1 Dec 2000, 11:02 UTC
SECLP CLAIM
- From
- Larry L Izzo larry.izzo@enron.com
- Date
- Fri, 1 Dec 2000 03:02:00 -0800 (PST)
Mike, I would appreciate your help on the following matter.
I attach the e-mail that I sent to David Haug on August 11 of this year about
the $2.9 million settlement payment that the SECLP project in the Dominican
Republic owes us and that they have not paid, and that has been accruing
interest for years. EECC will have to write off all of this amount unless
some resolution is achieved. The e-mail tells the story so I won't repeat
it, but will just update the note as follows:
After we sent this note, there were several internal Enron meetings between
EECC and CALME in which it was decided that Dan Castagnola would approach the
lenders in a last ditch attempt to obtain payment. If the Lenders refused to
approve payment, then EECC would be freed to file litigation against SECLP to
recover the full uncompromised amount of the claim (approx $5.6 million,
excluding interest).
This project was then transferred to Global Markets in connection with the
CALME breakup, and the owner's efforts to discuss the matter with the Lenders
seems to have ground to a halt. We do not think that the discussion with the
Lenders ever occurred.
However, we are still willing to consider alternatives to litigation, such as
selling the claim to the Enron shareholder in SECLP for the amount of the
settlement, and allowing the Enron shareholder company to hold and control
the claim against the project and perhaps have it treated as a capital
contribution for which shares might be issued later. This would allow EECC to
clean up its books without taking a write off and allow the Enron shareholder
to preserve the claim and perhaps capitalize it.
Please call me when you have had a chance to review this note. Hopefully, we
can work something out.
LI51600
*********************************
Larry L Izzo
08/11/2000 12:18 PM
To: David Haug/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
cc: John Schwartzenburg/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
Subject:
David, as you know we have been trying to get the open claim we have with
SECLP settled for some years now. I am sending you this note as part of a
last effort to get this settled, and so it is to be considered part of the
settlement discussions and used solely in that context, and is without
prejudice.
For you convenience, I wanted to summarize the history of the dispute
involving the outstanding invoice dated 19 March 1996 from Enron Power
Construction Company ("EPCC") to Smith/Enron Co-Generation Limited
Partnership ("Owner") in the amount of $5,586,145.00 ("Claim").
Project History
November 1993 Owner and GE execute the Turnkey Agreement;
November 1993 NTP issued to GE;
May 1994 Phase I Simple Cycle Commercial Operation achieved;
September 1994 Owner and EPCC execute the Construction Completion Agreement
("CCA");
August 1995 Phase II Combined Cycle Commercial Operation achieved;
The Construction Completion Agreement.
Under the CCA EPCC administered the final stage of the Turnkey Agreement by
stepping into the shoes of Owner in order to manage the schedule for
completion of the work under the Turnkey Agreement. It is important to
remember that (i) EPCC had no authority to settle disputes or determine if
the Commercial Operation was achieved and (ii) EPCC had no warranty
obligations for GE or any other third person.
The Costs under the Invoice.
Between August 1995 and March 1996 EPCC continued to incur costs including
additional scope of work items and costs incurred as a result of third party
actions (Force Majeure). Our costs totalled $5,586,145 and were included in
the 19 March 1996 invoice. Since we have not been paid, interest has been
accruing on that amount.
Settlement Discussions.
Beginning 2Q 1996 I personally had discussions with Owner about the Claim.
We discussed several payout options, most involving insurance proceeds. EPCC
and your partner, Smith Cogeneration Dominicana, Inc. executed a settlement
agreement in early 1997. This was negotiated personally by Rod Gray, on
behalf of EI. However, Owner refused to execute the settlement agreement
pending Lender approval. This Lender approval never materialized, and the
settlement agreement was never signed by the Owner. However, I was asked by
Rod, on behalf of EI, to await the insurance settlement.The settlement
agreement stated that Owner would pay EPCC $2.9MM as follows:
? 6% of Owner insurance proceeds (i.e. 10% of Owner,s 60%) for the first
$13.5MM gross
insurance (max is $800k); and
? 12% of Owner,s insurance proceeds (i.e. 20% of Owner,s 60%) above $13.5MM
until EECC
obtains $2.9MM.
Meanwhile, we have patiently waited to close out the CCA while Owner resolved
its claims against the responsible parties including Raytheon/Ebasco, General
Electric, and Foster Wheeler. We have spent considerable time and effort
investigating and addressing issues raised with respect to these liability
issues even to the point of allowing our personnel to be interviewed. We
have waited so long that we had to execute a Tolling Agreement on 1 August
1999 in order to protect our rights from disappearing due to lack of
prosecution!
Finally, in June 2000 your team suggested that the Lenders may consent to the
settlement agreement if we sent a stern letter outlining our position and
evidencing our frustration. Our litigation counsel drafted and sent such a
letter on June 7, 2000, but Lenders did not consent to the settlement
agreement.
Current Status.
We now have no prospect of repayment of the Claim and no path forward. EPCC
is prepared to move forward and initiate appropriate proceedings for
collection of this long overdue outstanding balance, but I wanted to give you
this letter as notice in case you had another solution to this dilemma.
Please note that the CCA allows for a 12% per annum interest charge on all
unpaid amounts and we will include four years at this rate in the arbitration
claim.
Please respond with your thoughts and comments. I look forward to discussing
this matter with you.
Larry
LI36500