26 Oct 2000, 11:26 UTC
Edison Prehearing Conference Statement Filed
- From
- Roger Yang roger.yang@enron.com
- Date
- Thu, 26 Oct 2000 04:26:00 -0700 (PDT)
It looks like SCE is proposing to increase frozen rate levels by 10% on January 1, 2001. SCE also recognizes TURN's proposal that the TCBA and TRA should never have been artificially segregated, but criticizes it as a short-term solution that puts utilities' at significant risk. The major problems I have with PG&E and SCE's attitude are: They are trying to renegotiate the AB1890 compact after viewing history; As TURN has pointed out, they are only focusing on their undercollections and not overcollections; They believe that they were able to extend the rate freeze at prices above market when wholesale prices were low, yet end the rate freeze when prices in the wholesale market are high resulting in an immediate rate increase. Where were the utilities' risk in CTC recovery? There is no discussion how direct access will be impacted; however, we must be careful that they are trying to move away from the current PX crediting mechanism; and They ignore how much CTCs they have recovered to date. As you know, we believe the rate freeze under the current mechanism must be maintained until the statutory date of December 31, 2001. Although a surcharge mechanism may be an appropriate solution, it should be implemented after December 31, 2001 and managed in a way to avoid sticker shock. If cash flow is an issue for the utilities, who were getting large sums of cash inflow prior to the wholesale price run-ups, then securitizing an accounts receivable may be a good solution. In short, AB1890 should be preserved through 2001 per TURNs recommended ratemaking accounting treatment. We should be amenable to a solution that allows utilities to recoup some of the undercollections past December 31, 2001, if necessary through securitazion. However, perhaps the amount of recovery may need to be discounted to reflect an appropriate sharing of risks between ratepayers and utility shareholders. We probably do not want to be out in front on this issue, so we should probably work through other parties such as TURN, CLECA, and CMA. Roger
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Roger Yang/SFO/EES on 10/26/2000 09:06 AM --------------------------- "Daniel Douglass" <douglass@ArterHadden.com> on 10/25/2000 06:25:09 PM To: <jdasovic@enron.com>, <mpetroch@enron.com>, <Roger_Yang@enron.com> cc: Subject: Edison Prehearing Conference Statement Filed The following is a summary of the attached Edison prehearing conference statement filed this afternoon in the proceeding dealing with its Petition for Modification of the end-of-the-rate-freeze decisions: ? Edison says there are There are four key elements to managing the situation: Support market reform, including providing greater freedom for utilities to contract for longer term supplies of power, completing review of SCE,s bilateral contract proposals, and urging other agencies to help rectify the market structure problems that have become apparent. Confirm that the utilities will be permitted to recover their reasonable procurement costs incurred on behalf of customers. Protect customers by implementing a post-freeze rate stabilization plan instead of the current plan which directs immediate pass through of volatile wholesale power costs. This should include a modest near-term energy rate increase of around 10% in the interest of avoiding a much larger rate increase in 2002 and thereafter. Promptly decide whether the Commission is going to permit the sale of the utilities, remaining generation assets. If the answer is &no,8 then fundamental changes in the implementation of electric restructuring would have to be considered. Either way, all parties need the Commission,s answer to this key question as soon as possible. Interestingly, Edison says that, "Based on the valuations SCE has filed for our hydro facilities, Palo Verde, Mohave and Four Corners (no one has argued that these valuations are too high), our stranded costs (for the purpose of Section 368(a)) were recovered no later than mid-August 2000. The Commission should approve our pending plant valuations as soon as possible so that the Commission can put in place a reasonable ratestabilization plan, including a modest energy rate increase beginning in January 2001, to deal with the necessary costs of procuring power." [emphasis added] ? The procedural schedule proposed by Edison is as follows: Prehearing Conference October 27, 2000 Comments on the SCE and PG&E Petitions to Modify due October 30, 2000 End of rate freeze tariffs and rate stabilization plan filed November 14, 2000 Briefs on sale of remaining utility generation assets. November 17, 2000 Decision on SCE and PG&E petitions to modify November 21, 2000 Comments on end of rate freeze tariffs and rate stabilization plans due November 27, 2000 Reply Comments due December 4, 2000 Proposed Decision issued December 14, 2000 En Banc Oral Argument December 20, 2000 Special Commission meeting (Decision adopting end of rate freeze tariffs and rate stabilization plans) December 28, 2000 New rates effective as of: January 1, 2001 - PHC STATEMENT-SCE_1.PDF