8 Dec 2000, 13:33 UTC
Rebuttal Testimony in the Hydro Proceeding
- From
- JMB jbennett@gmssr.com
- Date
- Fri, 8 Dec 2000 05:33:00 -0800 (PST)
Roger -- As we talked about yesterday, we need to make a determination as to whether to file rebuttal testimony in the latest round of the PG&E hydro case. The sooner we make this determination the better so that MRW will have sufficient time to conduct any necessary discovery and hone their preliminary analysis. On the issue of valuation, there are now basically two "numbers" which have been presented to the Commission for consideration. The TURN/ORA analysis sticks with their $2.7 billion valuation (credited to the TRA), with 100% ( or something close there to) of the ongoing profits from the operation of the facilities (by PG&E) to be flowed through to ratepayer. PG&E (using Lehman Brothers) has also conducted a DCF analysis which results in a market value range of $3.7 to $4.5 billion (the analysis was done based on an assumed date for the transaction was January 1, 2001). The testimony states that the range of $3.9 to $4.2 billion is most reflective of the valuation which likely bidders would pay in a competitive auction. The preliminary analysis done by MRW (which you should have received via e-mail late in November), resulted in a current market value of the assets being $4.7 to $4.9 billion. MRW utilized the ORA/Turn model but revised the underlying price forecasts and the assumptions regarding ancillary services. Given the way the Commission is leaning these days (as represented by the recent PD on Mohave), there is a good chance that PG&E will not be allowed to auction off these assets, but must retain them. Therefore, the issue then becomes does the Commission go with a low valuation, with ongoing profits going to ratepayers (as proposed by TURN/ORA), or do they go for a high valuation, which would allow PG&E to make the valid argument that ongoing profits go to shareholders. The rest of the parties in the proceeding are not focusing on the valuation as much as they are market power and environmental issues. In other words, the likelihood of alot of opposition coming in on the TURN/ORA proposal is very low. If we are of the opinion, that the valuation should be high (even if the assets remain with PG&E), then we need to do some rebuttal. If you would like me to set up a conference call early next week with MRW and anybody at Enron you think should be involved, let me know. Given that the holidays are only a couple of weeks away, we did to reach some conclusions pretty fast. Jeanne