10 Sep 2000, 15:32 UTC
California Power Issue Article II
- From
- Gavin Dillingham gavin.dillingham@enron.com
- Date
- Sun, 10 Sep 2000 08:32:00 -0700 (PDT)
Business Rate cap in S.D. stopgap solution PUC action not seen as cure-all for surging electric bills VANESSA HUA ? 09/08/2000 San Francisco Examiner ? The price cap on San Diego's skyrocketing electricity rates mandated by state regulators Thursday is only a stopgap solution to underlying flaws in energy deregulation - problems that could plague PG&E customers in the future, consumer groups and industry watchers say. The California Public Utilities Commission voted 5-0 to cap electric rates at 6.5 cents per kilowatt hour. They had soared as high as 21 cents per kilowatt hour this summer. ? The commission also agreed to investigate whether San Diego Gas & Electric has been paying too much for the power it supplies to its customers. The actions, affirming legislation signed Wednesday by Gov. Davis, will reduce the average customer's electric bill to $68 a month from the current $120. SDG&E, which serves San Diego County and southern Orange County, was the first utility in the state to buy power on the open market - and the first to pass soaring wholesale power costs to consumers. Now, SDG&E will be able to charge customers far less than it pays for energy in high-use months. The company projects that the shortfall between what it has to pay for power and what it can charge rate payers could reach $839 million by 2004. Area rate payers may be asked to make up the difference, but just how that might be done has yet to be determined, pending the outcome of the PUC investigation. Likewise, PG&E - which said it has run about $2 billion in fuel expenses - wants to pass it on to consumers with an extra charge in future power bills. The San Francisco-based utility said that if SDG&E is allowed to pass its increased costs to consumers, then it plans to seek the same treatment from the PUC. But for now, because of the state's electric restructuring law, PG&E's rates will remain frozen until no later than March 2002. San Diego's energy woes stem in part from the high demand for electricity in a booming economy. The new energy suppliers and generators that were supposed to foster competition and lower prices just haven't materialized under deregulation, analysts said. Now, the price cap on retail prices - lower than wholesale prices on the power exchange - will further discourage new entrants. "It's a question of who would be crazy enough to come. The marketplace is too risky," said George Spencer, editor of Restructuring Today, a Washington, D.C.-based newsletter about deregulation. "Putting on a cap is a Band-Aid, not getting (to) the root of the problem." The rate cap defers payments to the utilities, creating further market uncertainty. "Any kind of rate cap means that in the future SDG&E has to get it back. It's like a big IOU. But I'm not quite sure how it's going to work out," said Jamey Gessaman, marketing program manager for Wattage Monitor which assists consumers in finding alternative electricity suppliers. Truckee-based TenderLand Power Company, which aims to generate and sell electricity from renewable resources, differentiates itself from SDG&E, making clear that its prices - 8 cents per kilowatt hour - is not a deferred payment plan. Their customers won't have to pay more, later, to make up for the shortfall, a spokeswoman said. Assemblywoman Susan Davis, D-San Diego, who authored the price cap legislation, said that measures were a necessary first action in solving electricity crisis over the long term. "The most important thing to do was to stop bleeding in San Diego," she said. Consumer advocates slammed electricity deregulation as a legislative failure now punishing consumers. "This is botched legislation. There have been so many screw-ups, in the way it was set up and administered," said Michael Shames, executive director of the Utility Consumers' Action Network in San Diego. Gov. Davis defended deregulation Thursday by calling it "an experiment that will work if everybody acts responsibly. "The electrical generators that have bought up the facilities that exist in California are now selling power back to us at between five and eight times what it used to cost us," he said. "Utilities, who are now out of the generation business are basically just in the distribution business, and consumers - everybody has to accept their role and accept their share of the short-term pain to make this program work." In addition to the rate cap, Davis also signed a bill Wednesday that would speed up the approval process for new power plants. That could ease the soaring demand for electricity. However, the governor put off action on a third bill - also passed with much fanfare by the Legislature - that could provide up to $150 million in state money to cov er any future San Diego power debts. While Gov. Davis said his decision on that measure could wait until later this month, the timing increased speculation that he may veto the plan. Some critics have argued that pledging public money to cover private power costs could set a precedent leading to a far greater drain on taxpayers in the future. The PUC was scheduled to hold a hearing in San Diego on Friday to explore the cause of high summer wholesale prices. Examiner news services contributed to this report.