26 Oct 2000, 09:42 UTC
Fwd: PowerPlus Write Up on EPMI's White Paper on How to Fix California
- From
- Mary Hain mary.hain@enron.com
- To
- James D Steffes, Susan J Mara, jdasovic@ees.enron.com, Mona L Petrochko, Paul Kaufman, Sarah Novosel, Karen Denne
- Date
- Thu, 26 Oct 2000 02:42:00 -0700 (PDT)
Karen - thanks for getting the word out! PowerPlus ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ -- Seeking to eliminate price caps as solution Enron Pushes Four-Point Fix To CA Wholesale Power Market Broad-scale power marketer Enron, on the eve of the release of a proposed FERC remedy, has delivered a four-point plan of its own to remedy structural problems in the California wholesale power market. Observers say that the power marketer is seeking to push FERC into preempting state rules with structural changes for the California market, rather than continue reliance on price caps and other bidding controls as an interim solution to nascent wholesale power markets. In a white paper submitted to the commission for consideration, Enron tells the commissioners that the "problem in California is not that competition cannot work but that it has not been given a chance to work because the existing structure of the California market is only half complete." Enron's proposal, developed by two experts who are intimately familiar with the California Independent System Operator (Cal-ISO), suggests that FERC order four specific structural remedies: -- Removing Barriers to Market Transparency. Enron argues that the Cal-ISO "must release more information to the public in order to allow for efficient arbitrage." The absence of this information "is thwarting critical elements necessary for a vibrant and competitive electricity market;" -- Development of Forwards Markets and Risk Management. Here Enron places some of the blame on state regulators, stating that the "rules established by state authorities make the wholesale market in California overly reliant on real-time and spot market supplies." This has prevented the development of an adequate forwards market. "Virtually all observers agree that forwards markets are critical for whole market efficiency and competitiveness." Enron urges FERC to "preempt state policies that are interfering with the use of forwards markets" by utility distribution companies. [On the same day that Enron filed its white paper with FERC, Cal-ISO filed a plan with the commission intended to shift power sales from the higher-priced spot market to the forward market. The plan would cap generators' bid prices to $100 per megawatt hour (MWh) unless they offered a minimum of 70 percent of their power for sale in the forward markets.]; -- Removing Distortions on Prices That Affect Supply and Investment. According to Enron, generation supply and electricity demand signals "are distorted in the California market." Arguing against continued use of price caps, Enron states unequivocally: "Dealing with this through continuous and increasingly severe price caps causes price discrimination and creates disincentives for the development of needed generation." Enron says there are changes that can be made to the bidding process that will make the California market "more efficient, with undermining its long-term development through short-sighted price caps; -- Revising Cal-ISO and CalPX Governance Structures to Ensure Independence. Enron argues that the Cal-ISO and the California Power Exchange Corporation (CalPX) are governed by stakeholders that are not independent from local political forces and from the incumbent utilities that formed the basis for the ISO. "This conflicts with the 'bedrock' policy of [FERC] Order No. 888 that ISOs must be independent," Enron asserts. "The commission should therefore change the California ISO's board from a stakeholder board to an independent board comprised of industry experts." Enron tells the commission that structural changes are needed instead of continuation of short-term price caps and bidding controls. FERC is considering whether to implement a policy of price caps and bid controls being pushed by incumbent utilities for the California market and possibly for the New York market as a solution to shaky wholesale bidding markets. Power marketers are pressing hard for FERC to propose a more pro-competitive solution. Enron tells FERC that its proposed changes will prevent the commission from abandoning "its pervasive scheme of regulation (under Order No. 888 and Order No. 2000) to increase competition in the wholesale electricity market, as it would if it maintains perpetual price caps, or worse yet, it implements a return to cost-based generation rates." FERC is considering a proposal by the California Municipal Utilities Association for just that, based on the argument that reregulation is required until more generation capacity is brought on line in California. The Enron white paper comes just as FERC commissions begin to review a report by FERC staff on what went wrong in the California market last summer and a proposed remedy scheme. The commission is scheduled to release the findings of the report on November 1, along with a proposed remedy. There will be a three-week period of public review and comment before FERC makes a final decision. There has been much controversy over whether FERC should release the findings of the FERC probe immediately for stakeholders to review before they comment on a proposed FERC remedy. But FERC chairman James Hoecker has held hard, even in the face of criticism by fellow commissioner Curt Hebert, arguing that the commission needs time to review the document before releasing it.