11 Dec 2000, 13:01 UTC
An Editorial from Today's Electricity Daily
- From
- Daniel Douglass douglass@arterhadden.com
- To
- barbara_klemstine@apsc.com, dcazalet@apx.com, billr@calpine.com, jackp@calpine.com, glwaas@calpx.com, ken_czarnecki@calpx.com, Carolyn A Baker, gavaughn@duke-energy.com, rjhickok@duke-energy.com, GTBL@dynegy.com, kewh@dynegy.com, jdasovic@enron.com
- Date
- Mon, 11 Dec 2000 05:01:00 -0800 (PST)
Commentary: Things Get Even Worse in California Although it hardly seems possible, the California wholesale electric market is getting worse. And rapidly. Power prices are high across the board and the California Independent System Operator has taken to declaring simultaneous stage one and stage two emergencies every morning, right along with brewing the morning coffee. On Thursday afternoon, the ISO declared the first stage three emergency, although it was not necessary to implement rolling blackouts. Demand hit 31,600 MW during the day, far from a peak for the state. But planned and unplanned outages meant that the statewide capacity margin was a bare 1,000 MW. The chief culprit appears to be the state's price caps, which are driving generation out of the state, and the politicians appear poised to make matters worse. The caps combine with soaring natural gas prices to drive electricity out of the California market. Because of gas prices in the $7 per million Btu range, the price caps are simply not enforceable. They are, in short, a joke. With price caps of $250/MWh in place through the California Power Exchange, and with bids hitting the caps for every hour of the market, generators are fleeing the state. That's because prices in the Pacific Northwest are running in the neighborhood of $375/MWh, and generators are selling into Oregon and Washington instead of California. Dow Jones reports that utilities in the Northwest last week showed up as buyers in the Cal PX, buying power at $400/MWh -- $250/MWh for the juice and $150/MWh for transportation. Just how wacky has the California market become? In order to protect reliability, the Cal ISO has been quietly purchasing power in bilateral deals from out-of-state generators at prices above the cap. The price cap rules apparently allow the ISO to buy above the cap if needed to supply an emergency. But it can only buy from out-of-state companies, not the California generators. Last Wednesday, the ISO paid some $10 million to buy 1,000 MW -- most likely from BC Hydro, although the ISO isn't talking -- or about $900/MWh. Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, sitting in the catbird seat with excess capacity, sold the ISO some 1,200 MW at the capped rate of $250/MWh. A civil suit charges that LADWP has been -- shock! -- profiteering by selling its low-cost juice from Bonneville Power Administration into the California market at an order of magnitude above what it paid. How are the state's politicians responding? They don't seem to understand the short-term consequences of what is going on. They are talking about banning exports of power made in California (can you say "Commerce Clause"?), or forming a state power agency (not in this decade), or re-regulating the utilities (ditto). There is only one action that California can take to protect itself against blackouts this winter. The state must get rid of the price caps entirely. Immediately. California's choice is simple and stark. Does the state want to ensure that its citizens have not enough power at an artificially low price, or enough power at a politically unpopular high price? The need for power trumps the price issue.