6 Mar 2001, 12:17 UTC
Texas Announces Launch of Pilot Program; Pat Wood Distinguishes Texas from California
- From
- SCIENTECH IssueAlert issuealert@scientech.com
- Date
- Tue, 6 Mar 2001 04:17:00 -0800 (PST)
Today's IssueAlert Sponsors: [IMAGE] The CIS Conferencec provides utility management personnel unequaled insight and current information on Customer Relationship Management (CRM), E-Commerce, Technologies and Marketing. Fifty-four sessions conducted by utility industry representatives will focus on issues facing the industry. Over 100 companies will exhibit the latest technologies and services. Former President George Bush is our Honored Keynote Speaker www.cisconference.org Identify and discuss current issues confronting the energy and telecommunications industries at the Center for Public Utilities' annual spring conference. How should these problems be resolved? What tradeoffs are made with each solution? Join panel discussions led by utility executives and PUC commissioners in Santa Fe, NM, March 25-28th, at "Current Issues Challenging the Utility Industry." To register, or for more information, contact Jeanette Walter, Associate Director, at 505-646-3242 or 505-646-4876. The Center for Public Utilities is part of New Mexico State University, presenting programs sanctioned by the National Association of Regulatory Commissioners (NARUC). For advertising information, email Nancy Spring, or call (505)244-7613. [IMAGE] IssueAlert for March 6, 2001 Texas Announces Launch of Pilot Program; Pat Wood Distinguishes Texas from California by Susan Kellogg, Issues Analyst and Will McNamara, Director, Electric Industry Analysis In a satellite media event on March 5, Pat Wood, the chairman of the Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT), introduced the media to a statewide campaign of television advertisements that are part of a kick-off of the Texas Electric Choice Pilot Program. Electric choice begins in Texas on June 1, 2001, with the start of a pilot program in which 5 percent of customers served by Texas investor-owned utilities can choose their retail electric provider (REP). Most other customers will be able to choose their REP when full-fledged electric choice begins on Jan. 1, 2002. After fielding questions from a bevy of television media reporters at the 11 a.m. broadcast, Wood conducted an exclusive interview with SCIENTECH Issues Analyst Susan Kellogg on how and why the Texas deregulation plan will work; why California didn't; and what role the expanding renewables market (particularly wind power) will play in developing a vibrant, competitive energy market in Texas. Analysis: PUCT Chairman Wood is confident that Texas has done its homework well, and the state's overall deregulation plan has set the stage for a successful retail competitive market. When we think of Texas, we think "big, confident, independent." However, a comprehensive, statewide group of stakeholders explored deregulation from all sides*getting information and advice from other deregulating states and international sources*to make sure that Texans have a different experience with electric choice than Californians did. The summary of "what didn't work in California" has circulated in the media for weeks, but Wood has an interesting perspective on what complicated the state's energy deregulation market. Basically, Wood says, the California market worked pretty well until it stopped raining in California, Oregon and Washington. In Wood's opinion, the fact that California is dependent for one-quarter of its power supply on an intermittent source (in this case, hydroelectric power) makes little sense and is largely to blame for the supply / demand imbalance still wreaking havoc in the state. The lack of power plant investment exacerbated the dynamics of the market when a critical piece of the power supply dried up last summer. Wood's criticism of the California mismanagement focused on the "it's not my job" mentality, considering that three state agencies were involved in California deregulation and yet no specific agency seemed to be in charge. "Bush would have run me out of Texas if we had done anything like that," mused Wood. "Our job is to not only do our job today but to plan for the future to look ahead. Granted, there had been no power plant investment, but not looking ahead with accountable facts was an inexcusable critical piece of planning missed by the California Energy Commission." The perfect storm of colliding conditions that plunged California into survival mode could have been prevented. The whole energy market has a lesson to learn, says Wood. And Texas has an opportunity to practice. To counteract the mistakes made, Wood freely acknowledges that Texas "pirated" most of the infrastructure of Texas' deregulation bill from Pennsylvania's largely successful plan. The Texas legislature meets every two years for a 90-day session. Right before the 1999 session, Wood and a deregulation team went to Pennsylvania and visited with state commissioners, legislators, industry executives, consumer groups, and customers to find out what was working and what was not in the Pennsylvania model. What they decided to leave behind from Pennsylvania's overall successful deregulation strategies was the provision that allowed a Philadelphia electric affiliate to go back into Philadelphia and attract the customers away from their own utility in the name of competition. Texas' goal, Wood clarifies, is to have a market of unaffiliated companies participating, which will hopefully generate genuine, long-term competition. Yet, in contrast to Pennsylvania, Texas adopted a policy in which customers that do not opt to switch to a new provider are defaulted to an affiliated REP of their incumbent utility. This affiliated REP, which cannot be the Toperation of the incumbent utility, will remain subject to regulated rates in its assigned service territory, although it is allowed to freely compete without price regulation outside of its service territory. As a result of this policy, Texas-based companies such as Reliant and TXU have submitted multiple applications to the PUCT, covering separate subsidiaries that will serve different customer classes and allowing the companies to compete outside of their service territories. At last count, over 11 companies had filed for certification with the PUCT to be a REP in Texas. Companies that plan to be active in the Texas retail market include The New Power Company, Green Mountain Energy, First Choice Power (the competitive spin-off of Texas-New Mexico Power Company), TXU Energy Services, Sempra, Shell, Reliant, and Enron Energy Services (among others). Another Texan invention was the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT), the independent power grid that serves the bulk of the state and is essentially an electrical island in the United States. Not possessing multi-state jurisdictions has both its advantages and disadvantages. Wood sees it being a plus for the Texas energy market because of the ability to monitor the balance of supply and demand of energy flow. Another feature of the Texas approach to deregulation is to make the transition easier for both retailers and operators, in part by developing a seamless integration between supply and demand. Perhaps most significant is the emergence of wind power and other renewables in the state, in part because of a mandate (Renewables Credit Exchange) that allows a retailer to buy renewable credits from a renewable operator at whatever price they agree on. In addition, Texas has established the Texas Renewables Portfolio Standard. Until the end of 2001 is providing a federal tax credit for companies that produce electricity from wind. The deregulation law in Texas is considered the most supportive of renewable forms of energy when compared to the 24 states that have enacted legislation for electric competition. The key challenge for harnessing wind power in the state is to get the transmission grid to consistently and efficiently transport the power back into the main system. There is a high desire for wind power in Texas. According to Wood, once green power programs were available in the state, people jumped on board so fast that the pilot had to be put off a year so enough power supply could be purchased. Wood thinks the demand will certainly outstrip the 3-percent mandate put into place by the state. Right now, constructing a wind power plant in Texas is actually less expensive than building a more traditionally fueled power plant. An ambitious mandate of having 2,000 MW of renewable resources by 2009 is fueling investors interest, sending millions of dollars to Texas for renewable projects, says Wood. Will Wood take his lessons and leadership to Washington D.C.? There are two open positions on the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), which is now chaired by Curt H,bert. For months, it has been rumored that Wood will be appointed by President Bush to assume one of those positions. When asked whether he had any potential interest in a role with FERC, Wood fielded the question diplomatically. He'll "leave that decision to the president," he said. Right now, Wood is focused on bringing electric competition to Texas. As noted, the state's pilot program for electric choice begins this June with full competition starting in January 2002. With regard to population, Texas represents the second largest energy market (behind California), offering a market value of about $20 billion. Thus, many eyes within the energy industry are anxiously watching to see how deregulation will unfold in the Lone Star State. In turn, Wood acknowledges that Texas officials have been watching California closely for the last year, and remain confident that the power supply problems faced there won't happen in Texas. This is largely because Texas has avoided making some of the critical mistakes made in California. One important distinction between the two states is that Texas regulators have allowed for power plants to be built in about half the construction time that has been common in other states such as California. Since 1995, 22 new plants have started operations in Texas, generating 5,700 MW. By the time competition begins fully in January 2002, 15 more plants and 10,000 MW are scheduled to come online. As a result, Texas officials say that*unlike California*their state has more than enough generating capacity to meet peak demand and provide at least a 15-percent reserve for the next few years. The vast majority of these new plants are fueled by natural gas, with wind power being a supplement. In addition, there are significant differences between the market structures in Texas and California. First, California's structure is based on an auction pool, which the state modeled on the United Kingdom. Integral to California's system is a Power Exchange, into which power suppliers submit power that they want to sell on the competitive market. California's PX discouraged a healthy bilateral contract market from forming because generators could make more money selling into the PX. Texas, on the other hand, has no Power Exchange and in fact has encouraged bilateral contracts as the way in which electric service contracts will take place. In Texas, customers are encouraged to establish long-term bilateral contracts with suppliers to secure the best rates, which introduces the opportunity to protect them from wholesale market prices as customers in San Diego discovered this summer. The market potential for Texas competition appears very strong, which perhaps more than anything else is due to good planning on the part of Texas legislators and regulators. However, there are still some lingering concerns about competition in the Lone Star State. First, there is a shortage of transmission lines in Texas, especially in the northern half of the state. Although PUCT officials say that sufficient transmission lines will be put into place before competition begins, without sufficient lines companies could experience transmission congestion. Another concern is that Texas may be relying too much on natural gas. Almost all of the new plants that have been built in Texas are powered by this fuel source. As the price of natural gas has remained high, this could pose a problem for the market in Texas. Hedging will be a key part of a successful strategy for any provider in Texas, especially considering the rising natural-gas prices. Still, the espoused advantages of competition (i.e., lower prices for end-users) could fall flat if so much emphasis is placed on natural gas as the primary power source in the state. Yet, ironically, customers may still benefit because of the multitude of power plants within the state. Abundant supply in Texas may keep the cost of power low for end-users, but less profitable for suppliers. Overall, though, Texas remains the bright shining hope for those who support energy deregulation in this country. The size of the state's energy market will continue to attract new participants, at least on the front end of the restructuring process. Whether they remain in Texas, and whether or not competition in the state will truly bring benefits to end-users, remains to be seen. An archive list of previous IssueAlerts is available at www.ConsultRCI.com [IMAGE] The most comprehensive, up-to-date map of the North American Power System by RDI/FT Energy is now available from SCIENTECH. Reach thousands of utility analysts and decision makers every day. Your company can schedule a sponsorship of IssueAlert by contacting Nancy Spring via e-mail or calling (505)244-7613. Advertising opportunities are also available on our website. SCIENTECH is pleased to provide you with your free, daily IssueAlert. Let us know if we can help you with in-depth analyses or any other SCIENTECH information products. If you would like to refer a colleague to receive our free, daily IssueAlerts, please reply to this email and include their full name and email address or register directly on our site. If you no longer wish to receive this daily email, send a message to IssueAlert, and include the word "delete" in the subject line. SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts(SM) are compiled based on the independent analysis of SCIENTECH consultants. The opinions expressed in SCIENTECH's IssueAlerts are not intended to predict financial performance of companies discussed, or to be the basis for investment decisions of any kind. SCIENTECH's sole purpose in publishing its IssueAlerts is to offer an independent perspective regarding the key events occurring in the energy industry, based on its long-standing reputation as an expert on energy issues. Copyright 2001. SCIENTECH, Inc. All rights reserved.