8 Sep 2000, 10:48 UTC
Quick and dirty outline of issues for PX and EOB protests
- From
- Mary Hain mary.hain@enron.com
- To
- Susan J Mara, Joe Hartsoe, Christi L Nicolay, James D Steffes, Richard Shapiro, Sarah Novosel, Mona L Petrochko, Sandra McCubbin, Jeff Dasovich, Paul Kaufman
- Cc
- Elsa Piekielniak, Scott Vonderheide, Dennis Benevides, Jeff Richter, Chris Stokley, Robert Badeer, David Parquet, Tim Belden, Roger Yang, Harry Kingerski, Chris H Foster, Stewart Rosman
- Bcc
- Elsa Piekielniak, Scott Vonderheide, Dennis Benevides, Jeff Richter, Chris Stokley, Robert Badeer, David Parquet, Tim Belden, Roger Yang, Harry Kingerski, Chris H Foster, Stewart Rosman
- Date
- Fri, 8 Sep 2000 03:48:00 -0700 (PDT)
We may want to add other issues and there may be some overlap between the PX filing and the EOB filing. Sorry this is so rough. Protest of PX filing ? FERC should reject the PX,s price caps because ? Energy Markets are competitive in the West ) 20 loads and 40 sellers. ? Say what we and EPSA said in San Diego case and say that high prices are not due to exercise of market power, they are the product of scarcity and the failure of the IOUs to hedge in the forward market and their underscheduling in the PX day ahead market. ? FERC had to administer the price caps for the gas industry and they caused terrible problems ) list a few of FERC,s nightmares FERC as reminders. ? The Cal PX shouldn,t be able to do this on a whim and indefinitly. ? Cal PX should have to substantiate the request, which they haven,t. ISO and PX haven,t had the same prices as the ISO for years and they didn,t have the problems described in the filing. PX proposed this for political reasons. ? If two parties want to agree ) why shouldn,t PX match ) they have to be willing buyers, have the ability to go to the ISO real time market. Parties should be able to buy outside of the PX ) we don,t want to create a monopoly for the bilateral market. ? Recognize that the FERC may allow price caps, if they do ? FERC should have same cap they allow for New York, PJM. Inconsistent with other markets, including Canadian markets over which Commission has no jurisdiction. ? $250 Price cap in California is not enough to incent generation to be built because it does not allow a return on an investment in generation ? FERC should consider allowing a cap based on the price at which interruptible load is willing to be cut - $1,500. ? Could we make the argument that capping the price in the PX will drive up the price by making participants bid up to the cap? Isn,t this what happened in California? Ask for Seabron to help? Protest of the EOB filing ? FERC should reject it ? Cross reference anything we said with respect to the PX filing that applies ? Analysis ) provided by Seabron Adamson of why we can,t exercise market power the way the EOB says we have. ? The EOB,s filing confuses bid and price caps. After all, who would buy in the bilateral market if they can go to the ISO and the PX get power for less? ? Attach the joint resolution telling the ISO to show cause why it should not lower the price caps to $100/MW. Attach the EOB vote not to reaffirm directors. Of ISO and PX. If in response to the EOB,s show cause order, the ISO lowers prices to $100/MW and the PX follows suit - as they have indicated they will in their filing and as the EOB vote on their directors would force them - California generators will stop producing because if they generate they will not be able to recover their variable costs. Generators outside of California will not sell into California markets because they would not recover their variable costs and they could sell their power elsewhere and recover their variable costs. Therefore, the liquidity of the California market will dry up and reliability problems will occur. ? We &told you so8 FERC ? the EOB thinks they have much more power than you allowed them to have as illustrated by their issuing orders to show cause to the ISO to lower the price cap and ? the EOB is now making the ISO and PX unindependent by not reaffirming Board members because they won,t vote for lower price caps. This is ultra vires in that the EOB,s power is supposed to relate to retail jurisdiction, not setting wholesale price caps (not just bid caps) for the entire California market.
Quoted or forwarded from earlier messages
Susan J Mara@EES 09/08/2000 08:16 AM To: Elsa Piekielniak/Corp/Enron@Enron, Scott Vonderheide/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Dennis Benevides/HOU/EES@EES, Jeff Richter/HOU/ECT@ECT, Chris Stokley/HOU/ECT@ECT, Robert Badeer/HOU/ECT@ECT, Sarah Novosel/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Mona L Petrochko/SFO/EES@EES, Susan J Mara/SFO/EES@EES, Joe Hartsoe/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Mary Hain/HOU/ECT@ECT, Christi L Nicolay/HOU/ECT@ECT, James D Steffes/HOU/EES@EES, Richard Shapiro/HOU/EES@EES, David Parquet/SF/ECT@ECT, Sandra McCubbin/SFO/EES@EES, Jeff Dasovich/SFO/EES@EES, Tim Belden/HOU/ECT@ECT, Dennis Benevides/HOU/EES@EES, Roger Yang/SFO/EES@EES, Harry Kingerski/HOU/EES@EES, Chris H Foster/HOU/ECT@ECT, Stewart Rosman/HOU/ECT@ECT, Mike Swerzbin/HOU/ECT@ECT, Greg Wolfe/HOU/ECT@ECT, Kathryn Corbally/Corp/Enron@ENRON, Douglas Condon/SFO/EES@EES cc: rcarroll@bracepatt.com Subject: [Fwd: FW: You should look at this -- Reuters on $100/MWh price caps for ISO and PX] Price cap aand Oversight Board frivolities ---------------------- Forwarded by Susan J Mara/SFO/EES on 09/08/2000 08:09 AM --------------------------- Carl Imparato <cfi1@tca-us.com> on 09/07/2000 11:07:54 PM Please respond to cfi1@tca-us.com To: smara@enron.com cc: Subject: [Fwd: FW: You should look at this -- Reuters on $100/MWh price caps for ISO and PX] More bad stuff on the way... Carl Return-Path: <fpickel@tca-us.com> Received: from nautilus.shore.net (nautilus.shore.net [207.244.124.104]) by shell2.shore.net (8.8.7/8.8.7) with ESMTP id XAA13893 for <cfi1@shell2.shore.net>; Thu, 7 Sep 2000 23:49:38 -0400 (EDT) Received: from (mailnweb.tca-us.com) [207.31.208.21] by nautilus.shore.net with esmtp (Exim) for cfi1@shore.net id 13XFAY-00058W-00; Thu, 07 Sep 2000 23:49:38 -0400 Received: by mailnweb.tca-us.com with Internet Mail Service (5.5.2650.21) id <RLG1Y5TH>; Thu, 7 Sep 2000 23:48:44 -0400 Received: from tcaus (ZZYXP3DELL [172.16.121.84]) by mailnweb.tca-us.com with SMTP (Microsoft Exchange Internet Mail Service Version 5.5.2650.21) id RLG1Y5TF; Thu, 7 Sep 2000 23:48:32 -0400 Reply-To: <fpickel@tca-us.com> From: "Fred Pickel" <fpickel@tca-us.com> To: "Richard Tabors \(E-mail\)" <tabors@tca-us.com>, "Scott Englander \(E-mail\)" <sle@tca-us.com>, "Narasimha Rao \(E-mail\)" <nrao@tca-us.com>, "Judith Cardell \(E-mail\)", "Ellen [Banaghan] Wolfe \(E-mail\)" <ellen@tca-us.com>, "Carl Imparato \(E-mail\)" <cfi1@tca-us.com> Subject: FW: You should look at this -- Reuters on $100/MWh price caps for ISO and PX Date: Thu, 7 Sep 2000 23:45:44 -0400 Message-ID: <000c01c01947$ef44a680$547910ac@com.tcaus.com> MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/alternative; boundary="----=_NextPart_000_000D_01C01926.68330680" X-Priority: 3 (Normal) X-MSMail-Priority: Normal X-Mailer: Microsoft Outlook CWS, Build 9.0.2416 (9.0.2911.0) X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V5.50.4133.2400 Importance: Normal Oh boy!? What a mess. ? ?Frederick H. Pickel, Ph.D ?Vice President ?Tabors Caramanis & Associates ?Los Angeles, California ?& Cambridge, Massachusetts ?email: fpickel@tca-us.com ?alternate email: fred.pickel@ALUM.mit.edu ?tel +1 (323) 937-7920 ? -----Original Message----- From: Sam Van Vactor [mailto:svv@econ.com] Sent: Thursday, September 07, 2000 7:44 PM To: Lisa_G_Urick@calpx.com Cc: Dona K. Lehr Subject: You should look at this ? By Nigel Hunt ?? LOS ANGELES, Sept 7 (Reuters) - The cap on wholesale power prices in California could be cut for the third time this year, this time to $100 per megawatt hour after starting the year at $750 per MWh. ?? The state's Electricity Oversight Board (EOB) is to make a request to the California Independent System Operator (ISO) within the next few days on the issue following a resolution by the state's lawmakers last week. ?? "We will make a formal request within the next few days," EOB Executive Director Gary Heath said. ?? An assembly joint resolution approved last week called on the EOB to direct the ISO to "show cause why the price caps in the ancillary services and real-time energy markets should not be lowered to $100 per megawatt-hour immediately and continue until at least March 31, 2001." ?? The cap currently stands at $250 per MWh after previous cuts from $750 to $500 and $500 to $250 amid growing consumer unrest about skyrocketing electricity bills and allegations of possible price gouging by generators. ?? The assembly resolution says the EOB should report back to the legislature by December 1, 2000. ?? There was heavy criticism of the ISO, which controls most of the state's power grid, by lawmakers this year at its governing board twice rejected resolution to cut the cap to $250 from $500 before finally agreeing to such a move. ?? Heath noted the EOB at a meeting last week decided not to approve the appointment or reappointment of 13 members of the ISO board and 12 members of the California Power Exchange's governing board. ?? "We are trying to place people who are a bit more mindful of the implications of board decisions on Californian consumers," Heath said. ?? Existing board members will remain in office until replacements can be appointed. ?? Heath said that some individuals who were rejected may eventually be approved and the EOB was rather making a statement about the performance of the two boards. ?? "The board was making a very clear statement that we are not satisfied with the the efforts of the ISO or PX governing boards to proect Californian consumers," Heath said. ?? Wholesale power prices in California soared to record levels during a heatwave in June and many customers in San Diego faced a tripling in their electricity bills. ? Supporters of cutting the cap believe the power market is not "workably competitive" and prices rose to excessive levels during the heatwave, putting an unfair burden on both ratepayers and shareholders of investor owned utilities. ?? Opponents have been led by independent power producers who have argued a lower cap could make it more difficult for the state to import power at times of shortage. ?? Emergency legislation signed into law by Calif. Gov. Gray Davis on Wednesday imposed a price cap on how much San Diego residents should pay which was less than a third of the current "free market" rate. ? Customers of San Diego Gas and Electric, a unit of Sempra Energy <SRE.N>, had been exposed to market based prices under the terms of California's power deregulation. ?? Rates for customers of California's other two investor owned utilities, Edison International's <EIX.N> Southern California Edison and PG&E Corp.'s <PCG.N> Pacific Gas and Electric, are frozen. ?? A spokesman for the California ISO was not immediately available for comment. ?? ((--Los Angeles bureau + 1 213 955 6752))