Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

7 Mar 2001, 11:24 UTC

Summary of $ at Risk for Customs

From
Steven J Kean steven.kean@enron.com
To
Rob Walls Jr., Elizabeth Labanowski, Debra Hicks
Cc
Mark Schroeder
Bcc
Mark Schroeder
Date
Wed, 7 Mar 2001 03:24:00 -0800 (PST)
Please see attached.  Rob, perhaps while in London you could stop by Mark's 
desk to discuss.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Steven J Kean/NA/Enron on 03/07/2001 11:22 AM -----

	Mark Schroeder@ECT
	03/07/2001 03:45 AM
		 
		 To: Steven J Kean/NA/Enron@Enron
		 cc: Jane Wilson/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
		 Subject: Summary of $ at Risk for Customs

Steve - the issue to which I believe Jane is referring in the first sentence 
("confirmation of the issues which I have articulated") concern possible 
paymensts made to receive informal, and favourable, guidance, on customs 
issues (which informal opinions are now seemingly being reversed, formally).  
In some cases such payments may still be legal.  But, subject to Jane 
confirming that I am explaining this correctly (given that the communication 
below is a bit cryptic), it now seems to me to be timely (as Rebecca and Jim 
have apparently been alerted in London on Monday, per her note below) to 
satisfy yourself that we are now clean on this issue under the Foreign 
Corrupt Practices Act.  The informal customs advice was obtained by Muktesh 
Tyagi (spelling?), one of two people known as Sanjay's "fixers" (that should 
make you fell comfortable!).  You may wish to discuss with Jane further, but 
once you satisfy yourself that there is some smoke here, my thought was that 
you might want to simply confirm with Rebecca that we are running the facts 
to ground, so that we can satisfy ourselves that we are either clean, or need 
to come clean with USG.  let me know if you need more.   thanks mcs          
---------------------- Forwarded by Mark Schroeder/LON/ECT on 07/03/2001 
09:42 ---------------------------


Jane Wilson@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
07/03/2001 04:38
To: Mark Schroeder@ECT
cc:  

Subject: Summary of $ at Risk for Customs


	


Mark, I have confirmation of the issues on which I have articulated concern 
to you although such confirmation is verbal.  Apparently, there are more 
areas that I will identify in due time.  This information was conveyed to the 
Legal Team (which included Rebecca, Bruce, Sandeep Katwala and outside 
attorneys) in London on Monday.   In addition, below is additional bad news.  
In addition, there is at issue now the fact that the flow diagrams and import 
lists do not match.  I'll forward an additional e:mail from Seethayya,
---------------------- Forwarded by Jane Wilson/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT on 
03/07/2001 10:04 AM ---------------------------

Heidi Hellmann

03/06/2001 01:39 AM

To: Jane Wilson/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT
cc: Robert Mathis/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT, Chandran 
Bhaskar/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT@ENRON_DEVELOPMENT 

Subject: Summary of $ at Risk for Customs

I found out more info on some of these extraneous customs issues above and 
beyond the LNG stuff:

PHASE I ISSUES
1. SPM 
 (This equipment has already been imported at 22.38%, but customs is claiming 
merit duty rates of 67%.)
 This is currently being evaluated by the courts.
 Total Value at Risk = $7 MM
2. "D" - Stream
 Are Bechtel's design charges of $66 MM specific to our equipment or to the 
project as a whole? 
 If the former, then duty of 22.38% should apply.
 Total Value at Risk = $13.5 MM  ($66 MM x 22.38%)

PHASE II ISSUES
1. Services Loading on Power Plant Equipment
 Same issue as for LNG Equipment. Currently we are paying a 10% loading on 
duty into a reserve deposit to cover this.
 Total Value at Risk = $22.38 MM  ($100 MM x 22.38%)
2. LNG Equipment to be dutied at 53.8% or 22.38%?
 Think we all know this issue.
 Total Value at Risk = $56 MM (as per Risk Matrix)
3. Services Loading on LNG Equipment
 Think we all know this issue
 Total Value at Risk = $80 MM  ($149 MM x 53.8%)

TOTAL VALUE at RISK ~$180 MM - - This is WORST, WORST CASE!

Note:  There is still this issue of goods being imported under the wrong 
classification.  Currently, this is preventing goods from being imported on 
time, which could lead to delay claims by the contractors.  It will take me 
some time to hunt down what this could cost us if the problem isn't resolved 
soon.  Pavan's estimate is that it will take a month for Site to generate 
accurate equipment lists and for the same to be reviewed and approved by MSEB.
Heidi