington Hills, MI 48335, 1-800-555-5107 or e-mail: amlmalizia@aol.com Back to Quicklinks Real Estate BRAD B. ALDRICH, Law Offices of Brad B. Aldrich, PLLC, 645 Griswold, Suite 3261, Detroit, MI 48226, Phone: (313) 965-9490, FAX: (313) 965-9478, e-mail belmontald@aol.com. Back to Quicklinks Special Education Law LAW OFFICES OF MARSHA LYNN TUCK with 20 years experience, Martindale-Hubbell "AV-rated," representing students with and without disabilities in suspension, expulsion, integration, inclusion, and similar cases. Marsha Lynn Tuck, 30700 Telegraph Road, Suite 4646, Bingham Farms, MI 48025. (248) 585-9338. Back to Quicklinks Tax Litigation & Disputes JOSEPH FALCONE is available to assist attorneys with Federal and State Civil and Criminal Tax Litigation and Dispute matters. Joseph Falcone, a former IRS Detroit District Counsel Trial Attorney, has handled thousands of tax matters and has 27 years experience working in the specialized area of Tax Litigation and Disputes. If you require assistance with a major tax dispute, wish to refer a matter, or just need a few minutes consultation over the phone with your specific problem or question, telephone or e-mail us jf@lawyer.com. Visit our website at www.lawyers.com/falconerolfe. Falcone & Rolfe, P.C., 3000 Town Center, Suite 2370, Southfield, MI 48075. (248) 357 6610. Fax (248) 357-6613. Back to Quicklinks Transportation Law PAUL M. ROSS, P.C., 2840 East Grand River Avenue, Suite 1, East Lansing, MI 48823-4911, Phone: (517) 337-7677, FAX: (517) 332-9361, e-mail: pross1412@aol.com. Back to Quicklinks Worker's Compensation JOHN M. H ULRICH, IV, Crawforth Mcmanus Tenbrunsel & Ulrich, 999 Haynes Street, Suite 245, Birmingham, MI 48009-6702, Toll-free: (800) 424-4878, Phone: (248) 540-1270, FAX: (248) 540-3925. Back to Quicklinks To receive information on how to place a Fields of Practice listing, contact Stacy Sage or see Advertising Opportunities on our website. Back to Quicklinks classified advertising Confidential Records Destruction SHRED-IT. Confidentiality, Privacy and Document Security are vital in today's environment. SHRED-IT provides solutions for secure destruction of confidential, sensitive and proprietary information, utilizing a unique, mobile, ON-SITE document destruction system. Call 1-800-69-SHRED or 1-800-697-4733. E-mail Eastern Michigan; e-mail Out state Michigan or visit our website Back to Quicklinks Expert Witness-Building EXPERT WITNESS services for construction issues. Our cases include issues of faulty construction, failure to disclose, personal injury and ADA. Mr. Tyson is a member of many model code organizations including BOCA, ICBO, NFPA and ASTM. Our attorney clients represent plaintiffs and defendants. Rendering independent and unbiased opinions. Ortonville, MI. Phone (248) 627-6859. Back to Quicklinks RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION--ABR Construction Company, Inc. offering expertise in all phases of residential construction related to workmanship, cost, time, structural analysis, civil analysis, and other related problems. Contact Jack W. Belkin member BOCA, ASHI, Bldg. Spec. Inc. licensed builder and real estate broker. (248) 443-4063, cell (248) 867-5042 and fax (248) 443-4065, e-mail jwbelkin@mich.com Back to Quicklinks Expert Witness-Economics Consulting ECONOMIC LOSS CALCULATION and litigation support in personal injury, wrongful death and wrongful discharge cases. Over 25 years experience including Chief Economist for the Michigan Department of Commerce. John F. Hanieski, Ph.D., Economics Consulting Services, LLC, 8583 W. Eaton Hwy., Grand Ledge, MI 48837. (517) 627-6968. E-mail: hanieski.john@acd.net website: http://userdata.acd.net/hanieski.john Back to Quicklinks Expert Witness-Forensic & Environmental Geologist FORENSIC and ENVIRONMENTAL GEOLOGIST*Certified Professional Geologist; 29 years investigating soil and water issues for government and private sectors; deposition and trial experience applicable to cases involving insurance claims, construction accidents, environmental contamination, wetlands, property transactions, malpractice, murder, rape, etc. For more information, contact Robert A. Hayes, (517) 655-8348, or www.geoforensics.com Back to Quicklinks Expert Witness-Legal Malpractice LEGAL MALPRACTICE-EXPERT EVALUATION, pre- and post-litigation analysis, written opinions, deposition and trial testimony in plaintiff originated or defendant defended legal malpractice cases that involve Real Estate and Commercial Transactions and Civil Litigation. 18 years' experience as legal malpractice expert. Asher N. Tilchin, Tilchin, Hall & Reynolds P.C., 31731 Northwestern Hwy., Suite 106, Farmington Hills, MI 48334. (248) 855-0995, fax (248) 855-0850. E-mail antilchin@aol.com Back to Quicklinks Lawsuit Financials DO MONEY PROBLEMS caused by disability force some of your clients to settle strong, valuable cases for pennies on the dollar? A Lawsuit Financial, L.L.C. contingent advance allows you time to obtain the maximum dollar possible for your client's case. Lawsuit Financial, L.L.C., 29777 Telegraph Road, Suite 1310, Southfield, MI 48034. Call (248) 948-1800 or (877) 377-SUIT. Back to Quicklinks Legal Research OPEN online offers instant and cost effective access to public records. Select from many sources of criminal data, verify social security numbers, confirm driving records, find addresses, UCC and incorporation filings, real property records, bankruptcies, liens and judgments. For information call 800-935-OPEN (6736), email info@openonline.com, or visit www.openonline.com Back to Quicklinks Office Space Available SOUTHFIELD LAW OFFICE FOR RENT-Reception, conference, kitchen, photocopier, fax, file room; secretary to share. Central location near all major expressways for quick access for clientele and courts in the tri-county area. Attractive and professional. Call Sandra Maison at (248) 355-9400. Ddelong@thompsonmorello.com Back to Quicklinks Positions Available DAWDA, MANN, MULCAHY & SADLER a full-service Bloomfield Hills firm, with 25 attorneys and a national client base, is seeking a real estate/corporate transactional attorney. Qualified candidates must have 3-5 years experience with strong academic credentials. Send resume and references to Director of Administration, 39533 Woodward Avenue, Suite 200, Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304. Back to Quicklinks DAWDA, MANN, MULCAHY & SADLER a full-service Bloomfield Hills firm, with 25 attorneys and a national client base, is seeking a real estate/corporate transactional paralegal. Qualified candidates must have 3-5 years experience with strong academic credentials. Send resume and references to Director of Administration, 39533 Woodward Avenue, Suite 200, Bloomfield Hills, MI 48304. Back to Quicklinks ESTABLISHED MID-SIZED AV Rated Bloomfield Hills litigation firm representing businesses and insurance companies, seeks attorney with 0-3 years experience. Litigation experience helpful. Please direct resumes to Linda Pillsworth via e-mail: lpillsworth@kallashenk.com or, Facsimile: (248) 335-9889, or via regular mail: 43902 Woodward Avenue, Suite 200, Bloomfield Hills, MI 48302. NO TELEPHONE CALLS PLEASE. Back to Quicklinks EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR-The Grand Rapids Bar Association is soliciting applications for the position of Executive Director. The GRBA is a voluntary local bar with 1,500 members, a full-time staff of 7, one-half-time position and 8 part-time volunteers. The Executive Director is the chief operating officer. The GRBA includes a Lawyer Referral Service, which will become the centerpiece for a new Legal Assistance Center in September 2001. The GRBA has a combined operating budget of $850,000. The Executive Director also oversees, with a committee and the board, the Grand Rapids Bar Foundation with assets of $1 million. The Executive Director is responsible to a seventeen member Board in accord with policies and procedures adopted by the Board. The successful candidate will be a seasoned executive with a demonstrated record of achieving positive results, including experience in the area of fund development. The Executive Director will exhibit a high level of integrity with superior management, organizational, budgeting, personnel, and interpersonal communication skills. The GRBA offers a competitive salary and benefits package. Applicants are encouraged to submit a letter of interest, current resume, references, and salary requirements to Executive Director Search Committee, c/o Sherrie Parmelee, Smith, Haughey, Rice & Roegge, Calder Plaza Bldg., 250 Monroe NW, Grand Rapids, MI 49503, (616) 458-2385, sparmlee@shrr.com The Grand Rapids Bar Association is an Equal Opportunity Employer. Back to Quicklinks IMMEDIATE OPENING--Lague, Newman & Irish is seeking an associate with 1 - 2 years experience. Candidates must have strong academic credentials and excellent writing abilities. Send cover letter, resume, and transcripts to Eric Gielow, Lague, Newman & Irish, P.O. Box 389, Muskegon, MI 49443 (or ergielow@lnilaw.com). Back to Quicklinks INSURANCE CLAIMS attorney needed for growing company in pleasant, small town environment. 3-5 years experience in claims and/or litigation supervision with a property/casualty insurance company or insurance defense firm mandatory. Member of the State Bar of Michigan required. Send resume to jhutchins@hastingsmutual.com or mail to Hastings Mutual Insurance Co., Attn: Human Resources, 404 E. Woodlawn Avenue, Hastings, MI 49058. Back to Quicklinks MICHIGAN MIGRANT LEGAL ASSISTANCE PROJECT, INC., an established migrant legal services program, seeks an Executive Director. Ideal candidate has five years experience in farmworker law, and some administrative experience. MMLAP is a statewide program that brings high impact cases in state and federal courts. Candidate must be, or promptly become, licensed to practice in Michigan, and must be bi-lingual (English/Spanish). Salary $65,000-DOE, excellent benefits. Applications accepted through June 15, 2001. MMLAP is an EOE. Send resume to: Richard Kessler, Search Committee, c/o MMLAP, 648 Monroe, N.W., Suite 318, Grand Rapids, MI 49504. Back to Quicklinks PART-TIME LAWYER FOR HARLEY-DAVIDSON MICHIGAN, INC.*Lawyer needed (15 - 20 hrs/wk) at busy domestic and international Fortune 500 corporate trademark law practice in Ann Arbor, Michigan. Strong analytical and writing skills and excellent attention to detail are required. This is a year-round position. Please do not apply unless you have an interest in practicing trademark law. No telephone calls, please. Send your resume to: Ann Jackson, Harley-Davidson Michigan, Inc., 315 W. Huron Street, Suite 400, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48103. Back to Quicklinks RESPONSIBILITES of this person are to provide advice to various departments. Draft, review and negotiate agreements, debt instruments, and guaranties for domestic and international business units. Review all advertising for compliance with FTC regulations, trademark usage and adherence to corporate policies. Defend employment related legal actions and review and advise on hiring practices and procedures. Minimum qualifications are seven years experience from a law firm and/or a major corporation with relevant practice experience. Plus strong background with employment law. J.D. from a accredited law school, admitted to practice law in Michigan or other U.S. jurisdiction. Please send resume to Ashleys@dominos.com or fax to 734-930-4350. Salary is 110K.Legal Department, Domino's Pizza, 30 Frank Lloyd Wright Drive, Ann Arbor, MI 48106. Back to Quicklinks UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN*The Office of the Vice President and General Counsel of the University of Michigan is seeking exceptionally qualified applicants for an attorney who will provide advice and counsel on health law matters in the areas of managed care, reimbursement, research and privacy/security. The position requires experience in the above-noted areas. Candidates with strong business acumen-gained through in-house experience or by working closely with business clients-will be preferred. Minimum qualifications include excellent academic credentials, a law degree from an accredited law school, membership in the Michigan bar or eligibility for admission based on reciprocity, and at least 5 years of relevant experience. The salary will be commensurate with the selected candidate's experience and employment in the public section. Applications will be accepted until the position if filled, but applications should be submitted promptly to ensure full consideration. To apply, please send a cover letter and resume to: Office of the Vice President and General Counsel, Attention: HEALTH, 4010 Fleming Administration Building, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1340. The University of Michigan is an equal opportunity, affirmative action employer. Back to Quicklinks UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN--The Office of the Vice President and General Counsel of the University of Michigan is seeking exceptionally qualified applicants for an attorney who will take primary responsibility for coordinating the University's litigation in the medical malpractice area. The successful candidate will engage and supervise outside counsel in medical malpractice and will provide advice and representation in other areas of health care law. This position will work closely with the senior leadership of the University Health System, including the Chief of Staff for Clinical Affairs and the Director of the Medical Center Risk Management Office, other attorneys in the Office of the Vice President and General Counsel, and with individual members of the medical staff. The successful candidate will draft and review policies; serve on University committees; conduct educational programs on legal topics for the University community, and carry out other duties as assigned. Experience providing legal services for a university affiliated, or similar, health care system is desired. A law degree from an NALS accredited law school, membership or eligibility for membership in the State Bar of Michigan, at least five years litigation experience with an emphasis on medical malpractice, reasonable experience in health care law are required. Applications will be accepted until the position is filled, but applications should be submitted promptly to ensure full consideration. To apply, please send a cover letter and resume to: Office of the Vice President and General Counsel, Attention: MED MAL, 4010 Fleming Administration Building, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109-1340. The University of Michigan is an equal opportunity, affirmative action employer. Back to Quicklinks Services SOUTH FLORIDA ATTORNEY available for consultations, all legal and business matters, referrals, or local counsel, litigation and estates. Contact Mark M. Berkley, 385-C West 49th Street, Hialeah (Miami) Florida 33012, telephone 305.556.2626. Member of the State Bar of Michigan for 25 years and the Florida Bar for 14 years. Back to Quicklinks To receive information on how to place a classified advertisement, contact Stacy Sage news & moves Back to Quicklinks bar events Back to Quicklinks archived e-Journals Case Summary Cumulative Index Thursday, May 10 e-Journal Friday, May 11 e-Journal Monday, May 14 e-Journal Tuesday, May 15 e-Journal Wednesday, May 16 e-Journal Back to Quicklinks contacts For information on classified advertising, contact Stacy Sage For information on fields of practice listings, contact Stacy Sage For unsubscribe and change of address issues, contact: Carrie Pickett To list bar event information, send your information to Carrie Pickett Editorial comments may be sent to Nancy Brown Technical questions may be sent to e-journal-tech@michbar.org Who Does What at the State Bar Back to Quicklinks To receive the text-only version, please send an e-mail to lyris@lists.michbar.org In the body, type: subscribe ejournal-text. To unsubscribe from the html version, type: unsubscribe ejournal on the next line. You may re-subscribe or unsubscribe at any time. State Bar of Michigan Home Copyright , 2001, State Bar of Michigan --- You are currently subscribed to ejournal as: [mark.e.haedicke@enron.com] To unsubscribe, forward this message to leave-ejournal-255481W@lists.michbar.org