Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

11 Oct 1999, 08:54 UTC

Senate TVA hearing

From
Jeffrey Keeler jeffrey.keeler@enron.com
To
Cynthia Sandherr, Steven J Kean, Joe Hillings, Chris Long, Christi L Nicolay, James B Fallon, Ben Jacoby, David W Delainey, Barbara A Hueter
Date
Mon, 11 Oct 1999 01:54:00 -0700 (PDT)
EESI Environement & Energy Weekly -- October 11, 1999

Senate EPW panel hears differing views on changing TVA 

The federally owned Tennessee Valley Authority was put on the defensive at a 
Senate Environment and Public Works Committee hearing last week as its 
adversaries mounted an offensive against the power agency for its huge $27 
billion debt and unaccountability. 

With a bill (S. 1323), introduced by Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), serving as 
the backdrop, the need for changing TVA,s role in an emerging competitive 
electricity market was reviewed. 

TVA is one of the biggest power producers in the country, and it enjoys 
certain unfair privileges, according to investor-owned utilities, which are 
seeking changes to TVA to level the playing field in a competitive 
electricity market. 

McConnell,s bill is touted as making TVA more accountable by subjecting the 
power agency to, among other things, antitrust laws and to the jurisdiction 
of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. McConnell, who was present at 
the hearing, questioned TVA on its claim of providing low-cost power and why 
it should not be brought under FERC authority. 

Supporting the position of S. 1323, Robert Hewett representing TVA Watch, a 
coalition led by Duke Energy and other private utilities, decried the 
privileges TVA is endowed with. Hewett said TVA has the ability to set its 
own wholesale and retail rates, is exempt from anti-trust laws and makes only 
"token" payments in lieu of taxes to the local government. "No other entity 
in the country even comes close to having this type of authority or license," 
said Hewett. 

Hewett wants TVA to be subjected to antitrust laws and FERC jurisdiction. In 
addition, TVA must be restricted from building new generation capacity and it 
should not have preferential access to power from other federal facilities at 
rates below fair market value, Hewett recommended. 

Richard Munson, executive director, Northeast-Midwest Institute, continued on 
the same stream as Hewett, calling TVA a national problem. Munson said TVA,s 
inspector general in a recent report has highlighted "TVA,s most serious 
problem * its unaccountability." Decisions by TVA,s board of directors are 
not reviewed by state regulators or federal agencies and the power agency 
enjoys a monopoly in its service territory so it is not accountable even to 
market forces, according to Munson. Stating that TVA has been propped up by 
enormous taxpayer subsidies, Munson said, "The giant utility is exempt from 
hundreds of federal and state laws and regulations, it pays no federal or 
state taxes, and it obtains low-cost loans because of Washington,s +implied, 
support." 

But Mark Medford, TVA executive vice president, cautioned that proposals such 
as S. 1323 may risk compromising the low-cost, reliable electricity available 
to the Tennessee Valley region. 

Medford said S. 1323 would place new restrictions on TVA and expand 
regulation of TVA activities, which seems unusual in the context of a 
discussion of "deregulation" of the electricity industry. 

Medford also argued against FERC and state regulation of TVA prices and FERC 
determination of the need for new generation capacity. He said responsibility 
for fulfilling those missions is placed on the three-member TVA board 
nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate. Superimposing a 
higher regulatory body, such as FERC, "to pass judgment on the decision of 
the TVA board in these areas seems both duplicative and inappropriate." 

Medford also did not think that antitrust laws should be applied to TVA 
because it would be unfair to TVA ratepayers. "When a private utility 
violates the antitrust laws, its stockholders bear the cost. However, 
governmental entities like TVA have no stockholders, and the financial costs 
of such penalties have to be borne by the people who are supposed to be 
served," said Medford. 

Medford asserted that investors now hold all of TVA,s debt that finances the 
power program. He said TVA debt is neither backed by the federal government 
nor is it supported by mortgages on TVA plant property and equipment. It is 
secured solely by the financial operation of TVA as well as bond covenants 
and the provisions of the TVA Act, Medford said.

Also, Medford said TVA has been on the path of debt reduction in the last 
three years, bringing down the debt by $1 billion. 

Austin Caroll, representing the Kentucky Managers, Association, a group of 
municipal and rural electric cooperative utilities, did not totally agree 
with the principles of S. 1323, though it did want some changes to be made to 
TVA. 

Preceding the examination of S. 1323 was a hearing on the nomination of TVA 
board members -- Skila Harris and Glenn McCullough. 

Harris served until recently as the executive director of the Secretary of 
Energy Advisory Board, managing the work of the Tennessee Valley Advisory 
Committee, which comprises of representatives from groups interested in the 
future of TVA. 

McCullough previously served on the executive committee of the Mississippi 
Municipal League and as the director of the Mississippi office of the 
Appalachian Regional Commission. 

The TVA board of directors has three members serving nine year staggered 
terms.