9 Nov 1999, 13:56 UTC
Re: Bandwidth Trading Article
- From
- Lisa Yoho lisa.yoho@enron.com
- To
- Scott Bolton
- Date
- Tue, 9 Nov 1999 05:56:00 -0800 (PST)
Group -- Thought you might be interested in this article I picked up on "forced access." Lisa
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
> NET ADVANTAGE - [Pittsburgh Post Gazette Editorial] Washington should > regulate access to the Web Monday, November 08, 1999 Pittsburgh > Post-Gazette How will most of us access the Internet in 10 years? Via > wireless technology? Satellites? Cable wire? DSL phone lines? Like most > smart people humbled by the rate of technological change, Federal > Communications Commission Chairman William Kennard does not know the > answer to that question. As a result, the commission is wary of treating > the cable industry, however promising its prospects, as the sole provider > of high-speed, broadband Internet access and thus deserving of a whole new > regulatory regime. Mr. Kennard knows how stifling that can be on a nascent > technology. Better for the federal government to allow competing channels > to the Internet to develop unimpaired, and intervene only when absolutely > necessary to ensure competition. Unfortunately, local regulators across > the country have been undermining this federal regulatory restraint by > imposing Internet-related burdens on cable companies at the municipal > level, egged on by a powerful lobbying alliance of regional phone > companies and Internet service providers. Ongoing negotiations to renew > the city's cable franchise agreement have made Pittsburgh the latest > ground zero in this ferocious and important battle to determine the future > of the nation's telecommunications policy. Pittsburgh City Council should > resist the lure of notoriety, take a pass, and recognize that major shifts > in national policy should be left to the Congress and to the Federal > Communications Commission. Council members should desist from forcing > AT&T to require "open access" to other Internet service providers as a > condition to a new cable franchise agreement. Beyond the fact that such a > move would be of dubious legality, it would also set Pittsburgh at a > competitive disadvantage in terms of broadband access to the Internet, as > AT&T would likely delay expanding service during a protracted legal > struggle. Franchise agreements between municipalities and cable companies > used to be fairly cut and dried. Within the parameters established by the > Federal Communications Commission, each side would haggle over > rights-of-way fees -- in Pittsburgh's case, some $3 million a year -- and > then call it a day. But no more. Last December, as a condition for > approving the transfer of the local cable franchise, Portland, Oregon > required AT&T to open its cable lines to rival Internet service-providers > (instead of necessarily bundling its own affiliate @Home with the > service). They did so under the banner of "open access," and each > subsequent franchise negotiation has been a major battle. A federal > appeals court is now determining whether Portland had the power to do so. > AT&T is betting heavily on cable as the Internet's future, having spent > more than $100 billion on cable companies, and billions more to update > their systems. It was through its $54 billion acquisition of TCI Inc. > early this year that AT&T picked up the cable franchise in Pittsburgh, as > well as its controlling stake in, and exclusive contract with, @Home. > Relatively few Americans now access the Internet via cable, but more and > more will be making the switch as AT&T and other cable players complete > the necessary investment. Cable access is dozens of times quicker than > your traditional phone dial-up service. Though America Online now has 20 > times more members than @Home, it and other established Internet providers > fear the potential of an AT&T monopoly as people flock over to cable. > America Online does not want its members to have to choose between it and > greater speed; it wants to keep its members, whether they opt to dial in > via Bell Atlantic's phone line, satellite, or AT&T's cable line. The > "open access" proponents argue that it undercuts consumer choice and > desirable competition to have @Home as the sole cable-based portal to the > Web. They point to the long-distance telephone market as a regulatory > model, in which one company controls the wire into consumers' homes, but > consumers are still able to choose service providers, which in turn pay > the wire owner for their traffic. This is a compelling vision, and may > in time become the desirable model for federal policy. But the > Post-Gazette believes that it is premature to rush to such a judgment. > AT&T may yet conclude that it is best served by opening up its wires to > all players as a means of hastening Internet consumers' migration to > cable. There have been reports of talks between AT&T and AOL about such a > possibility, and AT&T management has made no secret of its mixed feelings > about being tied to @Home. Second, it may be too early to discount faster > DSL phone lines, satellite and wireless technologies as viable > alternatives to access the Net. But even if one ascribes to the view that > a forced "open access" is needed now, the fight should be taken up in > Congress and at the FCC. It is absurd to believe that policy crucial to > the Information Age's nervous system can be cobbled together > municipality-by-municipality. Pittsburgh should join such cities as > Seattle and Los Angeles that have declined to throw up roadblocks to the > timely rollout of what potentially will be one of many faster roads > online.