29 Sep 2000, 18:07 UTC
Utilities, Electric: Deregulation: Who Pays for Deregulation?
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- Bcc
- Steven J Kean
- Date
- Fri, 29 Sep 2000 11:07:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Miyung Buster/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT on 09/29/2000 06:06 PM ----- djcustomclips@djinteractive.com 09/27/2000 02:32 PM Please respond to nobody To: 86464@WCTOPICS.djnr.com cc: Subject: Utilities, Electric: Deregulation: Who Pays for Deregulation? Who Pays for Deregulation? Pam Kufahl ? 09/30/2000 Utility Business Copyright 2000 by Intertec Publishing Corporation, a PRIMEDIA Company. All rights reserved. As the gas and telecom industries can demonstrate, deregulation does not always live up to its promise. In San Diego these days, consumers are cursing the day they ever heard about electricity deregulation. As customers of San Diego Gas&Electric can attest, deregulation has yet to live up to its promise. Just after San Diego Gas&Electric President Edwin A. Guiles announced a $390 million dividend for customers as a result of the company's successful transition to a competitive marketplace, the utility's customers were hit with their highest electric bills this year. Many of those bills were two to three times higher than the preceding month's bill. The San Diego saga has left many consumers, utility industry leaders and policymakers around the country wondering about the future of efforts to shed decades of industry regulation. All are wondering whether deregulation can work - and whether benefits can broadly flow. They are watching intently as Californians sort their way through the shambles of the state's early deregulation efforts. Some industry insiders suggest these higher prices will spread to other deregulated states in the future. Concerns about deregulation's effects on customers began even before this summer's events. Natural gas prices have been increasing since late 1997. The increases haven't been as noticeable on winter gas bills because winters throughout much of the country have been mild. However, drilling slowed starting in 1997, and natural gas reserves have dwindled to two-thirds of what they will need to be by Nov. 1. Utilities were purchasing gas during the summer to build up their reserves for winter. In addition, the high summer temperatures meant utilities ate into their existing reserves to generate more electricity. Despite deregulation, residential gas customers may not be seeing as large of a decrease in their gas bills as commercial and industrial customers for a simple reason. Restructuring of the gas industry ended the cross subsidies that residential customers were receiving. While deregulation lowered their gas rates, the loss of these subsidies increased costs a bit. The result was that their savings were less than the savings of larger customers who never benefited from cross subsidies, according to Bruce B. Henning, director, energy practice at Energy and Environmental Analysis in Arlington, Va. The telecom industry has been deregulated for several years. While residential rates have decreased in that industry, the highest volume users and business customers have benefited the most from deregulation. The electric industry has followed suit so far. As the power industry is deregulated, utilities will have no choice but to serenade larger commercial and industrial customers, according to a February 2000 report by Dr. Eugene Coyle, independent economic counsel. The cost to go into a new area and market to new customers is so high while the return on residential customers is so low that the pursuit of residential customers just may not be worth it for non-incumbent utilities. This could mean that residential customers will be left out of the opportunities for electric deals that larger, power-hungry commercial and industrial customers are offered, according to the report, which was released by the American Public Power Association. Besides targeting customers who use the most power, energy providers will market to those who have more disposable income, which translates into the ability to buy bundled offerings. Customers who don't fit into these areas will be ignored, Coyle says. Kyle Datta, vice president and head of the utilities practice at consulting firm Booz Allen&Hamilton, doesn't agree completely with Coyle's predictions. "If you look at the customer base, there's certain commercial and industrial customers that are more profitable," Datta says. "They [utilities] will take actions to retain them. Those that are unprofitable they will keep, but they won't spend as much money marketing to them." Besides, Datta says, it just makes good business sense to offer discounts or special services to retain the most profitable customers. However, utilities understand their social obligation to provide power and will not drop customers, he says. Don't tell that to customers of DTE Energy Co., a deregulated energy marketing company that served residential and business customers in the Northeast. The company recently closed its DTE Edison America affiliates in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. "We believe that we have learned enough to conclude that the competitive residential and small commercial mass market is not profitable in this early stage of development," Jean M. Redfield, president, DTE Edison America, said in a statement released by the company. "A fully deregulated market with large numbers of residential and small business customers participating...remains at least a couple of years away." The company did not close its DTE Energy Marketing affiliate in the same states. That affiliate markets electricity and related energy services to industrial, commercial and institutional customers. However, sometimes, deregulation doesn't even pay for large commercial and industrial customers. In California, some energy retailers have withdrawn from the market, while others have been shedding customers. Commonwealth Energy of Tustin and AES New Energy of Los Angeles, two new entrants into the California market, recently had to drop more than 18,000 customers - primarily commercial and industrial customers in the state. The two companies have said that the rules of deregulation in California have made it too difficult for them to compete. Commonwealth Energy had amassed 95,000 customers in the area and notified the 18,000 that it could no longer sell them electricity. AES New Energy, which serves mainly large businesses, notified more than half of its 220 customers of the same thing. In California, 15.9 percent of industrial customers and 7.2 percent of large businesses have chosen new suppliers. Only 2 percent of residential customers in the state have switched. However, residential customers still find it more difficult to benefit from deregulation. In most markets, new entrants can't make much money on residential loads under the current rules unless they sell a bundle of products - power, gas, telecom, financial service offerings - to make their marketing investment worthwhile. "They must sell a large number of products to residential customers because electricity is a low-margin product," Datta says. "You have to offer a discount and by the time you offer a discount, then the spread between the actual price and the wholesale price is too great. So, you have to find higher-margin products" such as telecom. Pennsylvania's Condition Pennsylvanians are closely watching the situation in California. The state deregulated in 1999. About 10 percent or 500,000 customers in Pennsylvania are being served by alternative providers - and 400,000 of those are residential customers. The state has imposed rate caps to help ensure that residential customers can't be harmed by volatile prices. Some of the caps extend through 2010. "It is important that we have the rate caps," says Sonny Popowsky, consumer advocate of Pennsylvania. In addition, all incumbent utilities in Pennsylvania agreed to rate reductions of 3 percent to 8 percent for about one to two years. "To me, one of the most important issues was to make sure you didn't see a cost shifting to residential customers," Popowsky says. "We took steps to prevent that. Whether it works remains to be seen." Is "Going Public" the Answer? Some consumer groups are calling for a slow down or repeal of deregulation in California, warning that higher rates will occur in other deregulated states in the future. Harvey Rosenfield, president of the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights, says that deregulation just creates an unregulated monopoly. He calls deregulation "the most monumental mistake ever committed by public officials." "We're all going to pay for the greed of this industry unless we go back to public control over our utility system," Rosenfield said in a statement released by the organization. Calls for public control echo Coyle's February report. Coyle argues that with a cost structure like that of the electric industry, there has to be public control either through regulation or public ownership. "The picture isn't good unless there's some type of public intervention," says Coyle. But another answer may lie in aggregation. An American Public Power Association report, "Promoting Competitive Electricity Markets Through Community Purchasing: the Role of Municipal Aggregation," says that residential and small business consumers must be equipped with the kind of bargaining power that large consumers have in order to reap equal benefits from deregulated electricity markets. Municipal aggregation programs can provide these small consumers with enough market weight to capture the economic benefits they are missing. Some residential groups are giving this option a try. Public housing authorities in many cities are putting together consortiums to bid for energy for its members. In March, 21 towns and two counties, representing 185,000 electricity customers, came together as the aggregated group Cape Light Compact and chose a mutual power supplier. Online services, such as LowerMyBills.com may also provide answers to residential customers. Sites like this one help customers to find the least expensive provider of services including electricity, gas, telecom, cable TV and insurance. While consumer groups may complain about high rates and some industry insiders may project a darker future for residential customers, other experts saythe current situation is just a matter of a newly deregulated industry experiencing growing pains. "Over the long term, competition is an effective way of disciplining prices," says Henning. "In the long term, economists look at restructuring as a way to keep rates down." Competition should live up to its promise of lower rates for everyone, but residential customers may have to resign themselves to the fact that larger-volume users will see greater savings from deregulation than they will. It's only good business sense on the part of the service providers. Folder Name: Utilities, Electric: Deregulation Relevance Score on Scale of 100: 98______________________________________________________________________ To review or revise your folder, visit Dow Jones CustomClipsor contact Dow Jones Customer Service by e-mail at custom.news@bis.dowjones.comor by phone at 800-369-7466. (Outside the U.S. and Canada, call 609-452-1511 or contact your local sales representative.) ______________________________________________________________________ Copyright (c) 2000 Dow Jones &Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved