20 Sep 2000, 17:28 UTC
Re: Cal ISO Amendment 30 & Alliance RTO Filing
- From
- Susan J Mara susan.mara@enron.com
- Cc
- Mary Hain, Jeff Dasovich, Jeff Brown, Sarah Novosel, Joe Hartsoe, James D Steffes, Janine Migden, Carl Imparato
- Bcc
- Mary Hain, Jeff Dasovich, Jeff Brown, Sarah Novosel, Joe Hartsoe, James D Steffes, Janine Migden, Carl Imparato
- Date
- Wed, 20 Sep 2000 10:28:00 -0700 (PDT)
I have a pretty major philosophical disagreement with AMendment 30. I come from the camp that says we want an ISO that has minimal duties. If the ISO is able to enter into forward contracts, well ... how is that any different from a vertically-integrated utility? Let's see, so the ISO controls all the T and now will control some G. Aren't we concerned about that? I have heard from some that this is the "best solution" -- I need someone to explain to me why. To: Susan J Mara/SFO/EES@EES, Mary Hain/HOU/ECT@ECT, Jeff Dasovich/SFO/EES@EES, Jeff Brown/HOU/EES@EES, Sarah Novosel/Corp/Enron@Enron, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@Enron, James D Steffes/HOU/EES@EES, Janine Migden/DUB/EES@EES cc: Subject: Cal ISO Amendment 30 & Alliance RTO Filing EPSA needs feedback on Cal and Alliance filings and what position EPSA can take. Thoughts?
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
---------------------- Forwarded by Christi L Nicolay/HOU/ECT on 09/20/2000
03:32 PM ---------------------------
"Jackie Gallagher" <JGallagher@epsa.org> on 09/20/2000 03:07:06 PM
To: <bhawkin@enron.com>, <bmerola@enron.com>, <christi.l.nicolay@enron.com>,
<janelle.scheuer@enron.com>, <jhartso@enron.com>, <mary.hain@enron.com>,
<sarah.novosel@enron.com>, <tom.hoatson@enron.com>
cc:
Subject: Cal ISO Amendment 30 & Alliance RTO Filing
MEMORANDUM
TO: Regulatory Affairs Committee
Power Marketers Working Group
FROM: Don Santa, Regulatory Affairs Committee Chair
Joe Hartsoe, Power Marketing Working Group Chair
Julie Simon, Vice President of Policy
Mark Bennett, Senior Manager of Policy
DATE: September 20, 2000
RE: ? Cal ISO Amendment 30
? Alliance RTO Filing
Two issues arose on the weekly conference call today on which we need your
assistance and feedback. Please forward comments to Julie Simon at
202-789-7200 or jsimon@epsa.org by close of business on Monday, September
25th.
1. Cal ISO Amendment 30
On September 11, 2000 the Cal ISO filed Amendment No. 30 to its ISO Tariff at
FERC. In this filing, the Cal ISO is "reluctantly" asking FERC for authority
to buy forward contracts to meet its real-time balancing obligations. Costs
of the forward contracts would be allocated to Scheduling Coordinators who
deviate in real time from their schedules. Interventions and protests are
due on October 2nd.
While EPSA has consistently opposed an ISO role as market participant, there
are concerns here about the lack of alternatives available in California.
While an ISO's role in the real-time balancing market should be small, as a
practical matter, the Cal ISO has been forced to procure thousands of
megawatts in the real time markets. Thus, deciding how to approach this
filing balances difficult competing goals. Please let us know how you would
like EPSA to proceed.
2. Alliance RTO
On September 15th the Alliance RTO made a compliance filing at FERC seeking
to address all of FERC's concerns about its earlier proposals and purporting
to meet all the requirements of Order No. 2000. The filing retains a transco
structure, with a 5 percent ownership limitation for individual market
participants and a 15 percent ownership limitation on each class of market
participants. It also eliminates pancaked rates in favor of zonal, or
license plate, rates for deliveries within the Alliance and postage-rates for
through or out deliveries. While the geographic scope is unchanged, the
scope will be larger than any operating RTO. The filing includes a pro-forma
inter-RTO coordination agreement to address seams issues such as security
coordination, market monitoring, regional planning ATC and TTC calculations
and pricing reciprocity.
Until now, EPSA has not been a party to the Alliance proceeding. With this
latest filing it may be appropriate for EPSA to intervene, raising issues of
support or opposition to the filing. To determine how to proceed, however,
we need input from those companies that have been more closely involved in
the development of the Alliance. Please let us know how EPSA should proceed
with respect to this latest filing.
Jacqueline Gallagher
Research/Policy Assistant
Electric Power Supply Association
1401 H Street, NW
Suite 760
Washington, DC 20005
202.789.7200
202.789.7201
jgallagher@epsa.org