29 Sep 2000, 16:34 UTC
Electric Restructuring: Two Utilities In California Suffer Under Deregulation --- Wholesale ...
- From
- Miyung Buster miyung.buster@enron.com
- Bcc
- Steven J Kean
- Date
- Fri, 29 Sep 2000 09:34:00 -0700 (PDT)
The sender added no text of their own; everything below is quoted or forwarded.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
----- Forwarded by Miyung Buster/ENRON_DEVELOPMENT on 09/29/2000 04:33 PM ----- djcustomclips@djinteractive.com 09/27/2000 01:38 AM Please respond to nobody To: 235445@mailman.enron.com cc: Subject: Electric Restructuring: Two Utilities In California Suffer Under Deregulation --- Wholesale ... The Wall Street Journal Europe Two Utilities In California Suffer Under Deregulation --- Wholesale Power Costs Them More Than They Can Charge By Rebecca Smith ? 09/27/2000 The Wall Street Journal Europe 8 (Copyright (c) 2000, Dow Jones&Company, Inc.) California's two biggest utilities are losing so much money buying electricity in the state's deregulated market that they've run up deficits equivalent to half their net worth in just four months. If the cost of wholesale power continues to exceed the price utilities are allowed to bill their customers, it's conceivable they could become technically insolvent sometime next year, putting pressure on regulators to orchestrate a multibillion-dollar public bailout. Such a scenario is quietly being discussed by bond rating agencies that recently reduced their credit outlooks for Pacific Gas and Electric Co., a unit of San Francisco-based PGOCorp., and Southern California Edison, a unit of Edison International of Rosemead, California. Bond rating agencies say they're not sure how much additional debt can be borne by the two affected utilities before they'll have difficulty paying their bills. "If this is just a seasonal aberration, the utilities can get through it," says Lori Woodland, analyst for Fitch IBCA "If it goes on for six or nine months, it's a very serious situation." A.J. Sabatelle, senior credit officer at Moody's Investors Service, said, "At some point, you have a financial crisis." The utilities say they're having no difficulty meeting expenses and don't envision problems in servicing their debts. But they're vigorously lobbying state and federal regulators to change the rules of the game, hoping to somehow charge their customers for the shortfall. As such, California's experience may be a harbinger of what could happen in other states where wholesale power prices have surpassed the amount utilities are allowed to charge their rate payers. Today's situation represents a complete turnabout from what was expected when California deregulated its energy market on March 31, 1998. California tried to give its utilities a competitive edge nationally by deregulating faster than other states and by creating a mechanism to allow investor-owned utilities, like PGOand Edison, to quickly pay down debts incurred to serve customers under the old regulatory system. To do this, the state legislature set rates at high levels, which, at first generated fat surpluses. As the money piled up, utilities used it to pay down debts for generation facilities that looked like they would be unprofitable in the new deregulated world. By the end of June, PGO and Edison together had collected more than $12 billion (13.75 billion euros) and were on track to finish paying down debts well ahead of the March 31, 2002, deadline set by the legislature. At that point, rate freezes were to end and retail prices were to fluctuate with the market. But all that went out the window in June when wholesale power prices surged. Average prices at state-sanctioned energy markets were four to five times the prices a year earlier and three to four times the level utilities could charge customers. The cash-burn rate has been so enormous at PG&E, which serves one in 20 Americans, that analysts expect its undercollection to exceed $3 billion -- half its shareholder equity of $5.7 billion -- by the end of October. Southern California Edison finished August with a deficit of $2 billion, equivalent to two-thirds of its net worth of $3.2 billion. That leaves utilities in a bind. They want to end the rate freeze to be able to pass on the real cost of electricity to consumers. But as soon as the freeze ends, they get clobbered. That's because they'll immediately have to book a loss on their power-purchase deficits. What's more, they can't use the proceeds from power plant sales to cover those losses; instead, with the freeze ending, they'll be obliged to refund that money to ratepayers. In PG&E's case, the refunds could total $500 million, while in Edison's case, the amount is $254 million. Publicly at least, utility executives insist that a mechanism will be found to let them recoup the money spent on electricity. But that assumes politicians will be willing to change a law that protects ratepayers from this expense. Consumer advocates are gearing up for the fight. Nettie Hoge, executive director for San Francisco consumer group the Utility Reform Network, says ratepayers shouldn't end up footing the bill for a deal cut by utilities that benefited them before prices shot up. "Our heart bleeds for the utilities, but they have more power to get the wholesale market fixed than we do," she says. Utility executives are now distancing themselves from the legislation that got them into such a mess, which was drafted with their assistance. PGOChairman Robert Glynn says it's best not to "overanalyze" the "old deal." Instead, he says, regulators and legislators should sit down with utilities and construct a new agreement as "it's in the broad interests of the state not to have critical energy infrastructure look like a leper." Mr. Glynn says the current deal offers "mutually assured destruction" to both utilities and ratepayers. Something must be done, he says, or consumers throughout most of the state will experience "a San Diego-style rate shock." The utility serving that city, San Diego Gas and Electric Co., ended its freeze a year ago and began passing wholesale power costs directly through to ratepayers. Legislators intervened this summer, however, and temporarily capped retail rates when monthly power bills nearly tripled. As a result, San Diego Gas and Electric, a unit of Sempra Energy, also is accumulating a deficit. Folder Name: Electric Restructuring Relevance Score on Scale of 100: 47 ______________________________________________________________________ To review or revise your folder, visit Dow Jones CustomClipsor contact Dow Jones Customer Service by e-mail at custom.news@bis.dowjones.comor by phone at 800-369-7466. (Outside the U.S. and Canada, call 609-452-1511 or contact your local sales representative.) ______________________________________________________________________ Copyright (c) 2000 Dow Jones &Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved