28 Mar 2001, 03:42 UTC
California Power Crisis Update (No. 10)
- From
- suzanne_nimocks@mckinsey.com suzanne_nimocks@mckinsey.com
- Date
- Tue, 27 Mar 2001 19:42:00 -0800 (PST)
We have been pulling together these weekly(sometimes more often) summaries for internal purposes. Would you find it helpful to be on the distribution list? Hope you are doing well. Look forward to touching base soon.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Suzanne Nimocks/HOU/NorthAmerica/MCKINSEY on 03/28/2001
03:41 AM -----
Memorandum
TO: Pru Sheppard
BCC: Suzanne Nimocks
FROM: Pru Sheppard
B. Venki Venkateshwara
DATE: March 27, 2001
California Power Crisis Update (No. 10)
DEVELOPMENTS THIS WEEK, 3/23/2001
The weeks highlights include:
? Continued indications that the issue of market power and possible
remedies for it is likely to remain a high profile issue in
California and elsewhere (both retroactively and prospectively)
? An ironical situation with respect to QFs in which QF power under
contract is effectively being released into the market at higher
prices
? A court order requiring Reliant to continue to sell power to the
ISO even if it is not being paid in a full and timely manner
? Another Stage 3 emergency and rolling blackouts
Market power
There are continued indications that the issue of market power
will not be settled simply. This week there was a lengthy and
politically influential front page story in the New York Times about
FERCs passive approach to policing generators (Critics Say U.S.
Energy Agency Is Weak in Oversight of Utilities). The story was by
Jeff Gerth and Joseph Kahn. (Jeff Gerth's 1992 story on the
Whitewater deal is viewed by journalists to have been the origin of
what eventually became a multi-year investigation of Bill Clinton.)
The key issues are familiar:
? Does market power exist to a degree that warrants remedies such
as price caps, refunds, and so on?
? If so, what is the basis for asserting that market power exists
and what is the remedy? (See the discussion in the New York Times
article on the "good hours" vs. "bad hours" approach and the
associated political decision not to deal with "good hours").
? Can market power be used as leverage to eventually settle
generator bills in California at something less than 100 cents on the
dollar. (The California ISO filed a complaint claiming $6 billion
in overcharges this week.)
The QF irony
Through the 1990s, QF contracts were projected to be the source
of stranded costs because they were priced "way above market." In
recent months, in California, they look like a bargain (although some
are not such great bargains because a portion of their price is tied
to gas). You would think that the utilities would request QFs to
maximize their output. But credit problems have created an ironical
situation. The facts:
? PG&E and Edison have not been paying the QFs fully and promptly
for some time.
? The QFs form a creditors committee and threaten to push PG&E and
Edison into bankruptcy. (Some gas-fired QFs had to shut down because
they did not have money to pay for the gas.)
? Last week's court decision allows MidAmerican/CalEnergy to
essentially sell its power to others even though the QF contract
"dedicates" the output to the purchasing utility.
? CalEnergy does so immediately, selling to El Paso.
The Reliant Order
A court ordered Reliant to continue to sell to the ISO, when
requested, regardless of whether Reliant had been paid fully and
promptly for past deliveries to the ISO. Reliant announced it will
appeal the order.
This is somewhat of a contrast to the QF situation except that
the circumstances governing the 2 situations are probably different.
The QF contracts pre-date the ISO and are with the utilities and most
likely make no reference to providing power during emergencies. In
fact, many QF contracts have the opposite provision: authority for
the utility to cut takes during so-called "light load" periods.
Stage 3 emergency and rolling blackouts--again
There was another Stage 3 emergency in California ? with rolling
blackouts this week. This prompted everyone to wonder why this was
happening in March. Among the factors:
? Increased demand from summer-like temperatures
? Cutbacks in imports
? Loss of 1400 MW due to a transformer fire at an Edison plant
? Loss of about 3100 MW from QF plants that were forced to shutdown
because they could not afford gas bills (VV)
MARKET COMMENTARY
(For easier printing of all the articles in this section use the file
at the end of the section)
Critics Say U.S. Energy Agency Is Weak in Oversight of Utilities
By JEFF GERTH and JOSEPH KAHN
03/23/2001
The New York Times
Page 1, Column 1
c. 2001 New York Times Company
WASHINGTON, March 22 -- The pressure was intense when federal
regulators met
privately last month to debate remedies for soaring electricity
prices in
California.
Officials of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, the agency
whose mandate
is to ensure ''just and reasonable'' electricity rates nationwide,
had evidence
that a few companies had been selling electricity to California at
prices far
above the cost of generating it. The agency faced an imminent
deadline to
challenge those prices or let the companies possibly pocket hundreds
of millions
of dollars in unfair profits.
An internal memorandum laid out two choices. The agency could audit
and punish
''bad actors,'' the companies that were exploiting the market. Or it
could
identify ''bad hours,'' when electricity shortages were most acute
and spiking
prices were arguably nobody's fault, and order refunds for only the
most
exorbitant prices.
''It may be easier to identify bad hours than bad actors,'' the
memorandum said.
The commission took the easier way. It decided not to investigate
reports of
abuses by companies, but issued an order that could require them to
refund to
the state utilities up to $124 million collected during a relatively
few ''bad
hours'' in January and February. That is hundreds of millions of
dollars less
than California might have claimed, since the most potential
overcharging
occurred during ''good hours,'' when power was more plentiful but
prices were
often just as extreme. The order ignored those hours.
Today, in a criticism of the agency's lack of aggressiveness,
California
regulators estimated that generators had charged $6.2 billion above
competitive
levels over 10 months. They urged the agency to dig deeper, hoping it
would
demand more refunds or other stiff remedies. But the agency's track
record --
one of complacency in the eyes of state officials -- leaves
California
regulators skeptical that Washington will confront the big power
producers.
The small, obscure agency, tucked behind the rail yard of Union
Station here,
has largely soft-pedaled its role as the electricity industry's top
cop, even
though it has wide authority to keep power companies in line. To keep
rates
reasonable, it can impose price caps, strip companies of the right to
charge
market rates, force them to return excessive profits and even suspend
deregulation altogether.
Instead, the agency has largely left it to private companies to pry
open the
$250 billion electricity industry, which has historically been
controlled by
monopoly utilities and state officials. The agency's defenders,
including its
chairman, Curt Hebert Jr., a fierce advocate of unfettered markets,
say that its
largely hands-off approach reflects the delicate balancing of
competing
interests -- a commitment to protect consumers while not stifling
market forces.
But politicians, utility executives, energy economists and local
regulators say
California's rolling blackouts and skyrocketing electricity prices
are the signs
of a market running amok. They accuse the agency of standing aside as
companies
manipulate their way to windfall profits. The agency's critics, who
include one
of its own commissioners and numerous staff members, say that its
enforcement
mission has been blunted by free-market passions and the influence of
industry
insiders in its ranks.
When the agency began its first national investigation of high
electricity
prices last year, it named a newly recruited industry insider, Scott
Miller, to
lead the effort. Mr. Miller and his colleagues said in their report
that there
was ''insufficient data'' in California to prove any profiteering by
generating
companies. Yet his own former employer, PG&E Energy Trading, was at
the time a
subject of a civil antitrust investigation by the Justice Department
that
focused on electricity market abuses in New England.
The agency has given state regulators a lead role in monitoring local
power
markets. Yet even as these regulators have urged the agency to be
more
aggressive in investigating suspicions that companies have abused
their power in
California, New England, the Midwest and the mid-Atlantic, they have
frequently
been ignored or rebuffed.
Critics say that the agency began deregulation before it was ready or
willing to
make sure the markets worked effectively. They accuse it of showing
favoritism
to industry -- allowing companies, for example, to ignore
requirements to file
detailed reports of market transactions that are critical to proving
accusations
of market abuses.
''We need to wake up to the fact that this is a dysfunctional market
that is
being gamed and manipulated by those who participate in it,'' said
William
Massey, a commissioner of the agency who has become one of its
leading critics.
The agency's inaction, the critics say, leads to ''gaming'' --
jockeying for
profits that does not necessarily involve illegality -- and outright
market
manipulation. Consumers and utilities are the victims, paying
billions of
dollars more for electricity than if the markets were truly
competitive.
Agency officials acknowledge that enforcement of market rules to curb
gaming and
manipulation had not been a high priority in previous years. But they
defended
their recent California order as proof that they intend to keep
markets free of
abuse. They add that the agency is also pressuring two generators to
refund
almost $11 million for possibly manipulating the California market
last spring.
Agency officials and some outside analysts say that poorly conceived
deregulation plans by states, a shortage of power plants, rising
natural gas
prices, and even the weather have had more impact on electricity
prices than
abuses by companies or any failings by the agency. They say the
agency must
balance the competing interests of generators, local regulators and
utility
companies if it is to keep deregulation on track.
''We're trying to craft a system that gives breathing room to develop
a market,
but not so much room that undue market power punishes consumers,''
Mr. Hebert
said.
Fight Over Deregulation
Today's debate traces back to the 1930's, when President Franklin D.
Roosevelt
backed legislation to break up utility monopolies. The Federal Power
Act of 1935
gave the Federal Power Commission a mandate to ensure ''just and
reasonable''
electricity rates. The Federal Power Commission was abolished in 1977
and
replaced by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, an independent
agency with
1,200 employees that also oversees oil pipelines and the natural gas
market. The
president appoints the chairman and four commissioners -- two
Democrats and two
Republicans with staggered terms of five years. Two Republican seats
are
currently unfilled.
The deregulation of the electricity markets began in the late 1980's,
after the
agency had begun opening the gas markets. By 1996, the commissioners
issued a
landmark order that forced utility companies to open their
transmission lines to
other utilities and electricity wholesalers. The commission and many
private
economists expected that by prying open protected markets,
electricity prices
would immediately fall.
That possibility set off a deregulation frenzy, most prominently in
California,
New York, New England and the mid-Atlantic states. Generating
companies rushed
to expand in the new, borderless market.
But the agency's balancing act has grown more difficult as
electricity
deregulation has spread nationwide. Congress has forced it to trim
its staff in
recent years. Officials complain that investigating abuses in
electricity
markets strains their resources.
And as the California crisis has worsened, the commissioners have
begun sparring
publicly among themselves about what to do. This week, Mr. Massey, a
Democratic
commissioner, and Mr. Hebert (pronounced AY-bear), a Republican, sat
side by
side before a House panel and argued diametrically opposed positions.
Mr. Hebert
said high prices in California ''were sending the right signals to
get supply
there.'' Mr. Massey called the prices that generators were charging
''unlawful''
and said that his agency, by not reining them in, ''is simply not
doing its
job.''
The agency's leadership has been in flux for months. Congressional
and industry
officials in Washington say President Bush is considering replacing
Mr. Hebert,
whom he named to the top post less than two months ago, with Pat
Wood, who runs
the Texas public utility commission. A White House spokeswoman had no
comment on
the reports.
Though Mr. Hebert's positions are not far from those of the Bush
administration,
his relations with California leaders may have made his position
tenuous. Mr.
Hebert, a Mississippian who is a close ally of the Senate majority
leader, Trent
Lott, has warred with California politicians who have proposed new
solutions to
the crisis there.
Mr. Hebert, who has served as a commissioner since 1997, has often
taken the
most ideologically free-market position of any commissioner. He
flatly rejects
the idea of price caps on electricity as hopelessly ineffective and
contrary to
market forces. When Gov. Gray Davis outlined a plan to have the state
buy
transmission lines to relieve utility companies' debt, Mr. Hebert's
response was
dismissive. ''It's not in the interest of the American public,'' he
pronounced.
Even as new electricity markets opened in the summer of 1999, they
started
producing nasty shocks. The mid-Atlantic region experienced some
early
volatility.
As the turmoil grew, economists began raising the alarm about a
phenomenon
called ''market power,'' the ability of energy traders in the new
national
market to sustain prices above the competitive level. Proving such
abuses is
difficult, because it requires comparing tens of thousands of
separate
electricity transactions with the costs of the generators that
initiated them.
Joseph Bowring, who heads the market monitoring unit of the nonprofit
entity
that operates the mid-Atlantic transmission system, said that power
companies
there had exercised some market power. But only the Federal Energy
Regulatory
Commission, not local regulators, had the authority to collect the
data to
determine how much market power had been exercised and whether it had
been
abusive or not, he said.
Mr. Bowring said he talked to agency officials about doing so. In the
end, Mr.
Bowring and several agency officials said, the agency chose not to
investigate.
The decision roiled some agency officials.
Ron Rattey, a veteran agency economist, wrote a memorandum last June
describing
the staff as ''impotent in our ability to monitor, foster, and ensure
competitive electric power markets.'' The staff, the memorandum said,
did not
even enforce a requirement that power companies file detailed
quarterly reports
listing essentially every sale they make. Such data would have been
useful to
Mr. Bowring.
Local-Federal Clash
Local regulators who want to ensure competitive prices often have to
act on
their own. Monitors in New England have intervened about 600 times
since 1999 to
correct prices they determined had been caused, at least in part, by
market
manipulation.
The federal agency has sometimes chastised them for interfering too
much.
The industry, not surprisingly, shares that view. One vocal critic
was Mr.
Miller. Before the agency recruited him last July to head its
division of energy
markets, he was director of policy coordination for the national
energy-trading
unit of PG&E Corporation, the California holding company whose assets
also
include Pacific Gas and Electric, the California utility.
Although the utility has lost billions of dollars during California's
crisis,
Mr. Miller's former unit has become one of the most profitable new
energy
traders nationwide. PG&E Energy Trading, by several estimates, is now
the
second-largest seller of electricity in New England.
The company has had a rocky relationship with regulators. They
intervened
several times in 1999 and 2000 to retroactively cancel auctions they
said
produced excessive profits for PG&E and other companies. Mr. Miller
denounced
the practice, though he acknowledged in public testimony that his
company
sometimes charged ''very high'' prices when it could.
''One person's predatory pricing is another person's competitive
advantage,''
Mr. Miller said at a public hearing on deregulation in Texas in 1999.
New
England regulators too often acted as ''judge, jury and executioner''
when
overseeing the market, he said.
One year later, Mr. Miller and his new colleagues at the federal
agency got a
chance to examine New England's problems from the regulators'
perspective. Their
Nov. 1 report attributed New England's frequent price gyrations to
technical and
regulatory flaws.
As Mr. Miller's team was preparing its report, the Justice
Department, whose
threshold for stepping into possible industry wrongdoing is far
higher than the
agency's, began looking into whether price spikes in New England
pointed to
unlawful monopoly power or collusion, people contacted by the
department during
that inquiry said.
One subject of the civil inquiry is possible price manipulation in
one of New
England's ancillary services markets, people contacted by the
department said.
They said the department was examining whether PG&E and two other
companies
tried to corner that market for several months early last year. PG&E
confirmed
that the Justice Department had contacted it, but denies wrongdoing
and says it
has cooperated with the department's requests.
Mr. Miller has declined to comment on his role at PG&E or at the
agency. His
supervisors defended his work and said they had detected no conflict
of interest
between his work at PG&E and his duties at the agency.
Those duties brought Mr. Miller to California last August. With
electricity
prices there soaring, he and his colleagues sat down with several
utility
executives at the agency's San Francisco office.
One executive, Gary Stern, director of market monitoring for Southern
California
Edison, wanted the agency to stop what he suspected were market
abuses by power
generators. He provided a road map to help investigators figure out
how power
companies traded power contracts -- and whether they had manipulated
the
markets.
But when Mr. Miller and his team approached 11 generators and
marketers --
including his old employer -- a few weeks later, they did it their
way. They
asked eight questions, many of them imprecise, like: ''Describe your
strategy
for bidding generation resources into market.''
This question, Mr. Stern said in a recent interview, ''was equivalent
to asking
a suspected burglar how he spent his day.''
Some agency officials also thought the team should probe deeper. Mr.
Rattey
recommended that Mr. Miller seek the quarterly pricing reports that
marketers
were supposed to file. But his suggestion was not adopted, agency
records show.
Daniel Larcamp, Mr. Miller's supervisor, said ''there might have been
more
information that could have been obtained'' in the California
inquiry. But he
said the commission gave the staff only three months to finish,
making it
impossible to collect and analyze the reams of data involved.
For Mr. Miller, agency documents show, the investigation was so
time-consuming
that he had no time to fill out the financial disclosure form
required of new
federal employees. Mr. Miller submitted his form in late January,
after a
reporter requested it. Agency lawyers approved the form, but only
after he
provided additional information about his job and compensation from
PG&E. The
lawyers said Mr. Miller's participation had been permissible because
PG&E was
not the subject of the investigation.
When the staff report was issued on Nov. 1, it found high prices and
problems in
the design of the California market. But while the companies ''had
the potential
to exercise market power,'' the commission said, there was
''insufficient data''
to prove that they did.
Some marketers saw the report as an exoneration.
''This has been looked at several times, most notably by the FERC and
nobody has
found any evidence of market manipulation and profiteering,'' Rob
Doty, the
chief financial officer of Dynegy Inc., told a reporter earlier this
year.
California Inquiry
The agency has recently shown signs of wanting to apply pressure on
generators.
But its early efforts show how it is treading on new and uncertain
turf.
When the California crisis grew severe last December, the commission
issued a
refund order, a shot across the bow for generators charging high
prices. It
required them to submit detailed data any time they sold electricity
in
California for more than $150 per megawatt hour, considered at the
time a fair
estimate of the highest costs any of them faced.
It also told generators that for the next several months, they could
be forced
to give refunds if the agency found that they had charged excessive
prices. The
commission also said that it would examine bidding practices and
strategies for
withholding generating capacity to ferret out any efforts to
artificially raise
prices.
When the agency's own 60-day deadline for examining market data in
January
approached, however, it became clear that staff members had not made
any
detailed examination. Instead, staff members said, the agency
scrambled to forge
a last-minute compromise that would allow it to issue a statement
opposing high
prices in the state without a time-consuming investigation.
During this scramble, a senior staff member, Kevin Kelly, suggested
focusing on
bad hours instead of bad actors.
''Our attempts to find illegal behavior or legal 'misbehavior' by
sellers ('bad
actors') always seems to fail,'' his memorandum said. It said that
the agency
could more easily blame high prices on acute shortages during the
most critical
hours.
The suggestion won the day. The commission decided to limit its order
to the
hours when California declared a Stage 3 emergency, when supplies are
critically
low.
Mr. Stern of Southern California Edison and several private-sector
economists
have attacked the economic logic of that order. They said that the
commission
has focused on times when prices might be legitimately high. The
bigger worry:
Generators can and often do sustain artificially high prices when
supplies are
not as tight, they say.
Mr. Massey, the Democratic commissioner, dissented from the decision
for those
reasons. Because most high-priced transactions in January and
February did not
occur during bad hours, he argued, the commission effectively chose
to bless as
''just and reasonable'' the hefty profits generators are making from
the
California crisis.
''The problem with my agency is that we're so carried away with the
rhetoric of
markets that we've gotten sloppy,'' Mr. Massey said. ''We're talking
about
electricity. It's the juice of the economy, so it's got to be
available and
reasonably priced.''
Williams defends pricing of electricity
03/23/2001
Associated Press Newswires
Copyright 2001. The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
TULSA, Okla. (AP) - Williams Cos. Inc. says it can justify the rates
it charged
for wholesale power, despite accusations from federal regulators that
it sold
over-priced electricity to California.
Federal regulators claim Williams Energy Marketing and Trading Co., a
unit of
Tulsa-based Williams, owes California more than $40 million in
refunds for power
it sold to the state's Independent System Operator.
The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission says that Williams is one of
several
power providers responsible for $124 million in overcharges from
transactions in
January and February.
The Independent System Operator, which manages the state's power
grid, claims
the state was overcharged $6.2 billion by 21 wholesale power
providers,
including Williams, between May and February.
Williams says the rates it charged California were fair and were
based on
production costs and market conditions.
"Williams is confident that it performed within the guidelines
established by
the ISO," said Williams spokeswoman Paula Hall Collins. "We felt like
we had
worked within the regulations set up by ISO."
According to the commission, power prices levied by Williams in
January and
February exceeded federal price ceilings based on the cost of natural
gas and
other market conditions.
However, the price ceilings were established after the ISO accepted
Williams'
power prices, Collins said.
The commission will review Williams' explanation and either accept
the
justification or order the company to pay refunds.
Allegheny Energy makes big California connection
03/23/2001
Associated Press Newswires
Copyright 2001. The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
HAGERSTOWN, Md. (AP) - Allegheny Energy Inc. said Thursday it has
agreed to sell
$4.5 billion worth of power to California's electricity-purchasing
agency over
the next 10 years.
The company said the contract call for Allegheny to provide up to
1,000
megawatts that the Hagerstown-based company has secured from western
generating
plants through its new energy trading division, Allegheny Energy
Global Markets
- formerly Merrill Lynch Global Energy Markets.
"This is a win-win for both the state of California and Allegheny
Energy. It
provides a long-term source of fixed-price energy and should help to
stabilize
prices in California," said Michael P. Morrell, president of the
Allegheny
Energy Supply division.
Allegheny Energy is the parent of Allegheny Power, which delivers
electric
energy and natural gas to parts of Maryland, Ohio, Pennsylvania,
Virginia and
West Virginia.
Williams plans expansion of pipeline to help power Calif.
03/23/2001
Associated Press Newswires
Copyright 2001. The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
SALT LAKE CITY (AP) - The Williams Cos. plans to expands its Kern
River
pipeline, which runs through Utah, to provide more natural gas for
generating
plants in California.
Williams' gas pipeline unit in Salt Lake City said Thursday that it
plans to
construct nearly 700 miles of additional pipeline that will run
parallel to its
existing Kern River line.
Construction on the $1 billion project is expected to begin next year
and is
scheduled for completion in May 2003, said Kirk Morgan, director of
business
development for Kern River pipeline.
"Shippers are seeking more access to natural gas from the Rocky
Mountain basin,
where producers are aggressively stepping up production," Morgan
said.
The new pipeline is expected to deliver about 900 million cubic feet
of natural
gas per day to markets in Utah, Nevada and California.
Most of the gas will be used for generating plants planned in
California. If all
of the pipeline's capacity were used to generate electricity, it
could produce
about 5,400 megawatts. "That is enough to light around 4.5 million
homes,"
Morgan said.
The original Kern River line was completed in 1992. It enters Utah
from Wyoming
then crosses into the Salt Lake Valley near Bountiful. It turns south
near the
Salt Lake City International Airport then runs the length of the
state before
passing into southern Nevada and winding up near Bakersfield, Calif.
It currently transports 700 million cubic feet of natural gas per
day. Williams,
based in Tulsa, Okla., recently filed an emergency application with
federal
regulators to install additional pumping stations on the line to
increase its
capacity by 135 million cubic feet per day. That $81 million pumping
station
project should be completed by July 1.
During the 2002 construction period, the Kern River project will
employ between
1,500 and 1,800 people. The company estimates annual property taxes
it pays to
Utah counties will increase from $3.5 million to about $7 million.
Questar will be one of the customers on the new pipeline, Morgan
said.
The utility wants to supply additional gas to southern Utah cities,
including
St. George and Cedar City.
"Our own pipelines serving southern Utah are at full capacity so this
is an
opportunity to transport additional gas into those areas from
company-owned
supplies in Wyoming," said Questar Gas spokeswoman Audra Sorensen.
Calif Energy Commission OKs 3 Pwr Plants Worth 2,076 MW
03/23/2001
Dow Jones Energy Service
(Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.)
(This article was originally published Thursday)
LOS ANGELES -(Dow Jones)- The California Energy Commission Wednesday
approved
three power plants worth 2,076 megawatts, two of which are scheduled
to come on
line by the end of 2002, a CEC spokesman said Thursday.
The plants approved include BP Amoco PLC (BP) unit ARCO Western
Energy's 500
megawatt Western Midway Sunset Project, slated to come on line in
October 2002;
Caithness Energy's 520 MW Blythe Power Plant, to come on line by Dec.
31, 2002;
and Thermo Ecotek's 1,056 MW Mountainview Power Plant, scheduled to
come on line
in April 2003.
All three of the new plants will be natural gas-fired combined-cycle
plants.
The $550 million Mountainview plant will be located in Southern
California, near
San Bernadino. The $300 million Western Midway-Sunset plant will be
located in
central Kern County, while the $250 million Blythe plant will be
located in the
city of Blythe in Riverside County.
The latest approvals bring to 13 the total number of plants approved
since April
1999 by the CEC, a spokesman said. Those plants will supply 8,405 MW
to the
state, which has seen rolling blackouts and spiking wholesale power
prices in
the last six months, in part due to lack of supply.
-By Jessica Berthold, Dow Jones Newswires; 323-658-3872;
jessica.berthold@dowjones.com
Some CalEnergy Power Could Be Sold Outside Calif - CEO
03/23/2001
Dow Jones Energy Service
(Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.)
(This article was originally published Thursday)
LOS ANGELES -(Dow Jones)- Some of CalEnergy Operating Corp's power
could end up
being sold outside of California, though that is not the company's
intent,
CalEnergy Chairman and CEO David Sokol said in a conference call
Thursday.
CalEnergy, an affiliate of MidAmerican Energy Holdings Co, which is
majority
owned by Warren Buffett's Berkshire-Hathaway (BRKA), was given legal
authority
Thursday to suspend 270 megawatts of power delivery to Edison
International
(EIX) utility Southern California Edison and sell on the open market,
because
SoCal Edison has not paid its bills since November.
CalEnergy stopped supplying power to SoCal Ed immediately following
the court
ruling.
"We stopped supplying power at 1 PM (PST) and have been selling to
parties that
will pay since then....We are selling it to marketers; our current
marketing
agent is El Paso Corp (EPG) and they will sell it for us," Sokol
said.
Sokol added that while it was his company's intention to have its
power sold to
California, that could not be guaranteed.
"We leave the energy selling to El Paso....We've directed them that
we would
like the power to stay in California but we can't stop them," from
selling out
of state, Sokol said.
Wholesale prices on the open market are about $400-$500 a
megawatt-hour, three
times more than what the company had received under its contract with
SoCal Ed.
The court's ruling did not address the $45 million SoCal Ed still
owes CalEnergy
for November and December power, and Sokol said that his company's
separate
lawsuit on that matter sought to attach the utility's assets as
payment for that
debt.
Sokol said the court's ruling had "significant implications" for the
entire
community of small, independent generators, known as qualifying
facilities or
QFs, who have not received payment from SoCal Ed.
"Edison's own lawyer said it best....that every QF in the state will
begin to
mitigate if the judge allowed us (to sell on the open market)," Sokol
said.
Sokol said his company was prepared to push SoCal Ed into involuntary
bankruptcy
Friday if CalEnergy hadn't won the case, but said he couldn't
speculate whether
other QFs may be more or less inclined to do so as a result of the
court
outcome.
A group of renewable power suppliers, owed more than $100 million
from SoCal Ed,
said late Wednesday they want state lawmakers to release them for
their supply
contracts with PG&E Corp. (PCG) unit Pacific Gas & Electric and SoCal
Ed until
the utilities are restored to financial stability.
The utilities claim close to $13 billion in undercollections due to
an inability
to pass high wholesale power costs to customers under a rate freeze.
In a statement, SoCal Ed said it opposed CalEnergy's bid to suspend
its QF
contract because the utility believed Gov. Gray Davis and state
regulators are
close to resolving "very legitimate financial concerns of CalEnergy
and other QF
suppliers."
SoCal Ed said it was concerned that CalEnergy's request to sell to
third parties
would lead to a major supply shortage in California.
The utility said it has informed the QFs that it is working to
resolve the issue
without giving unfair advantage to one class of creditors.
While many of the state's large power suppliers have been paid by on
a forward
basis for the power they sell into California, the QFs, which make up
one-third
of the state's total power supply, haven't been paid by SoCal Ed
since November.
PG&E has made partial payments to its QFs.
-By Jessica Berthold, Dow Jones Newswires; 323-658-3872,
jessica.berthold@dowjones.com
(Jason Leopold contributed to this article.)
California and the West Judge Frees Small Firm From Edison Contract
KEN ELLINGWOOD; DAN MORAIN
TIMES STAFF WRITERS
03/23/2001
Los Angeles Times
Home Edition
A-3
Copyright 2001 / The Times Mirror Company
El CENTRO -- California's balance of electrical power shifted
slightly Thursday
when an Imperial County judge temporarily freed a small geothermal
energy
producer from its contract with Southern California Edison, allowing
it to sell
power on the open market.
The ruling by Superior Court Judge Donal B. Donnelly could lead to a
mass exodus
by hundreds of small energy producers that have been selling power to
the
state's financially troubled utilities for months without getting
paid.
At the same time, it may have staved off plans by a group of the
small
generators to send Edison into involuntary bankruptcy as early as
today.
In Sacramento, energy legislation pushed by Gov. Gray Davis passed in
the state
Senate but foundered in the Assembly. The measure was intended to
ensure that
the state gets repaid for the electricity that it has been buying on
behalf of
Edison and Pacific Gas & Electric, which say they lack the cash and
credit to
purchase power. The bill also was supposed to guarantee that the
small,
alternative energy producers--which together provide nearly a third
of the
state's power--get paid. But Assembly Republicans opposed it, saying
it hadn't
been given sufficient scrutiny.
The impact of the small producers was made clear in Imperial County,
where
Edison's failure to pay CalEnergy, the county's biggest property
taxpayer, had
outsize implications. CalEnergy had put county officials on notice
that it was
about to miss a $3.8-million property tax payment. The uncertainty
had prompted
the tiny Calipatria Unified School District to postpone a bond issue
for badly
needed school repairs.
Among CalEnergy Chairman David Sokol's first acts after the judge's
ruling
Thursday was to promise Imperial County Supervisor Wally J.
Leimgruber that the
company would pay its property taxes on time.
"That is great news," Leimgruber said.
Within hours of its court victory, CalEnergy had stopped transmitting
geothermal
power to Edison and begun selling it to El Paso Energy, a marketing
company that
purchased the energy at prevailing rates and resold it on the spot
market.
Some of the more than 700 other small energy producers in the state
said they
were considering similar action against Edison and Pacific Gas &
Electric.
"We absolutely need the right to sell to third parties," said Dean
Vanech,
president of Delta Power, a New Jersey company that owns five small
gas-fired
plants in California and is owed tens of millions of dollars by
Edison.
Sokol praised the Imperial County judge and said his company simply
wanted the
authority to sell its power "to a credit-worthy company that, in
fact, pays for
the power."
An Edison spokesman said the company was disappointed with the
ruling, but
sympathized with CalEnergy and other small producers because
"California's power
crisis has placed [them] in financial distress, just as it has placed
utilities
in financial distress."
Edison expressed concern that the ruling would prompt CalEnergy and
other small
producers to sell their power out of state. Sokol said CalEnergy had
specifically told El Paso Energy that it hoped its power would remain
in
California, "but if someone wants to pay a higher price out of state,
we can't
stop them."
Sokol said that Edison still owes CalEnergy $140 million and that the
company--along with seven other small producers--had been prepared to
file a
petition in federal bankruptcy court in Los Angeles today forcing the
utility
into involuntary bankruptcy. He said his company no longer intends to
do so, and
he believed--but wasn't certain--that the other companies would
shelve their
plans.
Edison filed papers Thursday with the federal Securities and Exchange
Commission
showing that it owed $840 million to various small electricity
producers, many
of which rely on renewable energy sources such as geothermal steam,
solar energy
or wind.
The alternative energy producers--and utilities--strenuously objected
to the
legislation considered in Sacramento on Thursday. The bill, spelling
out how the
utilities are to pay the state and the small producers, passed the
Senate on a
27-9 vote, the exact two-thirds margin required. But it stalled in
the Assembly
on a 46-23 party-line vote, well short of two-thirds.
"When I was a citizen back in Lancaster, I heard these stories about
pieces of
legislation that were cooked up late at night, that . . . were cut
and pasted
together and were rammed through by the Legislature," Assemblyman
George Runner
(R-Lancaster) said. "That's exactly what we have before us."
The alternative electricity generators, including oil companies,
warned that
they would lose money under the Davis proposal, while representatives
of Edison
and PG&E, which have amassed billions in debt in the worsening energy
crisis,
said the legislation would push them deeper into the hole.
"There isn't enough money," Edison attorney Ann Cohn testified at a
Senate
hearing on the bill Thursday. "It is a very simple question: Dollars
going out
cannot be greater than dollars coming in."
The bill, AB 8X, combined several proposals. First, it sought to
clarify earlier
legislation by spelling out that Edison and PG&E must pay the state
all money
collected from consumers for electricity that the state has been
buying.
Additionally, the bill would turn over to the California Public
Utilities
Commission the thorny issue of how much to pay alternative energy
producers for
their electricity.
Wind, solar and geothermal producers might agree to the prices
offered by the
administration. But most of the alternative energy producers,
including Chevron
and British Petroleum, use natural gas to generate electricity
through
"cogeneration," a process of creating steam for both electric
generation and
heat. With natural gas prices high, they contend, they would lose
money at the
prices Davis is offering.
*
Ellingwood reported from El Centro, Morain from Sacramento. Times
staff writers
Mitchell Landsberg in Los Angeles and Jenifer Warren, Nancy Vogel and
Carl
Ingram in Sacramento contributed to this story.
(BEGIN TEXT OF INFOBOX / INFOGRAPHIC)
Power Points
Background
The state Legislature approved electricity deregulation with a
unanimous vote in
1996. The move was expected to lower power bills in California by
opening up the
energy market to competition. Relatively few companies, however,
entered that
market to sell electricity, giving each that did considerable
influence over the
price. Meanwhile, demand has increased in recent years while no major
power
plants have been built. These factors combined last year to push up
the
wholesale cost of electricity. But the state's biggest
utilities--Pacific Gas &
Electric and Southern California Edison--are barred from increasing
consumer
rates. So the utilities have accumulated billions of dollars in debt
and,
despite help from the state, have struggled to buy enough
electricity.
*
Daily Developments
* Overcharges by major electricity suppliers were estimated at $6.3
billion, up
from the $5.5 billion first thought, California's power grid operator
said.
* Electricity producers denied that they have profiteered and argued
that
Cal-ISO's figures don't take into account all their costs.
* A Superior Court judge's ruling Thursday freeing a small producer
from its
contract with Edison could lead to a mass exodus by small energy
producers that
have been selling to the utilities without getting paid.
*
Verbatim
"If these guys have such high costs ... how come they're making so
much money?"
--Gary Stern, Edison's director of market monitoring and analysis,
referring to
power producers
Complete package and updates at www.latimes.com/power
Grid Operator Says California Paid Too Much for Power
By Rebecca Smith and John R. Emshwiller
Staff Reporters of The Wall Street Journal
03/23/2001
The Wall Street Journal
A2
(Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.)
California's electric-grid operator said power suppliers may have
overcharged
the state and its utilities by $6.2 billion, or a total of 30%, in a
10-month
period, and has asked federal regulators to step up their policing of
electricity markets.
Meanwhile, a California state judge handed down a decision involving
small power
producers that could result in more electricity being made available
in the
energy-starved state, but likely at greater cost to the state
government.
The $6.2 billion figure was contained in a market analysis by the
California
Independent System Operator filed yesterday with the Federal Energy
Regulatory
Commission. The ISO says it isn't seeking a refund -- for the May
through
February period -- because its analysis lacked important market data.
For example, it estimated costs for 21 suppliers based on published
prices for
natural gas, not on specific data showing what each generator
actually paid for
the fuel. "We don't know how much gas actually was purchased at
spot-market
prices," said Anjali Sheffrin, the ISO's head of market analysis.
Charles Robinson, general counsel for the ISO, said FERC needs to
become "more
aggressive about market-power mitigation." The ISO's filing, he said,
was
intended to push the agency in that direction, since FERC is
responsible for
policing deregulated electricity and natural-gas markets.
He said that if the FERC doesn't act, the state of California may
find ways to
discipline the market, such as through the state attorney general's
office. The
attorney general has been investigating the state's electricity
market for many
months but hasn't brought any court action.
Dynegy Inc., a big owner of power plants in California, said it will
provide
additional information to FERC supporting its position that the
prices it has
charged for power have been "just and reasonable." The Houston
company was one
of 13 energy suppliers that the FERC this month ordered to pay
refunds totaling
$124 million or "show cause" why it should be excused. Dynegy said
the FERC
analysis was flawed, because it used "inaccurate" prices for natural
gas and
pollution credits.
While big power producers such as Dynegy came under attack, small
power
producers won a potentially significant victory in a state court in
Southern
California's Imperial County. A judge granted 10 geothermal plants
operated by
the CalEnergy Co. unit of MidAmerican Energy Holdings Co., a unit of
Berkshire
Hathaway Inc., of Omaha, Neb., permission to suspend deliveries of
electricity
to Southern California Edison Co. and instead seek other buyers.
These plants, known as "qualifying facilities," are under long-term
contract to
Edison and other utilities but haven't been paid for months. Edison,
a unit of
Edison International, of Rosemead, Calif., says it has been unable to
pay
hundreds of millions of dollars in power bills to CalEnergy and
others because
it has been driven to the brink of insolvency by the state's failed
utility-deregulation plan.
While the CalEnergy case involves only about 320 megawatts of power,
the
repercussions could be far greater. Collectively, hundreds of
qualifying
facilities, or QFs, produce as much as 30% of California's
electricity needs.
QFs totaling 3,000 megawatts cut their production in recent weeks for
lack of
payment. This loss of output was a significant cause of the blackouts
that hit
California this week.
Observers believe the CalEnergy court decision could give other QFs
an
opportunity to sell power in the open market, presumably to the state
government
that now is California's biggest energy buyer. An hour after the
court decision
yesterday, some 400 megawatts of power came back into the market, the
ISO said.
However, additional QF power sales on the open market could
substantially
increase the state's tab. Already, the state has allocated more than
$4 billion
for electricity purchases.
Separately, Edison said in a Securities and Exchange Commission
filing that its
unpaid power bills could contribute to a write-off of as much as $2.7
billion
for 2000. Because of uncertainty caused by the energy crisis, the
company hasn't
yet reported year-end earnings.
Power regulators debate who should be exempted from blackouts
By KAREN GAUDETTE
Associated Press Writer
03/22/2001
Associated Press Newswires
Copyright 2001. The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) - State power regulators said Thursday they are
working to
exempt all California hospitals, regardless of size, from rolling
blackouts.
The Public Utilities Commission met with representatives from
hospitals and
investor-owned utilities after Los Angeles lawyer David Huard filed
an emergency
motion with the PUC on behalf of more than 500 hospitals throughout
the state.
Under PUC rules, hospitals with more than 100 beds are exempt from
losing
electricity during power emergencies. But during rolling blackouts
Monday, at
least a dozen hospitals from Long Beach to Clearlake were forced to
use their
backup generators.
Pacific Gas and Electric Co. and Southern California Edison Co. say
they blacked
out those hospitals specifically because they have backup generators.
Both
utilities said the temporary blackouts were part of their overall
efforts to
spread the burden of blackouts over more of their customers.
Linda Ziegler, director of business and regulatory planning for SoCal
Edison,
said the utility is following state law and will implement new
guidelines if the
PUC changes them.
But hospitals say there is a 10-second lapse before emergency
generators kick
in, which could harm patients in the midst of delicate surgical
procedures such
as organ transplants or brain surgery.
"You wouldn't fly a plane with only your emergency backup systems in
place,"
said Ann Mosher, a spokeswoman for California Pacific Medical Center
in San
Francisco. "Backup generators are just that, they're not designed to
keep the
hospital up and running at full capacity."
Ziegler said that power still goes out for reasons beyond the energy
crisis,
from incidents like lightning or a knocked-down power pole.
"If it's a serious problem for the hospital it's certainly something
they should
be address just from an ongoing basis," she said.
The exemption would cover all hospitals within the territory of the
state's
investor owned utilities PG&E, Southern California Edison and San
Diego Gas and
Electric.
Hospitals within the range of municipally owned utilities, such as
the Los
Angeles Department of Water and Power, are separately regulated.
For more than two decades, prisons, hospitals with more than 100 beds
and
emergency services such as fire and police departments have been
classified as
"essential" services, and are exempted from blackouts by order of
state power
regulators.
After rolling blackouts began darkening the state in January, many
other public
service groups began seeking relief from power interruptions,
including transit
systems, schools and water districts.
---
On the Net:
http://www.cpuc.ca.gov
Federal Judge Orders Reliant To Keep Selling Pwr To Calif
03/22/2001
Dow Jones Energy Service
(Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.)
SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP)--A federal judge issued a preliminary
injunction
Wednesday ordering a major electricity wholesaler to continue selling
to
California despite its fear that it will not get paid.
U.S. District Judge Frank C. Damrell Jr. said Californians were at
risk of
irreparable harm if Reliant Energy (REI) stopped selling power to the
Independent System Operator, which oversees the state's power grid.
The ISO buys
last-minute power on behalf of utilities to fill gaps in supply.
Damrell dismissed Reliant's attempt to force the state Department of
Water
Resources to back the ISO's purchases for the state's two biggest
utilities. The
state has been spending about $50 million a day on power for Pacific
Gas and
Electric Co. and Southern California Edison, both denied credit by
suppliers
after amassing billions of dollars in debts.
The judge said he had no authority to force the DWR to pay for that
power.
Gov. Gray Davis has said the state isn't responsible for purchasing
the costly
last-minute power ISO buys for Edison and PG&E, despite a law
authorizing state
power purchases on the utilities' behalf.
ISO attorney Charles Robinson said the ruling gives ISO operators "a
tool to
assist them in keeping the lights on in California."
"Had the decision gone the other way, one could expect other
generators to
simply ignore emergency orders," Robinson said.
Damrell's preliminary injunction will remain in effect until the
Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission rules on the matter.
Damrell denied the ISO's request for preliminary injunctions against
three other
wholesalers - Dynegy Inc. (DYN), AES Corp. (AES) and Williams Cos.
(WMB) - which
agreed to continue selling to the ISO pending the FERC ruling.
Spokesmen for Reliant, Dynegy, AES and Williams were out of the
office Wednesday
night and didn't immediately return calls from The Associated Press
seeking
comment on the ruling.
The ISO went to court in February after a federal emergency order
requiring the
power sales expired. The judge then issued a temporary restraining
order,
requiring the sales, but dropped it after the suppliers agreed to
continue sales
to California pending his Wednesday ruling.
The ISO said it would lose about 3,600 megawatts if the suppliers
pulled out,
enough power for about 2.7 million households. One megawatt is enough
for
roughly 750 homes.
Grid officials said Reliant's share alone is about 3,000 megawatts.
Reliant said
the amount at issue actually is less than a fourth of that, because
most of its
output is already committed under long-term contracts.
Reliant, which currently provides about 9% of the state's power,
worries it
won't get paid due to the financial troubles of PG&E and Edison. PG&E
and Edison
say that together they have lost about $13 billion since June due to
soaring
wholesale electricity costs that California's 1996 deregulation law
bars them
from passing onto customers.
Calif Small Pwr Producers To Shut Plants If Rates Capped
By Jason Leopold
Of DOW JONES NEWSWIRES
03/22/2001
Dow Jones Energy Service
(Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.)
LOS ANGELES -(Dow Jones)- Many of California's independent power
producers late
Wednesday threatened to take their small power plants offline this
week if state
lawmakers pass legislation that would cap the rates the generators
charge for
electricity they sell directly to the state's three investor-owned
utilities.
At issue is a bill that would repeal a section of the state's Public
Utilities
Code, which links the 688 so-called qualifying facilities'
electricity rates to
the monthly border price of natural gas.
Lawmakers, however, are poised to pass the legislation.
State regulators are then expected to approve a measure that would
restructure
the fluctuating rates the QFs charge PG&E Corp. (PCG) unit Pacific
Gas &
Electric, Edison International (EIX) unit Southern California Edison,
and Sempra
Energy (SRE) unit San Diego Gas & Electric from $170 a megawatt-hour
to
$69-$79/MWh, regardless of the price of natural gas.
Whereas each of the 688 QF contracts differed, largely because
natural gas
prices are higher in Southern California than Northern California,
the state
wants the QFs to sign a general contract with the utilities.
The cogeneration facilities, which produce about 5,400 megawatts of
electricity
in the state, said the rates are too low and they won't sign new
supply
contracts with the utilities.
"For $79/MWh, natural gas would have to be $6 per million British
thermal unit
at
the Southern California border," said Tom Lu, executive director
of
Carson-based Watson Cogeneration Company, the state's largest QF,
generating 340
MW. "Our current gas price at the border is $12.50."
Other gas-fired QFs said the state could face another round of
rolling blackouts
if lawmakers and state regulators pass the legislation, which is
expected to be
heard on the Senate floor Thursday, and allow it to be implemented by
Public
Utilities Commission next week.
Lu, whose company is half-owned by BP Amoco PLC (BP) and is owed $100
million by
SoCal Ed, said the proposals by the PUC and the Legislature "will
only make
things worse."
David Fogarty, spokesman for Western States Petroleum Association,
whose members
supply California with more than 2,000 MW, said the utilities need to
pay the
QFs more than $1 billion for electricity that was already produced.
State Loses 3,000 MW QF Output Due Of Financial Reasons
The QFs represent about one-third, or 9,700 MW, of the state's total
power
supply. Roughly 5,400 MW are produced by natural gas-fired
facilities. The rest
is generated by wind, solar power and biomass.
About 3,000 MW of gas-fired and renewable QF generation is offline in
California
because the power plant owners haven't been paid hundreds of millions
of dollars
from cash-strapped utilities SoCal Ed and PG&E for nearly four
months.
Several small power plant owners owed money by SoCal Ed have
threatened to drag
the utility into involuntary bankruptcy if the utility continues to
default on
payments and fails to agree to supply contracts at higher rates.
The defaults have left many of the renewable and gas-fired QFs unable
to operate
their power plants because they can't afford to pay for the natural
gas to run
their units. Others continue to produce electricity under their
contracts with
the state's utilities but aren't being paid even on a forward basis.
The California Independent System Operator, keeper of the state's
electricity
grid, said the loss of the QF generation was the primary reason
rolling
blackouts swept through the state Monday and Tuesday.
Gov. Gray Davis, recognizing the potential disaster if additional QFs
took their
units offline, held marathon meetings with key lawmakers Monday and
Tuesday to
try and hammer out an agreement that would get the QFs paid on a
forward basis
and set rates of $79/MWh and $69/MWh for five and 10 year contracts.
He also
said he would direct the PUC to order the utilities to pay the QFs
for power
they sell going forward.
"After next week the QF problem will be behind us," Davis said
Tuesday. "We want
to get the QFs paid...the QFs are dropping like flies...and when that
happens
the lights go out."
But this just makes the problem worse, said Assemblyman Dean Florez,
D-Shafter,
a member of the Assembly energy committee.
"I don't know how we are going to keep the lights on," Florez said in
an
interview. "Many of these congenerators are in my district. They said
if the
legislation doesn't change they are going offline. This compounds the
issue of
rolling blackouts, especially now when we need every megawatt."
Davis, who didn't meet with people representing the QFs, said he was
handing the
QF issue to the PUC because lawmakers failed to pass legislation that
would have
set a five-year price for natural gas and allow the QFs to sign
individual
contracts with the utilities. In addition, SOCal Ed opposed the
legislation,
saying the rates should be below $50/MWh.
Some renewable power producers said they aren't vehemently opposed to
the new
rate structure because it guarantees them a higher rate than what was
originally
proposed.
QFs Want Third Party Supply Contracts
John Wood, who represents the SoCal Ed Gas Fired Creditors Committee,
one of a
handful of groups that have formed since January to explore options
on getting
paid by the utilities, said his group of gas-fired QF creditors want
to be
released from their supply contracts and sell to third parties.
"Under our plan, we would be permitted to sell electricity to third
parties
(including the state Department of Water Resources) until a
resolution to the
crisis can be accomplished," wood said.
Hal Dittmer, president of Sacramento-based Wellhead Electric in
Sacramento,
which is owed $8 million by PG&E, has 85 MW of gas-fired generation
units
offline.
Under the state's plan, Dittmer said he risks going out of business.
"I can't buy natural gas for what I would be paid under this
decision," he said.
"The state needs to quit kidding themselves that they don't need to
raise
electricity rates. All of this is being driven by an artificial
construct that
California can avoid raising rates."
-By Jason Leopold, Dow Jones Newswires; 323-658-3874;
jason.leopold@dowjones.com
Power Strain Eases but Concerns Mount Energy: Officials say summer
prices will be high, and a state report shows that contracts with
generators are far short of goals.
DAN MORAIN; JENIFER WARREN
TIMES STAFF WRITERS
03/22/2001
Los Angeles Times
Home Edition
A-3
Copyright 2001 / The Times Mirror Company
SACRAMENTO -- California's fragile electricity system stabilized
Wednesday, but
a Davis administration report suggested troubles ahead because the
state could
be forced to buy most of its power for the coming summer on the
costly and
volatile spot market.
After two days of statewide blackouts, power plants that had been
shut down were
cranked up. Unseasonable heat tapered off. The operators of the
statewide power
grid relaxed their state of emergency.
But plenty of ominous signs remained. Many small producers remained
shut down,
skeptical about Gov. Gray Davis' plan for utilities to pay them.
State Controller Kathleen Connell issued a sharp warning about the
high cost of
the state's foray into the power business and announced that she will
block an
administration request that she transfer $5.6 billion into an account
that could
be tapped to pay for state purchases of electricity.
And a report from the administration summarizing contracts between
Davis and
independent power generators showed that the state has signed
contracts for only
2,247 megawatts of electricity, significantly less than the 6,000 to
7,000
megawatts previously claimed.
While there are agreements in principle for the full amount, the
report notes
that generators can back out of the contracts for a variety of
reasons,
including the state's failure to sell bonds to finance power
purchased by July
1. The Legislature has approved plans to sell $10 billion in bonds,
but none
have yet been issued.
"We are exposed enormously this summer," Senate Energy Committee
chairwoman
Debra Bowen (D-Marina del Rey) said after looking at the report. "We
owe the
people the truth about how difficult this summer is going to be. We
don't have a
power fairy."
Perhaps most significant, the report suggests that the contracts fall
significantly short of Davis' stated goal of buying no more than 5%
of the
state's summer needs on the spot electricity market, where prices can
be many
times those of long-term contracts.
After reading the report, Frank Wolak, a Stanford University
economist who
studies the California electricity market, said the numbers suggested
that the
state's long-term contracts will cover less than half of what the
state will
need this summer.
"We're definitely short this summer, next summer and the summer of
2003," he
said.
California was forced to start buying electricity in December--at a
cost of $50
million a day--because producers refused to sell to Southern
California Edison
and Pacific Gas & Electric. The two utilities amassed billions of
dollars in
debt when prices for wholesale power soared on the spot market.
Vikram Budhraja, a consultant retained by Davis to negotiate deals
with
generators, said the report represents a "work in progress." He said
the state
may yet sign new contracts.
However, Wolak said the contract figures confirm what he and others
have been
dreading: that summer is going to be rife with rolling blackouts
unless serious
steps to cut demand are taken immediately.
Wolak and other experts say large industrial customers must be
switched to
real-time meters and pricing to persuade them to use the bulk of
their energy at
times of low demand.
The head of the Energy Foundation, a San Francisco-based nonprofit
that promotes
sustainable sources of power, made the same proposal to Davis on
Wednesday.
"The government need not ask customers to swelter in the dark this
summer,"
foundation President Hal Harvey argued in a letter.
He also proposed a crash campaign to boost sales of efficient
appliances and
lightbulbs. He said the state needs to take over the utilities'
contracts with
alternative energy providers to ensure they stay in business, and
sign new
contracts for 1,500 megawatts of new wind power--the cheapest,
fastest and
cleanest source of new supply.
Davis had proposed a formula Tuesday to force private utilities to
pay the
alternative producers, some of which have not been paid since
November. But some
of them warned Wednesday that Davis' plan offers them little
incentive to turn
on their generators.
Alternative energy producers supply more than a quarter of the
electricity
consumed in California.
Many producers generate electricity from wind, sun and geothermal
sources. But
most of them generate power using natural gas--and the cost of
natural gas has
been soaring. Several natural gas users said Davis' plan, which caps
rates,
won't cover their fuel costs.
Davis assumes that the price of natural gas will fall. But small
generators say
they don't have sufficient purchasing power or sophistication to
gamble on
future prices.
The Public Utilities Commission is expected to approve Davis'
proposal next
week. It offers producers two choices: 7.9 cents a kilowatt-hour if
they agree
to supply power for five years, or 6.9 cents a kilowatt-hour over 10
years.
"The price of natural gas is higher than that," said Marty Quinn,
executive vice
president and chief operating officer of Ridgewood Power LLC, which
owns three
natural gas-fired co-generation plants. "If we operate, we'll lose
money."
Ridgewood is not operating, having been cut off by gas suppliers. The
company
sued PG&E last month seeking overdue payments and release from its
contracts
with the utility.
A hearing is scheduled in El Centro today in another lawsuit filed by
a small
energy producer, an Imperial Valley geothermal producer that sued
Edison for
refusing to let it break its contract and sell on the open market.
CalEnergy
says Edison owes it about $140 million for energy sold since
November.
A company spokesman, Jay Lawrence, said CalEnergy was going ahead
with its suit
despite Davis' proposal. "We've had promises before," he said.
In other developments:
* A federal judge in Sacramento on Wednesday ordered Reliant Energy
of Houston,
a major producer, to continue selling power to California during
emergencies,
despite the company's argument that it may not be fully reimbursed.
The order
will remain in effect for 60 days or until the U.S. Federal Energy
Regulatory
Commission decides a related case.
* Connell said the state budget surplus has shrunk to $3.2 billion
because the
state has spent roughly $2.8 billion on electricity. She criticized
the
administration for withholding basic information about state
finances, and said
she will begin an audit on Monday of the Department of Water
Resources, which is
responsible for purchasing power.
Davis' aides said Connell took her action because the Democratic
governor
endorsed one of Connell's foes this week in the race for Los Angeles
mayor,
former Assembly Speaker Antonio Villaraigosa. A Connell aide scoffed
at the
notion.
* Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) said she "never has had a
response" from
President Bush after writing him last month for an appointment to
discuss the
California energy crisis.
In a wide-ranging lunch talk with reporters in Washington, she
deplored the fact
that "huge, huge profits are being made" in the California crisis,
and said "an
appropriate federal role" would be to guarantee a reliable source of
power until
the state can get nine new generators online.
*
Times staff writers Mitchell Landsberg in Los Angeles and Robert L.
Jackson in
Washington contributed to this report.
(BEGIN TEXT OF INFOBOX / INFOGRAPHIC)
Power Points
Daily Developments
* Wholesale electricity suppliers overcharged by about $5.5 billion
between May
and last month, and that money should be refunded to taxpayers and
utilities,
according to a Cal-ISO report.
* The state may have to buy most of its power for summer on the
costly spot
market, which could drive consumers' bills up, a Davis administration
report
concludes.
* State Controller Kathleen Connell said she will block a request by
the Davis
administration for $5.6 billion for state purchases of electricity.
Verbatim
"We owe the people the truth about how difficult this summer is going
to be. We
don't have a power fairy."
Debra Bowen (D-Marina del Rey), Senate Energy Committee chairwoman
CPUC Must Address Rates In QF Repayment Order - SoCal Ed
03/21/2001
Dow Jones Energy Service
(Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.)
LOS ANGELES -(Dow Jones)- Any order from the California Public
Utilities
Commission requiring utilities to pay small, independent generators
going
forward must determine how that could be done within the existing
rate
structure, a spokesman for Edison International (EIX) utility
Southern
California Edison said Wednesday.
The utility was responding to a PUC proposed decision that would
require
utilities to pay small generators, called qualifying facilities, $79
a megawatt
hour within 15 days of electricity delivery. The decision will be
voted March 27
by the CPUC.
"We're still reviewing (the decision) and should have more to say in
a day or
two. To the extent that the commission orders us to pay going forward
of course
we will. But it needs to address how we will pay the QFs," a SoCal
Edison
spokesman said.
SoCal Edison and PG&E Corp. (PCG) unit Pacific Gas & Electric Co. are
struggling
under nearly $13 billion in uncollected power costs due to an
inability to pass
high wholesale power costs to customers under a rate freeze.
Gov. Gray Davis Tuesday blasted the utilities for not having paid
their QF bills
in full since December. Pacific Gas & Electric Co. has made some
partial
payments to QFs, but SoCal Edison has paid nothing. Together, they
owe the QFs
about $1 billion, but the order doesn't address that debt.
An Edison executive said, in reaction to the governor's sharp
comments, that the
company simply doesn't have the money to pay creditors.
"The root problem here is there just isn't enough money in the
current rate base
to pay our bills," said Edison Senior Vice President of Public
Affairs Bob
Foster. "We understand the financial distress (the QFs) face; we are
facing
financial distress ourselves."
The proposed PUC order would also require the state's investor-owned
utilities
to offer the small generators five- and 10-year contracts for power
for $79/MWh
and $69/MWh, respectively.
The QFs "may be able to live with" the PUC proposal, but the five-
and 10-year
contract prices may be inadequate if natural gas prices at one of the
California
borders are high, said Jan Smutny-Jones, president of the Independent
Energy
Producers Association. Natural gas prices into California are
currently higher
than anywhere in the country.
But some say the proposed decision may not be enough to prevent the
QFs from
filing involuntary bankruptcy proceedings against the utilities for
the money
they are still owed.
"There's still a lot of skepticism. To say our position has changed
based on the
CPUC decision or the governor's announcement is not accurate. A lot
still has to
happen," said Jay Lawrence, a spokesman for a renewable creditors
committee.
-By Jessica Berthold, Dow Jones Newswires; 323-658-3872;
jessica.berthold@dowjones.com -0- 22/03/01 01-27G
State Says It's Accelerating Plan to Buy Power Utilities' Grid
Government: Talks with Edison are reported near completion, but
agreement with heavily indebted PG&E has a way to go.
RONE TEMPEST; DAN MORAIN
TIMES STAFF WRITERS
03/21/2001
Los Angeles Times
Home Edition
A-22
Copyright 2001 / The Times Mirror Company
SACRAMENTO -- As blackouts hit California for a second day Tuesday, a
key
consultant to Gov. Gray Davis said negotiations to buy the power grid
owned by
the state's largest utilities "are proceeding at an accelerated
pace."
Wall Street consultant Joseph Fichera said talks with Southern
California Edison
could be wrapped up within days, although those with PG&E are much
less
advanced.
The administration and PG&E have not reached even an agreement in
principle, he
said. PG&E, which has more debt than Edison, says its transmission
lines are
more extensive than those of its Southern California counterpart.
The state wants to buy the utilities' transmission lines and other
assets for
about $7 billion to provide cash to the utilities, help stabilize the
electricity supply and ease the power crunch that has plagued
California for
months. To research the grid purchase, Fichera said, the state has
had to pore
over 80,000 documents just to assess the utilities' liabilities.
"We are working at a good pace," said Fichera, chief executive of the
New York
firm Saber Partners. " . . . If we get to a deal-breaker, it might be
longer."
By making Fichera, who is also a consultant to the Texas Public
Utilities
Commission, available to reporters Tuesday, the Davis administration
was clearly
trying to reassure the public that progress is being made on the
governor's plan
to pull the state out of the crisis.
Since mid-January, when the big utilities' credit failed and
suppliers stopped
selling to them, the state has spent nearly $3 billion buying
electricity from a
handful of large suppliers in Texas, Oklahoma, Georgia and North
Carolina. Not a
cent has gone to the hundreds of alternative energy suppliers in
California who
provide about a quarter of the state's electricity.
The Monday and Tuesday blackouts occurred partly because many of the
cash-strapped alternative suppliers, including solar, biomass and
wind power
units, cut their normal supply to the system in half. They say Edison
and PG&E
have not paid them since November; the utilities say they are out of
cash.
Assemblyman Fred Keeley (D-Boulder Creek) said the plight of the
alternative
suppliers has dragged on because of the complexity of dealing with
"almost 700
individual contractors."
Another delaying factor, said Keeley, who with state Sen. Jim Battin
(R-La
Quinta) worked for almost three months to come up with a legislative
plan to
lower the small producers' prices, was "the huge enmity . . .
manifested between
the utilities and the qualifying facilities. These people just don't
like each
other."
This week's blackouts provided two painful lessons for the Davis
administration:
* When it comes to electricity, size doesn't matter--every kilowatt
counts.
During peak use, a small wind power facility in Riverside County can
make the
difference between full power and blackouts.
* There is no such thing as a partial solution. Unless the whole
energy equation
is balanced, the parts don't work.
For the Davis plan to work, several key elements need to come
together or
utility customers will almost certainly face rate increases above the
19%
already set in motion * The cost of power purchased by the state must
be reduced
through long-term contracts with the big out-of-state producers.
These contracts, the details of which the Davis administration has
kept
confidential, are still being negotiated by Davis consultant Vikram
Budhraja of
the Pasadena firm Electric Power Group. The administration says it
has concluded
40 contracts with generators, about half of which have been signed.
According to the most recent statistics released by the Department of
Water
Resources, which buys power for the state, current prices are still
well above
the rate state Treasurer Phil Angelides says is necessary for a
planned
$10-billion bond offering to succeed.
The bonds, set for sale in May, will be used to reimburse the state
for the
money it will have spent by that time to buy electricity. The state
is currently
spending at a rate of $58 million a day to buy power. If prices stay
high, the
$10 billion in bonds will not cover the state's power purchases by
the end of
the summer.
Angelides says he cannot proceed with bridge financing for the bonds
until the
Public Utilities Commission devises a formula to guarantee that a
portion of
utility bills will be dedicated to bond repayment. Angelides has
estimated that,
under the January law that put the state in the power buying
business, the state
must be reimbursed $2.5 billion annually, and that $1.3 billion is
needed to
service the debt.
PUC Administrative Law Judge Joseph R. DeUlloa is expected to
announce his
ruling on the reimbursement rate later this week, leading to a PUC
vote on the
matter as early as next week.
* The rates charged for electricity by the alternative producers,
known as
qualifying facilities, must be cut at least in half, down from an
average of
more than 17 cents per kilowatt-hour. In his news conference Tuesday,
Davis said
he will ask the PUC to set QF rates at 6.9 cents for 10-year
contracts and 7.5
cents for five-year contracts.
Meanwhile, PUC Chairman Loretta Lynch, a Davis appointee, said
Tuesday that the
commission will vote next week on a proposed order requiring Southern
California
Edison and Pacific Gas & Electric to pay the QFs for electricity in
the future.
Lynch said a recent PUC assessment showed that the utilities have
enough cash on
hand for that.
"We are trying to make sure the folks providing the power get paid,"
Lynch said.
"The qualified facilities have demonstrated that they haven't been
paid and that
it is impairing their ability to provide power."
The utilities contend that if they pay the small providers what they
owe them,
there will not be enough money left to pay other creditors.
"There is not enough money in the current rate structure to pay the
[alternative
producers], pay the [Department of Water Resources] and pay the
utilities for
their generation," said John Nelson, a spokesman for PG&E.
* The utilities must sell to the state the power they produce
themselves, mainly
from hydro and nuclear sources, at a rate only slightly above the
cost of
producing it. This is tied to the ongoing negotiations between the
Davis
administration and the utilities to restore the near-bankrupt
utilities to
solvency.
*
Times staff writers Julie Tamaki, Miguel Bustillo and Tim Reiterman
contributed
to this report.
Davis OKs Subsidy of Pollution Fees Smog: As part of secret deal to
get long-term energy contracts, state would pay for some of the
credits that allow excess power plant emissions. Critics renew call
for full disclosure.
DAN MORAIN
TIMES STAFF WRITER
03/21/2001
Los Angeles Times
Home Edition
A-23
Copyright 2001 / The Times Mirror Company
SACRAMENTO -- As part of his closed-door negotiations to buy
electricity, Gov.
Gray Davis has agreed to relieve some generators from having to pay
potentially
millions of dollars in fees for emitting pollutants into the air,
Davis said
Tuesday.
Davis announced two weeks ago that his negotiators had reached deals
with 20
generators to supply $43 billion worth of power during the next 10
years.
However, the Democratic governor has refused to release any of the
contracts or
detail various terms, contending that release of such information
would hamper
the state's ability to negotiate deals with other generators and
therefore
ultimately would raise prices Californians pay for electricity.
Sources familiar with the negotiations, speaking on condition of
anonymity, said
the agreement reached with Dynegy Inc., a power company based in
Houston, is one
that includes language requiring that the state pay the cost of
credits that
allow emissions. Dynegy spokesman Steve Stengel declined to discuss
the
company's deal with the state.
"We couldn't get them to sign contracts; it was a sticking point,"
Davis said of
the decision to pay the fees of some generators. "We had to lock down
some power
so we were not totally dependent on the spot market."
The fees in question are part of an emission trading system known as
RECLAIM.
Under the system, companies are allotted a certain amount of
allowable
pollution. If their operations pollute more, companies are required
to purchase
credits on an open market. Currently the credits cost about $45 per
pound of
pollution--an amount that can lead to a bill of well over $10 million
a year for
a power plant.
The South Coast Air Quality Management District, which regulates
pollution in
the Los Angeles Basin, is considering steps to significantly lower
the cost of
the system--a step that could considerably cut the state's potential
cost, Davis
said.
Senate Energy Committee Chairwoman Debra Bowen (D-Marina del Rey)
defended the
decision to cover the power company's costs.
"It is a question of whether it brings down the price of power," she
said. "If
it brings down the price of power, I don't have a problem with it."
Nevertheless, word that the contracts could bind the state to pay
pollution fees
caused some critics of Davis' policy to renew calls for Davis to
reconsider the
secrecy surrounding the power negotiations. The payment provision
underscores
the fact that the contracts involve more than merely the prices the
state will
pay for its megawatts, the critics note.
"The Legislature should have known about it," said Senate President
Pro Tem John
Burton (D-San Francisco). "It is going to cost taxpayers money. It
makes you
wonder. . . . This was a policy issue that was never discussed with
the
Legislature."
V. John White, a lobbyist for the Sierra Club, who also represents
alternative
energy producers, called the contract proposal "a horrible
precedent."
"Until we know exactly what the state has agreed to and how much of a
subsidy
this represents, we can't determine how serious the breach of
principle this
is," White said.
Another critic of the secrecy of the negotiations, Terry Francke,
general
counsel for the California First Amendment Coalition, said the
provision in
question "raises the possibility that there are other [concessions]"
that have
not yet come to light.
In the summer, when demand for power is highest, some generators
probably will
exceed pollution limits set by regional air quality management
districts.
To avert blackouts, state officials might ask the companies to keep
plants
running. In such cases, some sources familiar with aspects of the
contracts
said, the contract language could be interpreted to suggest that the
state would
cover any fines--although Davis said Tuesday the state will not cover
the cost
of fines.
A recent Dynegy filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission
underscores
the rising cost of pollution-related measures. The company, which is
partners
with NRG Energy in three California plants in El Segundo, Long Beach
and
Carlsbad in San Diego County, said its "aggregate expenditures for
compliance
with laws related to the regulation of discharge of materials into
the
environment" rose to $14.3 million in 2000, from $3.6 million in
1999.
A South Coast Air Quality Management spokesman said Dynegy's
facilities appear
to be fairly clean--although Sierra Club lobbyist White said Dynegy
has been
seeking a permit at one of its plants to burn fuel oil, which is
dirtier than
natural gas.
Davis said he intends to "make this information public," but he added
that "we
do not want to put the public's interest in jeopardy by asking them
to pay
higher prices."
"Nobody likes the notion that [the administration is] not being fully
forthcoming," Davis said. "But I also have a corollary responsibility
that I
don't stick these generators with a higher rate."
FERC ORDERS WILLIAMS ENERGY AND AES TO EXPLAIN THEIR REFUSAL TO MAKE
CERTAIN RMR UNITS AVAILABLE TO CALIFORNIA ISO LAST YEAR
03/21/2001
Foster Electric Report
5
(c) Copyright 2001, Foster Associates, Inc.
Following a preliminary, non-public investigation, FERC directed AES
Southland
Inc. and Williams Energy Marketing & Trading Co. (IN01-3) on March 14
to show
cause why they did not violate section 205 of the Federal Power Act
(FPA) by
failing to provide power to the California ISO from two reliability
must-run
(RMR) generator units during a period in April and May 2000. The
investigation
responded to a matter referred by the Cal-ISO. If a violation is
found, Williams
Energy and AES could be required to refund excess profits of $10.9
million (as
calculated by FERC) and face restrictions on their market-based rate
authority
for a year.
The show cause order involves two generation units (Alamitos 4 and
Huntington
Beach 2), owned and operated by AES. Williams Energy markets all
output from the
Alamitos and Huntington Beach plants, including the two units at
issue here,
pursuant to a tolling agreement filed with the Commission. The
Cal-ISO
designated the two units as RMR units that it could call on when
necessary to
provide energy and ancillary service essential to the reliability of
the
California transmission network. The Cal-ISO makes both a fixed
payment to the
RMR owner or operator to compensate for the RMR unit's availability
and a
variable payment for the RMR unit's output (if the unit is not
otherwise
participating in the market). Williams Energy and the Cal-ISO
executed RMR
agreements, filed as rate schedules with the Commission, allowing the
Cal-ISO to
dispatch units "solely for purposes of meeting local reliability
needs or
managing intra-zonal congestion." The ISO may dispatch a non-RMR unit
if the
designated RMR unit is not available. Under its RMR agreement with
the ISO,
Williams is paid the greater of its contract price or marginal cost
for
operating RMR units. However, if a non-RMR unit has to be dispatched
because a
designated RMR unit is unavailable, Williams will be paid its bid
price, not the
RMR contract price.
During the April to May 2000 period, the Cal-ISO sought to dispatch
both
Alamitos 4 and Huntington Beach 2 as RMR units to provide voltage
support.
However, according to the FERC order, Williams Energy refused to make
Alamitos 4
available from April 25 through May 5, and to make Huntington Beach 2
available
from May 6 through May 11, "for reasons not directly related to the
necessary
and timely maintenance of the units." Consequently, the Cal-ISO was
forced to
dispatch non-RMR units at a higher cost, namely, Williams Energy's
bid price for
service provided by the replacement units.
By contrast, if the RMR units had not experienced outages and been
available
from April 25 through May 11, Williams Energy would have received
either (1) the
market revenues only from the respective units, which would have
resulted in no
payments for RMR output from the ISO to Williams Energy, or (2)
Williams
Energy's variable cost for operating the RMR units less the market
revenues from
the respective units' output. Accordingly, FERC observed, Williams
Energy had "a
financial incentive to prolong any outages of Alamitos 4 and
Huntington Beach 2
in April and May 2000."
The bid price for the non-RMR units was at or near the Cal-ISO's
then-effective
bid cap of $750/MWh, FERC continued. Therefore, Williams Energy
received
payments from the Cal-ISO of more than $11.3 million, or about $10.3
million
greater than the estimated average variable operating cost of the
non-RMR units
(approximately $63/MWh) during the period in question. This indicates
a refund
amount, including interest, of nearly $10.9 million.
The information in this order and a non-public appendix, the
Commission
declared, suggests that AES declared outages at the two RMR units and
maintained
Huntington Beach 2 in a manner inconsistent with good utility
practice, and that
Williams Energy took action to extend the outage at Alamitos 4 and to
make
Huntington Beach 2 unavailable for "pretextual reasons."
Based on this information coupled with Williams Energy's financial
incentive not
to make the Alamitos 4 and Huntington Beach 2 units available, FERC
found
serious questions about whether (1) AES and Williams Energy violated
applicable
RMR contracts and tariffs on file with the Commission pursuant to FPA
section
205 when they refused to make Alamitos 4 and Huntington Beach 2
available for
dispatch by the Cal-ISO; (2) whether Williams acted inconsistently
with its
market-based rate authority and the market monitoring information
protocols of
the Cal-ISO's tariff regarding the unavailability of the RMR units
during the
period at issue; and (3) whether AES violated a tolling agreement on
file with
the Commission pursuant to section 205.
The Commission identified two remedies for these potential
violations: a refund
by Williams Energy and/or AES of revenues received greater than the
amount that
would have collected from the ISO if the RMR units had been
available, and a
condition on Williams Energy's market-based rate authority.
Specifically, for a
one-year period, if an RMR unit were not available when dispatched by
the
Cal-ISO, a non-RMR unit dispatched in its place would only receive
payment
according to the terms of the applicable RMR contract. In other
words, Williams
Energy would not receive the bid price for operation of the
substitute, non- RMR
unit.
The Commission directed Williams Energy and AES to show cause, within
20 days,
why they should not be found to have committed the above-described
violations
and why the specified remedies should not be imposed.
Further, to ensure procurement of all relevant information, the
Commission
instituted a formal, non-public investigation into the operation,
maintenance
and sales of power from the Alamitos and Huntington Beach plants in
2000 and
2001.
Calif Consumers Failing To Conserve Pwr Despite Blackouts
03/20/2001
Dow Jones Energy Service
(Copyright (c) 2001, Dow Jones & Company, Inc.)
LOS ANGELES -(Dow Jones)- California consumers haven't been
conserving enough
electricity to relieve strain on the power grid and reduce demand in
the state,
a spokesman with the Independent System Operator said Tuesday.
The ISO said that despite two straight days of statewide rolling
blackouts,
consumers aren't using less electricity, which means additional
megawatts will
be taken off the grid. As a result, blackouts could last longer and
impact
additional communities, the ISO said.
ISO spokesman Pat Dorinson said Monday "conservation in California is
no longer
an option," but consumers in the state aren't heeding the call to
reduce
consumption.
Conservation efforts during rolling blackouts Monday and Tuesday were
far less
than Jan. 17 and Jan. 18, when blackouts swept through Northern
California due
to transmission constraints. Jim Detmers, the ISO's vice president of
operation,
said consumers saved the state about 1,000 megawatts of electricity,
enough
power for 1 million houses.
The ISO said conservation efforts Monday were about 500 MW or less.
"We would be very happy if we saw the same amount this time," Detmers
said.
The state's Energy Commission said consumers think it's no longer
important to
save electricity until blackouts are imposed.
"People have been saving generally, but it isn't a big bump from hour
to hour,"
a spokesman for the Energy Commission said.
Gov. Gray Davis launched a massive conservation campaign this month,
promising
consumers a rebate on their summer electricity bill if they save at
least 20% of
electricity, compared with last summer.
The governor said he believes conservation this summer will amount to
possibly
saving 5,000 MW and averting the chance of rolling blackouts.
-By Jason Leopold; Dow Jones Newswires; 323-658-3874;
jason.leopold@dowjones.com
Gas Co.'s Success Opens Debate Southern California energy supplier
has reaped
millions of dollars in state incentives for keeping down its costs.
Though
consumers get a share of the windfall, regulators are asking whether
they should
get more of the bonus, which is expected to be huge this year, as a
form of
price relief. The natural gas provider says it deserves to keep its
reward.
TIM REITERMAN
TIMES STAFF WRITER
03/18/2001
Los Angeles Times
Home Edition
C-1
Copyright 2001 / The Times Mirror Company
SAN FRANCISCO -- While consumers suffer soaring energy bills and the
big
electric utilities lurch toward insolvency, the news is not all dire
at Southern
California Gas Co.
Through vigorous deal making, the Sempra Energy subsidiary has
consistently
beaten the volatile natural gas market during the last year, and the
company
stands to reap millions of dollars in savings through a state
incentive program
that rewards utilities for keeping costs down.
For several years, the utility has been splitting the savings 50-50
with
ratepayers whenever the company's gas costs fall slightly below
market levels.
Those savings, Gas Co. executives acknowledged, have shot to
unprecedented
heights during the state's power crisis.
Now, in this climate of high consumer gas bills and runaway market
prices,
regulators are taking another look at the program. The question
before the
Public Utilities Commission: Should Gas Co. ratepayers, who endured
huge bill
increases this winter, get a bigger share of the savings?
The total windfall under the incentive program has in some years
exceeded $20
million. But the amount for the last 12 months is expected to
multiply many
times over, company executives said, partly because the Gas Co. has
done so well
in the wild market by selling, lending and trading gas as well as
buying it.
"The recent market conditions . . . could possibly result in some
unintended
consequences that result in shared savings of benefits that may be
more
appropriately allocated entirely to ratepayers," the PUC's consumer
protection
arm, the Office of Ratepayer Advocates, reported Oct. 30, even before
the latest
upward market spirals.
Gas Co. representatives express frustration, saying they have done
what the
state has requested under its gas-cost incentive program: Buy
smarter, and pass
the savings along to its 5 million residential and small-business
customers. The
company contends it has worked hard to keep bills down and should be
rewarded
for taking risks to obtain gas at the lowest possible cost.
"The PUC, every time we do well, raises the bar on us," said Jim
Harrigan,
director of gas acquisition. "I don't necessarily agree with it."
By virtue of its purchasing power and storage and pipeline capacity,
the Gas Co.
has become a big player in the regional natural gas market. In the
company's
bustling trading room at its Los Angeles headquarters, 15 employees
track price
movements, pipeline supplies and even the weather via computer, while
cutting
deals and arranging gas shipments.
Although the Gas Co. buys the commodity for its customers, the
company also
sells to marketers, other utilities and producers. State officials
say the
number of transactions by the company has risen steeply to 10,000 to
20,000 a
year, including gas sales along California's border, where prices
have rocketed.
The PUC created the cost incentive program for the state's three
major gas
utilities--San Diego Gas & Electric Co. in 1993, Southern California
Gas the
next year and PG&E Corp.'s Pacific Gas & Electric Co. in 1997. Like
Southern
California Gas, SDG&E is a subsidiary of Sempra Energy.
The program was designed to give utilities added motivation for
obtaining gas at
the best price for customers. It replaced lengthy and contentious
reviews by the
PUC, which assessed whether utilities had purchased gas at reasonable
prices and
sometimes ordered them to return millions of dollars to customers.
An annual audit of the Gas Co. program and a staff evaluation
requested by the
PUC recently concluded that the program has achieved many of its
goals, but it
also proposed adjustments that would give customers a greater share
of the
rewards.
"These incentives were designed in less volatile times," said program
supervisor
Mark Pocta of the Office of Ratepayer Advocates, which conducted the
audit.
"There is a question of how much should go to ratepayers and
shareholders." His
office also plans to assess whether the Gas Co.'s trading had any
negative
effects on the gas market, resulting in diminished supplies or higher
prices for
other utilities and their customers.
Under the program, the Gas Co. shares risks and rewards with its
ratepayers, but
since the program was launched, it has consistently produced awards.
If the cost
of gas is 0.5% or more below a benchmark based on monthly gas market
indexes,
the company and its customers split the savings 50-50.
California's gas utilities are not allowed to profit on their raw
commodity
costs; they merely pass along those costs to ratepayers with no
markup. The
savings under the incentive program are automatically reflected in
consumers'
monthly gas bills but are not itemized.
At the end of the year, the utilities request their share of the
savings, and
the PUC has routinely granted approval. Then the companies, and thus
their
shareholders, are paid through customer utility bills.
The resulting bill increases typically have been modest, less than
1%. But as
the awards increase, regulators say, the effect on customers will
become more
significant unless the present structure is changed.
"There's no question, when you start to talk about $100 million [or
more in
savings], and add [the company's award] into rates in a year, it will
make a
noticeable difference," said Los Angeles economist Jeff Leitzinger,
president of
Econ One, who has done consulting for the Gas Co.
Still, he said, ratepayers should bear in mind that they already
benefit from
below-market gas and transportation costs.
In the early years of the program, records show, the Gas Co.'s awards
went from
zero to $3.2 million, $10.6 million, $2 million and $7.7 million.
Last year's
award of $9.8 million is awaiting PUC approval.
This year's proposed award, covering the period through the end of
this month,
has not yet been submitted by the Gas Co. But the utility has
provided monthly
figures and oral updates on a confidential basis to PUC officials,
who declined
to provide figures.
Harrigan of the Gas Co. said the savings are expected to multiply
"many times
over," largely because the company was well-equipped for the market
fluctuations
and tried to insulate its customers from high gas prices.
"Any trading company, especially one with assets like we have, has
benefited
from volatility in the market," he said.
Harrigan said, however, that he does not believe the company's level
of activity
has adversely affected the market and that its trading pales in
volume to that
of unregulated energy companies.
Anne Smith, the Gas Co.'s vice president of customer service and
marketing, said
the utility will not release figures for this year's incentive
program until
they are filed with the PUC in June.
"I don't want to interrupt that process," Smith said, noting that the
PUC
ultimately will determine the company's award. "I think they need to
focus on
what [the Gas Co.] has done for the ratepayers. It has been immense."
Although the typical monthly gas bill has risen to $80 from $50 a
year ago, Gas
Co. customers tend to have lower rates than those of other California
utilities.
The company's gas procurement cost in February was 66 cents per
therm, or 100
cubic feet. That's more than twice last year's cost but only about
half what
sister company SDG&E paid for its 740,000 customers in February. It's
also much
lower than the $1.09 per therm PG&E pays.
"We were as upset about the overall [gas price] increase as anyone
else,"
Harrigan said. "I would rather see the prices of a year ago, even
though we
managed to do a little better in the [recent] environment."
When it comes to keeping down costs, regulators say, the Gas Co. has
advantages
over other utilities in the marketplace. For one, the company has so
much
pipeline capacity at major gas basins that it purchases a relatively
small
portion of its needs--about 10% to 15%--at the California border,
where prices
in December briefly rose to the equivalent of $6 per therm, or 20
times those a
year earlier.
This presents opportunities.
"At the beginning of the month, they forecast a certain amount of gas
they have
to buy," said Pocta of the Office of Ratepayer Advocates. "If they go
out and
buy and do not need to use as much because the weather is more
moderate than
expected, they can either inject the gas into storage or they can
make sales at
the border."
With gas price run-ups like those seen in the last year, Pocta said,
"there is a
question: Should that benefit be shared, or flow entirely to
ratepayers?"
Customers, he pointed out, may be entitled to additional benefits
because they
pay for the interstate and intrastate pipeline capacity and the gas
storage that
give the company the flexibility to make advantageous deals.
"By the same token, we want [the Gas Co.] . . . to go into the market
and
generate cost savings that can be passed on to the customers," he
added. "We
want them to have incentives. The question is how to balance them."
Under deregulation, the Gas Co. adopted the nontraditional role of
marketer,
according to a PUC Energy Division report in January. The company
makes gas
sales at various locations. It engages in exchanges. It makes futures
transactions to help stabilize costs.
"They look for ways to lower the gas cost," said Richard Myers,
program
supervisor at the Energy Division. "Before they were lots more
risk-averse. Now
they feel they can take risks and make money for shareholders, and it
is a
benefit for ratepayers at the same time."
The incentive programs are tailored to individual utilities, so it is
difficult
to compare them. Records show that the shared savings at SDG&E, a
much smaller
utility, declined steadily from $9.2 million in the 1996-97 cycle to
$560,000 in
1999-2000.
Spokesman Ed Van Herik said the falloff largely represents a drop in
gas
purchases, especially as the company sold off its own gas-fired
electricity-generating plants. He said the company does not yet know
how much
savings have accrued in the last year.
In an annual report to the PUC in February, PG&E said it had no
savings under
the incentive program and thus it is not entitled to any award for
the 1999-2000
cycle.
The Utility Reform Network, a San Francisco-based consumer advocacy
group, said
it will closely watch the PUC's evaluation of the incentive program
at the Gas
Co.
"We want to make sure, given the dramatic changes in the gas market
and prices,
ratepayers are not left out of the [additional] benefits," TURN
attorney Marcel
Hawiger said. "We'll look to see whether the mechanism should be
changed."
Severin Borenstein, director of the Energy Institute at UC Berkeley,
said the
program should be changed to provide more incentive for utilities to
enter
long-term contracts that would smooth out volatility in the market.
"Unfortunately, under the system," he said, "the only incentive is to
beat the
[spot] market."
Use this file to download and print all the articles in this section
(See attached file: Dow Jones
Interactive-california-03233001-selected.doc)
IMPLICATIONS FOR OTHER MARKETS
(For easier printing of all the articles in this section use the file
at the end of the section)
New York: New York at the crossroads
Wednesday, March 21, 2001
Energy Insight
(Embedded image moved to file: pic24389.pcx)
By Dave Todd
dtodd@ftenergy.com
U.S. Energy Secretary Spencer Abraham declared this week that the Big
Apple is on the verge of being bitten hard by power cuts and rising
energy prices.
Delivering the keynote address at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce's
national energy summit in Washington Monday, Abraham said,
"California is not the only state facing a mismatch between supply
and demand," what with "electricity shortages predicted for New York
City and Long Island this summer" and low capacity margins
threatening electricity reliability elsewhere across the country. But
how likely is it that New Yorkers will face blackouts of the sort
confronting Californians?
Not very, says energy trade specialist Edward Krapels, managing
director of Boston-based METIS Trading Advisors. Krapels, a
consultant helping major Northeastern utilities, such as Consolidated
Edison, design market-hedging programs, adamantly decried what he
said are facile comparisons between conditions in New York and
California, there being "more differences than there are
similarities" between those two industrial cornerstones of the
country's economy in respect to energy security management.
"First of all, New York has a more varied portfolio of energy
generation sources than California," he said. California has hydro,
nuclear and gas, but when it lost a lot of hydro, the state needed
gas to pick up the slack, and the "capacity just wasn't there." In
New York's case, the state has oil and coal still in the mix and its
overall dependence on gas is much lower than California's, Krapels
added.
New York avoids making same mistakes
Portfolio diversity is one pillar of any effective plan to help New
York avoid the same errors made in redesigning California's
marketplace. New York's Independent System Operator (ISO), in a new
report warning that the state is at an "energy crossroads" in terms
of its capacity adequacy in the immediate future, argues that a
concerted effort is required to arrest declining in-state generation
capacity reserve margins, and a strategy must be put in place,
whether or not new generation comes on-line, in accordance with
current anticipated scenarios.
A measure of New York's essential difficulty is that, between 1995
and 2000, statewide demand for electricity grew 2,700 MW, while
generating capacity expanded by only 1,060 MW. With no major new
generating plants in downstate New York fully approved, the gap is
expected to continue to widen. To avoid "a replication of
California's market meltdown" the New York ISO calculates the state's
daily generating capacity needs to grow by 8,600 MW by 2005, with
more than half of that located in New York City and on Long Island.
Expressing concern this may be too big a burden for the current
bureaucratic process to bear, the ISO wants to see a state-appointed
ombudsman named to help would-be merchant power plant investors plow
through red tape.
"Increasing New York's generating capacity will also lessen the
state's escalating and risky reliance on out-of-state sources of
electricity," the ISO added. "Since 1999, New York State has been
unable to cover its reserve requirements from in-state sources."
Not everyone agrees with that analysis, insofar as it argues for
circling the wagons inward. Some analysts believe the ultimate
solution lies not in tying in more inwardly dedicated power, but in
expanding the marketplace by breaking down inter-jurisdictional
barriers. In any case, New York energy regulatory authorities and
those responsible elsewhere in the U.S. Northeast, such as PJM
(Pennsylvania-New Jersey-Maryland) Interconnection and the New
England Power Pool, are in vastly better shape in terms of
"cross-border" cooperation than California and its neighbors in that
efforts are being made among various authorities toward developing an
integrated regional electricity market. In California, by contrast,
the state's focus?for example, in the case of new gas-fired power
plant development?has been to ensure dedicated supply to the
California market alone, rather than on a regional marketplace.
(Embedded image moved to file: pic05075.pcx)
The New York ISO's new broad-based analysis of market-restructuring
needs argues that the relatively stronger health of its reformed
environment is "due in large part to the ability of New York's
utilities to enter into long-term power contracts."
What needs to be done most, it says, is to move aggressively to build
some of the more than 29,000 MW of "proposed new generation in the
siting pipeline."
In the meantime, the 30,200 MW of electricity New Yorkers used on a
peak day last summer shouldn't be eclipsed on too many days this
coming summer (given early long-range weather forecasts). Demand,
however, is expected to increase at an annual average rate of up to
1.4%.
So while New York City, the rest of the state and adjacent parts
might breathe easy this year, it could be a brief rest from the fray.
Meanwhile, a 4% shortfall is still being planned for this summer that
is not yet provided for, as authorities hurriedly seek to arrange new
generation plants around Manhattan, on Long Island and even on barges
offshore.
One way or another, whether it is the weather or the politics of
siting new energy facilities, it's going to be a hot time in the
city.
Long-term solutions hit brick wall
Meanwhile, attempts at longer-term solutions continue to run into
trouble. Last week, Connecticut state regulators came out against a
proposal to run a new underwater cable under Long Island Sound that
Hydro-Quebec subsidiary TransEnergie U.S. Ltd. wants to build to pump
more juice into Long Island Power Authority's load pocket. Despite
strong promises from TransEnergie to be diligent in avoiding damage
to oyster beds in Long Island Sound, the proposal failed to convince
authorities, who were persuaded the pipeline project could lead to
diversion of electricity from Connecticut.
In similar fashion, private companies wanting to build 10 small
independent power plants and temporary generators offshore New York
City are running into intense opposition from environmental groups
and citizen orga
nizations?some of whom have taken their cases to the
state assembly in Albany.
The David vs. Goliath nature of such controversies has further
alerted energy companies to the difficulties of addressing complex
energy supply issues that may ultimately devolve to people not
wanting things in their backyard, regardless of what the alternative
might mean to their fellow citizens or the greater public good.
But suddenly, in New York, California's troubles?while still distant
in their intensity? may not be so far away. By some estimates, this
summer's bills for Consolidated Edison customers could be up as much
as one third or more over last year's charges.
Letting the time slip when it comes to building new infrastructure
isn't going to make the pain go away.
NEW YORK: NY-ISO REPORT SAYS STATE NEEDS 4,000 - 5,000 MW OF NEW
GENERATION SOON TO AVOID SEVERE SHORTAGES; NY-ISO ALSO ASKS FERC TO
EXTEND BID CAP AND TEMPORARY EMERGENCY PROCEDURES
03/21/2001
Foster Electric Report
2
(c) Copyright 2001, Foster Associates, Inc.
Raising the specter of an East Coast version of the California
crisis, the New
York Independent System Operator, Inc. (NY-ISO) is warning of serious
electricity shortages, air quality deterioration and stunted economic
growth
without immediate approval of between 4,000-5,000 MW of new
generating capacity
in the state. Of this amount, 2,000-3,000 MW is needed to serve New
York City.
Another 8,600 MW of new capacity will have to be built by 2005, the
NY-ISO said
in a recent report, Power Alert: New York's Energy Crossroads.
"New York is heading towards a very serious situation unless it acts
immediately
to get new supply sited within its borders," said NY-ISO president
William
Museler in a statement accompanying the report. "This report is
essentially a
caution light at New York's energy crossroads."
Sources in the New York Public Service Commission have downplayed the
NY-ISO's
warning, asserting that a process for bringing on new generation is
well
underway, with more than 85 projects in the approval pipeline.
In a related development, the NY-ISO asked FERC to approve a proposed
tariff
amendment (ER01-1517) extending existing bids caps in some of its
markets until
10/31/02, and a separate and related amendment (ER01-1489) extending
the
NY-ISO's so-called temporary extraordinary procedures (TEP) that
allow the ISO
to make price adjustments and take other corrective actions if it
finds evidence
of market power abuse.
The NY-ISO Report --The NY-ISO likened the situation in New York to
that faced
by California, where a relentless increase in demand has not been met
with an
equal increase in supply. The NY-ISO said that between 1995 and 2000,
statewide
demand for electricity rose by 2,700 MW, while generating capacity
increased by
only 1,060 MW. With no major new generating plants in downstate New
York fully
approved for construction at this time and generation demand in the
state
expected to grow around 1.3 percent annually for the next several
years, the
NY-ISO said this gap will continue to widen.
The inevitable result of this trend is large rate increases for New
York's power
consumers. The NY-ISO's modeling suggests that "by 2005, statewide
prices are
likely to be more than 20-25 percent lower in the case in which new
plants are
built than in the case where they are not." In New York City, "the
price to
consumers of electric power could be reduced by as much as 28 percent
when
compared to the case of no new supply or load management programs."
Besides large rate increases, the NY-ISO asserted that a failure to
site and
build new plants in New York will threaten power reliability in the
state and
lead to increasing reliance on out-of-state resources. The report
said that if
no new in-state generation comes on line in the next five years, the
state's
generation reserve margins will shrink from the current 14.9 percent
above peak
demand "to a dangerously low 8.4 percent by 2005." Pointing to
California's
situation, the report added that increased reliance on power imports
"can
subject electrical suppliers and customers in New York to
transmission
restrictions and political and economic considerations beyond the
control or
influence of responsible New York State entities."
To avoid these harsh consequences, the NY-ISO said New York's new
siting law,
known as the Article X process, needs to be modified. Since the law
was passed
18 months ago, the report noted that only two plants have been
approved (both
upstate) and neither has yet been built. The problem, according to
the NY-ISO,
is that the siting process "requires the cooperation of multiple
state
agencies." To expedite the process, the report suggested the "clear
designation
of a lead agency and the adoption of an `ombudsman program' to
expedite and
coordinate the work of the agencies responsible for the Article X
process must
be made." The NY-ISO added that an expedited approval process would
improve the
environment because older, more polluting power plants would be
replaced by
cleaner gas-fired units.
On a more positive note, the NY-ISO reported that New York's
restructured power
market "is far healthier than that in California, due in large part
to the
ability of New York `s utilities to enter long-term power contracts.
The basic
structure of the New York market will also reduce unwarranted price
spikes and
other market disruptions through mitigation programs which
automatically correct
price spikes due to market power abuses."
"Nevertheless, California `s experience raises a caution flag for all
New
Yorkers," the report continued. "The deregulated market in New York
cannot
achieve lower costs through competition without an increase in
generating
capacity similar in magnitude to the recommendations of this report,
along with
simultaneous efforts to institute greater conservation, better load
management
and alternative energy supply initiatives. Additionally, closer
integration with
regional suppliers of power is both inevitable and beneficial."
The report also recommended (1) accelerating conservation, real-time
metering
and price-sensitive load programs; and (2) upgrading the state's and
the
Northeast's transmission infrastructure.
The Proposed Tariff Amendments -- New York's Article X siting process
and
continuing tight supplies were also cited in the NY-ISO's request to
extend from
4/30/01 until 10/31/02 its $1,000/MWh bid caps. FERC first approved
the
1,000/MWh bid caps in July 2000 (see REPORT No.197, pg.6), and
subsequently
extended them.
The NY-ISO's board "is sensitive to the Commission's concerns about
undue
intervention in energy markets," the filing related. "Nevertheless,
the NY-ISO
is submitting this request because it believes that delays in New
York state's
`Article X' process for licensing and siting new generating capacity
is
inhibiting supply from increasing to match continued demand growth. .
. .
Moreover, although the NY-ISO proposes to implement several
demand-side measures
this summer, it is not yet clear whether they will make demand
sufficiently
price-responsive to avoid periods of high prices that would not occur
if there
were an efficient demand-side response."
Thus, the NY-ISO insisted that the requested extension is needed to
provide more
time for the development of additional generation and to gauge the
effectiveness
of the NY-ISO's proposed demand-side response mechanisms "in order to
avoid
exposing consumers to price spikes that are not a product of the
interplay of
competitive market forces."
Other problems cited in the NY-ISO's filing which keep New York's
power market
from being fully competitive include continuing capacity and
operating
constraints at the state's Central-East interface, and questions over
adequate
gas supply.
"The NY-ISO remains acutely aware that taking steps to deal with
price
abnormalities can have undesirable consequences," the filing
continued.
"Nevertheless, the NY-ISO believes that the $1,000/MWh cap that has
been used in
the PJM's markets since inception does not appear to have had an
adverse impact
there. . . . The permanent bid caps in PJM, and the interim bid caps
in ISO New
England (proposed for extension through the end of 2001) also make
continuation
of the NY-ISO's bid caps more important in order to maintain
uniformity across
the Northeastern markets. The NY-ISO also continues to believe that
suppliers
will not be materially harmed by the continuation of bid caps, which
are likely
to come into effect very rarely and are set at levels that prevent
only
artificially high run-ups in prices."
The NY-ISO's request to extend its TEP procedures (which also were
previously
extended) through 10/31/02 cited similar problems with New York's
power markets,
but claimed that the NY-ISO "has made great strides" toward
eliminating market
design and software flaws. "The TEPs were, and remain, an
indispensable tool for
responding to and correcting market flaws and other instances where
the markets
are not operating as the NY-ISO and the Commission intended," the
filing
insisted.
MASSACHUSETTS: Attorney general says summer poses electricity
concerns
By JOHN McELHENNY
Associated Press Writer
03/19/2001
Associated Press Newswires
Copyright 2001. The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
BOSTON (AP) - The state's top consumer advocate warned that
Massachusetts may
see "California-type" electricity blackouts this summer when
temperatures rise
and residents turn on air conditioners and fans.
"It would be a mistake to feel this is a cold weather problem," said
Attorney
General Thomas Reilly in an interview with The Associated Press. "Our
major
problem will come this summer."
State deregulation of the electric industry has been among the
factors blamed
for local power outages in California, and on Monday, California for
the first
time suffered rolling blackouts across the entire state.
Massachusetts relaxed regulations on its own electric industry in
1998 to
attract more companies to stir competition. But that hasn't happened
yet,
largely because the current high cost of oil and gas make it
expensive to
produce electricity.
"The promise of deregulation was that there was going to be
competition," said
Reilly, a Democrat. "That competition in the wholesale market is not
happening."
Hot summer weather drives up electricity use as residents turn on air
conditioners and fans, and Reilly said a few particularly hot days
could strain
the grid that provides the region's power.
A spokeswoman for the region's power grid said electricity use is
expected to
rise 1.5 to 2 percent this year, but the region should have enough
power because
of six new power plants that have begun generating electricity in the
past 18
months.
"The situation is unlike California because we have new generation
coming on
line that is outpacing demand," said Ellen Foley, spokeswoman for ISO
New
England Inc., which manages the grid of 330 generators connected by
8,000 miles
of high voltage transmission lines.
Still, a particularly hot day and an unforeseen power generation
breakdown could
prompt ISO to ask residents to conserve electricity, a situation that
arose once
last summer, Foley said.
In order to avoid any power outages and protect consumers, Reilly
repeated calls
for electric companies to build more power lines and to offer more
options for
new customers who have signed up since deregulation. Those customers
typically
pay more than long-term customers.
Electric transmission companies should also be allowed to enter into
two-year
contracts with suppliers, instead of the six-month contracts many
have now, to
avoid short-term price spikes for consumers, Reilly said.
The Attorney General's Office acts as an advocate for consumers.
Michael Monahan, a spokesman for NSTAR, which provides electricity to
more than
1 million customers, is upgrading some of its power lines and last
year built a
new line to Cape Cod, but currently has no lines under construction.
"I wholeheartedly concur with the attorney general that it's
something we have
to focus on," Monahan said, but he added, "The indications I see are
that we
have an ample supply of electricity."
California's statewide outages were ordered on Monday after a
transformer fire,
high demand and a lack of electricity imports pushed power reserves
to near
zero.
California partially deregulated its electric industry in 1996, two
years before
Massachusetts.
---
On the Net:
Attorney General's Office: http://www.ago.state.ma.us
NSTAR: http://www.nstaronline.com
ISO New England Inc.: http://www.iso-ne.com
NEVADA: Discussion of bill stopping power plant sales to continue
Wednesday
By JOHN WILKERSON
Associated Press Writer
03/19/2001
Associated Press Newswires
Copyright 2001. The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
CARSON CITY, Nev. (AP) - Lawmakers hit more delays Monday in trying
to pass a
measure that pulls the plug on the sale of Nevada power plants to
avoid
California-style energy problems.
"The goal of this bill is only stopping the divestiture of power
plants and
making sure it's constitutional," said Senate Commerce and Labor
Chairman
Randolph Townsend, R-Reno. "And that's not as easy as it sounds."
Townsend's comment just before his committee began working on SB253
was
prophetic - witnesses kept bringing up the need for more flexibility
in the
measure.
Translation: Don't kill all deals by stopping Reno-based Sierra
Pacific Power
and Las Vegas-based Nevada Power from selling their Nevada power
plants until
June 2003 - and possibly until 2006.
Pete Ernaut, a lobbyist for Reliant Energy which has been trying to
buy a power
plant, said unforeseen market changes could make a plant sale before
2003 a deal
that would be in the public's interest.
"If you put a two-year moratorium on these plants, all these deals
are going to
go away," he said. "When the cow leaves the barn, it's difficult to
catch."
Townsend had hoped to wrap up committee work on SB253 on Monday. Now
it's up for
review again Wednesday in the Commerce and Labor Committee.
Reliant isn't the only company trying to keep power plant purchases
alive.
Earlier this month, executives of Pinnacle West Energy told the
committee that
it's in the public's interest to allow Sierra Pacific Resources to
sell its
Harry Allen power plant.
The Harry Allen plant produces about 72 megawatts out of the 2,900
megawatts of
energy that Nevada utilities generate. Pinnacle has plans to expand
that to 700
megawatts by 2004.
Other provisions not strictly related to the plant divestitures, such
as ways in
which Sierra Pacific and Nevada Power can recover the cost of undoing
the sales
contracts, don't have to be included in SB253, Townsend said.
Townsend said the other concerns dealing with the energy crisis and
utility
deregulation can be handled in later bills - but the power plant sale
issue must
be handled now.
Nevada's PUC and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission had
directed Sierra
Pacific and Nevada Power to sell the plants as a condition of the
companies'
merger in 1999 under the parent company Sierra Pacific Resources.
Critics of the plant sales say the plants generate about half the
state's
electricity - and if they're sold, the unregulated new owners could
sell the
power to other states and put Nevada into the energy dilemma
California faces of
shrinking supply and rising prices.
The Southern Nevada Water Authority has presented an analysis stating
that rate
payers will save from $1.7 billion to $3.5 billion by July 2001 if
the power
plant sales are stopped.
Nevada's Consumer Advocate's Office previously had projected a
conservative
estimate of $915 million in savings.
MAINE: Panel of experts would review impact of energy deregulation
By GLENN ADAMS
Associated Press Writer
03/19/2001
Associated Press Newswires
Copyright 2001. The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
AUGUSTA, Maine (AP) - In the wake of rolling blackouts in California
and rate
spikes in their home state, Maine's top legislators proposed a study
Monday into
the effects of deregulation of the energy industry.
"Deregulation of electricity is a new idea and we still have a lot to
learn,"
Senate President Michael Michaud said as he called for the analysis.
A panel of industry insiders, elected officials and consumers would
study issues
such as what standard rate consumers can expect and the likelihood of
energy
shortfalls over the next three years, and whether Maine consumers are
vulnerable
to anti-competitive activities.
In addition, the Blue Ribbon Commission would look into whether
changes in
Maine's deregulation law are needed to encourage more generating
capacity,
improve conservation and spur competition.
The study is being proposed as consumers remain mindful of a power
crisis in
California that resulted from high wholesale energy costs, a consumer
rate cap
and too few power plants in that deregulated state.
Maine's deregulation law is designed to avoid such pitfalls, said
Rep. William
Savage, D-Buxton, House chairman of the Legislature's Utilities
Committee.
Maine's law does not cap consumer prices, as California's does, and
the state
has more than enough generating facilities to meet the state's energy
needs,
Savage said.
Since Maine's deregulation law took effect in March 2000, Bangor
Hydro-Electric
Co. rates have increased 19 percent. The Public Utilities Commission
approved a
residential standard rate increase as recently as last month.
Federal energy regulators are reviewing their decision to allow steep
fee
increases for utilities and power wholesalers that fail to arrange
enough
capacity to meet customers' peak load. Gov. Angus King and all four
members of
Maine's congressional delegation oppose the hike.
The PUC has approved standard rate increases for energy delivered by
Central
Maine Power Co. to medium-sized and large industrial users.
On the other hand, some towns and school districts are saving money
on energy
through deals they can get in the deregulated market.
In the meantime, legislation has been introduced in response to some
of the
changes that have occurred in Maine's deregulated energy industry.
One would use some of the money from the sale of power-generating
assets to
offset an increase in rates paid by large industrial users, said Sen.
Norman
Ferguson, R-Hanover, Senate chairman of the Utilities Committee.
Supporters of the utility study that was proposed Monday said they
are not
looking to make changes in Maine's deregulation law, but if it needs
fixing it
could be done during next year's session.
The lawmakers' primary interest is to find out how trends in a new
environment
designed to encourage competition will affect consumers, and to try
to identify
what consumers can expect in the few years ahead.
House Speaker Michael Saxl, D-Portland, said the Legislature "has a
fundamental
public policy interest in making sure rate-payers and businesses are
protected
against exorbitant rate hikes."
Michaud, D-East Millinocket, said he's interested in finding out how
future
changes in electric prices and availability might affect businesses
and
consumers in northern Maine.
"The economy in my part of the state is the most vulnerable, and I
want to make
certain we are leaving no stone unturned in our effort to prevent any
shocks to
the economy in northern, western and eastern Maine," Michaud added.
The commission would include House and Senate members from each
party, a utility
executive, and representatives of energy producers, providers, a
large
commercial consumer and individual consumers.
OREGON: State Senate moves to combat energy crisis
03/16/2001
Associated Press Newswires
Copyright 2001. The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
SALEM, Ore. (AP) - In an attempt to avoid a California-like energy
crisis, the
Oregon Senate approved a bill Friday that would quicken the process
of siting
power plants that use gas and renewable resources.
"It's important for Oregon. It makes sure that energy will be
available to
everyone," said Sen. Lee Beyer, D-Springfield.
The measure, SB843, would shorten the siting process for power plants
that use
gas and renewable resources, like wind, from a year and a half to a
matter of
months.
The speeded-up process would be in effect for two years.
"If we can act now, we can actually start to solve power supply
problems by this
summer," said Sen. Jason Atkinson, R-Jacksonville
California's strict regulations on the construction of new power
plants has
contributed to its current shortage and legislators took note. Beyer
said though
California was definitely a wake-up call, the measure is a reaction
to the
larger power picture in the Northwest.
With low rainfall, hydroelectric generators will have trouble meeting
demand,
Beyer said. Gas-fired and wind plants could come online as soon as
this fall and
would provide relief.
"We are not in a position to sit back and do nothing about the energy
crisis the
Northwest and the country are experiencing," said Senate Minority
Leader Kate
Brown, D-Portland.
Conservationists, however, caution that lawmakers should be careful
not to rush
to provide power at the expense of environmental standards.
WISCONSIN: Two utilities to add 975 megawatts in plan to avoid
energy crisis
By The Associated Press
03/22/2001
Associated Press Newswires
Copyright 2001. The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.
Plans of two state utilities to add 975 megawatts to Wisconsin's
electric power
grid as a way of avoiding an energy crisis similar to California's
were
questioned Thursday by a consumer advocate who said too many power
plants may be
in the works.
"Certainly nobody wants to see blackouts like you have in California
but there
is the danger Wisconsin could be overbuilding," said Steve Hiniker,
executive
director of the Citizens' Utility Board, which represents consumer
interests in
utility rate cases. He noted that plant construction costs ultimately
are born
by the utility customers.
Alliant Energy Corp. announced its proposal Wednesday - in a filing
with the
state Public Service Commission - to spend $1 billion to build one
coal and two
gas-fired power plants.
Alliant has proposed building a 500 megawatt coal-fired plant and a
100 megawatt
natural-gas fired plant by 2006. It also wants to build a 200
megawatt natural
gas-fired facility in 2011. Wisconsin has not built a coal-fired
plant in more
than two decades.
Alliant has not determined the plants' locations.
Also, Madison Gas & Electric, the state's smallest investor-owned
utility, said
Wednesday that it had signed deals to buy 175 megawatts of power from
three
generating plants in Wisconsin and Illinois.
"Three out of the four past summers, we've had public appeals for
conservation
due to shortages somewhere in the state. We need to take steps to
avoid that,
and the California situation makes that even more clear," said
Alliant spokesman
Chris Schoenherr. "Getting more iron in the ground will give us more
flexibility
in the state to be able to react."
Alliant acknowledged the new plants will probably mean rate
increases, but it
was too early to say how much rates would go up.
California's problems, which this week resulted in the first
deliberate
blackouts since World War II, stemmed from underestimating the
state's power
needs, forcing utilities to sell their power plants but not allowing
them to
secure long-term supply contracts, and freezing rates, among other
things.
But Wisconsin's situation is far different.
The state has moved slower than California toward deregulation, and
there has
been no desire here to speed up the process in recent years as power
reliability
became a problem.
The PSC estimates that Wisconsin will need an additional 3,000
megawatts of
power over the next decade.
Hiniker said Wisconsin needs to coordinate its planning to avoid
overbuilding.
The costs of new power plants are passed on to ratepayers, meaning
electric
bills will increase as new generation is added. In addition,
coal-generated
power plants are a major source of air pollution in the state.
"We don't have the advance planning that has kept Wisconsin from
overbuilding in
the past," said Hiniker. "This is something the PSC should be doing."
MG&E's deals are:
-A 10-year contract to buy 75 megawatts from Calpine Energy Services
starting in
May 2004. The power will come from the natural gas-fired plant Rock
River Energy
Center, near Beloit.
Calpine Energy Services is a unit of San Jose, Calif.-based Calpine
Energy Corp.
The plant is being built by Northbrook, Ill.-based SkyGen Energy LLC,
which
Calpine bought last year from SkyGen President Michael Polsky and
Wisvest Corp.,
a unit of Wisconsin Energy Corp.
-A 10-year contract to buy 50 megawatts of power from the Rainy River
Energy
Corp. starting in May 2002. The power is coming from a natural
gas-fired plant
near Joliet, Ill. owned by LS Power Co. Rainy River is a unit of
Duluth-based
Minnesota Power Inc.
-A five-year contract to buy 50 megawatts from an El Paso Merchant
Energy plant
near Cordova, Ill., in western Illinois.
The owner of the natural gas facility is the Cordova Energy Center
Co., which is
a unit of Iowa-based MidAmerican Energy Holdings.
Alliant also offered support in the Wednesday filing for a $7 billion
plan of
Milwaukee-based Wisconsin Energy, which includes five new power
plants in Oak
Creek and Pleasant Prairie.
--
On the Net:
CUB: http://www.wiscub.org/
Alliant Energy: http://www.alliant-energy.com
Wisconsin Public Service Commission: http://www.psc.state.wi.us
Wisconsin Energy: http://www.wisenergy.com/
Madison Gas & Electric: http://www.mge.com
Use this file to download and print all the articles in this section
(See attached file: Dow Jones
Interactive-california-03233001-implications.doc)
If you wish to be removed from the distribution list for this update
please contact Pru Sheppard - DC.
All recipients of this message have been Bcc'd as part of industry
best practice for broadcast emails.
+-------------------------------------------------------------+
| This message may contain confidential and/or privileged |
| information. If you are not the addressee or authorized to |
| receive this for the addressee, you must not use, copy, |
| disclose or take any action based on this message or any |
| information herein. If you have received this message in |
| error, please advise the sender immediately by reply e-mail |
| and delete this message. Thank you for your cooperation. |
+-------------------------------------------------------------+
- Dow Jones Interactive-california-03233001-selected.doc
- pic24389.pcx
- pic05075.pcx
- Dow Jones Interactive-california-03233001-implications.doc