Enron email

Algorithmic Indexing

13 Jul 2001, 14:47 UTC

RTO Orders - Grid South, SE Trans, SPP and Entergy

From
Donna Fulton donna.fulton@enron.com
To
Steven J Kean, Richard Shapiro, James D Steffes, Christi L Nicolay, Sarah Novosel, Ray Alvarez, sscott3@enron.com, Joe Connor, Dan Staines, Steve Montovano, Kevin M Presto, Rogers Herndon
and 28 more Mike Carson, John M Forney, Laura Podurgiel, gretchen.lotz@enron.com, Juan Hernandez, Miguel L Garcia, Rudy Acevedo, Heather Kroll, David Fairley, Elizabeth Johnston, Bill Rust, Edward Baughman, Terri Clynes, Oscar Dalton, Doug Sewell, Larry Valderrama, Nick Politis, Fletcher J Sturm, Chris Dorland, Jeff King, John Kinser, Matt Lorenz, Patrick Hansen, Lloyd Will, dduaran@enron.com, John J Lavorato, Louise Kitchen, Greg Whalley
Date
Fri, 13 Jul 2001 07:47:00 -0700 (PDT)
The Southeast RTO orders are out and have followed through with what we 
expected from the discussion at the FERC meeting.

The SPP and Entergy RTO proposals have been rejected because they fail to 
satisfy the scope and configuration requirements of Order No. 2000.  The 
Commission  notes that the required discussions between SPP and Entergy and 
its neighboring RTO/TOs has led to no increase in the original scope and 
configuration.  The filings by SPP and Entergy were brief, indicating only a 
lack of interest by other RTOs or utilities in joining to enlarge scope; they 
failed to specify any details of the talks, what changes could be made or 
what could be fixed to accomodate combination with other RTOs.  The order 
states that the Commission favors the development of large, regional 
transmission organizations reflecting natural markets.  The Commission 
indicates that they favor four RTOs - NE, SE, MW and West.  Therefore the 
order requires the participants in SPP and Entergy to participate in 
settlement discussions as set out in the mediation order.  Note that these 
meetings will start next Tuesday, July 17 before a FERC ALJ.

The Southern Company RTO is also found by the FERC to fail the scope 
characteristics of Order No. 2000.  The order finds that Southern's approach 
to focus on MOUs and seams issues with its neighbors is inadequate.  The 
order states, "We reiterate: the Commission's goal is to have a single RTO in 
the Southeast, and to have that single RTO operational as soon as possible."  
The Commission recognizes that start-up costs in forming a larger RTO may be 
more, but that over the longer term, large RTOs will foster market 
development, will provide increased reliability and will result in lower 
wholesale electricity prices.  The order therefore directs the parties to the 
mediation as stated above.

The Grid South participants are also directed to the mediation which is 
starting on next Tuesday.  It is a lengthier order with more details on other 
aspects of RTOs, including Independent Board requirement, congestion 
managment, interconnection procedures, planning process and CBM.  Therefore, 
I am attaching a summary of the order.  One of the important findings of the 
order is that GridSouth is not sufficiently independent; the Applicant TOs 
are making policy decisions that should be made by an independent board.  
Therefore, the order requires GridSouth to install an independent board and 
file a compliance filing within 90 days.

If anyone wants copies of the orders, let me know.