1 May 2001, 17:50 UTC
Fw: Cal-Tax e-Alert: Windfall Profits Tax Update
- From
- Jeff Dasovich jeff.dasovich@enron.com
- To
-
Alan Comnes, angela.schwarz@enron.com, beverly.aden@enron.com, bill.votaw@enron.com, brenda.barreda@enron.com, Carol Moffett, cathy.corbin@enron.com, Chris H Foster, christina.liscano@enron.com, craig.sutter@enron.com, Dan Leff, debora.whitehead@enron.com
and 86 more
Dennis Benevides, Don Black, Dorothy Youngblood, Douglas Huth, Edward Sacks, eric.melvin@enron.com, Erika Dupre, Evan Hughes, fran.deltoro@enron.com, gayle.muench@enron.com, Ginger Dernehl, Gordon Savage, Harold Buchanan, Harry Kingerski, Iris Waser, James D Steffes, James W Lewis, james.wright@enron.com, jeff.messina@enron.com, Jeremy Blachman, Jess Hewitt, Joe Hartsoe, Karen Denne, Kathy Bass, Kathy Dodgen, Ken Gustafson, kevin.hughes@enron.com, Leasa Lopez, Leticia Botello, Mark S Muller, marsha.suggs@enron.com, Marty Sunde, Meredith M Eggleston, Michael Etringer, Michael Mann, Michelle D Cisneros, mpalmer@enron.com, Neil Bresnan, Neil Hong, Paul Kaufman, paula.warren@enron.com, Richard L Zdunkewicz, Richard Leibert, Richard Shapiro, Rita Hennessy, Roger Yang, Rosalinda Tijerina, Sandra McCubbin, Sarah Novosel, Scott Gahn, Scott Stoness, Sharon Dick, skean@enron.com, tanya.leslie@enron.com, Tasha Lair, Ted Murphy, Terri Greenlee, Tim Belden, tony.spruiell@enron.com, Vicki Sharp, Vladimir Gorny, Wanda Curry, William S Bradford, Kathryn Corbally, Jubran Whalan, triley@enron.com, Richard B Sanders, Robert C Williams, Greg Wolfe, Dirk vanUlden, steve.walker@enron.com, Jennifer Rudolph, martin.wenzel@enron.com, Douglas Condon, wgang@enron.com, Scott Govenar, Hedy Govenar, JOHN G KLAUBERG, Mike D Smith, John Neslage, Janel Guerrero, Eric Letke, Gary S. Fergus, Michael Tribolet, Robert Frank, Susan J Mara - Date
- Tue, 1 May 2001 10:50:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Jeff Dasovich/NA/Enron on 05/01/2001 05:50 PM ----- "Chris Micheli" <cmicheli@carpentersnodgrass.com> 05/01/2001 04:05 PM To: "Susan McCabe" <smccabe@mccabeandcompany.net>, "Sue Mara" <smara@enron.com>, "Steven Kelley" <steven@iepa.com>, "Steve Ponder" <steve_ponder@fpl.com>, "Stephanie Newell" <stephanie-newell@reliantenergy.com>, "Scott Sadler" <sadlersa@earthlink.net>, "Scott Govenar" <sgovenar@govadv.com>, "Sandi McCubbin" <smccubbi@enron.com>, "Ron Tom" <rtom@govadv.com>, "Roger Pelote" <roger.pelote@williams.com>, "Robert Ross" <robbiz@cwo.com>, "Rina Venturini" <rventurini@teamgsi.net>, "Richard Hyde" <rwhyde@duke-energy.com>, "Rachel King" <rachel.king@elpaso.com>, "Phil Isenberg" <isenberg@hmot.com>, "Paula Soos" <paula_soos@covantaenergy.com>, "Mike Monagan" <mrmonagan@aol.com>, "Maureen O'Haren" <oharen@hmot.com>, "Marie Moretti" <mmoretti@mccabeandcompany.net>, "Lynn Lednicky" <lale@dynegy.com>, "Kent Palmerton" <kent.palmerton@williams.com>, "Katie Kaplan" <kaplan@iepa.com>, "Kassandra Gough" <kgough@calpine.com>, "Julee Ball" <jmball@ns.net>, "John Stout" <john_h_stout@reliantenergy.com>, "John Larrea" <john.g.larrea@williams.com>, "Joe Ronan" <joer@calpine.com>, "Jeff Dasovich" <jeff.dasovich@enron.com>, "Jean Munoz" <jmunoz@mcnallytemple.com>, "Jan Smutny Jones" <smutny@iepa.com>, "Jack Pigott" <jackp@calpine.com>, "Hedy Govenar" <hgovenar@govadv.com>, "Greg Blue" <gtbl@dynegy.com>, "Fred Pownall" <fred_pownall@ka-pow.com>, "Delaney Hunter" <dhunter@s-k-w.com>, "Chuck Cole" <ccole@advocation-inc.com>, "Bev Hansen" <bhansen@lhom.com>, "Anne Kelly" <kelly@hnks.com>, "Andy Brown" <abb@eslawfirm.com>, "John Norwood" <janorwood@norped.com>, "Pete Conaty" <pcaceo@pacbell.net>, "Matt Kilroy" <matt.kilroy@pge-corp.com>, "Cary Rudman" <cjrudman@softcom.net>, "Carolyn McIntyre" <cmcintyre@sempra.com>, "Barbara LeVake" <blevake@syix.com>, "Pat Pape" <ppape@calpine.com>, "Mohammed Alrai" <mohammeda@calpine.com>, "Kent Robertson" <kentr@calpine.com>, "Katherine Potter" <katherip@calpine.com>, "Juan Rodriguez" <juanr@calpine.com>, "Eileen Koch" <eileenk@calpine.com>, "Bill Highlander" <highlander@calpine.com>, "Aymee Ramos" <aymeer@calpine.com> cc: Subject: Fw: Cal-Tax e-Alert: Windfall Profits Tax Update ? ----- Original Message ----- From: Lisa Martin To: lisa@caltax.org Sent: Tuesday, May 01, 2001 1:41 PM Subject: Cal-Tax e-Alert: Windfall Profits Tax Update ? [IMAGE] Cal-Tax e-Alerts keep you informed on key tax and public policy issues?related to your industry as they develop.? We invite you to visit Cal-Tax Online (http://www.caltax.org) for more information on this and other Cal-Tax activities.? If you wish more information about Cal-Tax's e-Alerts or Cal-Tax Online, please contact Greg Turner at greg@caltax.org? If you wish not to be included on future Cal-Tax e-Alerts, please contact Betty Rickard at betty@caltax.org and your address will be removed from our distribution list. May , 2001? To:????????????Cal-Tax?Board of?Directors and Interested Parties??? From:????????Larry McCarthy, President? Subject:????Windfall Profits Tax Update?? This is?coverage that will appear in the next Caltaxletter, relating to the latest development of?the windfall profits tax legislation:?? ?WINDFALL PROFITS TAX ON ENERGY PRODUCERS HITS SENATE FLOOR? Majority Democrats muscled n?electricity &windfall profits8 tax bill to the Senate floor on Monday when the Appropriations Committee approved SB 1X (Soto), imposing a 100 percent excise tax on sales of electricity to California that exceed $80 per megawatt hour. With Senate President Pro Tem John Burton leading the charge, the fiscal panel approved the bill on a party-line 7-3 vote.?? Opponents testified that the bill would have a perverse result by discouraging investment in new energy generation in California despite a consensus over the need for additional power plants to add more electricity and rein in the costs. &While it makes good political theater, this bill does absolutely nothing to solve the energy crisis,8 said Mike Kahl, representing the Western States Petroleum Association and alternative energy providers. He said such a &confiscatory tax sends a perverse message8 to investors in electricity generation to avoid California. He also said it is a &transparent attempt8 to enact illegal price regulation of interstate commerce. Carrie-Lee Coke of the California Manufacturers and Technology Association said the bill is the &wrong medicine,8 would worsen the energy crisis by reducing supply, and would cause &financial disaster8 for CMTA members. Carl London, representing InterGen, an international energy generator, said SB 1X will scare away investment in badly needed power plants. &I can say with all certainty that the prospect of having this bill hanging out there8 will cause InterGen to stay away from California, he said. Senator Burton said the bill &says you can,t come in and rip us off. It doesn,t say you can,t come in and do business.8?? Senator Jack Scott, principal co-author of the bill, said, &We have been royally mistreated8 by energy providers headquartered in other states that have &gouged us like no consumer has been gouged in history.8 He said the bill still &guarantees a generous profit for wholesalers.8?? Revenue from the tax would be returned to California through income tax rebates. Since none of the revenue goes into the state,s general fund and would be returned to taxpayers, proponents contend that the revenue-neutral bill can increase a tax by mere majority-vote approval of the Senate and Assembly, not the two-thirds majorities required for tax increases in the state Constitution. Cal-Tax has long disagreed with this interpretation.? Supporters of the bill included Toward Utility Rate Normalization, representing &small8 ratepayers; the public-employee financed California Tax Reform Association; the California Public Interest Research Group; the California Labor Federation and the Service Employees International Union.? When Senator Jim Battin noted that the bill would impose windfall profits taxes on energy contracts negotiated by the Davis Administration (at $86 per megawatt hour), Senator Scott agreed to amend the bill to exempt existing contracts.? While Governor Gray Davis has indicated support for a windfall profits tax, his Department of Finance had no position at Monday,s hearing. A spokesperson said there was no analysis from the Franchise Tax Board on the impact on state revenues. The department also noted that a company would have to have nexus (physical presence) in California to be taxed, so at least some of the wholesalers could be immune. The department also expressed concern about how poor people would benefit if they don,t earn enough to file income tax returns.?? Co-authors Nell Soto and Scott accepted a number of amendments suggested by committee staff.? ? ? ? ? - e-alert3.gif