Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

5 Mar 2001, 18:17 UTC

Fw: Fessler Fesses Up to What Went Wrong in California

From
Gigi Coe gcoe@firstworld.net
To
jdasovic@enron.com
Date
Mon, 5 Mar 2001 10:17:00 -0800 (PST)
This was too choice not to pass on.  Whadda guy.  Happy birthday, by the
way.  You ageing beauty, you.  I do want to catch up on lots of stuff but my
current schedule is extremely hectic.  Do you have schedule constraints?
Coffee some morning good for you?  G.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
-----Original Message-----
From: Schmid, Elena <ESchmid@caiso.com>
To: 'gcoe@firstworld.net' <gcoe@firstworld.net>
Date: Friday, March 02, 2001 4:39 PM
Subject: FW: Fessler Fesses Up to What Went Wrong in California


>FYI
>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Alaywan, Ziad
>> Sent: Thursday, March 01, 2001 6:45 PM
>> To: Winter, Terry; Schmid, Elena
>> Subject: FW: Fessler Fesses Up to What Went Wrong in California
>>
>>  fyi
>>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Kasarjian, Vicken
>> Sent: Thursday, March 01, 2001 2:56 PM
>> To: Fluckiger, Kellan; Alaywan, Ziad; Detmers, Jim; Bibb, Tracy;
>> Carlson, Trent; McIntosh, Jim; Riley, Ed; Perez, Armando
>> Subject: Fessler Fesses Up to What Went Wrong in California
>>
>> Breaking a lengthy refusal to comment publicly on the California
>> electricity "Perfect Storm," Dan Fessler (chairman and a member of the
>> California Public Utilities Commission from 1991 to December 1996)
>> described to a recent conference in New York why things have gone so awry
>> in the state and what he thinks might now be done.
>> His explanation of why the crisis arose is fairly conventional: a
shortage
>> of generation capacity; grossly erroneous predictions of the timing and
>> strength of the economic recovery in the state; and a fatal decision to
>> separate the California Power Exchange from the California Independent
>> System Operator. That's a policy to which Fessler (now with the meaty
>> LeBouef, Lamb law firm) believes that the PUC should never have agreed.
>> "Little did I realize," he told the meeting, "that the market design to
>> which the commission and legislature had acceded would turn out to bear a
>> striking resemblance to the battle cruiser, that ill-fated darling of
>> virtually every naval power in the period 1910-1914. At Jutland, it was
>> belatedly discovered that these vessels-imbued with attributes of speed
>> and weaponry that made them so appealing on paper-could not take a punch.
>> Their armor was too thin: a fatal design flaw revealed only when they
were
>> tested in battle."
>> So what do we do now? Fessler suggests "a technique which I advocated in
>> 1996 and which remains available for deployment next week. If
successfully
>> implemented, my suggestion would directly assail the vehicle of high
>> prices by enlisting self-interested opportunistic behavior to make the
>> demand curve elastic for the first time in the power crisis.
>> "I propose that California pay large users to get off the system the
>> moment reserves approach Stage One conditions. Demand bidding would
>> replace interruptible tariffs for the simple reason that [the latter]
have
>> not worked."
>