26 Oct 2001, 16:14 UTC
ALLIANCE FERC BEAT: GENERATORS/POWER MARKETERS FERC Post-Meeting Memo for October 24, 2001
- From
- The Alliance of Energy Suppliers alliance@eei.org
- Date
- Fri, 26 Oct 2001 09:14:52 -0700 (PDT)
[IMAGE] GENERATORS/POWER MARKETERS FERC Post-Meeting Memo for October 24, 2001 Highlights At Wednesday's Commission meeting, generators scored a major victory with the Commission's order setting a new interim generator interconnection policy whereby transmission owners must pay interest to generators for interconnection costs for system upgrades needed to interconnect. Commissioner Massey, although supporting the order only on an interim basis, said that "if the generator is going to used as a bank, it should be paid interest." Chairman Wood continues to be "uncomfortable with generators being the bank." The remainder of the meeting focused on establishing processes for continued development of RTOs. Within that framework, the Commissioners discussed the status of the Southeast, Northeast and Midwest RTOs. Chairman Wood, although joking of the less than pleasant comments made by the Chairman of the Maryland Public Service Commission, Catherine Riley, and many other state commissioners at last week's RTO Conference, acknowledged that the FERC took heed to the state commissions' concerns and will involve state commissions in the decision-making process and formation of the RTOs going forward. To back that up, Commissioner Brownell proposed the creation of a "regional panel" consisting of state commissions and FERC staff. This new panel will offer a forum for all regulatory bodies to provide input in the RTO process. Commissioner Brownell's proposal was supported by all three commissioners, although Commissioner Massey expressed a little reservation. It seems that the Commissioner is taking steps in that direction by convening the Western Infrastructure Adequacy Conference to be held during the Western Governor's Association Meeting in Seattle, WA on November 2. This conference, too, was aimed at strengthening relationships with the states and involving them in the decision-making process. In addition, the Commission extends bid caps for the ISO NE and NY ISO markets, addresses the issue of costs responsibility for interconnections and allows virtual bidding in the NY ISO real-time market. These and other proceedings are reported below. If you would like copies of any orders, please contact us. Commission Discussion FERC Orders Transmission Providers to Pay Interest to Generators for System Upgrades It is clear that the Commission is taking a serious look at the current interconnection policies and is not afraid to revisit earlier FERC policy to make sure that they get it right. In a dramatic move, FERC changed policy course and ordered on rehearing that Indiana Michigan Power Company pay DPL Energy, Inc. interest on the transmission credits it will receive from Indiana to repay it for interconnection costs associated with system upgrades of facilities. Chairman Wood believes that the transmission owner "should both construct and take responsibility for getting transmission built". Wood went on to say that "generators should do what they do best" ...and "not be the bank". Commissioner Massey tried to stress that his support of this order is only on an interim basis: " My long-term view has not yet been formulated... I have an open mind about how to price interconnection costs." However, Massey supported this order because he believed that " if a generator is going to be used as a bank, it should be paid interest." Commissioner Breathitt, on the other hand, was the lone dissenter on this order. Commissioner Breathitt called this item for discussion in conjunction with six other interconnection-related proceedings being considered on this agenda (E-7;E-10;E-12;E-17; and E-17). This policy shift is to be applied prospectively. In support of her dissent, Breathitt said that she "was not convinced that this order adequately counters the July order which denied rehearing on this very issue. Commissioner Breathitt also stated that she believed it premature to address interconnection issues and cost responsibility in light of the Commission's earlier announcement that it will issue an ANOPR on generator interconnection procedures and costs allocation issues. American Electric Power ER01-2163-001 FERC To Establish Regional Panels to Facilitate RTO Formation At the request of Commissioner Brownell, FERC will establish regional panels to help facilitate information exchange and collaboration between FERC and the state commissions. This decision is a direct result of the Commission responding to comments voiced by many state commissions at last week's RTO "Boot Camp". It was clear that the state commissions have felt like they have been left out of the RTO debate and process. So to remedy that going forward, FERC has recommended the creation of this regional panel structure. The goal of this regional panel is to strengthen relationships with the states, help FERC with problem-solving, and bring more efficiency to this RTO process. The Commissioners have recommended that this newly created structure within FERC have a dedicated staff and serve as sort of a "one-stop shop" for states to retrieve and exchange information with FERC. Chairman Wood expressed his support for this initiative and thanked Commissioner Brownell for her vision. Wood also spelled out what he sees as the duties of this regional panel: (1) setting up RTOs; (2) addressing transmission cost and infrastructure issues; (3) devise demand-side response mechanisms; (4) help develop market monitoring and market mitigation programs; and (5) consider best use of "distributed generation". Chairman Wood said that he would like this panel to look at the use of "distributed generation" on his behalf. Although conceding that distributed generation "looks more like a retail issue", Chairman Wood went on to say that he and the Commissioners would do everything it could to help assist the states in that process. Even though Commissioner Massey supported the order, he did, however, voice his frustration over the continuous use of conferences and other forums aimed at developing regional transmission organizations that have yet to yield the desired result: "It is my belief that we have had a lot of process.. if we need more we ought to structure it so to get to the 'end game'." ALJ's Discuss RTO Mediation Reports and Recommendations Southeast RTO Mediation The Commission heard presentations by staff and both the Administrative Law Judge presiding over the Southeast and Northeast RTO meditations. FERC staff signaled the audience that "governance is where this discussion will focus." Identifying the unique nature of this mediation process, Judge Bobbi Mc Cartney viewed this as a "new approach to mediation" in which she now terms as a "market-based mediation" approach. In Judge McCartney's summary of her Southeast mediation report, she recommended that out of the two governance models that rose from the Southeast RTO Meditations, the Collaborative Governance Model "represented the most fully-developed model." Judge McCartney went so far as to highlight several components of the GridFlorida RTO model: "It [GridFlorida] has a nicely prepared for-profit Transco model." Interestingly, FERC staff, in its presentation, stated that both models satisfied compliance with Order 2000. However, upon questioning by Commissioner Massey, staff conceded that the alternate "Independent System Administrator (ISA)" model may NOT fully comply with Order 2000 and may need additional work to bring it in compliance. Apparently wearing two hats, Judge McCartney's mediation advisor, Chairman Herb Tate, expressed his preference for the ISA model. He stated that public power entities and states may be more "comfortable" with this model because of its similarity to the Independent System Operator (ISO) model currently in place in the Northeast. Both Judge McCartney and Chairman Tate called on the Commission to take this report and build from it. Judge McCartney made it very clear that the findings were limited to the narrow scope she was asked to address. Judge McCartney only looked at the filings made in the Southeast RTO dockets and made no comparisons to other region's RTO proposals. Because of that limitation, Judge McCartney and Chairman Tate asked the Commission to do what they did not have an opportunity to. Ultimately, the Commissioners were very impressed by the results of the Southeast RTO meditations, but recognized that much more needs to be explored and resolved:(1) who does transmission planning; (2) how do you preserve the low-cost energy while restructuring the wholesale market?; and (3) should sub-regional RTOs still be allowed to continue developing knowing that they will be superseded by the creation of a supra regional RTO? (EX02-2; RT01-100 GridSouth; RT01-34 Southwest Power Pool; RT01-75 Entergy Services; RT01-77 Southern Company Services) Northeast RTO Mediation Discussions on the Northeast RTO Meditations went very much like the Southeast. Judge Peter Young summarized his findings from the Northeast mediation with assistance by his mediation advisor via telephone, Joe Garcia. The Northeast mediation did not concentrate on substantive issues and structures, instead it concentrated on process and timelines. The meditations yielded three options stakeholders offered for consideration: Option I-M; Option 2-M; and Option 3-M. Judge Young expressed his favor with Option I-M. However, again, the advisors and Judges were split on the appropriate model to use going forward. Joe Garcia recommended to the FERC the use of the 3-M Option, since it garnered the most "broad based support" from industry mediation participants. Without committing to one model or the other, Chairman Wood did, however, state that "Option 2 has some attractiveness" because of the of the shortened time frame for implementation. (EX02-1-000; RT01-99 PJM; RT01-98 PJM-West; New York ISO RT01-95) Midwest RTO Developments The Midwest RTO discussions took a different approach beginning with a staff presentation that highlighted the status of both the Alliance RTO and the Midwest RTOs. From the FERC staff presentation, it seemed as if the staff portrayed the Midwest ISO as the more progressive of the two RTOs before them. Of particular note, Commissioner Breathitt pointed out that Southwest Power Pool had announced its plan to merge with the Midwest ISO, which could address Commission's concern that its scope was too small. Looking to gain more intelligence on the announced proposed merger of MISO and SPP, the Commissioners asked Jim Torgenson of MISO to join the panel and answer staff questions. The Commissioners were very concerned with the possibility of seams between the two areas,( i.e. Midwest ISO and SPP). Mr. Torgenson quieted those concerns by telling the Commission that there will be "no seams"... "they will function as one." Under the new proposed structure, Jim Torgeson will become CEO of the newly created and named structure and Nick Brown will assume the position of COO for the new structure. In addition, the Midwest ISO/SPP RTO will seat an entirely new independent 11 person board. Representatives from the Alliance RTO were not given the same opportunity to update the Commissioners on their RTO progress. The Commissioners only had the staff presentation summarizing what the Alliance had filed in its most recent status report afforded to them. In the presentation, staff noted that the Alliance RTO would not be operational by the December 15 RTO start-up date, but that the Midwest ISO intended to be. Much of the Midwest discussion centered around the viability of "stand-alone" transcos and for-profit transcos within the RTO structure. Commissioner Breathitt stated that she "hope(s) to see a stand-alone transmission company." she went on to say that with regards to Transcos, "maybe it is a time that has not yet come." With so much uncertainty surrounding the Midwest and other regions, Commissioner Brownell instructed the Commission no to allow these "models to be exposed in the market while we [FERC] tincker." Commissioner Massey made a statement along the same lines asking for the Commission to consider "what functions do investors need to invest in RTOs" that could make the investments more appealing. It is conceivable that this uncertainty in the market surrounding the creation of RTOs, both for-profit and not-for-profit could deter much needed investment in these models. (EX02-3; RT01-87 Midwest ISO/Alliance; EL01-80 National Grid USA) - The message the Commissioners got across at Wednesday's meeting is that it will attempt to give people certainty by proceeding in a manner that will involve the necessary parties to bring RTOs into fruition. (1) perform an updated cost-benefit analysis of creating RTOs; (20 issue a NOPR on RTOs that spell out what the Commission is looking for compliance; (3) issue an interconnection ANOPR to resolve a huge outstanding issue that could impact functionality of RTOs; (4) create regional councils to facilitate collaboration between states and FERC; and (5) issue a NOPR on Open Access Tariffs to guide the industry in fashioning tariffs. Discussion of Western Infrastructure Adequacy Conference AD01-2 The staff started off the presentation by stating that it views this conference as a "fact-finding mission". Staff proceeded to lay out three questions the FERC will attempt to answer through this conference: (1) Is current infrastructure adequate?; (2) What are the infrastructure needs in the West?; and (3) What factors are inhibiting adequate investment in infrastructure? In addition to those questions, staff is looking to address offsets of those larger contextual questions: (a) what is the outlook for population and growth of demand in the West; (b) Why isn't needed infrastructure being built? what are the barriers? (c) What can FERC and the states do to increase investment in the West? Chairman Wood ended the discussion by stating that "what is good for the West is good for the rest of the country." So, we can probably expect FERC to move forward with a series of regional discussions similar to this conference in the West. Individual Contested Proceedings Bid Caps/ Market Mitigation New York ISO ER01-3001-000 - The Commission granted the NY ISO an extension of its $1,000 bid cap until which time a Northeast RTO becomes operational. The Commission also directed the NY ISO to file semiannual reports on the progress of its efforts to implement programs that could minimize occurrence of extreme prices, e.g. demand-side management programs. In addition, as condition for approval of an extension for the use of the NY ISO's Temporary Extraordinary Procedures (TEP), the NY ISO must file within 30 days a more defined set of procedures for triggering TEP in the market. ISO New England ER01-3086-000 - The Commission granted the ISO-NE an extension of its $1,000 bid cap until such time as a Northeast RTO becomes operational. Morgan Stanley Capital Group v. NY ISO EL00-90-000; ER01-3009;ER01-3153-000 - The Commission accepted the proposal to allow virtual bidding, (i.e. bidding of non-physical generation and load) in the NY ISO's real-time market. The Commission also accepted the NYISO's revised Market Mitigation Measures aimed at addressing potential gaming or market power that may result from the introduction of virtual bidding. Generator Interconnection New York Independent System Operator, Inc. ER01-2967-000 The Commission addressed the issue of cost responsibility for interconnection by ruling that generators may only be assigned costs of System Upgrade Facilities to the extent that these costs are not already in the "Baseline Assessment". In addition, siding with generator arguments, the Commission also ordered the NY ISO to delete from its tariff its "Material Impact Standards" without prejudice. Market Complaints E-19 San Diego Gas & Electric Co. v. Sellers of Energy EL00-95-034; EL00-98-038 - Order on the CA ISO's compliance filing proposing a new generator outage and maintenance coordination plan. Dynegy and other protesters allege that the CA ISO is attempting to circumvent FERC and "seize control of the outage monitoring" function that is currently FERC' s responsibility and role. Pacificorp Power Marketing ER01-2685-000 - The Commission accepts Pacificorp Power Marketing's request to withdraw its filing of a 10-year power Purchasing Agreement contract with the California Department of Water Resources. Attempting to comply with a Commission order in the Southern Case rescinding waiver and requiring that all long-tern power contacts be filed with the Commission in place of submitting quarterly power marketing reports, Pacificorp filed its long-term contract and later realized that the waiver was still in effect at the time it made the power contract filing. Mirant et al. v. ISO New England, Inc. EL01-93-001 - The Commission granted NSTAR's clarification request and directed the ISO NE to file with the Commission all mitigation contracts negotiated under Market Rule 17, effectively eliminating the discretion the ISO NE attempted to exercise. E-30 Calpine Eastern Corp., Mirant et al. v. ISO New England EL01-124-000 - The Commission agreed with Calpine and granted its complaint ordering the ISO NE to include external energy contracts in its calculation of the energy clearing price and Real-time Marginal Price during non-OP4 conditions in the ISO's market. NOTE: FERC Issued ANOPR on Generator Interconnection Tonja Wicks Manager, Energy Supply Policy Alliance of Energy Suppliers Edison Electric Institute Phone: (202) 508-5098 Fax: (202) 508-5600 Fax: (202) 508-5445 ______________________________________________ To subscribe to this list, send an e-mail to alliance@eei.org containing the following information: name, company, title, address, phone, fax and e-mail address. To unsubscribe from this list, send an e-mail to alliance@eei.org containing your name and e-mail address. For more information, please contact the Alliance of Energy Suppliers at alliance@eei.org P-(202) 508-5098 F-(202) 508-5600 Tonja Wicks Manager, Energy Supply Policy Alliance of Energy Suppliers Edison Electric Institute Phone: (202) 508-5098 Fax: (202) 508-5600 Fax: (202) 508-5445 - IMAGE.gif - Tonja Wicks.vcf ********** Several EEI meetings have been postponed or canceled. For more information about a specific meeting, go to ( http://www.eei.org/resources/meetings/postponements.htm )