21 Mar 2001, 09:02 UTC
San Diego Union-Tribune
- From
- Karen Denne karen.denne@enron.com
- Date
- Wed, 21 Mar 2001 01:02:00 -0800 (PST)
Tim -- This is the only article our "research department" could find. Hope it's the one you were looking for. kd
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Karen Denne/Corp/Enron on 03/21/2001
08:55 AM ---------------------------
From: Ann M Schmidt 03/20/2001 04:14 PM
To: Karen Denne/Corp/Enron@ENRON
cc:
Subject: San Diego Union-Tribune
Karen,
I have combed carefully through past San Diego Union-Tribune articles for the
article Tim Belden is looking for and below are the only two articles that I
can find that remotely address Steve Peace and the stranded cost issue. I
have a feeling it may not be what they are exactly looking for but then again
it may be. I even had Miyung Buster and Lynette Barnes take a stab at
finding it and they had no luck. Please let me know if this is it and if not
I can combed through again. Thanks, Ann
NEWS
ELECTION '98 | PROPOSITION 9
Sparks fly over utilities measure | Consumer groups vs. broad coalition
Ed Mendel
STAFF WRITER
10/11/1998
The San Diego Union-Tribune
1 2
A-1
(Copyright 1998)
SACRAMENTO -- It looked like a triumph of legislative deal-making when, after
a year and a half of talks, a sweeping plan to deregulate electricity in
California came together in the final hours of the legislative session two
years ago.
The bill, brokered mainly by state Sen. Steve Peace, D-El Cajon, was not
opposed by any special-interest group. The complicated measure sailed through
both houses of the Legislature without a single "no" vote. But then consumer
groups took a second look.
They reached two main conclusions: A promised 10 percent rate reduction is
"phony," they say, and ratepayers should not have to pay for privately owned
utilities' ill-advised investments in nuclear power plants. Now the consumer
groups, backed by one of the biggest names in consumer protection, Ralph
Nader, have placed an initiative on the Nov. 3 ballot, Proposition 9, that
would make major changes in the deregulation plan passed two years ago.
"Billions of dollars of ratepayer money has been committed not to a
sustainable energy future but to the outright bailout of uneconomic nuclear
and fossil-fuel plants owned by investors," said Nader.
Proposition 9 prohibits ratepayers from being charged to pay off $6 billion
in bonds issued last year to finance a 10 percent cut in electricity rates
that took effect last January.
Furthermore, the initiative promises a 20 percent rate reduction by
prohibiting utilities from charging ratepayers for the "transition" costs as
they move nuclear and other uneconomical power plants into a deregulated
system.
The ballot measure is alarming to opponents, a broad coalition that includes
nearly all of the major business, labor, agriculture and local government
groups, some environmental groups, the Republican and Democratic parties, and
the leading gubernatorial candidates: Democrat Gray Davis and Republican Dan
Lungren.
Opponents say the initiative would be a severe setback for the deregulation
process needed to bring more competitive electricity prices to California,
where rates have been 50 percent higher than the national average. The
opponents also contend that the initiative could force taxpayers to pay off
the $6 billion bond, drive up the cost of borrowing for state and local
government by damaging bond credit ratings, and ultimately result in higher
rates for residences and businesses.
"I think it's fair to say Proposition 9 is categorically the most
disingenuous, misleading, anti-consumer proposition ever put on the ballot,"
said Peace.
With heavy funding from utilities, opponents have launched an extensive
television ad campaign to defeat Proposition 9. Backers of the measure say
their campaign will probably be limited to grass-roots work. Some polls have
shown Proposition 9 with a lead. But the statewide Field Poll, which has
decades of experience polling on ballot measures, showed the initiative
trailing by a ratio of nearly 2-to-1.
Mark DiCamillo, Field research director, said that successful initiatives
usually have a lead of about 2-to-1 in early polling. DiCamillo said the
results of the poll are "very ominous" for Proposition 9. The stranded issue
At the heart of the dispute is what has become known as the "stranded" costs
of the three large privately owned California utilities: San Diego Gas &
Electric, Southern California Edison, and Pacific Gas and Electric. The rates
that the utilities could charge in the past were set by the California Public
Utilities Commission. In exchange, the utilities had little or no
competition, and they were required to serve all creditworthy customers in
their service areas.
The utilities invested in nuclear power plants and, at the direction of
regulators, also made long-term contracts at relatively high rates to ensure
a stable supply of electricity from sources that minimized pollution.
But in a deregulated market, the utilities cannot sell power from nuclear
plants and their long-term contracts at competitive prices. Thus, the
utilities' cost of paying off the debt on their nuclear power plants and
other long-term contracts is said to be "stranded."
The nonpartisan Legislative Analyst's Office said the nuclear-related
stranded costs for the three utilities is about $10 billion. Estimates of
their total stranded costs are as high as $28 billion.
Peace and the backers of the deregulation legislation argue that it would be
unfair and illegal to force the utilities to pay their stranded costs,
because the state changed the rules of the game and the marketplace. A
federal court ruled against a New Hampshire restructuring plan last year that
would not have allowed a utility to recover its stranded costs. The utility's
lawsuit argued that the plan violated the "contracts" and "takings" clauses
of the U.S. Constitution.
The California plan allows the utilities to pay off their stranded costs in
two ways. The utilities received $6 billion from a bond issue that will be
paid off by ratepayers over 10 years, and the utilities can add a Competition
Transition Charge to ratepayer bills until March 31, 2002. Meanwhile, rates
are capped, and the amount of the competition surcharge that could be added
to ratepayer bills shrank or disappeared last summer as energy costs soared.
There is no guarantee that all of the stranded costs will be paid off under
the plan. Pacific Gas & Electric, a Northern California utility with
hydroelectric power sources, is said to have plenty of room under the rate
cap and may recover all of its stranded costs. But some think that San Diego
Gas & Electric and Southern California Edison could fall short of full
recovery. In the view of the backers of Proposition 9, the deregulation
legislation is far too generous to utilities. The consumer advocates say that
the shareholders of the investor-owned utilities should share risk as well as
profits, particularly from the nuclear power plants. Harry Snyder of
Consumers Union said that other states, such as Pennsylvania and Illinois,
are not asking their ratepayers to pay all of the stranded costs of
utilities.
Proposition 9 would prohibit ratepayers from paying most of the transition
costs and all of the bond payments, resulting in a rate reduction of at least
20 percent. A disputed preliminary staff report from the state Energy
Commission estimated that the reduction could be 32 percent. The bond deal
Most of the controversy has centered on the $6 billion bond issue.
After the amount was determined by the Public Utilities Commission, the bond
was issued by private trusts created through the state Infrastructure Bank.
The bond refinances some long-term utility debt at a lower interest rate.
Peace said ratepayers save $1.2 billion on the amount that would be paid on
the debt if there had been no refinancing.
Furthermore, said Peace, the bonds allowed the deregulation legislation to
include a 10 percent rate reduction that took effect last January. He said
the lower rates not only benefit customers, but also thwart unscrupulous
competitors.
"I didn't want a bunch of fly-by-night operators coming in here with all of
the rip-offs that we saw during the deregulation of telephones," said Peace.
But the consumer advocates say that the bond payments will offset most of the
rate reduction, making the alleged short-term savings from the deregulation
little more than a shell game.
"What they did was deny the 10 percent rate reduction," said Lenny Goldberg,
a lobbyist for The Utility Reform Network, or TURN. "We ended up with a rate
reduction of 2 to 3 percent by financing the entire thing and making us pay
for 10 years."
Opponents have been running television ads contending that passage of
Proposition 9 could result in the state -- meaning taxpayers -- paying off
the $6 billion bond, rather than the utilities and their shareholders as
intended by the authors of the initiative.
But many think that the courts, citing long-standing laws covering contracts,
would be virtually certain to overturn the provision in Proposition 9 that
prohibits ratepayers from paying off the bond.
Under the existing deregulation, the bonds are in essence being financed by
ratepayers.
After talking to experts, the Legislative Analyst's Office concluded that the
probability of taxpayers becoming responsible for the bond is "very low." The
possibility is not even mentioned in the analyst's discussion of Proposition
9 in the ballot pamphlet.
One of the co-authors of the initiative, Mike Florio of TURN, conceded at a
legislative hearing that the provision barring ratepayers from paying off the
bond is likely to be overturned in court. If ratepayers are charged for the
bond payments, the initiative has a fallback provision that is intended to
require utilities to reduce their rates to offset the bond payments made by
ratepayers.
Consumer groups drop support
California and other states began to move toward deregulation after a 1992
federal law removed restrictions on the ownership of power-generating
facilities and made it easier for independent power generators to use
existing transmission lines.
Consumer groups and some legislators said that a California Public Utilities
Commission decision on deregulation guaranteed full recovery of stranded
costs and was skewed toward businesses and big customers at the expense of
residential users.
At first, consumer groups welcomed the legislation put together by Peace and
others as an improvement over the PUC's plan.
A four-page letter from TURN and the San Diego-based Utility Consumers'
Action Network expressed some reservations about the plan, but concluded with
these words:
"However, we will not oppose a bill which, under difficult circumstances, has
successfully incorporated a number of the concerns of residential and
small-business customers."
But after more study, Proposition 9 was written by a group of consumer
advocates, including Florio of TURN, Snyder of Consumers Union, and Harvey
Rosenfield, whose Proposition 103 cut insurance rates a decade ago. Backers
of the deregulation legislation accuse the consumer groups of "betrayal" and
breaking a deal, while the consumer advocates denounce the legislation as a
"fraud" and a "rip-off."
Peace and Snyder, who once had a good working relationship, are now
exchanging bitter barbs.
Snyder said of Peace: "He is doing the bidding of the utilities, not the
public, and he is really a disgrace to democracy."
Peace said he has never been so disgusted with political opponents: "It isn't
so much the issue, as it is their total disrespect for truth and for the
process itself."
The consumer groups used a contribution of about $800,000 from the Public
Media Center, a nonprofit organization in San Francisco, to gather the voter
signatures needed to place the initiative on the ballot. Opponents of the
initiative have suggested that the Public Media Center laundered
contributions from out-of-state energy companies and may have exceeded the
political contribution limit for nonprofit organizations. Herb Chao Gunther,
Public Media Center president, said the organization has received no
contributions from out-of-state energy companies. He said the organization,
which grossed $32 million during the last two years, is well within the
contribution limits for nonprofit organizations based on revenue.
"It's the classic defensive posture of trying to make us the issue," Gunther
said of the allegations from Proposition 9 opponents.
Proposition 9
What it does: Changes a state law deregulating the electric industry.
Electric utilities would be barred from charging customers to recover the
cost of nuclear power plants. Customers could not be charged to repay $6
billion worth of bonds issued last year to finance a rate reduction. Requires
a 20 percent reduction in electricity rates, rather than the 10 percent
reduction currently required by deregulation. Arguments for:
{} Privately owned utilities pushed through a deregulation law that allows
them to raise electric rates to pay off their money-losing investments in
nuclear power plants. The bonds used to cover the cost of a phony 10 percent
rate cut would be paid off by private utilities, not consumers or taxpayers.
Consumers would get an honest 20 percent rate cut not covered by back-door
payments to private utilities. A study suggests that rates eventually could
be cut by a third. Supporters:
{} Consumers Union, Ralph Nader, Harvey Rosenfield, The Utility Reform
Network and League of Women Voters.
Arguments against:
{} Taxpayers would be liable for the $6 billion bond repayment, potentially
causing a major cut in funding for schools and other services or a tax
increase. Changing the source of repayment for the $6 billion bond would
jeopardize state and local bond ratings. The plug would be pulled on a
deregulation plan that eventually will produce permanent electricity rate
reductions through a competitive market system. The poorly written measure
would trigger a major court battle. Opponents:
{} California Chamber of Commerce, California School Employees Association,
California Organization of Police and Sheriffs, Environmental Defense Fund,
Planning and Conservation League, California Taxpayers Association,
Democratic and Republican parties.
3 PICS | 1 CHART; Caption: 1. No charge: Proposition 9 would prohibit
utilities from charging ratepayers for much of the cost of uneconomical
nuclear plants,including San Onofre. (A-19) 2. Proposition 9 (A-19) 3. Steve
Peace: "I think it's fair to say Proposition 9 is categorically the most
disingenuous, misleading, anti-consumer proposition ever put on the ballot."
(A-19) 4. Ralph Nader: "Billions of dollars of ratepayer money has been
committed . . . to the outright bailout of uneconomic nuclear and fossil-fuel
plants." (A-19); Credit: 1. FILE PHOTO 2. UNION-TRIBUNE
Copyright , 2000 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
BUSINESS
Only a few unplug | Despite deregulation, 99% of consumers stay with same
power firms
Craig D. Rose
STAFF WRITER
10/13/1998
The San Diego Union-Tribune
1 2 3 6 7 8
C-1
(Copyright 1998)
State Sen. Steve Peace can take credit for co-authoring California's
electricity deregulation bill -- legislation that appeared to revolutionize
the power market and provide an array of choices to consumers. But when it
comes to his own home, Peace hasn't revolutionized anything: His household is
still drawing current from SDG&E.
"Here is where my wife's skepticism is," said the Democrat from El Cajon.
"And she makes the decisions."
The Peace family belongs to a very big club.
About 99 percent of the state's consumers continue to receive electricity
from their local utility, despite the nominally competitive market now in
place. In fact, a full six months after deregulation of the state's $23
billion power industry, the outcome remains short of electrifying. In August,
about 17,000 of the 10 million utility customers switched to a new power
provider. But during the same period, 3,300 switched back to their local
utility.
Overall, about 9 percent of the load in competitive markets has switched to
new providers, with utility companies retaining the 91 percent of the market
they've traditionally held.
If consumers are underwhelmed, would-be competitors also express surprise at
the lack of competition in the newly opened market.
"Of the 300 that signed up (to be new power providers), only five or six are
legitimate power providers," said Frederick Bloom, chief executive officer of
Commonwealth Energy, which claims 39,000 customers. Under California's
deregulation plan, SDG&E and other local utilities have retained their
monopolies over regional power grids. But there is supposed to be competition
in the power-generation business.
Companies registered with the California Public Utilities Commission win the
right to sign up customers and supply power to a state pool in amounts
equivalent to the usage of their customers. And hundreds of companies signed
up to compete.
But the new power companies say that technical hassles and the burden of
paying utilities about $28 billion for their unprofitable nuclear plants and
other investments -- so-called stranded costs shouldered by all ratepayers --
is limiting their ability to truly compete.
Many find they're unable to offer much if anything beyond the 10 percent rate
reduction mandated to all ratepayers under the state's deregulation law.
The payback of stranded costs, meanwhile, has provoked Proposition 9, a voter
initiative that would rewrite terms of the open power market and cancel the
payoff to utilities, while promising deeper rate cuts to small power users.
If smaller users have found little to excite them in the new market, some
larger commercial power users have found savings in the deregulated market.
Collectively, these larger users have switched about 20 percent of their load
to new providers.
A small number of residential consumers also are unplugging from local
utilities for green power, electricity said to be generated by means other
than burning a fossil fuel.
Peace says all this is what he expected.
"This is probably the single most complex transition of any single market,"
Peace said. "I'm stunned by how smoothly it has gone."
But Harvey Rosenfield, a consumer activist leading the effort to pass
Proposition 9, says consumer indifference proves that California's
deregulation is a "total fraud."
"It's a devastating indictment of the way deregulation was crafted by the
Legislature to destroy competition for residential ratepayers," Rosenfield
said.
Either way, deregulation has opened the door to small savings for at least a
few local power users.
The San Diego Association of Governments, which purchased about $40 million
in power annually from SDG&E, hopes to cut about $1 million from its yearly
power bill by purchasing its energy from Commonwealth Energy Corp. in Tustin.
The savings were hard to find.
The association had to twice bid out its power needs before finding a vendor
that could provide savings worth the effort to switch. Even with a vendor in
hand, the changeover has been prickly.
"It's a very detailed process for switching each account," said Steven Sachs,
senior planner with SANDAG. What had been expected to be a 60-day process is
now nearing completion after more than three months, he said. "We hope the
headache was mostly at the front end," Sachs said. "The real issue is that
all local governments have to be in the energy market so it's a great chance
for these people to learn about what is going on." Macy's department stores
in San Diego have also unplugged from SDG&E and contracted for power from New
Energy Ventures.
The department store chain made the switch to save money, said Russ Brown,
energy manager for Macy's Western division, but he declined to discuss the
amount of savings the stores hope to achieve.
"Nobody does this to lose money," Brown said.
New Energy Ventures, which is supplying power to Macy's, meanwhile, touts
itself as the biggest winner in the new market. The Los Angeles-based company
says it's won about 40 percent of the power load now being supplied by
companies other than the major utilities.
The company says the key to its success has been shared-savings contracts
with customers, in which the power company and its customers share the
savings that are achieved through the relationship, said Michael Peevey, the
company's chief executive officer. Smaller users
Peevey noted that such savings are unavailable to residential and small
commercial customers. The automatic 10 percent rate cut plus the stranded
cost payments make it difficult for new companies to compete against the
utilities for smaller power users.
"We look forward to the time (in 2002) when the utilities industry's stranded
costs are paid by customers so that we can begin to provide truly significant
reductions in energy costs for customers," said Peevey. Arthur O'Donnell,
editor of California Energy Markets, a weekly newsletter based in San
Francisco, agreed that the rate cut and the burden of stranded costs has
eliminated the potential for lower prices for most Californians. Attempting
to compete on price under the current market structure can be fatal,
O'Donnell added, who noted that at least three companies competing for
residential customers have already defaulted, unable to deliver the power
they promised consumers and forced to turn their accounts back to utilities.
"That's the first solid evidence of people getting washed out of the market,"
said O'Donnell.
Peace says small customers will have more significant choices in power
company offerings within a few years.
"It was always our preference in the Legislature that the transition to
competition in the residential arena not be pushed fast because residential
customers are vulnerable to scams," said Peace. Moving slowly will allow
residential power users to become more sophisticated about their choice. In
the meantime, he said, small customers have benefited from the 10 percent
rate cut, plus from the boost to the state economy from the savings that
larger companies are achieving in their power bills.
Green power niche
That said, green power has found a niche in the new market, although these
offerings require customers to pay up to 25 percent above the cost of
conventional power. O'Donnell calls green power the most robust sector of the
new market.
Among the leaders in the niche is Green Mountain Energy Resources of Vermont.
The company declines to disclose the number of customers it has signed up
beyond saying it's greater than 10,000 and should exceed 50,000 by year-end.
Douglas Hyde, president of Green Mountain, believes that more than 20 percent
of California's 11 millions power users are potential green power customers.
"The lack of active price competition is not what we expected, but on the
other hand we're convinced the value of the (green power) we bring to the
market will excite people," said Hyde. "We sell cleaner resources to
customers who care about the market."
That customer base may extend beyond what many expected. Edison Source, for
example, a unit of Edison International, has won a contract to supply power
from renewable sources to several of Toyota Motor Sales USA's offices in
California. Other commercial users have also gone green, said O'Donnell. But
any revolution in the California market is unlikely for several years, he
said.
"What has happened is kind of what was expected," O'Donnell said.
"Deregulation was not meant for residential customers."
Trickle but no bolt
A few thousand of SDG&E's 1.2 million customers each month request to leave
the utility for a new power supplier. More than 97 percent have stayed put. A
smaller number each month are filing requests to return to SDG&E. 1997
Leaving SDG&E Returning to SDG&E
Nov. 224 0
Dec. 612 0
1998
Jan. 268 0
Feb. 828 0
March 1,892 12
April 6,878 81
May 1,562 104
June 1,840 143
July 5,074 375
Aug. 5,897 242
Sept. 4,225 2,214*
*2,012 returned to SDG&E because one company defaulted.
1 ILLUSTRATION | 1 CHART; Caption: Trickle but no bolt | A few thousand of
SDG&E's 1.2 million customers each month request to leave the utility for a
new power supplier. More than 97 percent have stayed put. A smaller number
each month are filing requests to return to SDG&E. (C-7); Credit: 1. KRIS J.
LINDBLAD / Union-Tribune 2. UNION-TRIBUNE | SOURCE: SDG&E
Copyright , 2000 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.